Fantastic pizza but they use AI when you try to call to place an order, so four stars.

A month ago we got an Italian flag pizza and it was delicious. Last week we got one and the crust was tough and the toppings were sparce. We were very disappointed, especially since we were sharing it with a friend. The pizzas are not consistent. read more

We get cheesesteak strombolis and pizza here... we love it. They are hot, delicious and great with pick up or delivery.

We visited this place in a Sunday evening. The place was not far off the main road and there was plenty of parking. We hadn't been before and the menu is HUGE so we opted to use the mobile ordering screen on the wall so we didn't hold up the register line. The employees were friendly and offered to help us decide on food once they took the other customers orders. We ended up with a medium pizza, small calzone, boneless wings, and the corn nuggets. The food came out quick and portion sizes were massive!!! We loved everything and needed a to-go box since the sizes were so big and we couldn't finish it all. My only complaint about the place is it was really hot inside, almost like a sauna, and occasionally it would get a little smoky from the ovens, but with food that good that the entire family liked, I really can't complain. read more

See all

Friendly, clean, reasonably priced, and oh so fast. I didn't call ahead and decided to order there and wait for my food. Only 15 minutes before my two strombolis, wings, and bacon/nacho cheese fries were handed to us to go. Food was hot and delicious. Located about a mile north of the center of Lititz, there is plenty of parking. I'll definitely be back and can't wait to try their pizza. read more

Lititz Pizza Company - Personal Delicatessen Boli (pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami, mozz cheese), bacon/nacho cheese fries, and 6 wings. - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Simply "Spettacolare" That means spectacular in Italian. This is my first time here and I must say that I am very impressed. The Supreme Stromboli is to die for. Basically everything is delicious, why because everything is homemade and fresh. This is a legit ITALIAN family business and it shows. Don't bother going anywhere else when visiting Lititz. Enk read more

Very cool space. Plenty of inside and outside dining. Fairly busy at 6:30pm this past Friday. I popped in before a show at Micky's Black Box to grab a sandwich. Friendly and quick service all around. Huge menu. I ordered the Chicken Rancher w/out bacon. It looked quite good, but the grilled chicken (cubed) was not good. Not sure of the brand, but it was tough, chewy. It actually had me take a piece out of my mouth to be sure it was cooked the way it felt when biting into the meat. Taste was OK, but I ate half since I was starving and tossed the rest. The pizzas being served looked great. If I end up in the area again, I'll have to go with a pie. Can't trust the chicken (grilled or fried) will be any different. Bummer. read more

So. For 2 years I've wanted to try this place and just never did. I called in placed an order at 7:20pm on 9/13/25 for 3 pizzas. 1 pepperoni 1 meatball 1 white add shrimp 1 cannoli and 1 peanut butter explosion. The guy that took the order even suggested the peanut butter over the chocolate for my wife. Told me 25 minutes. I arrived 30 minutes later. Paid the bill to find out they did NOT even make the pizza. The young lady apologized and now told me they would be ready in 10 minutes.............. I'm a full blooded Italian and pizza takes longer than 10 minutes. So I'm outside smoking and writing this and really ticked off. No offer to compensate even after I left them a nice tip. Soooooooo as us Italians you know what .........???????!!!!! Yup first and last time here. Again the order was in the system but they never bothered to make it . I'll go back to Uncommon pizza. 40 minutes later got my pizza and again back to uncommon pizza forget this place read more

Lititz Pizza Company - KMA NEVER AGAIN heading back to UNCOMMON Pizza on the other side of Lititz - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

New to Lititz and have been looking for some great pizza.....found it. The staff were cool and welcoming. The vibe was cool....the Whispers were playing. Can't wait to explore the menu. read more

Friendly service, delicious subs! We had super italian and sausage pepper and onion subs. We will be back! Thank you

Wow. Amazing spot! It doesn't get any better or closer to New York than this. In town on biz, and being from new york / long island i know my pizza and food. Excellent pizza and heros, dont walk, run to this place. Trust me. read more

The wings were really good but the pizza sauce is where I stop at. The pizza sauce was basically onion sauce.

When you mention you want sautéed onions 5 times to the guy who apparently does not know English very well. I expected him to get it right but no, I did not get any onions. One simple order with one small change that should have brought me what I asked for. Bad business and now I cannot chance what I end up with in the future. read more

The service is helpful & friendly. The staff stays busy attending to customer's needs. The food is good. There is a nice variety. 3 or 4 different soups. Loved the marinara sauce served with the huge, crispy onion rings. I also loved the retro tables. This was my first visit, but I plan to return. . read more

See all

Great pizza! Love this place. We usually get carry out. Had a calzone, spinach pizza, and greek salad recently that was ready quickly and right when we pulled in. We will go there again and again! Best in Lititz! read more

Decor: overall a nice place. Classic old time pizza place vibes 4/5 Service: service is quick and friendly. Generally no order issues 4/5 Food- Pizza: classic PA pizza. Sauce is plenty flavorful and definitely the best part of the pie. Cheese and pepperoni are fine but nothing special. Was a little undercooked and lacked a nice crisp 3/5 Mac and cheese bites: I'm a huge Mac and cheese bites fan and these were bad. Dry and deff not worth the price. Didn't even eat them all 1/5 Corn nuggets: pretty good corn nuggets. Nothing amazing but solid 4/5 read more

Overpriced. They charge for small containers with any sauce or dressings, and prices do not match the menu prices. Extra charge for any topping or sauce. read more

I took off a star because the person taking our order seems to lose his patience with us. This was our first time in the area and found this place on Yelp although it said it was an American Diner but that had been closed and turned into the pizza place. Orders are taken at the counter. We went for a late lunch about 2:00. We had some questions about the menu which is very large. It was kind of award to stand at the cash register and look at the menu. The guy was a little short with us and told us quickly about a lunch special or the pizza by the slice, like he wanted us to hurry. So we took his suggestion and got a 1/2 a hot chicken sub with fries and a drink for only $10. While ordering we didn't want the ranch dressing on the sandwich but wanted honey mustard instead. He tried to get us to order a different sub that came with honey mustard. He acted like he didn't want to change the way the sandwich was built. We were the only people in the entire place! Even while we were talking to him he was tapping his fingers like someone who was completely bored with us. So we just asked for them to leave off the ranch and not add anything else. That he would do. Drinks are self serve. My husband didn't even notice, until his drink was half gone that there was "something" dark in the bottom of his glass. Minus one star. I didn't even want to look as I still had half my food to eat. The guy was very apologetic and gave him a styrofoam cup to replace it. The person who took our order did bring it out and place it on the table. No silverware was offered and we were afraid to ask. He did come back out and ask if we wanted some honey mustard after we started eating. So we did get that finally. Now the 3 stars are for the food! Delicious and came fast and hot. The sub was huge and full of flavor. It was so large I wish I had a fork to eat some of it out of the bun. The fries were crisp and oh so hot. Not greasy or salty, just perfect and loads of them. It was truly a bargain to pay $10 for all this food. If we lived closer we probably would order take out. read more

Lititz Pizza Company - Sorry I had already eaten some of it when I remembered to take a photo. It doesn't show how huge the fries are or the sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

We just moved to the area and were too tired to cook tonight, so we took a chance on this place. And wow are we glad we did. We got a meat lovers and mozzarella sticks to go and both were excellent. The crust is New York style, the cheese is generous, and each of the meats stood out. The mozzarella sticks were proper salty and crisp, which no restaurant south of Delaware seems to be able to do . I think we've found our go to pizza joint. Next time we will try sit down, as the restaurant has a nice patio and a cool 60's diner vibe, and we want to try the cannoli, which we didn't notice they had until we got home! I do wish they did their own delivery instead of DoorDash, but if that's the only thing I can find wanting, that's pretty damn good. read more

I've been trying to figure out how to have pizza delivery from the Lititz pizza company -from day one. Customers should not have to search all of the internet for a means of delivery from Lititz Pizza Company. I'm going to back Nonna's in Akron, PA. Highly rated, and delivery is readily available. They've served me well with many delicious orders. Great Italian pasta, and pizza. Nonna's in Akron, PA. Nonna's in Akron, PA. Nonna's in Akron, PA. Nonna's in Akron, PA. read more

New pizza place. It was packed when I came to pick up the food, and they were definitely in the weeds. Order well ahead of time as it can take an hour plus for orders. Overall the food was ok, wings were good but not a lot of sauce and they charge for blue cheese, I ordered extra crispy, but they were not. The chicken parm sub was 4 stats, could use more sauce, but quality chicken is used. Pizza... their menu says Gourment Brick Ovenn but they don't have a brick oven... so I was a little confused by that. The pizza was just OK and a bit under done. I will give it another try, but they have some stuff to work out as all new restaurants do. Also pricey $ 43 for a small pizza, chix parm sub, small wings and a salad. read more

The negative reviews truthfully shock me. Me and my fiancé eat here almost once a week. I've tried a few of their subs, always delicious. Pizza is good also. The staff is always friendly even when they are super busy. It's the only place we go to in this area with this type of food. Caruso's in rothsville we had nothing but negative deliveries. Even pick ups. Food went down hill. Thankful for this spot read more

Moved to Lititz from New York last summer and haven't really had pizza since, which is a shame. I finally looked into some local pizza places the other night and was mostly disappointed with what the area how to offer- but then I found Lititz Pizza Company! It just opened in January so there aren't many reviews but I decided to give it a shot, and I'm glad I did! The outside was cute with red lights and a nice logo, though a little hard to find from the street without knowing where to go. The inside looks like an old diner type setup with a pizza counter- those red vintage looking chairs and tables. Pretty cute! All brand new too so it's all nice and clean. Got a large margherita pie, large buffalo chicken pie, greek salad, and 12 piece garlic knots, about $60 total. The pizza was good, not too greasy but still flavorful. Crust was a bit on the softer side but maybe that's more common around here. Could've used more chicken on the buffalo pizza but it was decent. Garlic knots were super small but they were the price of less usually so the value adds up. Greek salad was good. Of course this was definitely PA pizza and not NY pizza, but it was pretty good for what it was. I'll definitely be ordering again soon! read more

My wife and I finally got around to trying Lititz Pizza Company and we were very pleased. The restaurant had a unique appeal with the inside looking like a 50's diner. The food was really good. I had a chicken cheese steak and my wife had a California chicken cheese steak. Both were outstanding and I would go so far as to say that my chicken cheese steak was as good as any I have ever had. We also had an order of fries and they, too, were outstanding - not sure what they did, but they were exceptional. My wife and I had been looking forward to this place opening and now that we have tried it, we will be back on a regular basis. Thank you for a wonderful experience. read more

Lititz Pizza Company - Dining table - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

You need people answering the phone who know what they are doing. We ordered on 12/13/23 and the female person taking our order butchered the entire thing to the point where people couldn't eat due to food allergies and we had to make other arrangements. Get it together! read more

We had a phenomenal experience with Lititz Pizza Company! We needed to feed 40 teachers/staff members at our local elementary school. I called them up and they agreed to make 4 trays of delicious pasta and meatballs, salads and garlic bread. The owner made it work with our budget and even came in to cook on his day off so we could pick it up hot. He called the next day to make sure all was good. The teachers were RAVING about how delicious their meal was. As a PTO, we will absolutely use Lititz Pizza Company again! We are so thankful for them! read more

Lititz Pizza Company - All the hot trays of pasta, huge meatballs (that were gone that evening!) and bread. They also provided large trays of salads! - Pizza Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Got food delivered quickly. Good atmosphere Diverse menu options with everything from Italian to Mexican to traditional American cuisine

Within walking distance of the Lititz Inn we were pleasantly surprised for the 4 cheese pizza was hot and and plenty of cheese. Thumbs up!

It's really in the details. We have ordered from LPC for a while, and we've enjoyed their food every time. Their meatballs are amazing, pizza is great, and we love all the appetizers. The meals come with tossed salad and focaccia bread. They are both super tasty. We've also found they are the best value in the area. Please consider this place as your go to for pizza in Lititz! read more

Last day of school we took my son and several friends here not realizing they were closed on Monday. The owners were there and insisted we come in! They made pizza just for us! Not only is the pizza the best ever, the customer service is above and beyond!!! read more

2nd visit the week of Jan. 17, 2022. Ordered a chicken Parmesean sub and a greek salad. 12 inch sub(?) very tasty, could use perhaps 2 more tsp. of sauce; good bread. Real chicken, and not microwaved (Hot and Fresh?). Elaine on "Seinfeld' would classify this as a "Big Salad". Didn't skimp on the Kalamata olives. the sub was comparable in Price to a sub from Quizno's or one from Bruno's in Lititz. read more

Very good pizzas & salads here! The GF crust is one of the tastiest around! Recently placed a large order for 7 pizzas (2 GF) for a party, and it was ready as scheduled, hot, and tasty. Always great customer service! read more

Was told by a friend to give this place a try and was glad we did. They have a good variety of food. They have great gluten free pizza crust options. I do not have to be gluten free, and their pizza holds their own with any other place I have been to. Will definitely be going there again. read more

Second time coming here both times food was outstanding!!! Great customer service and the ingredients are of great quality 10/10 absolutely love this place! read more