Andrew was great. I came yesterday for the first time and he suggested I have a burger I can't remember the exact burger but whew it was fantastic. I told him his review is based on his suggestion lol. And he delivered. Great guy kept me company at the bar. I would definitely recommend read more

Once again, fabulous customer service and tasty food! A sweet and super picky eater finished every last bite of her burger and fries - and wants to go back! I'm always too full for dessert, but they always have some scrumptious things listed. It's usually fairly busy, but worth any wait you may experience. read more

See all

My wife and I have attempted twice to dine and we're not happy with the service. First off neither time were we greeted with a hi/hello or even a how are doing.upon our first visit we were told it would be 30 to 40 minutes however this was during the week and there were many tables with no guests.The most recent time we received the same greeting and very rude young lady, took my wife and I to a table and just put the menu on the table and walked away. I think we're finished!! read more

Service was great and food was delicious! Went during a weekend morning and had to wait a little bit that is to be expected.. read more

This is a tiny establishment that has been around more than 20 years. It's family owned and they have a huge variety. It's a town favorite with plenty of parking. My turkey Ruben will never be the same without the apple dipping sauce that is so good. The girls are great servers and so kind! It's a super casual family place. read more

Main Street Cafe - Menu - American Near Me - Newtown, Ohio

Appetizers were great and so is the service. We ordered several appetizers before our lunch. The Mac and Cheese was very thick and creamy. The onion rings were crispy, hot, and delicious! The show stealer was the coleslaw though. I am usually not a fan of restaurant coleslaw because it usually is just cabbage in watery mayo. (You know what I'm talking about!) Not this stuff. Actually has flavor! We also ordered a reuben sandwich to split. We got both sauces but personally I thought it tasted better with mustard. Some brown or spicy mustard would have been better. You'll need some kind of sauce for the sandwich though. The bread was nicely toasted. We ended with a piece of the Italian Lemon Cream Cake. I love lemon so I was looking forward to this, but I couldn't taste any lemon. It's a fine cake otherwise. Reminds me of a lighter pound cake. read more

See all

Always really liked this place bc it's nice and homey with friendly servers and good food. It's a pleasant lunch spot especially. They have very good soups and sandwiches. Also they have a small bar right when you come in that is cozy. read more

Food and service are always great here! But, tonight's dessert was awesome. Look how beautiful the presentation of the whipped cream is by our server, Averi! So cool! read more

Main Street Cafe - Pumpkin Pie - American Near Me - Newtown, Ohio

The best chili and burgers The cup of chili is large and the burgers come with all the toppings.

Place was not crowded. Service was slow. Was told there was a rush. No rush was visible. Burgers, beers, mozzarella sticks, and kids meals were not worth the price. $98 for three adults and 2 kids before tip. Ordered the black and blue special that included bacon and grilled onions on the burger and chips. Burger came out without the grilled onions. It was the classic that took a while to get corrected because the waitress didn't come back. We usually enjoy The Main Street Cafe however tonight was a strikeout. read more

See all

Very small, quaint restaurant. Had music that night, don't know if that's normal, but was enjoyable. Food good but portions smaller than I'd have liked. read more

Food is very good. Atmosphere is very nice. Very friendly place. Well run and delicious food. One of my favorite places to eat.

They offer to switch sides and fail to mention additional cost of $3,50. Seems they are trained this way because I overheard every server fail to disclose upcharge and all off "switch" insteads of TRUTH They offer an upgrade. read more

very tasty burgers! Nice size portions and fresh tasting food all around. Good value for quality and size of portions also. Friendly neighborhood place.... small, casual atmosphere with a nice little bar. Just happened to pass by when we were hungry, looking for a place to eat, and very pleasantly surprised! The service was great and quick. We will definitely return. read more

Main Street Cafe - double Swiss burger with bacon and the works!! - American Near Me - Newtown, Ohio

A really great local place for burgers, chili , salads with good service. Like everything, prices are up but the food quality is very good! read more

My Mr has been here three times and raves about Main Street Cafe. I've been here 10 years ago and forget what I got but remembered that I had no complaints. Time to revisit. Went for lunch and they definitely follow the 6 foot rule and social distancing with the seating. Especially at the bar where we ended up sitting. They had very limited seating and didn't want to sit at a small table. Also, they sanitize the counters, tables and all employees are wearing masks. Our bartender was super friendly and very attentive. I started off with a glass of Noble Vines Cabernet Sauvignon and my Mr got a pint of Blue Moon. For lunch I ordered the Boursin Cheeseburger ($8.00) loaded with lettuce, pickles, Mayo and onion. It comes with chips, but subbed it for shoestring fries ($2.75). My Mr ordered a Rueben sandwich (you can choose between thousand island dressing or their house dressing) packed with corned beef, Swiss cheese, and sauerkraut on Toasted Rye Bread $7.75. Chips also comes with his meal. We got our meals less than 15 minutes. Wow! My burger was juicy and cooked to perfection. The Boursin cheese was amazing. I was going to give a portion of my burger to my Mr but I ended up leaving him two bites. It was that good. The fries was hot and not greasy. I tried my Mr's sandwich and the house dressing went well with the sandwich. A hint of sweetness that complimented well with rueben. Can't go wrong with sweet/salty. Overall the experience and service was awesome. I am glad we had lunch here. Definitely want to come back and actually get a rueben sandwich for myself. read more

See all

Very tasty food served up in a great atmosphere. I had the Rueben and it was very tasty, friend ordered ham and bean soup and said it was delicious. Recommended for a quick stop if you're on the bike trail! read more

Food is always good, the staff always friendly and attentive. The servers are always smiling and interacting comfortably with the customers. Main read more

The best burger in the area. Great vibes too. I asked for an ungodly amount of pickles on my burger and they delivered. I'm a happy girl.

Main Street Café knows what it is and doesn't shy away from that. The menu is small, a little predictable, but done well. If you're in the mood for a bowl of chili, a burger, or my personal favorite the buffalo chicken sandwich, you can't go wrong here. Because I only ever end up here at lunch time, though, I do wish there were one or two more vegetable-forward or just lighter things on the menu. A burger and fries in the middle of the day is not necessarily conducive to my afternoon productivity! Still, the food is solid, the people are nice, and there's something to be said for knowing what you're getting. read more

The food was fabulous!!! The server ,Casey was great !!! We got the Borsin Burger pizza soup ,& sweet potato sticks . All the food tasted GREAT!!!! We then had dessert which didn't disappoint at all! Our group had Strawberry Cake, Chocolate Cake, Key Lime pie & Blackberry Cream pie!! Highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Very good food and service. The staff are friendly and attentive to all your needs. The ambiance is causal. The deserts are homemade and to die for. read more

Great specials! Better desserts! Small and cozy atmosphere. They are not open on Mondays.

I've been hearing about Main Street Cafe for months from a co-worker and I was finally able to go to MSC during a work trip yesterday afternoon - and the hype was real! My co-worker (and others) have sworn by the chocolate cake at MSC and I was worried with all of the hype that it wouldn't live up to expectations. Wrong. It was totally worth it. The cake is very thick and is also topped AND filled with a thick, delicious chocolate frosting that is out of this world. I devoured the large piece of cake despite being full from my lunch. My eyes won the battle over my stomach. :) For my actual lunch, I got the Texas Onion burger - which was good. The onion ring had great flavor, as did the southwest sauce. I just feel like it was still missing something. I added a side of fries, which were standard shoestring fries. Perhaps, I will get a different side next time to add to my meal. Our service was great and we were seated immediately. As a funny side note, I was definitely the youngest patron here this day by about 50 years. :) read more

See all

I hadn't been here in years after I got honked-off for paying $5.75 for five onion rings they (then) had on "Special". Probably 5+ years later, now, onion rings are apparently on their normal menu. I decided to give them another shot, and they were at least a dollar cheaper. Upon walking into the restaurant tonight I was immediately smacked in the face with a very sour smell. This smell was the smell of a dish towel that has gone sour, but all throughout the place. Whew!! I was surprised there were people sitting in that stink. I just hoped my nose got used to it before I ate anything. They have 12 taps, I'd say about 50% locals, and no special/seasonal locals (unless you count Sam Adams). Bottle/can selection was pretty bad, existing in a land prior to craft brewers, most exotic being Stella Artois or Yuengling Light. Food was akin to their "sister restaurant," Zip's. Menu was fairly similar, burgers, metts, sandwiches, chili, fries, simple salads, Onion Rings, etc. Boursin burger is not something you'll find at Zip's, and it was pretty good! (Though the Boursin wasn't melted in, just kind-of scooped on top). Ambiance here is pretty simple/country style. This building used to be someone's home, I assume, as it looks like a house, and the rooms are about the size that you'd fine in one's home. Not my most gleaming review, but it wasn't necessarily bad, it wasn't necessarily good either. Though the service was good and attentive, putting them over the 50% hill for a 3 stars rating. I'd be back, but if I walked in and smelled that sour stink again, I'd turn right back around, not to return. Hopefully that was an anomaly! read more

Main Street Cafe - Boursin Burger and Onion Rings - American Near Me - Newtown, Ohio

See all

Great local restaurant. Specialty is burgers, but plenty of other options! Nice beer choices. Homemade desserts

This is the best restaurant in Newtown. The food and service are excellent. Enjoy food and drinks with friends lunch or dinner. The staff are welcoming and timely. read more

I just hopped in to this nice restaurant after I went to jungle Jim. It was nice and friendly, this quarantine is perfect for me to just sit in a quiet corner. It's clean and nice atmosphere. I had patron and Budweiser. Onion rings and chili. Can't wait to try their desert... it looks soooooo delish ! read more

See all

Charming place. Table for 3 for lunch on Saturday. Good crowd of very nice people. Food was very good. Reuben, Blue cheese burger, fries, chili and salad. Coppola wine is way too nice for a basic house wine at $8.75/glass. House wines should be around $6.50 and be anything but Barefoot wine. Also, server was very slow in delivering our 2nd glass of wine. Surprised to hear from our server that this place does not offer an N/A Beer option as one in our party does not drink and would have liked a beer. Please note that some of the YELP photos of this place seem to be from a different restaurant. read more

Good food and a cozy family run cafe. We've been here several times and will continue to come back.

Amazing amazing food service drinks atmosphere service , no complaints at all local and great I've tried two dishes and two drinks both times and I was not disappointed. read more

A classic all-American diner done RIGHT is how I'd begin to describe Main Street Cafe in Newtown, OH. Great spot for lunch, dinner with the family, or a date night with that special someone. That place itself isn't big at all, but what it lacks in size, it makes up for in character and flavor. Anyone could feel right at home with the cozy seating and super friendly staff. They have an excellent beer selection if you wanna start out with a good craft brew. Their menu isn't large but features great selections that anyone can enjoy. Sandwiches, salads, burgers, pasta, chili, and more. I stopped by here for a quick lunch and was definitely impressed from the start. I took a seat at the bar, where the bartender quickly greeted me with a smile, asking if it was my first time. I said yes, and he told me the specials of the day, as well as a few recommendations from the menu. I opted for a reuben with fries. Their reuben comes with either traditional thousand island dressing or their house dressing. I went with the house dressing for a change of pace, and I'm glad I did. It kinda resembled preserves, and had a sweet, fruity flavor, but when added to the reuben, it turned it into the absolute BEST reuben I've had in a LONG time. The sweetness of the dressing combined with the savoriness of the cheese, the saltiness of the corned beef, and helped contrast the brininess of the sauerkraut. Just perfect! Everything about Main Street Cafe makes it a place I'll certainly visit again. I'm thinking lunch with my lady next time or even dinner. read more

This place smells good. When I walk in the door, I am suddenly hungry! We sat out in the outer room in a corner so we had a private space. Our waitress Grace was attentive without hovering. It was perfect. I had a Black and Blue Burger. It was go good! The potato pancakes were more like Tater Tots. But they had great flavor. Wish they had Coca Cola. It would be a "home run"! read more

Main Street Cafe - A fabulous tomato on the Brioche Burger and an even better one on my Black and Blue Burger! - American Near Me - Newtown, Ohio

Been dining at Main Street Cafe for years. In the last couple months the food quality has really went downhill. Obviously there has been a change in Management since I no longer see Karen the old manager working there. I believe Karen was responsible for the wide variety of homemade desserts made from scratch that were irresistible after my meal. I also noticed a smaller selection and an increase in prices. read more

Best hamburgers and other menu items are great. Wonderful service and a perfect local family owned restaurant.

Mostly love that this place is walking distance from my house. I get the veggie burger with cheese and fries. I'm not a big sweets person, but they have pretty good desserts too. read more

Lunch can get crazy busy. Parking is tight, so be prepared. The food was really tasty. The chicken sandwich was very good. The desserts are excellent and worth hit the bike trail for a few extra miles. The staff was very attentive and friendly. read more

I love this little hole in the wall. You can always count on quick, friendly service, and the food is definitely on point. We're not out this way often, but whenever we are, we make it a point to grab a buffalo chicken or hamburger from Main St. read more

My new favorite restaurant in Mount Vernon, Ohio! The restaurant is so quaint and country chic. The coffee is made by them and is AMAZing! Food and Customer Service excellent! read more

See all

THEIR SOUPS! I've yet to have a soup here that I didn't fall in love with. I believe they only serve one soup a day, but always have their chili, which is so delicious. Make sure to try their chili as well. You will find something on here. I always get the 1/2 club sandwich and whatever soup they have that day. They make the sandwich to your liking, it's a generous portion and it's delicious. They also have delicious burgers and I LOVE their fries. I'm a booth girl, but Main Street only has tables. But get a table in the back room so you have a view. I'm also a Diet Mountain Dew girl and Main Street serves Coke. But they do have Mello Yello. Yay!! read more