Wasn't gonna leave a review but the owner was rude and argued with me about the food I brought back. Ordered two empanadas. To put it lightly it was gross- over fried and empty literally air In The middle a spot of cheese or beef in both. Just a big pocket of dough called up she told me to bring back then the owner I assume said he's never had anything returned in 15 years lol amd he said thanks for the complaint amd gave my money back . Nice customer service. Never will go there again. read more

Chicken quesadilla for $10+ has barely any chicken. What chicken it does have is dry and flavorless. The cheese tastes like Kraft Mexican Mix shredded cheese. It comes with a tiny cup of funny tasting, extra salty sour cream. No chips. No guac. No pico. No salsa. No hot sauce. read more

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - Terrible , over priced quesadilla. Barely any chicken and it doesn't come with guac or even pico, salsa or hot sauce. - Tacos Near Me - Babylon, New York

The shrimp tacos are the best!! Not too many places know how to marinate and cook shrimp. The burritos are really good too but the shrimp tacos are my favorite. read more

Authentic and they have corn tortillas for me! (Gluten Free). I've had the Carne Asada-a must! Chicken and shrimp too. Service is great, food makes my belly happy and full! Guacamole is also of course in my list and hits the spot. If I'm around the village I like stopping here fir a bite : ) read more

Todo es perfecto aquí. El servicio es muy bueno todos simpáticos. El ambiente es muy chill y siente como estás en un lugar muy auténtico (porque es!). La comida siempre es muy fresca y el sabor es muy rico. Mis favoritos son los tacos y el guacamole. Lo recomiendo! read more

A solid 3.5 stars but I'm rounding up to 4 because of the excellent customer service me & my son received from the 2 counter girls & the cook who I am assuming is the owner also. Plus it's a pretty new business. Kinks have to be worked out. To be expected. The Good: 1. Sons steak burrito was delicious he said. Henceforth no pic. He devoured it. Filled with steak & tightly rolled. 2. They have tongue tacos. Yay! 3. My Steak Nachos were plentiful. The steak was seasoned perfectly to my taste preference. Lots of cheese sauce, beans & jalapeños. The Not So Good But Easily Remedied: 1. Tongue tacos had no flavor & were not tender enough. 2. No sauce was given for Burrito or Nachos just a very small container of sour cream. 3. The green & red sauce given for my tacos were TINY. If I didn't get both I wouldn't have enough for both tacos. Plus both sauces lacked flavor. The packets of Cholula hot sauce saved them. Soooo would I go back? Hell yeah! The steak Nachos & Burrito were delicious. I'd like to see how the pork & shrimp tastes. Plus the owner & staff were amazingly accommodating so I know to ask for more sauce next trip. Overall a win in my book. I hope they stick around. 9-16-2017 read more

See all

Been here a couple of times and find the food tasteful, fresh, and well prepared. Staff is friendly. read more

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - the front of a mexican restaurant - Tacos Near Me - Babylon, New York

Haven't ordered takeout in a while but got home late from work and just didn't have it in me to fuss in the kitchen-- and then I remembered Mamey-- so so delicious! I love the Sopes! I usually go for the chicken sopes which I haven't found anywhere else in NY (but were always a menu favorite when I lived in AZ and would go out for Mexican food there) love the fresh grated cheese, shredded lettuce, & diced tomato on top! Authentic, delicious, fresh, and always satisfies! Also recommend the horchata which goes so well w the spicy chicken on the sopes. Will definitely order again and again! read more

The food- phenomenal! The service- fast! The employees- unbelievably sweet! One of the best Mexican Restaurants around! read more

This place is a family-owned gem, and the owners are very kind. We get takeout and it always tastes fresh and homemade. Great guacamole. Ask for sauces - they're good. Its clean inside, and they are careful and courteous about adhering to health and safety guidelines I highly recommend the nachos! read more

Always one of my go to spots to get tacos from. Quality ingredients. I love the shrimp. The salmon is good too, but I recommend the shrimp if you're going for fish. Love the tostadas and my bf loves the burritos as well. I'll definitely continue ordering from there! read more

I saw this place from the train platform and knew I'd have to come back to try it. It's run by a really nice couple making wholesome food. I tend to have low expectations in Suffolk County when it comes to anything other than pizza or bagels, so I had my doubts about this place. But I was pleasantly surprised. I got three tacos. I always get lengua and al pastor when I try a new taco place and I couldn't resist getting a chorizo taco as well. While a far cry from what you'd get in Queens or in Southern California, the tacos were pretty good for this area. There was a generous portion of tongue, although the lengua flavor was minimal and it was less tender than I'm used to. A little lime helped bring out the flavor. The al pastor was decent, but was way too salty. It got so salty that I couldn't finish the taco. I also prefer the pineapple being a thin slice added on top instead of diced and cooked in, but that's just a preference. The pineapple flavor became too pronounced and covered the flavor of the pork. The chorizo taco was a total miss for me. The filling was not chorizo. It was an Americanized chorizo sausage link cut up into cubes. It was one of the stranger tacos I've ever had. I expect chorizo to be almost like ground meat, with some grease and a lot of flavor. This "chorizo" was none of those things. They might as well have gone to the market, bought chicken and apple sausage, and used that to make a taco. The highlight of the meal was the horchata. They make the horchata in-house and it was delicious. It was creamy with generous cinnamon flavor. It was rich and the kind of horchata that you have to mix each time you take a sip or it starts to separate. It was a nice contrast to the rich tacos. Mamey was a bit more expensive than I expected. I'm used to $1 tacos in Southern California or $2-2.50 tacos in Queens. Here, the lengua and the al pastor were $4 each. And the chorizo was $3. This place was definitely "Americanized" to fit the area. They call the lengua taco the "run your mouth" taco and they use that weird chorizo. But it's more authentic than what you can get from Del Fuego or Swell Taco in the area. This is a nice, safe, and clean place to get some real tacos instead of the mess you get from Del Fuego. read more

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - Horchata made in-house - Tacos Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Mamey is a fairly new spot to Babylon right by the train station. My parents are usually pretty particular about Mexican food and when they raved about it I was excited to give them a shot. The food is consistently delicious. The Al Pastor Tacos are hands down the best item on the menu. Typically get their quesadillas and burritos which never fail. My mom loves their Spring Salad so if you're feeling something lighter that's another option. Last but not least, the owners are beyond friendly. They know you by name, and truly care about the way they represent themselves to the community. For those in quarantine looking for a pickup or delivery option, you've found it at Mamey's. read more

Cute place right off the train!!! We got 2 drinks, 4 tacos altogether chips and guac and our order was less than 20$! That's not all! Everything is made fresh! The guacamole was delish! Cilantro and lime, onions in it! The best guac I've ever had!!! And I know my guac... The meat is fresh!!!! Authentic tacos, with cilantro, they give you a fresh lime to use if you so choose! And onions! Also red or green sauce. Only thing is if you like cheese on your taco like me just need to ask for it! My husband and I will come here again! It's good for a quick bite, they have a seating area, also participate in Uber eats! read more

Eh tacos were fresh but very plain and lacked flavor. I wasn't impressed. We tried the trio (chicken, steak and carnitas) and chorizo and shrimp. The tacos were only topped with tiny amount of onion and cilantro. For 5 tacos they also only gave us two tiny containers of salsa. If you are one of those people who likes their food very plain without any seasoning or sauces then this place is for you. If you are like me, and like a lot of toppings, dressing and seasoning then you won't be impressed. Also the parking situation isn't great here. read more

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - Tacos Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

We went in here with my brother in law. He swore it was good but unfortunately it really wasn't. I am giving 3 stars because the staff was really nice. I had a salad with black beans and cheese. I asked for extra cheese, of course the usual case they didn't give me enough cheese so I had to ask for more. They were nice they gave me more when I asked for it. Unfortunately the salad wasn't really all that good. My husband didn't really like his food either. We don't understand why my brother in law loves it. Sorry staff of Mamey because you guys are very nice. read more

Have picked up take out from there every month or so. Never disappointed. Would go there more if I were closer

AUTHENTIC MEXICAN SPOT! The prices are so good but what's even better is how delicious the the food is. Our favorite thing to get there is the Al Pastor tacos and Chicken Enchiladas with green sauce. Can't forget the churros either. They are soft and not too crunchy. They give you a side of melted fudge so drizzle over them. I've been getting food from them for the past 1 1/2 years and everything from the tortas to the tostadas to the variety of tacos is just sooo good. You can only order takeout at this time so we just take it home but it travels well. The staff is always nice. It's right next to the Babylon train station which is how we found this place so please visit next time you are thinking of ordering Mexican takeout. read more

See all

I just had lunch here and it was decent. I got the taco trio and thought it was bland. The chicken taco was my least favorite and the steak taco was my favorite. The prices are great. My friend tried the Birria Tacos and said they were amazing. I would come back here and try something else next time! read more

I like this place a lot. It's a very small family place and everything is like homemade. The quality is very nice, everything we order is always delicious. We usually get takeout here because it's so small that there's really only a handful of tables to sit at which is fine for lunch. It's immaculate inside, and the ingredients are all fresh, you can tell it is made with care and love. The people are very nice here it seems to be a family. read more

Delicious and very fresh, a hidden treasure in Babylon. Food tastes very much home-made, light compared to other places with similar food. By default it's mild, but they offer sauces to drive up the spicy level depending on what you like. Very nice people too, they have been excellent with their Covid precautions through all of it as well, and I wish nothing but the best for them. read more

This place should have more stars. If you want Some GOOD and REAL tacos or tostadas etc, go here. I always end up craving this place on nights we order in. Their food is consistent, tastes delicious and this little stop by the Babylon train has great service inside and even better when you grab a seat and enjoy a meal straight out of the kitchen. Their steak tostadas with a cold Jarrito and some warm churros for dessert are my go to favorites from here. read more

Ive been wanting to try this new Mexican place. What a disappointment. I got 2 tacos. One carnita, and one beef I think. I also got a chimichanga and couldn't tell what kind of mushed meat it was. The tacos have little pieces of tiny diced meat. ?? Whats up with that. The Guacamole is black and brown and definitely not fresh. I also got chips to go with the Guac. The chips were the only part of the meal i could eat. Also the guac came in a tiny 4oz container. The pico salsa came in a 2oz container and the salsa verde came in a scamp 1 0z container. I will upload a pic. I definitely prefer Swell, Or Pico. read more

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - Tacos Near Me - Babylon, New York

Food is always amazing. Except this time I ordered off of their website because I was sent a coupon code, the delivery fee was $8, yes $8 and the delivery was routed by them to Uber Eats. Meanwhile, on Uber Eats itself, the delivery fee is .49 cents. Delivery time got pushed back a few times due to my 3 tacos taking so long to prepare. read more

Their food is so fresh. It is made to order. Try their Tres Leches cake; it's amazing!

First time ordering from Mamey and it was great! Al pastor tacos and shrimp tacos, chips n guac, churros with chocolate sauce!!! What?? Stop it. It was really friggen delicious. Easy order and accurate delivery via Ubereats. My new go to. Thanks Mamey!! read more

Small Mexican eatery outside the Babylon train station with only three tables so take out is the better option. For me, the food was just mediocre at best. Tried the beef enchiladas which had a slightly spicy red sauce on top but the meat was a tad underwhelming and the rice on the side was a bit crunchy. Also tried a carnitas taco which only got its flavor from the onion, cilantro and lime juice I sprinkled on it. Service, however, is very welcoming and nice and prices are low. Not my favorite Mexican take out, but you'll be warmly greeted at least. read more

See all

5 stars for their nachos. One for their flautas. So my math that is cinco minus uno. Much much better than del fuego's nachos.

Their was no wait at all, the lady at the register was very polite and helpful and the food was delicious, definitely will be coming back soon :)! read more

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - Cheese Quesadilla was phenomenal! - Tacos Near Me - Babylon, New York

Sooooo good!!! Love that it's a family run place! They were so sweet and attentive. The food was great!!! I love Mexican food and it's hard to find anything close to authentic and that is not a chain. My daughter who is super picky, ate all of her food!!! So I am deff coming back! read more

Mamey Mexican Taqueria - Tacos Near Me - Babylon, New York

Hey listen I've seen some of these reviews and do t know how long ago they were or if the reviews were after a night out drinking or maybe they were minutes away from dying due to starvation? Who knows but let me tell you-I stopped at this place after getting off the train in Babylon. The place was empty which was great at the time since I would be in and out. When I got home and opened the food i knew I'd never go back there..the worst tacos I ever had. I remade them!! The ground meat had 0 flavor no seasoning onions tomatoes Nothing!! I couldn't believe it. The worst in Mexican food history. Now, about a hundred feet away on the same block, ironically is another Mexican spot! I walked past Mamays (it's always empty!) to go to this other Mexican spot literally a hundred feet away on the same block and whats even crazier is that the food is official!! It doesn't even make sense how Mamay's is still in business with this other Mexican spot next door?! read more

I was craving authentic tacos ... I was trying to get my hubby to drive me to 108 street in queens to this amazing taco truck ... he said no obviously and he googled and found this spot . I was reluctant thinking it would be Americanized Mexican food ... was I pleasantly surprised . It's authentic ... as good as the food truck if not better. There is a lady who works there such a sweetheart . She noticed I was indecisive and she gave me recommendations. I love it when ppl are helpful. I basically had a little bit of everything . I recommend the steak tacos , the carnitas nachos ... guacamole and last but not least tres leches for dessert I also had a chicken taco and shrimp taco but by farm my favorite was steak and carnitas . read more

See all

It was very good. It's a very basic spot with very basic options. If your looking for a chicken quesadilla or taco Youl definitely enjoy it but it's not something i crave. The food is always good it just needs a little extra flavor to bring it to the top! read more

Wanted to support a local business I've never tried before and decided on Mamey. I ordered the carnita nachos, a steak quesadilla and a side of guacamole. Everyone knows take out nachos are a hit or miss and these were a hit! My quesadilla on the other hand was pretty underwhelming in regards to portion and taste. Guacamole was fresh but pretty small for the extra charge. read more

Just tried Mamey for the first time and everything was absolutely amazing!!! Chimichangas were on point!! Taco Salad Bowls also amazing!! Just gained a frequent customer!!! read more

Mamey's is sooo frickin good! It's like having street tacos and more from a nice super clean looking store front. I have been here maybe half a dozen times. Every time the food and the service was excellent!! One of my favorites is the Steak Chimichanga. There is nothing else like it. Last time I went I tried the Spring Salad. It was super fresh and the balsamic dressing was really good. Pork taco is also really good - very juicy and had a good amount of filling. Their guacamole is small but it has the perfect amount of lime balance. The side sauces are also small as others have stated. There are like 3 tables for 4 inside. I do their take out and there is absolutely no compromise to the high quality of their food when it gets home due to their attention to detail. Perfect location for Babylon train people. It's not meant to be a sit down dinner place. Prices should stay where they are...you get what you pay for here read more

Best Mexican food in town, fresh food and love the CHURROS delicious I give 5 stars Great service. read more

This is my favorite Mexican place in town. Everything is fresh and made to order. Their guacamole is off the hook amazing. The owner and staff are so hospitable. I look forward to eating here. Give it a try. It's soooo good. read more

Went a couple days ago with a friend and we ordered a little bit of everything to try things out. Atmosphere is cool and comfortable. It's great that it's right near the train station, and the food comes out pretty quick so if you want something good to eat before catching the train, check this place out. The guacamole is a little steep for the amount you get but, the food over all is awesome- more authentic Mexican than the Tex-Mex LI usually has. The chimichanga I had (with carnitas) was particularly great, as were the enchiladas. Service was great as well, I will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Delicious lunch and easy to order online which I love. Had a shrimp burrito and it was tasty. Also have had the veggie tostado which has avocado so good and fresh. I just needed more napkins in my bag lol read more