Amazing pizza! Service was great and the space is large and combined with a bar. Lots of parking. They had an large pizza over, my mistake was taking it to go. After 30 minutes still tasted great but know it would have been better as soon as it came out. Highly recommend if in the area! read more

Drove 30 mins out of the way to try this place and would 100% do it again. Friendly, laid back atmosphere and staff. AMAZING food. Our only regret is not being able to try more things. Will definitely come again if ever in the area. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

See all

My friend and I came here for a late lunch after a hike. It's a cool little pizza spot that also has a convenient store attached to it. They're dog friendly as well on their screened in patio. We did the lunch special which was the tomato soup and half pizza combo. We got pepperoni pizza and it was so good! There's a bunch of games to play too. We started playing checkers until our food was ready. The staff were friendly as well. Real cool spot, would come back! read more

See all

Very fun spot with great food and games for the whole family. Highly recommend if you're in the area. Service was wonderful as well. read more

See all

Delicious wood-fired pizzas with fresh, quality ingredients that really hit the spot. Perfect for taking on a picnic to Lost River State Park just down the road. The covered, enclosed patio area is comfortable & dog friendly. Staff were friendly and helpful. They allow you to get creative with interesting pizza options, as well as order half & half pizzas for splitting. Plenty of vegetarian and vegan options. We opted for one side supreme and the other side veggie (minus broccoli, add hot cherry peppers) and could not have been happier with our choice. Can't wait to try out their other offerings as there will definitely be a next time! read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Half supreme pizza, half veggie minus broccoli - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

What a fantastic addition to the area. This place is a true gem, their menu of simple yet delicious pizzas with creative and playful toppings has something to please everybody. Fantastic wings as well and an amazing selection of beer and wine. The space itself is inviting, friendly, and provides covered outdoor dog, friendly seating. What's not to love? From the moment you walk in your greeted with a smile the team here is top notch, always spot on with their recommendations, but really you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. read more

We have returned. What a great place. The food (half a pizza and wonderful salad). WV beer on draft. You gotta go. Great staff. Very friendly. Check out the attached store. We drove to the state park. Entrance across the street. 4 miles up Howard Lick trail. Great time.we took Crooked Run road over the mountain from Bayse to mathais. Need 4 wheel drive. And drive slow. At least 3 switch backs at 5 miles an hour Have fun read more

Husband and I just traveled for the holiday, and once we unpacked we were starving! Looking around what was close, we both thought you can't go wrong with pizza. AND WOW!!! What a gem we found! The service was quick, the pizza was absolutely delicious, and the sandwich was the icing on the cake! Such a laid back, fun, cool place to check out if you're in town! We highly recommend! read more

This place is pretty wild. Small store, food, great people. The store was clean. Ordered pizza to go and let me say, it's one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. Fresh, hot, and quick. It'll be rough not spending a lot of money on pizza. Lol. I think the price isn't to bad being that the flavor is fresh and great. Thanks for the service and great food. read more

I had the smashburger here. That was unexpected from a pizza place. Who puts those ingredients between pizza crusts? It worked out well, and I would eat that again! read more

See all

Incredible and delicious. Relaxing, friendly, yummy food, local beers. Large main area with screen in outer area. It's down the road from Lost River State Park. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - 1/2 pepperoni, 1/2 veggie with Big Timber IPA - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

Great pizza with a really nice view. If you are visiting the state park or camping in the area this is a nice place to retreat to for a beer and hot meal. read more

The pizza is wow with super fresh ingredients and delicious crust. You will not be able to stop eating it. The service was great. They have really nice outdoor seating. The best part is that you are welcome to bring your pup outside. Great overall experience here at the lost and found. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Lost and Found - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

Antipasto salad and Apple Pizza were fantastic. Also got BBQ chicken, pepperoni, and cheese pizzas. Judging by the lack of leftovers they were superb also. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Apple pizza (yep apple) - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

See all

We visited both the pizzeria and the Provisions store, first I must say that the staff from both establishments were very friendly and helpful. The provisions store had a good selection of drinks, both alcohol and non. They also had a good snack and collectible selection. The pizzeria was great! We had the Hawaiian and Chicken bbq pizza. Both were delicious and the chicken wings were amazing too! The pizzeria had a great feel to it, kind of rustic and welcoming. This was a great stop for us and we will stop there again when in that area. read more

Fantastic pizza and a must-visit if you live nearby or happen to be visiting Lost River State Park or Mathias. This place has a seriously good pie - much better than I expected in an area where the nearest competition is a gas station that offers a menu of cold cuts and "microwave sandwiches." This place has a legit pizza oven that is the centerpiece of the restaurant. They have a spacious and comfortable indoor dining room but also have a nice outdoor dining area looking out east toward Lost River and the scenic vistas beyond. They only have one size pizza - eight slices - but the dough is really good and so are the toppings. Prices were reasonable. As of July 2024, a three-topping pizza and an order of cheesy bread came to less than $25. They take phone orders for takeout, but from what I can tell, their website does not offer online ordering. The menu beyond pizza is pretty basic - strombolis, some basic salads, wings, and a couple of sandwiches. They do pizza well enough that's fine though. Next door is their "provisions" store which was sort of a convenience store with a rather limited selection (too limited for my taste). I think they are trying to stock more "upscale" products and specialty products versus trying to compete with the aforementioned gas station or the nearby Dollar General, so, for example, you can get a glass bottle of Jarritos or a Mexican Coke but no Dr. Pepper or Funyuns. They looked to have a decent selection of fancier canned beers. Employees were consistently friendly on both sides of the building. My family has made it a tradition in recent years to come stay at Lost River State Park for the Fourth of July to escape the celebratory madness of a Washington, D.C. Independence Day, but this was our first time trying Lost & Found Pizza. Bottom line: it was good enough that we ate here twice in just a couple of days. We usually stock up on supplies to use at the cabin in nearby Moorefield and sometimes get takeout there, but I can assure you: no pizza there holds a candle to what you can get right here down the mountain from Lost River State Park in Mathias. Getting a pizza here will now be a part of our annual tradition. read more

After owning property in this area since the 70s, our family was so excited for a pizza place to arrive!! We came to the soft open and it was amazing. We tried a little bit of everything - cheese, veggie, apple, margherita, meatza. I am hoping they will add some appetizers and additional entrees in the future but I don't want to complain - the pizza was great and I am happy with that. We will be back. Also, the view on the patio is amazing. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Our boys enjoying the view. - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

Friendly, fast service, even though they were very busy. Pizza was hot, fresh, and tasty. We didn't have any adult beverages or check out the store, but definitely would visit again for pizza. We would have liked to eat on the porch, but it was blazing hot! read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Smoked BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

See all

Stopped here on a road trip between Morgantown WV and Ashland VA. It's a funky little place with a wood fired pizza oven, an assortment of wines and beer, and a few items besides pizza. Husband and I shared the fun guy pizza with was pretty good especially the crust. There's also a store attached with an assortment of wine, beer, food,snacks, and crafts. Great service and the decor is fun. read more

This pizza place rocks! What a great addition to Lost River Valley. The pizzas are great - high quality. The wood fire pizza oven is very cool, a little bit of Italy in West Virginia. I've had the Margherita, Pepperoni, the Fun Guy (mushroom - get it?! ), the Veggie and the Supremo so far. I heard people raving about the Heat. I think it's great that they offer vegan ricotta at no uncharge for vegans or anyone who prefers it to dairy cheese. Really thoughtful planning. And you can get gluten-free cauliflower crust for an additional $5. Salads are really good too. I've stuck to the soda fountain but they also have beer & wine. Everyone is so friendly and most times I've been there, Max, one of the owners, has checked in with to ask how everything is - they care! The decor and everything else shows a lot of thought went into every detail. In warm weather, I love sitting on the porch with its lovely meadow view. read more

Great food (Pizza)! , relaxed atmosphere clean environment and friendly staff and patrons.

Awesome pizza with lots of vegan and gluten free options. I always stop by if I'm in the area.

This restaurant will undoubtedly improve with experience. The staff is friendly, the facility is nice.....even offering seating in a screened porch where customers can bring their pups. The oven produces a wonderfully tasty pizza and the crust is thin and cooked to perfection. Service if eating in is excellent too! The reason I have given it only three stars is because of the scarcity of some of the toppings. I ordered "The Fun Guy" pizza (take out) which basically a mushroom pizza with mozzarella, Parmesan and minced garlic. I added and paid extra for olives and extra mozzarella. When I opened the box at home I was surprised that fully 3 of the 8 pieces had no olive at all and 3 of the remaining pieces had only 1 or 2 olive pieces (see picture). Additionally, the amount of mozzarella on the pizza appeared pretty normal........certainly not what you would expect after paying for "extra mozzarella ". The distribution of mushrooms and garlic on the pizza was fine.....no issue there. I'm giving this restaurant a pass and will definitely order from there again and, hopefully, add more stars in the next review. I really want them to be successful and frankly the pizza tastes great despite the deficiencies. I am trusting that reviews like this will be helpful to the management and that it will help to make corrections in the preparation process going forward. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

We are so excited this pizza place opened right by Lost River State Park! We only got take out since we were driving back from our weekend house late on Sunday, but all the pizzas were delicious! We are from Arlington VA, and the pizza is on par with Pupatella. Such an amazing addition to Lost River area! We look forward to enjoying at the restaurant next time! We highly recommend it! read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Delicious wood fired pizza! Highly recommend! 10 out of 10! - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

Best pizza for sure. Wood fired is the best and a real variety of other options. Super folks.

Great tasting wood fired pizza, the best I've had!! Friendly staff and for the dog lovers, they have screened in back area that looks out at the mountains, that's dog friendly. For you dart lovers, they have boards and weekly games. Plus I thought they had very reasonable prices for the food and drinks. read more

Super cozy little pizza lounge. Delicious pizza, made fast. Scarfed down most of the pizza before taking pictures. Friendly staff. The provisions store is separate but attached to pizza place - good variety of beer/wine and treats. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Pineapple olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

This is an amazing place. The pizza is so good. You couldn't get pizza this good in the big cities that are 2 hours away. The pizza is thoughtful and perfect. Save your crusts for the delish olive oil and parmesan cheese. I relish every part of every piece. And the staff-- amazing! Competent, courteous and kind. The ambiance is perfect. Check out the mural on the back porch that was done by a local artist and depicts all of the sites that mean something to the locals. It feels like you're in Schitt's creek. This is the place that everyone in town retreats to. read more

Lost & Found Pizza & Provisions - Pizza Near Me - Mathias, West Virginia

Stopping at Lost & Found Pizza and Provisions after hiking in Lost River State Park turned out to be an excellent idea! The wood-fired pizzas were outstanding--we tried The Apple and The Fun Guy, and would definitely recommend both. All of the staff were super friendly and helpful. We were initially going to get pizzas to go, but stayed once we learned that our dog could join us in their covered outdoor seating area. Loved the decor and the view from the patio. We're looking forward to visiting the Lost River area again, and we'll be sure to stop here for more pizza! read more

Since it opened, this place has been a weekly (sometimes bi-weekly, sometimes more) spot. The pizza is fantastic. The Heat is my personal favorite but there's something for everyone on the menu. They continue to add new items and specialty pizzas so the menu always feels fresh. But what really seals the deal is the people. The service is always welcoming and friendly. The ambience is a warm hug of a place. Seriously, just go. read more

Best food and service ever!!! Great staff to help you get what you want and need!! Always getting more items added to menu.

The service i only did pick up the piazza was very very good will be ordering again the out side looked great