They Skimp on the meats and charge for add-ons they don't give you. Lost me as a customer.

I had 2 large pizzas delivered to my home and sadly the bottoms of them were burnt. The one pizza, a Supreme was burnt black on the bottom. It made them inedible in my opinion. I was very disappointed as this is usually my go to pizzeria. I feel like the quality is slipping. And for what was charged, that's not good value. read more

Johnnys Pizzeria - The burnt bottom of a Supreme pizza. - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Wow! If you are from Philly and LOVE good pizza, you gotta try this place. Good old fashioned thin but artisan dough. No pooey soft dough! The Texas salad was very satisfying. The meatballs and ziti were good as any good Italian restaurant. The wings were crispy and meaty. All of us had a good meal. Tired and don't want to cook? Whomp here it is!! read more

Moving to Sewell from South Philly I guess I am a pizza Snob. Sorry about that. But Johnny's was pretty good. Fast delivery or pick up. Pizza is thin crust which I like and I guess as close as I am going to get to my kind of pizza. I will probably just start making my own pizza this winter. read more

Never had a bad meal here.Cheesesteaks to pizza all are good.Highly suggest the Johnnys special.

Fire food. Been going here for years. Wings are absolutely immaculate. Pizza is just as good

Gotta say i grew up on Johnny's pizza definitely the best in the area. But besides the great food and the great counter girls. The people in the back could give you PTSD any counter girl ive known that worked there feels unsafe and disturbed by the comments some of the other workers make. Someone i had known who worked there left because she felt uncomfortable and when she told the boss was asked to leave and not paid. Could be a really awesome spot but they'd rather employ creeps who cant mind there own business and have 8 of there kids in the eating area screaming. But good food if you can put all that aside. Haven't been there since she told me that. Probably a year ago couldn't tell you if the food changed. Hope it didn't because thats all they got. read more

The WORST customer service I've ever dealt with. My husband and I have ordered here a few times hoping that our orders being incorrect were just a mistake, but will never order here again after our experience today. I called to place my order and the woman who answered my call was incredibly rude. I asked her to apply a coupon & my total actually went up in price because of her mistake. I asked her to explain the price and she was not able to. The past few times we've ordered here, they forget at least one item so we have to wait even longer. Save yourself time, don't order here. There are plenty of pizza places in the area that have better deals and are pleasant to deal with. read more

Their prices do not match their online prices or their paper menu prices. Food quality has definitely dropped. if you want to use credit card then its an additional 3%. I have tried to give them business multiple times but its just not worth it anymore. read more

Ordered pizza for my son's birthday at his daycare the day before for the 12pm next day only to receive a call from the same person that took the order that they forgot while already charged my account. He said they could get it out the following day and said no thank you but his bi was today. They gave me the run around on crediting my account and even said someone called in to cancel because there was enough food. Well that's a lie and the children would have gone hungry if not for the daycare. Looked at my account and was charged over $100.00 for (4) plain cheese pizzas. Ridiculous prices, horrible service. Never again...lesson learned! JM read more

I love this place ! The salads are amazing and you get such a big portion . Sausage is amazing as well !

I have been ordering here for years. For a corner pizza place it is great! Their delivery is quick and the wait for take out is never long. They have the best hot sauce around though so if you are a fan of wings- I would suggest that you try them and the hot sauce! The inside is okay but doesn't give off the type of vibe that you want to sit inside, it is more of a hole in the wall pizza place than a restaurant. I always order take out and within 20 minutes my order is ready. A few tips- the last two times I ordered mozzarella sticks they weren't fully cooked so the cheese hardened on the inside and get cheese on the side of your fries and not on top! Overall, this is some of the best pizza in the area and I continue to come back! read more

I love how they put a lot of cheese on everything! Great customer service and delicious food! read more

Johnnys Pizzeria - a plate of spaghetti and a hot dog - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

There are so many pizza places where I live and johnnys has stood out. Pizza is great. Delivery is fast. read more

Johnnys Pizzeria - Plain pizza - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

See all

I ordered three panzarotti's from you tonight. I had a coupon which was brand new for three original panzarotti's for $14.50. On the phone a woman answered and was extremely rude saying it was $14.99. My first impression was "the woman on the phone is really nasty. I don't know if I still want these", but I figured I'd give it a try anyway. Things went downhill when we went inside. I showed her two coupons both which were valid and from YOUR pizzeria. And she didn't even glance at them. She said she'd accepted them, but when we left and look at our receipt we see she didn't take off the coupons. We went back in to talk to her about the coupons and being overcharged. She rolled her eyes, threw her hands in the area, and went to get her co-worker. When we seen that she through her hands up at us we asked "Do you have a problem?" and her response was, excuse my language, "What the fuck?". At that point we asked for a full refund. I don't trust food from places with such poor customer service. I bet she spit in the food. We also called your business to speak to the owner when we got home and couldn't even so much as get an apology? Really? Is that too much to ask for? read more

Great sandwiches! The cheesesteaks are awesome! Wraps are also good. Fresh ingredients, big portions!

Great pizza, fast delivery and it's heads and toes above the other local places. I moved to Sewell 4 years ago and finally found a spot that saves me a trip across the bridge for good Pizza. Don't get me wrong, I'm not comparing this to some of the Pizzas in Philly, but for South Jersey.... it's delicious. Another awesome note...if you order french fries, and ypu get them delivered....they will NOT be soggy. read more

Quality/standard of food is down significantly from recent years. This used to be my favorite pizza place.

Used to be our go to place. They are now inconsistent and mess up every order. The girl who answers the phone doesn't even know the menu. Ordered buffalo chicken fingers got chicken fingers and fries. Chicken fingers were more like chicken nuggets. That's another place gone down hill. Should've known they've had help wanted sign out front for years. Can't even get people to work there. read more

See all

I wasn't going to write a review, but I still haven't received my full refund from them sooooo I ordered a sandwich from Johnny's and as I was eating it I started to choke on something super sharp. Well it was a shard of hard plastic that took me a good while to throw back up. It was the size of a fork prong. I will not be ordering from there ever again. read more

Johnnys Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

This looked and tasted like the world's worst Cheesesteak Hoagie pizza. You can almost count the pieces of steak on this pizza. Biggest disappointment when you want it. It tasted so bland. Next time I'll pay more and go pick up the best Cheesesteak Hoagie pizza at Angelo's Pizza on Fries Mill Rd in Turnersville; so mad I gave Johnny's a chance read more

Johnnys Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Pizza is good. We ordered from there 4-5 times. Delivery. We live close by. Each time the cheese was sloshing off the pizza and it was basically ruined because it was way too hot to drive. We have never experienced this before. I actually called about this. We asked the next time if they would let it cool for a few minutes so it didn't ruin the pizza in transit. But, the last 3 times the pizza cheese slid right off and we had to reassemble it. I guess we are too close for delivery but this shouldn't happen so we won't order anymore. Maybe we will go in to pick it up. read more

Overall great little hole in the wall. I grew up in Turnersville and I am always looking for some great take out pizza/ Italian food and when I found Johnnys pizza I was pleasantly surprised. Don't get me wrong this is a nice little pizza shop with some delicious food, but don't go in expecting Home cooked Italian like your family makes or a high end Italian restaurant. Other than that My favorite order is the old way pizza with the sauce on top, The calzone which is perfect for sharing and the ricotta is very good, or my husband loves their Chicken Parm subs. Delivery can be hit or miss...I have waited over 40min. sometimes which is a bit weird considering I lived less than 15 min. form Johnny's. That being said they are usually accurate with the time they give you on the phone when ordering. Picking up is recommended if your in a hurry to eat..Most orders were less than 15-20 wait when I ordered over the phone for pick up. I now live in Philadelphia and still will sometimes have to make the trek to Johhnys to curb my pizza craving. read more

Love the lunch specials! Great prices with a great portion of food. The crispy chicken wrap is delicious. Full of chicken, you don't get ripped off. Fries are crinkle cut and delicious always hot and fresh. Pizza is great. Salads are always fresh and crisp. Soups are delicious. Italian wedding is the best!!! This is our go to lunch delivery place. Delivery is always quick and food is hot. Prices are unbeatable! read more

My family and I come here every week. Today when my sister came to pick up our food, the owner charged her extra for a mistake that THEY made. The owner was rude and couldn't even admit his mistake, or give us the food that we had to pay for. We won't be coming back here, sorry that a 19 year old girl's $7 means that much to you. Don't order here, especially online. read more

I ordered two pizzas, fries, and 10 wings. Was told 45 mins for delivery. After two hours the pizza finally showed up cold. I called to complain and the two girls working started laughing and said "hope you enjoy your cold food" They are very unprofessional. I will not eat here or the Mexican restaurant next to it that they own again. read more

Excellent! Great sauce! I am Tired of emilios and Mangia and Mona Lisa- even Brooklyn Square is over-rated! Pizza is fresh and made exactly as you ask- crispy crust- you get just that! Friendly and very accommodating- kkapper- Jackson. read more

Great pizza. Fast delivery and pizza is always hot. They have great cheesesteaks and meatballs sandwiches too.

This is my favorite pizza place around, but that's a personal preference. I like a sweeter sauce and a thinner crust, and I think Johnny's has it down. Prices aren't bad and they're pretty punctual, which is a definite plus. read more

Good quality food, they don't go cheap with any of it. Try the crispy buffalo chicken wrap! Mmmm

Lunch Box deals are fantastic and they don't cut anything out great food , trying everything on menu one lunch at a time

Very straightforward food for a Philly-area pizza joint. Prices are great and cheesesteaks are surprisingly very good. Definitely one of the best quick food stops in the area. read more

Ordered pizza ther last night. Why n Haven't I tried this place sooner? Excellent pie. read more

Was my favorite place to order from but, will probably never order from here again. First forgot my dressings and cheese for my three salads then came back with the wrong kind and no cheese. Called to inform and was told "sorry I have to go, I'm too busy" horrible for business read more

This is the second time I've ordered from this place and got the wrong order. I ordered a veggie Stromboli which the menu said consisted of broccoli, spinach, tomato and garlic. It came chocked full of mushrooms which I could be allergic too. I called the establishment , the foreign owner told me it was a computer mistake, would not refund my money and then promptly hung up on me when's asked for a refund. I will never order from this place again. I've had a neighbor order and receive the wrong pizza and had that pizza taken back in lieu of a new pizza...so, this place is bad news all around. So unprofessional . Will never refer this place to anyone read more

We ordered the Chicken Florentine pizza and received the Chicken Parmigiana pizza. I called to let them know the order was incorrect... They fought me tooth and nail saying what the delivered what what I ordered. They did attempt to read back the order but the English is difficult to understand so I may have off the cuff said "yes". It was the end if their business hours when we received our order and spoke with the manager. He was not helpful at all and blamed us for the miscommunication. I asked for a credit because I didn't want them to stay after hours and make us another pizza, but they insisted on delivering the correct order. By this time it was 10pm and we were hungry and they were closed. It's a shame it had to come to this, but we will not order from here again. read more

Just had the hot roast pork w/provolone and long hots on a perfectly toasted roll, DELICIOUS!! I found a new place in Sewell.

Regular customer, yet when placing a phone order today, pricing went up significantly. Would not honor menu. Told new menus were on order. Asked if on-line prices were correct. Told on-line would be updated next week. No idea regarding customer service and keeping a repeat regular customer. There are other pizza establishments in the area and WILL NOT SHOP again. read more