We love going for Italian food at Lucky's Pizza! Impressive ice cold beer mugs, great selection of Italian food and pizza selections and always delicious and fresh! Very generous helpings, friendly owners and family-like ambience! A very comfortable and laid back place with a great staff! read more

I read several positive reviews on Nextdoor so I went Saturday, June 13, 2026 at 1:30 in the afternoon. There wasn't one other person in the restaurant. The owner was behind the counter and I told him I was there because of the positive reviews on Nextdoor he just glared through me. He had a very negative attitude and energy. The Pizza was just OK. I will never go back, Fabio's on fire is MUCH better Fire Oven Pizza and the owner is from Italy and very friendly he imports all of his ingredients from Italy. Well worth the drive for me even though Luckys is much closer to the Grand where I live . I'll never go back to Lucky. He's lucky he has ANY customers with his negative attitude and energy. read more

Ordered a medium pepperoni mushroom and tomato pizza. Great crust, slightly crunchy, thin in the middle with a slight crunch. Delicious full flavored sauce, toppings were perfect. Slices are huge in the medium box, you could easily cut slices in half to make the pizza go further. Excellent customer service. read more

See all

A true family-owned gem! They've been serving authentic Italian food since 2001, and it shows in every dish. The portions are huge, so come hungry! Tony, the owner's son, was incredibly friendly and made us feel right at home. Great food, warm hospitality, and a welcoming atmosphere. We'll definitely be back! read more

Lucky's Pizza - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all

Great pizza! Fast service. We called ahead and ordered for pickup. Try the "white" pizza it was delicious.

Pizza and wings were good The ranch was SWEET .....please go back to the original ranch read more

I didn't realize just how much time had passed since our last stop here. We used to frequent the location in Glendale years and years ago, but when we moved unfortunately we don't make it that way often. When we walked in we were greeted right away and decided to order the medium special with 10 wings. We added pepperoni, ham and black olives. We asked for extra crispy crust so it didn't get so soggy after sitting. Everything came out fairly quick and perfectly cooked. It was all really good. Service was friendly . My only drawback was it was so hot inside and hard to get comfortable. Other than that a pretty good visit. read more

Lucky's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all

Best pizza in Surprise!!! We love East Coast pizza and this is the best! Thin crust, great sauce! read more

For the west valley it's a good pizza. I would like it a little crispier next time so I will ask them to cook it just a bit longer. It had a little too much flop for my liking for a NY style pizza. I got a cheese pizza. We enjoyed it. Prompt and friendly service. It also reheated nicely the next day when we had leftovers. We'll be back. read more

The pizza was so delicious! Service was quick and the staff was incredibly kind. The atmosphere screams "your local pizza spot." We will definitely be back and look forward to the pasta dishes! read more

Bussin. I really like the lunch special. Salad always fresh and pizza melty and delish. Good guys in there too... Ty!!

Rarely eat out but met a group of friends. Medium Pizza and dinner salad were very good with large portions. Large dine in space. Happy to recommend and will return. read more

Nice little pizza spot. It's not something I would travel out of my way for but if I'm in the area and want some really good pizza at a fantastic price this is definitely where I'll be going. The pizza sauce was not too sweet. The crust was perfect. For the size of the slices they weren't too floppy either. The pepperoni was a little sweet which was a nice surprise. Great service and a welcoming atmosphere. Really good pizza for a great price. read more

See all

Toppings were different, but good. The crust unfortunately was like cardboard. Service was good. Too bad the crust was not edible. We had one piece and threw the rest out. read more

Food and atmosphere just ok . Service wise everyone is very friendly! I just don't like the sauce something missing for me the spaghetti sauce was worse. read more

I absolutely love Lucky's pizza they are from New York as I am and they make the best pizza regardless of their size. It's always a pizza you can fold and awesome double bite their wings are also the best I get the honey barbecue wings and I also get a salad that's just lettuce and mozzarella cheese and Italian dressing and then you know it's me plus I always call and order a pizza pie and they know I'm automatically from New York once I say pizza pie so this is definitely my go to place read more

Not bad but not great either. I am originally from NY so I might be a harsher critic about pizza than most. Sauce was very intense and they use alot of it and the dough was a bit thick compared to what I'm used to back in NY. People seemed nice and the pie came out quick with minimal waiting, which was great. I'm not familiar with what's around the area yet but both me and my wife gave it a 6 1/2 out of 10 on our rating scale. read more

We were visiting family in Sun City West and had pizza for dinner one night at the recommendation of my in-laws. My favorite pizza is pepperoni and jalapeño. Lucky's totally delivered! The amount of jalapeño on our pizza was perfect. The pizza itself was so tasty and also huge! We had a lot of pizza leftover. My in-laws loved the mushroom and jalapeño pizza. I really liked the crust. The pizzas were delish. I highly recommend! read more

Lucky's Pizza - Pepperoni and jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all

Hands-down, best slice I've ever had, that's all that needs to be said I walked in there after smelling the pizza cooking from outside and just got one slice with pepperoni and it was blown away. Atmosphere in service seemed very authentic too. read more

Great NY style pizza. I like that thin crust pizza. A whole pie is around $20. I have to admit last time I I got a whole pie I went to little Ceaser's for $10 bucks. read more

Pizza was cooked perfectly, quality ingredients, really liked the sauce. Meat raviolis were the same quality. Service was above and beyond!

Great NYC style pizza. Tasty calzones. They have lunch specials that are priced reasonably & friendly staff.

My first time here. I ordered the meat calzone. A very generous fresh tasting crust, and tasty meat and cheese, but not very much of it. 3 stars for the calzone. I ordered 10 wings. They were dry, hard to chew, and had no flavor at all. I struggled with the first 3, then threw out the rest. Not going to waste my time or calories with this. 1 star for the wings. read more

Yesterday I called and ordered one item. A large pizza. When my family member arrived to pick it up they handed him a pizza and a paper bag of wings. The guy at the counter insisted that was indeed my order. Well, it wasn't. Turned out to be a crappy large cheese only pizza and a bag of extremely fiery hot wings totaling $45. We live about 15 miles away so I wasn't about get in my car and go back. Dinner went in the trash. I'm NEVER going back. read more

Today we decided to try another pizzeria. Lucky's is in our neighborhood and had decent reviews. The service was friendly and we received our hot fresh pizza in a timely manner. The pizza was excellent! We will try the wings next time. For now I will give Lucky's Pizza in Surprise 5 pizza stars! We will be back! read more

The last two times I ordered from here through slice my order has been wrong this last time when I called the restaurant and Tony was so rude and told me just don't order from Lucky Pizza again and hung up on me. I have never experienced this kind of customer service from Luckys. This will be the last time I buy pizza from there. read more

I'm giving 4 instead of 5 because I ate here twice and the pizza was inconsistent. The first time I loved how it felt light and doughy without the crust having to be too thick to feel doughy. The last time I went it wasn't the same, thinner and chewier aka harder to bite...but even though the pizzas were inconsistent...the cannolis hit both times. Fire! I dont even like cannolis and now I crave theirs lol. Super casual place but not trashy, have the games on, friendly service, clean. I usually do takeout and it's very quick for pizza! read more

So I called to place an order and asked for the total . The guy said I don't know 20 minutes order 1. Rude!!!! I get there in 12 minutes and my food is already sitting on top of the over done . I asked the lady at the register for an itemized receipt and she swipes my card and says we don't do itemized receipts. I wanted to walk out and get my money back considering I need an itemized receipt for my expense report. Rude!!!! I tried a slice of pizza as soon as I got in the care and it just flopped . Surprised since it just came out of the oven . Pizza was good once I cooked it for 10 minutes when I got home . It was average at best . They must have new owners. read more

Great standard NY slices and wings. Been going here for years. Pizzas always come out hot & fresh with wings being hot & crispy. Always very happy with trips here. Guys running the shop are always professional and get your food out quick. Sandwiches are always well made and stuffed with all the right ingredients & toppings. From Cheese to meatlovers cant go wrong. read more

Had Lucky's pizza and wings and zucchini.. everything was amazing and they are always super nice

The pizza was excellent and took only about 20 fro the time I ordered online. The problem was that I ordered online and my wife wanted some toppings and I wanted others. The Ordering site allowed me to divide the pie in half for choosing toppings. The price for each topping is $2. My thinking was that just ordering topping for half the pie would cut the price per topping to $1. As it turned out, I was charged full price even if the topping was for just one half the pie. The guys at the shop couldn't do anything because I paid online. Not a major deal; but I was overcharged $8. Not happy. read more

First timers here at Lucky's Pizza and it did not disappoint! We ordered fried zucchini, medium wings and a large pizza. The food was amazingly delicious! Wings were spot on and served steaming hot, crispy with a good amount of sauce. The zucchini was crispy on the outside, perfectly cooked..and oh so tasty! The pizza.. well it was on a different level compared to others we have tried. The pizza was Noticeably made and cooked to perfection with just the right amount of sauce, loads of fresh toppings and the crispy (not flimsy!) crust was amazing! We found our new place and can't wait to come back! read more

See all

The pie was really good and my wife said she would definitely have another sausage and peppers sandwich. If you're in the area and looking for a quality place, give them a shot. The girls running the front were super nice as well. read more

Best New York pizza and wings in Surprise. There's a reason they've been there for years on end. I question your tastebuds if you disagree.

We always love coming to eat pizza here. Always have a great experience, friendly staff, and clean place with fun ambiance. Staff are friendly, food is always made to order. A must stop. read more

Lucky's Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

We ordered takeout. Super easy to do using Slice. Very good pizza. We ordered meat lovers 5/5 and ham and pineapple 5

I've been going here since I was a toddler now I'm almost 30 and they still got me coming back for more. Enough said some of the greatest pizza in the west valley! read more

I'm a Chicago pizza fan, Lucky's is not. So I'm not a fan of this place but the ingredients were good, the crust was okay. the sauce needs brightness. The veggie pizza was supposed to come with extra cheese, but there was no sign of it. Good food, but not our style. The service was great. Nice folks. Decent size dining area. read more

Everything was great! The pizza, wings, and cheesy bread were all good. The service was good and it was family friendly. Their sauce and marinara was top notch. read more

Pizza has gone way downhill and I don't see any chance to return to decency. Very bland slices with no spices in sight except for the ones in shakers which you must add to get any flavor. They use too much cheese to claim NY style and the language they speak in there is clearly not Italian. They fooled me once, but these guys are frauds. read more

Lucky's Pizza - Cheese separation. Not NY style. - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

See all