I've been to a different location before but not here. We were seated pretty quickly on a Saturday night. We got to sit upstairs which was cool to be able to feel a little separated. I ordered the pot roast and it was pretty good. Loads of food and I like that it was topped with the crispy onions. Our server was also very friendly and service was pretty quick. read more

Maggie McFly's - Pot Roast - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I came here with my boss for a working lunch and had a great experience. I made reservations the day before, and we were seated in a cozy upstairs booth, which was perfect for a productive yet relaxed lunch. My boss ordered the New England clam chowder and beef skewers, and I had the lunch Greek salad along with the fried calamari. Everything was delicious, fresh, and well-prepared. The service was quick and attentive, which we really appreciated during a workday. The menu offers a wide variety of options, which can feel a little overwhelming at first, but it also means there's something for everyone. Overall, it was a wonderful experience, and I'll definitely be back; especially since it's just 10 minutes from the office! read more

Always a great experience at Maggie's. Staff is always friendly, plenty of seating. I ordered the salad with chicken and it was enough for two people. They also have lunch size portions. On nice days, they have a patio where you can sit outside. read more

Maggie McFly's - Salad with chicken - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

Food quality / price (value) rating 10. The atmosphere is eclectic contemporary with a theme park kind of twist, plenty to interest adults and children alike. The menu and beer offerings are very similar to the other Maggie McFly's restaurants. I had the Buffalo Chicken Salad, which included a large amount of chicken, and I had enough to take a second meal home. The wife had the French onion soup that was beautifully presented and of large size. She also had the Chinese Chicken Salad, and that had a generous enough portion to also take a second meal home. We each had a glass of wine and got out of here for $76. This place is a great date venue, as well as a great place for parties and entertaining guests. I've never had a bad time at any Maggie McFly's! read more

See all

My friend wanted to come here for lunch, so my friend and I ended up dining here. I was interested, as I had never been here before, but I had heard about it. The restaurant concept is about aviation since the owner's logo resembles Amelia Earhart. While the owners were shopping one day, they came across an 18-by-12 radio-controlled Faulkner airplane that a man had built for another restaurant, which no longer exists. The owners liked it and had the builder recreate the airplane, three-quarters of its actual size, to be used in their restaurant with the Maggie character. Maggie McFly's offers an extensive menu, so there is something for everyone. I ordered the Sriracha Habanero Chicken Wings and the street tacos. I ordered a Fried Avocado, Barbacoa, and Baja street Tacos, which came with Rice and Beans. My friend ordered a Fried Avocado appetizer and a Salmon. The street tacos were okay. They stuffed the Tacos to the max, but I felt the meat inside them didn't have that slow-cooked meat taste. The meat inside the Taco was okay, but it needed more love. The Fried Avocado Taco lacked flavor because how much flavor could you get from an avocado? The Chicken Wings were the best thing I had. They were crispy, flavorful, and cooked just right. The customer service was spot on, and the waiter was friendly, outgoing, and personable. read more

See all

Much better experience in this location this time around than what I have encountered in the past. It was the weekend and my friends and I were near by attending a fitness competition. Food was delicious, came out fast and our waiter was awesome. Got there around 5 and there was no wait. Can't go wrong with Maggie's menu! There's options for all! And it's a good vibe in there. Family oriented and chill . read more

See all

Food had gone down hill recently, used to frequent this location - but not anymore. Sad they took the pilgrim sandwich off the menu....

Family of five adults for lunch, enjoyed the great food and the excellent service (thanks, Jayden). Pot roast, burger, fish n chips, and BLT were all very tasty. Plenty of seating, not too crowded. Looking forward to next time! read more

Maggie McFly's - Pot Roast lunch plate with veggies and mashed potatoes -- delish and tender! - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

We had a good meal at this location with our college kiddos home on break. While the decor inside is cool with an airplane and fake palm tree, it is also incredibly dusty which is a bit off putting. We were seated upstairs in church pews. Food was good I had a shrimp salad, daughter Mac & cheese, other daughter burger with Mac & cheese, hubs a gyro with fries and plant based chicken. Everyone's food was good, I'm always super grateful when a place has plant based options. Drinks were great. read more

See all

I ordered the Bourbon Ribeye (medium well) with garlic mashed potatoes, and it was amazing. The steak was flavorful, tender, and cooked perfectly, with a rich bourbon taste that really stood out. The garlic mashed potatoes were creamy, well seasoned, and the perfect side. Everything arrived hot and fresh. Definitely ordering this again. read more

See all

Like the atmosphere albeit a little loud. Our waiter was very nice and attentive. I apologize I forgot to take pics.. ‍.. of my food. I had the Turkey Club with Truffle fries. The sandwich was good but the fries were meh, kinda on the cold side. All in all not bad I'd like to go back and try something different from their extensive menu. Something for everyone here. read more

Maggie McFly's - Barbie drink. I liked it. - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

How do you explain being served a martini that is filled to 1" BELOW the rim of a "V" shaped glass, if that your standard then you're short pouring your customers! read more

Food and service were both absolutely amazing!!! Ambiance is always amazing and makes you feel comfortable and at home.

Another good meal here! I noticed a lot of bad reviews lately but my experience here was fine. Our server Erica was nice and helpful. The food portions are always large. The food was good! I got the burger salad and took most of it home because there was so much of it! My friend got the lettuce wraps which is an app but was her meal and there was SO much of that too!! We shared the eggplant fries and there was too much of that so we took the rest home! read more

Maggie McFly's - Lettuce wraps with chicken - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

See all

I've always liked this place but hadn't been in quite a while. Went on 4th of July. The inside is so interesting but it was a beautiful day so we ate outside. Pretzel burger was good. Husband loved the pot roast and son liked his gourmet mac and cheese with blackened chicken. Service was great! Will be back. read more

Our go to restaurant, never had a meal that wasn't above great. Great food, great service, great people. You gotta go!

Expensive meals now. Not worth it. $21 for frozen fish n chips . Fish was minimal and so were the string fries. read more

We had a great family dinner there during the holidays. We topped it off with their s'mores campfire style dessert- so fun and festive . The only drawback was the draft near our table every time the door opened, and the waitstaff was stretched too thin so our service was slow- patience required here but the meal was delish! read more

My good friend suggested this spot for a birthday dinner and it was fabulous. The menu is ginormous so be prepared for a little analysis paralysis as you figure things out. We are outside on a Tuesday evening in late August and everything was pleasant. Our wait staff was very attentive and knowledgeable. The food arrived in good time and was delicious. I went with the lobster bisque bread bowl and it was freaking amazing! There was a piece of fresh lobster in it and the bowl was crunchy and soft. I was not disappointed. For my main I just had a salad because I knew I wanted the lava cake for dessert. The side Cesar salad was fresh and tasty and the cake was decadent. The staff sang to me and included a little candle for me to blow out. It was fantastic. Can't wait to vid again! read more

Food is delicious, I'm never disappointed, love the menu, so many choices of different variety of foods. Got the combination tacos, short rib cod and beef. So yummy. read more

Maggie McFly's - Taco combination, beef, cod, and short rib. So good! - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I received a terribly small tasteless meal, while my partner received twice the amount of food for the same choice of a meal. substituted a small salad for fries and was charged more. Avoid this restaurant at all costs. The Lager cod fry, was bland and a childs portion. On a scale of 1 to 5 I say -1. read more

This menu at this restaurant reminds me of The Cheesecake Factory with so many options. My coworkers often have it delivered via DoorDash during work meetings since there is something for everyone on the menu. read more

This is a casual restaurant with a unique vibe inside. The ambience is really neat. I come here a few times a year for quick work dinners. This is the restaurant that if you can't find something you want to eat.....you are incredibly picky. Their menu rivals a cheese cake factory with its breadth of offerings. This last time we stated with the deviled eggs and Buffalo cauliflower. They are both solid but not exceptional. For an entree I had a spare rib in a house Cabernet sauce over butternut squash risotto. The risotto was excellent but the spare rib was over cooked and tough. The servers are always friendly and surprisingly knowledgeable about the menu given how large it is. read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

Avoid this location, it's gross. Especially the "brunch" menu. Bathrooms need renovating too it's gross in there.

The food was outstanding and Tory our server was excellent. We were very satisfied. I highly recommend stopping by if you are in the area.

Can't go wrong at Maggie McFly's, I will concede that not everything is going to 100% perfect 100% of the time, but their menu and range is huge! The service is excellent, and it's a pleasant establishment for the family. read more

10/31 lunch with family! Good food, relaxed environment! Enjoyed the healthy portions and options. I ordered the signature protein Grain Bowl without the meat. It was delicious and plentifully satisfying! Our server was fast and friendly! read more

Maggie McFly's - Signature protein Grain Bowl without the meat! - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

The best place around for steak . Early bird special is unreal value with desert Owner Tommy is the best always funny and welcoming

The absolute WORST restaurant I've been to probably in my life. It is DIRTY and literally gives you the creeps sitting in there looking at thick dust, cobwebs, sticky tables, and dirty floors. The bathroom is also disgusting and the floor was filled with water, definitely gave outhouse vibes. The service was horrendous! We ordered 2 appetizers, 2 entrees and 1 kids meal. Our appetizers arrived 10 minutes after our entrees-help it make sense! There was no apologies, no explanations nothing. My husband ordered the brisket meal based on the server's recommendation. TOTAL fail! It looked absolutely disgusting! My husband took one bite and gave it back (which he never does, he usually sticks it out). He also didn't even receive the correct sides he ordered, also with zero acknowledgment. My toddler who loves burgers, took her second bite and spit it out and said, "yuck mommy!" Knowing she was hungry I kept trying to force her to eat with no avail. Finally I tasted it myself. Absolutely disgusting! The burger was hard, rubbery, dry, and tasteless! My fish and chips was ok, frozen fish and tasteless fries, although I asked for tater tots, again no acknowledgment of the error. The egg rolls sampler was filled with so much oil it was all over the plate! GROSS. 10 minutes after all the food was dropped off I took my daughter to the car so she could eat the snacks in there because she was hungry while my husband paid. We definitely would NEVER return. Do yourself a favor and eat ANYWHERE else! YUCK!!! read more

Maggie McFly's - Oil Filled Eggrolls Sampler - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

it takes a lot for me to waste my time for a review but after they wasted mine so here goes. waited an hour for food. didn't top off drinks. food came at different times, some people in our party finished before others got food. forgot meals altogether. food cold. staff we're not switched on. read more

Wasn't sure what to expect from this huge eatery but we were pleasantly surprised. Our mid-week lunch on the outdoor patio was as lovely as the menu was large. Too many choices... but for my vegan wife, the surprise of multiple options including soy-chicken and vegan cheese. Huge selection of non-alcohol beers and cocktails too. The service was prompt and attentive and the portions immense, though reasonably priced. read more

My wife and I received gift cards to visit the middlebury CT location near our home. I want to know what I did wrong to the person who gave me these gift cards to go to this location and have a horrible experience. First the calamari was soggy outside and rubbery in the inside. I ordered fish and chips. The fries were over cooked and hard, the fish was ok at first then tasted dry and the cole slaw was dry. The only thing I had that was good was the Stella Beer. my wife ordered the lobster roll she didn't eat all of it and her fries and slaw were the same as mines. Alex that was taking care of us was polite and working hard. I know none of this is his fault. I think he noticed something was wrong because our feelings changed on being there. I don't like making a scene that's why we quietly left after paying. unfortunately we won't be visiting again. read more

Great lunch here today! Good food and service was great. Have had good and bad experience here but today was one of the good ones! Wish it was more consistent!! Their Thai chicken salad is one of my favorite dishes and one I come back to over and over ... same with garlic chicken pasta for my daughter ... their breakfast burger was cooked a perfect medium too! read more

See all

Maggie McFlys is good family restaurant with a huge menu. So many choices. I had a BBQ Brisket Sandwich with coleslaw and BBQ sauce on a sourdough roll. My friend had a huge Cobb Salad.Nice atmosphere with good food, and service. read more

See all

I went to this location of Maggie McFly's with my husband and another couple. We initially had plans to go to a different restaurant but once we got there, it was closed and decided to come here. We had a really enjoyable experience. The wait staff was intentive and refilled our drink. I felt like breakfast and it was during the brunch time on a Sunday so I got the French toast. I thought it was very good. My husband likes lobster so he got three lobster tacos. He was very happy with it. My friends husband got the tacos as well, however, he got two of the fried cod and one lobster. He thought they were all good but preferred the cod. My friend got this bowl with chicken and all these different things. She thought it was really good. She was only able to eat some of it and took the rest home for dinner. I actually would like to go back and try her bowl. Overall we were very happy with our lunch. read more

See all

This was by far the slowest service I have ever received here. The help was severely understaffed. The restaurant was packed well over 50% its capacity and did i mention the service was SLOW! My order should've been ready 45 mins ago and I'm still here. Do better Maggie McFlys. I'm so mad right now. read more

Maggie McFly's - Overcrowded - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

The one thing I can say about Maggie McFly's Middlebury location is that despite the enormousness of their menu, the quality of the food is consistently good! I got the Ruben with a gluten-free cheese bun. OMG! It was out of this world! I've never had a cheese bun before, and they made a believer out of me. It was soft and fresh. The Reuben was made with Angus beef and it was juicy and cheesy with the zip of sauerkraut! My sweet potato fries were hot and crispy and went well with my Sauvignon Blanc. To quote Arnie.. I'll be back! read more

Maggie McFly's - Angus Ruben on a cheese bun with sweet potato fries - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

A cockroach ran across our table. Didn't offer to move us after we told them the first time. Had to wave them in the kitchen once we realized our new table guest hung around for us to grab a photo. Didn't give us a discount or anything after knowing we didn't eat our food afterwards. read more

Maggie McFly's - Cockroach - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I am a frequent patron of Maggie Mcflys and at numerous locations throughout CT. This particular visit was of my typical experiences at Maggie's with good service, good atmosphere and great food. However, when it came time to pay the bill at the end of the evening my waitress Natalie came to the table to get the check and my credit card to pay the bill. After a bit of waiting, she came back and when I opened the check presenter only the receipt was in there, not my Credit card that I paid with. I asked my waitress where my card went to which she could not give me an answer other them "maybe it fell out, let me check". She returned later saying that she could not find it. She then told me to "just cancel it and get a new one". I was completely upset at the lack of regard for my situation not to mention I cannot understand how my card just disappeared from the register to the table. This credit card is also one of the heavy metal cards not the plastic cards, so I know from experience that if it drops to the floor, it is quite loud. I feel that she did not take the time to thoroughly look for the card, nor take any type of responsibility for its disappearance. Needless to say, the whole experience was something to be desired and put a bad taste in my mouth. I'm concerned with how this happens when it's the waitress job to take the payment and return it to the table, where did it get misplaced in the process. I do not think that I would personally return to this location after this encounter. **update** I have spoken to a manager on the phone the day after the incident. She was very rude on the phone. I had let her know about the situation from last night where a server ran my card to pay my bill then returned with receipts for payment but no card. She rudely cut me off and said "yea yea, we have it come get it whenever at the bar area". She made it seem as if I were the one who misplaced my card. That is unacceptable. She did not even apologize or offer any resolution to the situation. I will most definitely not be returning to this location. I am very disappointed in how this situation was handled. read more

Maggie McFly's - Bang-Bang Shrimp & Chicken - New American Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

See all

Food is usually good but in my Caesar salad i asked for chicken and instead of regular chicken it was BBQ. Additionally, there was a large shard of GLASS in my salad. The manager took it off our bill and gave us a small gift card but the gift card wasn't even enough to cover a main course and a drink. Pretty pathetic overall, not going back. Clearly they don't care all that much about the cleanliness of their kitchen and the safety of the customers. read more