While not our first time in Lyon Hall, it was the first time we've dined inside AND for a special holiday menu. I must say that the prior experience we've had at Lyon Hall was present; solid table service, great menu options and a pleasant environment. Being Thanksgiving, we made sure to have our reservation well in advance. While we were there mid-afternoon, I wouldn't say that they were slammed, but steadily busy.
Obviously on a holiday, one needs to celebrate with a good cocktail to start off with. Our group chose to start off with a twist on two classics, My Mom's Manhattan and a Paper Plane to Paris and a newcomer for us, the Arc 'de Triomphe. Both of the classics were terrific, the Manhattan with a splash of Cointreau and the Paper Plane sporting Cardamaro. The Arc was a unique and tasty treat-starting with a vodka base and rounded out with spiced pear purée, allspice and lemon juice. So nice it had to be tried twice!
In a bow to the holiday, they had a special Prix Fixe Menu that has an abundance of options. The 3 course opportunity had such a wide variety of appetizers it was truly hard to choose from. Ultimately our party went with the Oysters on the half shell, Shrimp Cocktail and the Charcuterie Plate. We also started with an add on of their delicious Pomme Frites, which we had experienced on our earlier visits. The rock star of the apps was the Charcuterie Plate that had 3 different meats (Chicken Pate, Bresaola, Saucisson Sec, toasts along with cornichons, and plentiful pickled veggies. Don't get me wrong, the Oysters at Lyon Hall are worth a visit in themselves and the shrimp were on the extra large size, but the Plate made it a great start.
For entrees our party went with the Traditional Turkey Day option, the Pork Chop and the Duck Breast. The star of the three was the duck, beautifully prepared large portion of duck confit, in a la'orange sauce over lightly sautéed kale, black Venus rice, and a braised salsify. Oh my goodness, it was delicious. The Pork Chop too was outstanding, perfectly cooked in a pan to the right temp accompanied with bourbon sweet potatoes, braised mustard greens, in a whole-grain mustard demi-glaze. The traditional Thanksgiving option, White turkey meat with roasted garlic mashed potatoes, green beans with almonds a small side of cranberry sauce, bread pudding stuffing and turkey gravy didn't disappoint, but arrived as a lukewarm option, almost as if the kitchen thought pre-prep of that meal as an afterthought. Tasty, but just not a knock-out.
At this point, dessert was not needed, but included, so our group powered through a Creme Carmel, a very unique mini-pumpkin pie and the ice cream. While the last option was billed as home made ice cream and sorbet, the sorbet wasn't present, but instead featured 3 ice creams. All were fantastic but the Pumpkin pie made as almost a tart, had a wonderful maple flavoring and whipped topping that made it delectable. Likewise the Creme Carmel had a fruit compote in a apple cider cake based with a salted caramel wafer.
The only deterrent to being a perfect experience was being seating directly under a blowing vent that kept our party chilled. With the restaurant mostly full we didn't feel it appropriate to request a reseating assignment so we were much more expedient about the length of our stay; an after dinner apertif was something we usually enjoy, but we skipped that this time to avoid the continued chill. Our advice is don't be shy to mention this to your server, so that you'll have the perfect experience at a great restaurant. read more