So, my last review was harsh, but understand where I was coming from: when you are used to getting awesome pizza from them then for the next orders get horrible quality and just opposite of what you are used to at full price, you'd totally understand my frustration. Maybe someone there read my review bc they are back to the awesome Pizza that we are used to. I love the Italian Guy who answers and takes your order. He's so thorough and so personable, ya gotta love him. Thank God I didn't give up on them. After taking a break from them, our orders have been so delicious and yummy, I'm giving them 5 Stars!!! The gravy on the pizza is 1 of the best I've had. Their Mushrooms are huge & fresh. The sausage....OMG, so yummy!!! Very Happy with Sal's, I'm Italian and know good pizza...go and get some when you can (no delivery). read more

The pizza crust was tough. There was no taste to the sauce or the cheese. It lacked seasoning. We won't be returning to Sal's.

I ordered the SAUAGE and pepperoni Stromboli. It had very nice flavors . I give it an 8 out of 10 . All I ask that it had been cooked a little longer . I will differently be back for more items. read more

I am very disappointed. Not in the quality of food, the pizza was good. But in the person that processed my payment after hours. My bill was 18.85 for a large pizza and when I signed the receipt, I circled the price and drew a line down through to the total. So $0 tip since all they did was hand me my pizza box. I look today and they charged me $26.85. They added an $8 tip to my receipt. Completely unacceptable and downright dirty. I will NOT be back based on the fact that they cannot be trusted. 1 Star is kind since I cannot give 0 Stars. Service outshines quality of food. I would hope they see this and credit my card back. read more

Sal’s Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Wasn't bad at all. Hubby loved the chicken fingers n fries were really good! Son loved the chicken cheesesteak hoagie. I had eggplant parm, was just ok. Not the best but ok enough to eat. Grabbed a bottle of Birch Beer, one of my favorite sodas. Rare find. read more

See all

One of the best pizza places in the area! I ordered a Medium cheese pizza on a Friday night. The wait was about 25 mins, which I didn't mind since it was busy. I've gone here a few times now and they always seem to be consistent with their pies, which is great. The employees seem friendly and the whole atmosphere of the business seems very professional. The pizza was absolutely amazing as always! Definitely will look to try some other pies they have to offer. Highly recommend checking them out! read more

Sal’s Pizza - Medium Cheese Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Sals has great pizza and sandwich's, never had a bad meal! Fast service and Pleasant employees too!

Best pizza ever!!! Been established a longtime! Thepastadishesareexcellent too! Itmightbeapizza placebutthqtpizza is crispyonthebotyom, doesn't droop when youpick it up andthecheesedissolves like butter on the tongue, youdomthavetokeepcheeing likea mouthful of rubber bands. read more

The sauce!!! It's the addicting sauce on the pizza. If I could drink it, I would. It keeps me coming back for years now. To Sal's ownership and staff, don't drop the ball. Stay in the top tier of pizza and Italian fare. read more

The pizza was just ok, certainly nothing special. We didn't like the sauce at all. This was a one and done. I really wanted to like it!! read more

Great pizza! One of the best in the area. Always fresh and hot. Haven't tried much of anything else on menu.

It's just ok, I try a new pizza place every time I travel to Jersey, and this one is middle of the road. The crust is just tasteless, sauce is good. This is not one I will go back to. All the edge pieces were lacking cheese. read more

Sal’s Pizza - Sicilian Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Sal's isn't as good as it gets anymore. They're hardly even "good." The food I received the other day was just plain mediocre. I ordered my usual -- a large pizza and Italian hoagie -- and couldn't wait to have it once more after a long, accidental break from visiting my hometown pizza shop. I arrived, saw only the side and back parking spots were available, and parked in one of the side spots. Walked in, nearly hurt my back even more trying to shut the heavy door behind me in the wind (while a guy-patron looked on apathetically -- cute, thanks), and picked up my food. Walked back to my car, sat down, started settling the food in my passenger seat, aaaand a driver next to me slammed down on his horn. What the actual what? As it turned out, someone had double parked next to the regular line of spots, and since I was parked on the side, he couldn't get through to the back lot. But that was not my problem, and I do NOT appreciate being rushed...and it's very possible I rolled down my window to call him some not-so-nice words and to point out that I was legally parked, which he promptly ignored because I guess he was too pompous to care. But, unfortunately, it gets worse. When I opened the pizza box at home -- since I couldn't check it in the lot god-forbid man had to wait a second for a parking spot -- I noticed that the bottom was caked in flour. The pizza itself was just not good. Overly oily, bland, boring. Nothing like how they used to taste for years. As for the Italian hoagie, they blatantly ignored my request. If I say "Italian hoagie with JUST (emphasis on 'just') mayo and lettuce," you should NOT translate that to "please cake this baby in oil." Your oil is gross, Sal's, and my Sicilian grandmother agreed. As is the brand of meat you chose for your hoagies. I only ate a quarter of the hoagie, and the rest went in the trash. What happened to you? This was a true waste of $22! I won't make that mistake again. Such a shame, but at least I still have the fond memories from loving this place as a kid. read more

Sal’s Pizza - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Best slice in twp! They use real ingredients so no need to add extra cheese to your pie. Plain slice is solid enough. 10/10

The extra large sausage pie is chefs kisssss! Crust is the perfect thickness along with the sauce to cheese ratio. Great in town pizza spot!

Worse pizza I ever had. Dough was chewy cheese wasn't cooked right . Horrible experience

I'm Brooklyn born Brooklyn raised. Best pizza I've eaten in decades period.9 3/4 stars

Pizza was decent. Sauce isn't bad at all... BUT the menu prices advertised are not quite right. Small works price on menu $17, my husband takes in a $20 and has to go back to the car for a $5... change $2? Tax was $6?? 1st and last order read more

The food was very good & well priced. I've tried a few pizza places and can definitely say that Sal's is my favorite! If you're thinking about trying the wings- I would highly recommend them! read more

Sal’s Pizza - We ordered a large pizza with half pepperoni & sausage it was very good! I will definitely order again. - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

See all

That extra large sausage pie. So good!! Great taste, great pizza dough & crust! The sausage is exactly how we like (crumbles). Very quick service with high quality taste! read more

You know it's a good pizza place when they don't deliver. I grew up on Sal's Pizza and in a town where pizza places are as common as traffic lights I still choose to drive to Sal's. Not a great place for eating in because there are few tables and not designed for families. Still gets 5 stars. read more

Sal’s Pizza - This is happiness. - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

See all

Hands down best Pizza(& everything else!!) In New Jersey! I live in Lubbock Texas now& crave it all the time! We go back to visit family and friends atleast twice a year& this is my absolute favorite treat when we are in town!!! Reccomend to everyone!!! read more

Everyone knows we've got plenty of pizza places in Washington Twp. But each stands out for its own reasons. At Sal's it's simply the pizza. It's the best in town. It's always busy. And there no delivery. (Isn't that in itself a sign of a fantastic pizza shop?!) order ahead and come early. Leave with a delicious smelling, steaming hot ooey gooey cheesy pie. The chicken cheese steaks here are okay too. The wing sauce has improved. The wings are served dry with sauce on the side. I've got other favorites in town for sandwiches, salads and wings. They have about 8 tables inside and friendly staff. A whole other entity and review is their attached restaurant, Pasta Pomodoro, which is also fantastic. read more

Pizza tastes great. I've been going here since I was a teen. I've had my orders messed up numerous times though. Missing toppings or not well done. Heck 2 times I've had 2 pizzas undercooked which should of been well done. One time they rushed because I called at 7:30 not knowing they close at 8... why not just not take my order? They need to have better quality control and read the tickets better. A whole pepperoni pizza with half sausage should have pepperoni on the whole thing and sausage only in half not half of each. read more

The 3 cheesesteaks were delicious. The customer service needs improving. I was the only customer and I stood at the counter while 4 employees just and ignored me. Then, after I was served, the guy immediately walked away. I asked one of the other employees for sweet and hot peppers. He walked back into the kitchen and returned with 3 packs of sweet peppers. I said to him may I have 1 pack of hot peppers for my son. He got annoyed and said he would have to charge me, even though I tried to return one of the sweet peppers. He walked back into the kitchen and never came back out! I stood there waiting several minutes. When I was getting In my car I watched him come back out. Wow, I don't care how good the food is if you treat customers like dirt. I paid $27 for 3 cheesesteaks. Give me a pack of hot peppers without an flipping attitude. Now I do not want to go back. read more

Best pizza in the township. The closest you can get to boardwalk pizza without the tolls. The cheese steaks have been hit or miss lately. Not bad but when you live close to Philly your standards are a bit higher. The fries are good but they do have a tendency to over cook them. read more

Best mozzarella cheese fries ever also great salads and other appetizers... the pizza is great but I'm not too fond of the crust but it's good quality ingredients just a different style. read more

Sals pizza is as good as it gets chicken parm sandwich is amazing pizza rocks good people there go get yours if your in the area I keep rolling around south jersey and these guys rock keep it up Sals ty read more

One of the best pizzas I've ever had in my life. The family that works there are great people. The girl that works there cuts the pizza for my little boy just the way he likes it. I especially love their Eggplant Parmagiana, and if you ask anyone at Sal to add or take anything on the menu, they gladly will. If you haven't come here for the pizza you're definitely missing out! read more

The greatest pizza on the planet. I have been going there since I was a child. The owners are some of the nicest people I've ever met and have become like family. I live in Florida now and miss this place a lot! Especially around Christmas. read more

I love their cheesesteaks! They're so good! This place is one of my go to spots for cheesesteaks!

I'm a pizza snob and Sal's fits the bill! The sauce is absolutely delicious and it always tastes fresh. The grandma pizza is my favorite and is great for a change of pace from a traditional pie. It's not just the pizza either, everything is absolutely delicious! I 10/10 recommend. read more

The pizza is delicious. Great crust,dough is fresh as well as all of the ingredients. Grandmas pizza is amazing!! Full of flavor and the sausage is that shaved type and talk about flavor It's full of it! In the mood for a plain slice no problem it's just as amazing as the resp of their food. The staff is very friendly and actually remember you and talk to the customers as if you were family. read more

Absolutely the best pizza you can get in South Jersey. The sauce is absolutely delicious and always tastes fresh. The crust is always amazing and crispy. I cannot recommend Sal's enough to my friends and family. read more

I've been eating here since I was a little girl and I love that my kids get to eat here too! Best pizza in South Jersey!

I love this place. No delivery which sucks but their pizza makes everything better!! Huge skies for a good price. The crust is just the right crispness and there is a great ratio between sauce and cheese read more

Great food. They've been in town as long as I can remember and still owned by the same family. Typical Pizza Shop menu. The pizza is consistently good, which i think is the most important quality of a good pizza place. anyone can make a good pizza, but can you make the same quality pizza on a busy friday when the place is slammed with orders. Sal's rarely disappoints. Oh, and try the cheesesteaks, Little known secret, they're actually quite good. read more

Sals pizza. Grew up on it and if you want me to shed a lil memory this was the first place my mother let me drive to when I first got my license. Great place. Consistent. This is Washington Township. Were famous for our little Italy pizza shops but this one stands out to me. Love their pizza can't go wrong ! read more

Service was so-so. I felt like I was bothering someone by ordering 2 Sicilian slices and a large coke for me and my daughter on a Wednesday for lunch. No "thank you" and an eye roll when I asked for a corner piece. It wasn't crowded by any means. Pizza was okay (not many other menu choices). Nothing memorable about it. We stopped here because we were hungry after my daughters orthodontist appointment. Unless we're right in the area and really hungry again, I won't be making an effort to come back. read more

One of the few places left in township to get a good steak since DiStefano's closed. Nice about of chopped steak. i got the pizza steak and hubz got the regular cheese steak. Very good was ready when told. Been here many times and will go back many times. read more