It's just not so good, plain and simple. I'll relay a few experiences that may help crystalize the type of "management" MAC offers for their tenants.
First and perhaps most annoying was move in day. I show up with my car and a UHaul full of everything I hold near and dear in downtown Hyde Park to pick up my keys from the office. Parking is hell (not their fault, just saying), so I'm a little agitated when I go inside, but I figure it's all smooth sailing seeing as I've already paid first month's rent, fees, etc. But no. First guy I talk to doesn't want to help because I'm not in a building he oversees. I ask if he would mind pointing me to someone who can/will help. He actually rolls his eyes and begrudgingly goes and gets someone who's apparently less important than he is. Someone who promptly tells me that they've misplaced the keys. I sit around for about a half an hour while they search, then another 40 minutes while they cut new ones. (And this isn't an isolated incident--my roommate experienced the exact same BS when she moved in a week later). They give me a couple of free movie passes for my trouble. I would have settled for keys.
Next on the list, threatened eviction. This story is a little complicated so get ready. Basically, when I was first looking for an apartment in Hyde Park, I answered an add through the UChicago marketplace for a student whose roommates were moving out, but she was staying and trying to fill the two vacant rooms. Nothing wrong with that, right? Wrong. When we all signed our new lease and set up our online payment account, instead of just making a new account for us, our manager person (she was fired a number of months later, surprise surprise) just added us to the last group of tenants' account. Normally, this probably wouldn't have been an issue, except we paid our fees before the previous group's last month's rent was due, which meant that our couple hundred dollars worth of fees went toward their balance. Naturally, the previous tenants had no idea what was going on, and just paid less rent for that month seeing as an inexplicable $200 had been credited. Fast forward a month, when we pay our rent there's still an outstanding balance of $200 on the books because our fee money went toward paying the previous tenants' rent instead of our fees. I go through the account history and figure out what happened (I could even see where one of the previous tenants paid $200 less than the previous 11 months), save a copy of the account history, and send it to our building manager. She says that she'll take care of it, but she doesn't. We start receiving phone calls about our outstanding balance even though we all pay our rent on time and in full every month. I try to explain it again and tell them to look at the account history. When I try to pull it up they'd taken it down!!! Alas, unfortunately for them I had a copy, which I promptly printed out in triplicate thinking I may need it shortly. Finally, they send a letter telling us that they're going to evict us in a week if we don't pay. Great. It's worth noting that they can't do that. And not in the "that's so cruel, you can't do that!" way, but in the it's required by law to give something like 30-60 days notice before eviction way. So they were trying to scare us into paying. I called again, talked with some manager, and asked if she could contact the previous tenants and get them to pay or simply start a new account for us that had no outstanding balance (I figured if they could just remove the payment history from one account, they could add history to another...). She said that she wasn't really supposed to contact former renters like that, but that she'd make an exception. Finally, after months of nonsense, one of the former tenants pays the money all inside of a day. How simple it would have been to just contact them from the start...
Last. My bike. It was stolen. Yes, this is Chicago, I know, and perhaps my bike would have been stolen regardless. BUT, I think a good deterrent might have been, say, if the lock on the 6 ft tall gate surrounding the area where everyone locks their bikes hadn't been broken. What's more, it had been broken for at least 3 weeks and stayed broken for a couple weeks after my bike being stolen (which I'm told they "can't be held responsible for in any way"). Incidentally, 2 weeks was also about how long we had to use only the back door when our front door's lock broke and they took forever to send someone to fix it.
Add onto all of these annoyances the fact that they don't always shovel the snow, the laundry room not infrequently smells like death, and the internet is spotty and frequently goes out, and you have a rather annoying place to live. (Btw, my building was 54th and Maryland, in case you're wondering where to stay away from.) I know that MAC is the preeminent rental business in the area, but if you can stay away. read more