We haven't ordered from Little Sicily since they moved locations, so when my husband ordered pizza as a surprise one Saturday night, I was excited to try it again. Considering this family loves cheese I was shocked he opted for the tomato pie, a thick crust with a thick tomato sauce on top. The sauce was one of the best sauces I have had in the area. I like mine a little sweet and this was perfect. The second pizza he chose was the Greek, which was basically a white pizza with broccoli and tomatoes and feta cheese instead of the typical ricotta. The feta actually was a pairing I didn't know I needed and it was so much better than I envisioned. We will definitely be ordering from Little Sicily again. read more

Little Sicily Pizza - 16" Tomato Pie - Pizza Near Me - Glassboro, New Jersey

See all

Delicious pepperoni slice, incredibly kind service, warm cozy ambiance and lovely! The cheesesteaks are delicious, too! read more

Little Sicily Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Glassboro, New Jersey

A day of two cheesesteaks with broccoli rabe, provolone and roasted peppers with Amigo Dan and his sidekick Eric took us to Little Sicily. These are the reviews I don't like to do because it looks like a new business venture and the Rowan students are mostly virtual so the town of Glassboro is dead meaning most of the businesses are dead and I feel like I'm kicking someone when they are down but this cheesecake just wasn't that good. We took it to Bonesaw Brewing. It is a short ride and the roll did not hold up very well. It needed more better meat. The broccoli rabe was a little leafy for my liking but very tasty and flavorful. read more

See all

Lovely place, always good to eat here and see Marcelo and my favorite cashier Nick. Love it here, best pizza in glassboro in my opinion!

I just wanted wings. I give them a zero and that's being generous. These are terrible. I also got fried mushrooms....star of the show but that's not saying much. Ugh. I'm so disappointed....so gross...I initially thought bad but they've been downgraded to gross. It's like they boiled wings...so gross....I'm gagging looking at them read more

I don't normally read/write reviews, as much is untrustworthy these days. But I feel that this particular issue must be addressed - hopefully by the business owners. My kids & I decided to try this place out as it's pretty local & the online menu seemed well-rounded & reasonably priced. To make a long story (hopefully) shorter, I would rate the food as 4.5 stars - very very good, as was the overall service. My problem was with the pricing - rather, the fairly big discrepancy between the "website" & the actual, in-person menu. We we particularly looking at the "lunch specials". On the "website", the prices are listed as $11.49, but in the restaurant, the paper menu showed $13.49. That doesn't seem so bad in & of itself, but I questioned the discrepancy with the gentleman who took our order (don't know if he was part-owner/owner, or an employee). The only explanation he offered was that "we don't even use the website anymore", even though it's a fully functional site, with their current address & phone number, as well as fully functioning navigation. As a former "techie", I'm acutely aware of how websites/web hosting works. One doesn't pay for hosting if the site isn't meant to be accessed, along with other bells & whistles associated with sites like this. Now $6.00 (the difference between what I expected to pay/actual cost) doesn't seem that much, but in these days of hyper-inflation, that $6.00 was about 13% of our total. It makes a difference - not only to me, but more so to the college students raised on digital interfaces. They see one price on the web, & another in person. Oh, & NOWHERE does the site state that the posted prices for specials is an "online-only" deal, so we expected to pay the price on the website. In short, this needs to be addressed immediately, with the restaurant either removing its website (since, according to them, it's "not being used anymore"), or correcting it with the current prices. I will be contacting the BBB to find out if this constitutes false advertising, & will proceed from there - unless, that is, the owners correct the problem. Incidentally, this same, incorrectly priced website is posted right here on Yelp. That also needs to be removed - again, unless Yelp wants to get a bad review for pointing customers to outdated websites & pricing. Thank you. read more

One margarita pizza, one calzone and 10 wings $48 delivered before tip. Margarita, the dough wasn't a good taste or texture,the sauce was like tomato paste with no seasoning and the "Buffalo mozzarella " was scarce to be polite $21.00. The calzone had sesame seeds all over it, nuff said.$10.00. Garlic wings were good, no complaint. There are just too many decent shops around to order from here. La Scala fire in Glassboro is supposed to be "fancy" and it would have been better and cheaper to order from there. read more

The food here is amazing. Most of the staff friendly. What's not great is the fact that the tall guy with the glasses is involved with drug sales while on and off the clock. His product is Amazing. Ask for Francisco. His prices are about as high as his THC based flour will get u. read more

Little Sicily Pizza - The guy with the good stuff - Pizza Near Me - Glassboro, New Jersey

My boyfriend & I randomly ordered wings & waffle fries from here one night.. they turned out to be one of our favorite wing spots in the area! Crispy, tasty, overall a great wing. I love me some waffle fries & they were exactly what I was looking for. Highly recommend. Looking forward to trying out a few other items in the menu. read more

We have ordered from here several times, but tonight was very disappointing. Not only did our food never arrive, but the phone number doesn't work because either no one picks up, or the message is for an architect company. Order at your own risk, I suppose. We won't bother ordering from here again. read more

My friends and I ordered from here. We picked up about 20 minutes later and the cooks just started making it. Cmon. It came out good though, we got a normal plain pie and a pepperoni Sicilian pie. read more

Little Sicily Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Glassboro, New Jersey

Ordered from here once so far and was actually surprisingly impressed with their pizza. We got half plain, half buffalo chicken and both were very good. The buffalo chicken had a great taste and the chicken was in small cubes which I liked. The plain had a very flavorful sauce, a little bit sweet which is perfect. Crust is a little thick for my liking but I guess that's a South Jersey thing because it's that way everywhere (being from North Jersey I prefer that thin crispy crust.) Overall, it's one of the best places we've gotten delivery from. Delivery was pretty quick too. Will most likely order from here again! read more

Giving this place the benefit of the doubt opening a new location.. I am very disappointed.. we ordered wings and a couple sandwiches nothing was fresh and it felt like the food they served us was two weeks old. Gold bless I wish them the best read more

I study at Rowan and eat here frequently. Pizza is the best around. They have a range of different choices. I always go with the pizza! Food is always delicious and the hours are great. If you want fast quality food, this is your place to go. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Me and my brother have both currently gotten food poisoning from here. Do not recommend

The food is so damn good I can't even. Eat here every Thursday. However I wind up coming more often in a week no matter what. Get the chicken parm. read more

Was at the Town Square Festival recently and took grandson there for a slice. Place was clean and cozy. Customerservice was so so. Very curt. Ordered two slices of plain cheese pizza. Pizza was nice and hot but not much in the way of flavor. In fairness going to return and try something different... read more

I have had takeout from Little Sicily on many occasions. Based on the quality/quantity for the price its a solid four star gem. One of several meals I have ordered was the eggplant rollitini. It is excellent for a quick service pizza shop. Comes with salad, bread and a side of pasta. More than enough for one person and shareable. Great especially for the price. Their pizza is also decent for the Glassboro area. Don't feel like cooking but want decent Italian take out, then this is the place to go. Service is also friendly and quick. Very consistent cooking and service. Really appreciate this type of establishment in town. read more

Great pizza and steaks! I have tried both the cheese and Buffalo chicken pizza and both were consistently good! Friendly, fast service every time I have been here so far! read more

Great hoagies, great wings, and pretty quick delivery. The guy who answers the phone is always nice and I have never had any issues. It's my go to joint for hoagies and pizza in Glassboro. read more

This place is so great this one driver is so fast and polite I'm sticking to this restaurant forever

Definitely would go again! Was not disappointed. Can't wait to try what else they have, so many things on the menu sounded great! read more

See all

Buffalo roll is the most amazing thing on the menu. Like drool worthy i drive 30 mins to get little Sicily i love it!!!

Not exaggerating: worst pizza and experience I've ever had. We placed a timed order for 6:00 on Superbowl Sunday. While I completely understand that they were busy, having worked in pizza restaurants for 4 and a half years now, I am disgraced by the way they handled the order. Not only did we not recieve our pizza til nearly 6:50, but the pizza was extremely undercooked. The crust was white and flimsy, the cheese wasn't fully properly melted, and it was just terrible. When I say just terrible I mean: the ingredients are clearly super cheap which I understand might be cost-effective to their business, but it really just genuinely is not good. And of course there was no compensation for the nearly hour late order. This is not how a small business should ever be run. While I understand they were busy, they could've handled the situation way better. For this experience, they will certainly never get my business again. read more

About a month ago I order food from Little Sicily. I was told my food would arrive in 30 to 35 min. After 55 min I call to see where my food was. Guy who answered was kinda rude and just said it's on the way. No apology or anything. After an hour and 10 minutes the driver finally showed up and acted like nothing was wrong. The order was like$31 and I gave $40. The delivery goes do you want change? I said yes I've been waiting over an hour and I got no apology when I called 15 min ago. He goes digging through his pockets and says all I have is $3. How do these guys send a delivery guy out with only $3 in change. Of course I took the $3 but I will never order from this place again. Piss poor service and management! read more

i placed a simple order today at 2:15pm from my office ONLY FIVE MINUTES AWAY (maybe even less) for a cheesesteak with fried onions and green peppers with a pepsi...the time is now 4:15pm and there is still no food or phone call. I called to politely ask what the hold up is and i was nastily hung up on. I think that was extremely rude and unprofessional. The fact that im only less than five minutes away there should be no excuse as to why it takes TWO HOURS+ (since it was never delivered). DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. read more

Horrible customer service. Mediocre food. Better places that would appreciate your business.

The Pizza here is good, and they have different Gourmet pizza's you can try. The food is reasonably cheap. The service is fast here. They have a few tables, but it is mostly take out. read more

Horrible customer service and it does not matter how pleasant you are to them over the phone. I will never patronize this business again. PAPA LUIGI's IS WHERE IT'S AT...YOU WILL ENJOY GREAT PIZZA AND FABULOUS CUSTOMER SERVICE!!! read more

Best food and great prices for Glassboro. The wings and pizza are great. The chicken is fresh and the veal is also fresh. They have some of the best fresh to order dinners also. Delivery is quick, prompt and accurate. I always get the foccacia paninis as they make them fresh and make the foccacia bread right at the shop. The staff is courteous and friendly and they also habla espanol to make sure that all customers needs are met. I would recommend this establishment to everybody and everyone. read more

The food is excellent and the the prices are right. I enjoy eating everything on their menu and I like to eat in or get food delivered. The delivery is quick and timely and the food is always made and prepared properly. The staff is very friendly and they try to cater and make all of the food fresh and to order. I promise that you will enjoy it. You must try this when you have a chance or are in the Glassboro area. You will not be disappointed. read more

Their food is fantastic. The service is great and the deliveries are quick. I love everything they have to offer and I love ordering their American cheese fries. Me and my daughter love the mild sauce they use for their wings and we always get it on the side to dip our fries in. We love to get the American cheese fries with the steak fries because they are very tasty. Their buffalo chicken cheese steak with ranch dressing is awesome. Occasionally we eat in but most of the time get delivery because it is quick and convenient. You must try this place if you have a chance as they are always great. I also love the burgers here as they are a lot of burger for a great price. I would recommend this place to anyone and everyone. This is the only place I get food from in Glassboro whenever I am desiring pizza, wings, sandwiches, burgers, or whatever. I give them a 10 out of 10. Keep up the good work guys. Thanks for everything read more