Mamey Mexican Taqueria

My second time at Swell Taco (I absolutely live for the good foodie finds in Babylon Village) was,…read morefor lack of a better word, *swell.* (I just had to do it, hehe.) We sat in their insulated outdoor area amidst string lights and beachy vibes, and every meal starts out with their addicting tortilla chips and salsa verde. (Pro-tip -- save some of this green salsa to have with whatever you order!) We tried their chicken flautas appetizer, and if you are a fan of all that is cheesy and crispy, you will definitely enjoy this one. My favorite item on the menu was next -- the Crunch and Munch ground beef taco -- this literally was an elevated version of Taco Bell's cheesy Gordita crunch, and it made me super happy. We also shared their shredded beef burrito (think barbacoa), which was a Saturday special, but honestly, any of their burritos would be worthwhile. (I dare say that the burritos also feel kind of light? They are not over-the-top in the best way possible!) If you're looking for a casual taco spot after a day at Robert Moses or Overlook Beach (or any day, really), definitely check this place out -- you will fall in love after the first flavorful bite.

There's a reason this is a cult classic in Babylon! Year after year, Swell Taco continues to…read moredeliver tasty bites and a chill surfer aesthetic. I grew up in the Babylon area but my fiancé didn't so when I introduced him to Swell Taco he could not believe this hidden gem was on Long Island. The tacos are yummy and come in a great variety and the prices cannot be beat. He cannot wait for our next chill date night here!

See all

Loaded Nachos

Del Fuego

3.7(601 reviews)

food was amazing and the waitress was very nice. game was on let's go Colombiaread more

Staff was genuinely very friendly. We did have trouble trying to find someone when we wanted to…read morepack up the leftovers and pay the bill. Food was made using fresh ingredients. The Citrus salad had a lot of greens and what felt like a WHOLE sliced avocado under the added tuna protein. The Diablo wings were hotter than hot in a good way. The guacamole and chips was a large portion. It needed a squeeze of lime. The tuna burrito bowl was filling. The complimentary chips and salsa was much appreciated. They have a rewards program that offers you $20 after sign up, you can't beat that! And you also can get a $10 birthday rewards. Different days also has different specials. Next time we'll order some drinks, chips and watch the game on one of the many TV's.

Complimentary nachos

Virgin strawberry dacquiri

See all

Three mushroom quesidilla

Taco Fresco Mexican Street Food

4.4(58 reviews)

0.1 mi

Food was a 10/10 I've been trying to find a Mexican restaurant that hits the spot for me and I can…read moresay this one really did. The service was quick with a very welcoming, kind and professional environment. No complaints The restaurant is beautiful and full of color which made the experience even more enjoyable, if you're like me and love Mexican food this is definitely the spot.

I came here with friends for Cinco de Mayo, and it ended up being exactly the kind of spot you hope…read moreto stumble into on a day like that. Everything had that fresh, made to order feel that immediately sets the tone for a great meal. The place was booming and the staff was so welcoming! The fish taco really stole the show. The batter on the fish was light, crisp, and perfectly golden. None of that heavy, greasy coating you sometimes get. It had a really clean crunch that let the fish itself shine, and every bite tasted fresh and beyond flavorful with the cabbage and crema on top. The carne asada mulitas were just as impressive. Rich, savory, and layered with flavor, with that perfect combo of melted cheese and grilled meat tucked into the house made tortillas. And the drinks tied everything together. The margaritas were super fresh and well-balanced, especially the spicy piña. No pre-made sour mix or after taste! You could tell everything was made with real ingredients bright, refreshing, and just the right kick of heat to keep it interesting. Overall, it was the perfect Cinco de Mayo stop! Great energy, fresh food, and standout flavors across the board. I will definitely be a regular here!

Hand-Made Corn Tortillas

See all

Elote - Mexican Street Corn

Besito Mexican Restaurant - West Islip

4.0(386 reviews)

0.7 mi

Delicious food, top quality service and a ton of options for everyone including me as a vegetarian!…read moreIt's a beautiful restaurant with tons of great ambiance and my group thoroughly enjoyed every single item we ate! Thank you to the general manager and waitstaff for making us feel so welcome.

Had a great experience at Besito in West Islip. The place is beautiful and the food is…read moredelicious--my favorite is the guacamole. I was expecting it to be prepared tableside like at the Huntington location, but I understand the space here is a bit smaller. Service is good though. The salmon was especially excellent, and overall everything was flavorful. Will definitely be coming back!

See all

A refreshing margarita with a chili-salt rim, paired with fresh guacamole for a perfect meal.

Cebollines

4.4(83 reviews)

2.2 mi

This place pleasantly surprised us…read more Not your typical "Mexican" restaurant. We walked in during karaoke and barely saw any Hispanics in there which, in a Mexican restaurant, that tends to be a red flag... but LET ME TELL YOU.... They have gained another repeat family of customers! The service was good, everyone was super accommodating and attentive. The drinks were top notch ! We had the coconut margarita and it was one of the best we've ever had, no exaggeration. We also had the carnitas tacos 10/10, steak tacos 10/10 and steak nachos 8/10. Their green sauce was super flavorful and accompanied all the dishes very nicely. The karaoke was actually also very entertaining! We joined in at one point singing from our table as we enjoyed our meals. We'll definitely be back!

The service is good and the ambience is nice. The portions are small for the price. I want them…read moreto succeed because there is nothing else like them in Lindenhurst.

Friday night

See all

The Local

3.9(218 reviews)

Wanted to go to a place with good apps and non meat . This is essentially a sports bar across the…read morestreet from the train station. The noise volume is fairly loud, if that is an issue for you . The food however was delicious! And we were able to have a variety of vegetarian dishes! My favorite was the perogie appetizer with ford onions and cheese, really great. As were the dried pickles , the GUAC and chips and the tuna tacos. Service was good. There are all high top tables and a few outdoor tables to sit. They didn't exactly have a children's menu but they offered hamburgers, chicken fingers or Mac and cheese.

Grabbed a quick bite with my teenager. We were so full from the appetizers and had to wrap up the…read moremain sandwiches lol. This place is always a hit for us. A little tricky with the parking but there's an app where you can pay your numbered spot. The server helped us out which was a huge plus! The portions are huge here (hence the take out). My son loved the skillet Mac n cheese and the buffalo chicken egg rolls were so filling. For dinner I had the black bean burger and was quite pleased. It was topped with avocado, red onion, tomato, sauce and the patty was homemade and full of flavor. Special shout out to the truffle fries yum yum yum! My son enjoyed the steak sandwich for dinner no complaints!

Beer list

Smashville Chicken Sandwich Drunken Burrata Flatbread Sliced Steak Sandwich Fried Chicken Sandwich Local Specialty

See all

Drink menu

Nzgrei Taqueria Grill Mexican Food

4.5(17 reviews)

0.0 mi

This is the kind of Mexican taqueria you need to visit…read more Forget the contemporary fancy restaurants, you want small spots like this for the authentic food. I know it wont be for everyone but I'm telling you DO NOT sleep on these small low frills spots. It's some of the best food from the best people. The moment I walked in I knew it was going to be excellent. The look of the store, the smell, the drinks, and the hot sauces. Service was very good and with a big smile. I ordered 3 tacos. Chicken, pastor, and steak. All were very good. Chicken may have been one of the best chicken tacos ive ever had. Jonathan also brought over a birria taco to sample(will be getting 3 of them next time). Will be back 1000%.

It's a little tough to sit inside, the tables and chairs are a bit of a mismatch. It is also small…read moreinside like a deli, just keep this in mind if you're looking for a place to dine in. The food however was delicious! The guacamole had a very nice limey punch and fresh taste. I had the fish tacos, they were so tasty- definitely plan on ordering them again!

The Al Pastor was the first smell that hit me.

See all

The Brixton

4.3(443 reviews)

I have been here many times over the years and always enjoy their creative dish options and…read moreinteresting flavor combinations. The staff is great and there is a lovely bar area in the front. Nice outdoor space in the back during warmer weather. Excellent drinks and a causal yet elevated vibe.

They serve only small bites, so we ended up ordering several dishes, all ofn which wer delicious…read more Our server, I think his name was Sal , was very personable. Service was fast. I would recommend it and go again.

The bar at the brixton, Babylon

Garlic Cajun shrimp

See all

6 years later and the place has never disapointed. It's the perfect spot to spend with close friends.

Bang Bang Burritos

3.9(93 reviews)

1.5 mi

What a hidden wonder! "Bang Bang Burritos" was not even on my radar until today. Now I wish I went…read moresooner. This place is worth your attention. Parking Is easy with plenty of shared space, I really liked that. Heading to the building you notice a theme. Very bright and festive. The green makes me want avocados. Inside the place was immaculate. They definitely cared. At the counter the staff were incredibly friendly. The one lady in the back particularly. I sat down to wait for my order, but she walked it right over. When I asked for a sauce to dip my nachos, she gave me a list and recommended a good one. I appreciate the details. But not as much as I loved that burrito. This thing needed its own zip code. It left nothing to be desired. This monster had it all. It also tasted better than it looked. One of the best burritos I've had in a while. Trust me when I tell you I'll be back. There are so many choices I want to try. Also, it doesn't hurt that the staff, are there to help with dipping sauces.

So good, been there twice and every time the seasoning is on point! Service is kind, ambiance at…read morethis location is more like a quick grab and go, there are small tables to sit though and a high counter with tall chairs. To me- it has a more authentic Mexican seasoning than other Mexican-American food in West Islip/Bab. Area

Steak Fajita Burrito

See all

Hermanas Kitchen and Cocktails

4.7(210 reviews)

2.6 mi

Foodie 'Sisters' and Brothers, Hermanas Kitchens & Cocktails should be visited by those whom seek…read moreexceptional Hispanic, Spanish, Latin flavors with handcrafted flare to make your tastbuds pop with every bite and sip! The location might seem small, but it's jammed packed with traditional flavors that are being executed to perfection. Can't believe I waited this long living in the neighborhood (2+yrs) to finally stroll in and experience what some might say is 'Pura Vida' or !Magnífico¡ Upon first visit, I had to try one of their margaritas and at least one 'Street food' menu item, so opted for their Pear Margarita and Birria Empanadas. Let's say Bravo, Brava and Encore to explore more of their menu. The cocktail was totally on point without being overpowering in any way, very balanced and brightly refreshing. The empanadas were deliciously crispy without being greasy, stuffed and sealed perfectly. Then opted to try their Mashed Potatoes Fries and requested a side of their advertised Shishito slaw seen topping another menu item. I loved the way they created and presented both. The fries were a perfect balance of soft but crisped with the creme drizzle and pickled onions. :* The Shishito slaw was a summery, crunch lightly dressed which has me wanting and requesting more the next visit. They should definitely add that as one of their regular listed sides. My husband had a burger with regular slaw and an old fashioned styled cocktail which he mentioned to be exceptional as well. Can't wait to dive deeper into their menu and would highly recommend to others.

Another amazing experience! Staff is the absolute best. Never had a better quality margarita…read moreever!!! Had the spicy passion fruit and pear margaritas this time and both were 10/10. Cajun lime wings were to die for as always and loved the yucca fries. We can't stay away!

How cute is this bathroom?

A different quesadilla every Wednesday. (Only on Wednesdays.)

See all

Sirloin Steak

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Linda W.

9 years ago

Very good and fresh! I had the shrimp and salmon soft tacos and they were excellent. My husband had the chicken flautas and they were crispy and good. My tacos were better. Excellent value and great service. This is quick serve (order at the counter) or take out. read more

Michael R.

4 years ago

This restaurant never disappoints, always fresh and always delicious. You are out of your mind if you have any complaints about this restaurant. Highly recommend! read more

Meredith L.

9 years ago

Wonderful staff and absolutely delicious fresh food. Been coming here for a few months and I can't get enough!

Lois S.

9 years ago

Excellent tacos! So fresh. Will definitely be back

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - tacos - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Mamey Mexican Taqueria also viewed

Taco Fresco Mexican Street Food

(58 reviews)

Tito's Birrias and grill

(44 reviews)

We ordered take out. The meat I got was a little tuff. The guacamole is out of control delicious…read moreThe street corn was also really good. In one order you get two cobs

I had ordered here the other day for delivery I was really excited to try. We ordered a single…read morebirria taco with no onions separate from 2 regular ones. They had put them in the same box, even though they were ordered separately. Also only cane with one birria sauce, when ordered separately. When you do not want to share a dip with someone else, kind of inconvenient. The beef empanadas were nothing too crazy. Kind of average. The guacamole was heavily citrus flavored. I put it in my fridge and it didn't even turn brown after 2 days which I found odd for guacamole/avocados. The bean and cheese pupusa was okay as well. Nothing too amazing. I'd like to try other things next time.

KTO Cuisine

4.7

(72 reviews)

I was doing laundry a few doors over from this restaurant and wanted something to munch on. I…read morebriefly looked through their menu and what piqued my interest was their a la carte tostadas. I knew immediately that I wanted one but which one? Well everyone raves about the birria so I made my choice. My tostada was made fresh, the shell still a little warm from the grease and crispy. The birria was good but it kind of just tastes like a basic stewed beef to me, unremarkable. The guacamole was nice and fresh... but! It was way over salted. I had to brush quite a bit off because paired with the birria it was a salt bomb. Also I love cheese but I wasn't feeling the cheese on this one. It didn't have much flavor so it felt like it was there for the sake of it, I took it off. Now the tostada tasted good after my alterations but it shouldn't be better after removing ingredients. I would like to try another tostada, maybe their al pastor? And I'd hope their guacamole is appropriately salted.

Talk about a hole in the wall amazeballs place! The smell when you walk in makes you want to order…read more1 of everything on the menu!! My favorite was definitely the Birria tacos. We had steak and pastor tacos. Mom had the steak tostadas crunchy and delicious. My dad is picky and eats like a child so he has the fried wings and French. He said both were great. Last but not least kids had cheese quesadilla and chicken with white rice. Overall this was an amazing meal for all and will be going back again.

Don Juan Pupuseria

4.5

(22 reviews)

Cant say enough about this place. Came with my daughter for an early breakfast. Made a nice big…read moreplate of rice, beans, stewed chicken and empanada. No frills - they put it on a paper plate for you - and it's authentic and delicious to the last bite. We ended up getting a second plate. And the people working there were so kind. $8 plate can't beat it. Highly recommend!

It's a very simple restaurant with a few tables. A lot of food is out, pre cooked/buffet style and…read moreyou tell them what you'd like. We moved here 3 weeks ago and I've been craving rice and beans and flautas so we decided to try it out! We've already been 3 times and I can't get enough! The rice and beans are perfect-perfect consistency and flavor. This last time, my husband an ordered a large container of beans and rice and a taco de lengua. The taco was the most flavorful we've honestly had and the corn tortilla was super thin and delicious! We will definitely continue coming back. The service is great, although we did quickly learn they're primarily Spanish speaking, but each time we've gone, another customer has helped translate, which was so so sweet. I've got to gain some confidence and try my Spanish out with google translates help . Also, the prices are extremely reasonable!

Garcia's Taco Bar

3.1

(70 reviews)

We called ahead of time so we didn't have to wait. We ordered a burrito, a shuco with carne asada…read moreand a mango drink. Everything was tasty and flavorful. The service provided over the phone was good. The people at the bus location were great as well!!! Definitivamente recomendado! La comida deliciosa y el sabor muy bueno!

I got the Birria Ramen came with corn tortillas jalapeño limes cheese in the bottom bottom it was…read moreabsolutely hot and delicious. Delicious a meal for two. I also got the pupusa that came with pickled cabbage and that was delicious. Also, I highly recommend.

Tito's Birrias

3.6

(10 reviews)

I have been wanting to try this place and tonight I DID!! WOW it's good. Best birria taco I've…read morehad and the sweetest most helpful girls behind the counter! -- at Tito's Birrias & Grill.

I pass by Tito's Birrias a few times in DP and when I finally stopped in I wasn't able to eat…read morebecause the cannot accommodate my food allergies due to only one grill. I found out they opened a second location in WB. I called over to my surprise they were able to accommodate my food allergies. I headed over right away. The dining space is spacious and the staff was friendly. I ordered a corn and birria tacos. I went straight home to try it. The birria tacos were ok. The corn was very cold. Which stinks because to warm it up meant everything on it melted to.

Cochinita Porky

(42 reviews)

Finally made it back to Cochinita Porky, and I am THRILLED to report than my one prior bad…read moreexperience a couple years ago was an anomaly. I ordered my old fave, the al pastor taco, and this time the meat was perfect and it reminded my of why its my favorite taco on LI. I also gave their birria taco a try and it was delicious. Anyway, so happy

I have been passing this distinctive pink truck for YEARS but haven't stopped till recently. The…read morebiggest issue I have is finding someplace to park. The truck is in a very crowded and busy parking lot for an automobile service facility. There is a big parking lot across the street but then you have to try and get across Long Island Avenue to place your order. Fortunately for me, I can usually find some place to squeeze in my motorcycle by the truck itself. I've read a lot of reviews of this truck so finally had to stop in and give it a try and I am SO glad I did. This could be my new favorite "Taco Spot" near my office. First time I stopped I tried their Birria Tacos and quickly decided they're at least as good as the ones I get from Taqueria el Sabor Poblano in Hicksville. Today I tried three different tacos: Chicken, Sausage and BBQ pork. All three were GREAT! Because of their lower overhead, it costs less than what I get from the place in Hicksville and the tacos are every bit as good. I'll definitely be back again and again.

Empanadas and More

4.6

(144 reviews)

Listen, I saw an abuelita packing up orders and knew this place was still going to hit after all…read morethese years. Granted I have come to Empanadas and More a few times since my last visit. This time around, I ordered the chicken soup, shrimp and potatoes empanada and a few Columbian snacks. The prices may be a bit higher, but the portions have not skimped in the slightest. The soup was pretty much 2/3rds chicken and in this economy? Not complaining at all. It even came with the lil cob of corn again! The shrimp and potato empanada was filled with fluffy potatoes and shrimp. Make sure you get the hot sauce to drizzle over. Its like cholula with actual heat and makes a great addition to the nada. Its still pick up and go. And service is quick and efficient. But still cannot recommend this place enough.

Beef empanadas are my absolute favorite- the have so many great mixes which i try a new one every…read moretime but always have to get 1 beef

El Nopal Deli

3.4

(12 reviews)

Best burritos ever , los mejores burritos que e probado , son enormes y tienen buen saborread more

I ordered 4 pupusas revueltas and 2 with cheese and beans. The pupusas had almost nothing inside…read morethey were empty. Not enough cheese and meat and the bean and cheese the same. I can't speak for the rest of the food they offer but whatever you do. Don't waste your hard earned money on their pupusas!!! You've been warned!

Chicos Tex Mex