This is one of the must visits on my list when going to the Circleville Pumpkin Show. There is always a very long line out the door and down the street to get into this little shop, but it moves pretty quickly. I think the wait was about 10-15 min this year. Once inside the small bakery, look to the left and see the World's Greatest pumpkin pie, this pie is really big and many people take their photo in front of it. What to buy during the pumpkin show is pie and doughnuts. This year we just bought the doughnuts. I have learned that they sell pumpkin doughnuts all year round. However it's too far for me to drive so I'll just get my fix in October each year. read more

Lindsey's is a timeless cornerstone biz of Circleville. They have killer pumpkin donuts, and beyond the orange season, they aren't half bad with cupcakes and cakes too. They are very reasonably priced, and have a make-shift drive thru (in the adjoining alley) for early-morning donut pick up, etc. My only main complaint is that they have a reputation for being somewhat lenient on their sanitary measures, but as long as you don't think about it too much they are still delish! read more

They cater well to the pumpkin cravings of Circleville and make great cakes, cupcakes and cookies in the off-season. We've bought countless cakes from them throughout the years, from my every-six-year-old-wants-to-be-Cinderella cake, to the cake served at my grad party and have always been more than pleased. I actually asked for Santa to bring me Lindsey's pumpkin doughnuts when I was 2. read more

Well, Lindsey's has the best pumpkin donuts in the world, that's not really a question. But they also have delicious long johns, and pretty much everything else. The women in there are super nice as well. It's been around for such a long time, and I hope it will continue. Be sure to check them out during Pumpkin Show to see the world's largest pumpkin pie! read more

Delicious cookies and donuts. I love the new look inside as well. They are giving a traditional place new life and I love that. Super tasty treats that any visitors to Circleville need to stop by and check out. read more

Opening day @ the pumpkin show with the fam, Lindsey's is a must stop .. Made it to the bakery and yes there was a line, duhhh..lined moved fairly quickly (15 min), once inside they had the world's largest pumpkin pie (great photo op!), many excellent choices but I had one thing on my mind Pumpkin Donuts!!! Which is the reason for the lines outside this little gem of a donut shop...ordered a box of dozen pumpkin donuts with a coffee (delicious)and found a nice little table across the street to enjoy my donuts and coffee...The donuts were awesome!! Slight glaze on the donut, but the actual donut tasted like a luscious cake, with a slight orange color - bomb!!!! And they are even better when you take them home and heat them up!!! OMG, so get a few extra for home as a treat...you won't be sorry..do yourself a favor and get there for the pumpkin donuts at the Pumpkins Fest or anytime, they truly are a treat!! read more

The pumpkin donuts are definitely addicting. It's hard to eat just one, just saying!

2 words. Pumpkin. Donuts. I'm also amused by their selection of "Lindsey's bakery" t shirts.

This was our first time getting pumpkin donuts from here and it won't be our last! I will continue coming here each year for the pumpkin show! We were hesitant with waiting in such a long line, but it was worth the wait. This was the best, most moist and flavorful donut I have ever had! We got half a dozen and they did not last long! We look forward to returning when we are in town again! read more

The icing on their cakes is to DIE for, there is no other competition for it. If you want to order anything ahead of time in the fall, order very far in advance because three get super busy and backed up with the pumpkin show. read more

By far the rudest employees we have ever had the displeasure of encountering. We have come for years for the thumbprint cookies, and despite following all of their "suggestions" for arriving early, calling ahead, and being patient, we arrived to the Pumpkin Show disappointed. They kept saying that they didn't plan ahead accordingly and didn't have the materials to make it, like they have for a few years now. You'd think they'd learn eventually that planning ahead is half the battle. Normally, we wouldn't make a stink about some missed cookies, but their attitudes about the lack of them was what iced the cake. No apologies, no suggestions for anything else, and just an "I really don't care" attitude. We are a VERY numerous family, and we WILL be telling our friends about the disgusting customer service. read more

Best thumbprint cookies you will ever have for sure. Been in same spot for decades and is awesome every time. Very well known for their pumpkin donuts which are fantastic for sure and you should buy a dozen. Worth the drive from wherever you are from. read more

I love this place. The doughnuts are amazing every day! I cant recommend it enough. The staff are friendly and fun, the cookies are delicious the pumpkin pies are a fall favorite. Support your local Bakery! read more

Lindsey's Bakery is a common stop for those that visit the Circleville Pumpkin Show. I stop here every year at the show to get the wonderful pumpkin donuts. While I know they're available year round. Something about getting them during the show males them better. These donuts are so moist and tasty that they don't last long in my house. They are even great when they start to dey out after a few days! The bakery also carries other wonderful coomoea and pastries. The huge pumpkin pie is also always somethi g to see when at the show. read more

Year round favorite for Pumpkin Donuts and if you come during the Circleville Pumpkin show you will most likely have to stand in line to get them (if they are not sold out) but well worth the wait. All of their baked goods are Over the top, but their Pumpkin donuts are the Bomb. read more

The best cake donuts you can find in the state of Ohio, or for that matter, anywhere else in the US! Always fresh and always excellent. The only thing that I would steer clear is the cupcakes and cakes. The icing is far too sweet and doesn't complement the vanilla cake. But the donuts are to die for and the service is excellent! read more

The best pumpkin doughnuts (available all year) AND a drive-thru.

This place is amazing. A great old school bakery. Pumpkin donuts are awesome. They also make great cakes.

I have been going here since I was a kid. The owners need to start respecting the quality of their food, and worry less about profit. Today I bought thumb print cookies, I asked if they were fresh, but they were very stale and hard. They belonged in the trash not in a customers hands. Last year my wife saw the owner at big lots buying lots of cake mixes. It was graduation time and I know that they are busy, but we had ordered a birthday cake and it tasted like a cheap box mix, not their normal cake (our family buys 5-6 per year). I can't say for sure, but strange that the owner was seen buying cake mixes a few days before and our cake tasted like a cheap cake mix. If their food is fresh, it is good, but unless you are ready to put up with inconsistent quality, I would stay clear read more

Lindsey's Bakery here in Circleville offer some of the absolute best pumpkin Donuts that you will ever have. They're made fresh everyday along with many other of there donut creations. They also make the largest pumpkin pie for the pumpkin show here in town. Come by and grab some pumpkin Donuts and you won't be disappointed. I highly recommend them to everyone. read more

I come from a small town in Massachusetts, where all the local bakeries were shut down years ago and replaced with Dunkin Donuts and Tim Horton's. Thus, Lindsey's was a welcome surprise. I get treats here way too often (being across the street from my work, I'm bound to gain 50 lbs by the end of the year!) and everything I have tried so far is delicious. The best? Pumpkin donuts! read more

Best donuts I've had in a long time!! Nice people too! And did I mention a fritter the size of a small cat!

The best pumpkin donuts ever, available year round. They have other flavors of course. Great small town family business.

Definitely worth the drive no matter if it's Pumpkin Show time or any other time of year. Couple dozen pumpkin donuts I suggest for future visitors. My kids love them and they aren't fans of too many things pumpkin flavored. Delicious. read more

Our first time to Lindsey's was a fabulous experience!!!! The staff were very pleasant and generous. They let us sample a donut before we bought several because we had never had them before. I bought a creme horn and that left only one so they gave me that one free. Great Bakery!!!! Will definitely return!!!! read more

Love love love this place!! First time I had ever gone here was last year, And OMG I loved it small cute like homemade donuts YUM YUM. I even took some back to Buffalo..But now I live here in circleville and I still go for the pumpkin doughnuts only thing ill get! read more

I was born in Ohio and now live in Idaho for the past forty years. I have ate there cream horns sense I can remember . I always get me a couple when I go back home to Ohio . I love taking a picture and bragging to my friends on facebook about my cream horn. They don't not have a place any where in Idaho that I know of that can beat Lindseys . Thank you for making me happy when I come home. I want to order some and have them shipped to me in Idaho so I can share with my grandkids.. read more

I love this bakery! I have been coming here since I was 9 years old. I love their thumb print cookies! There white cakes with butter cream icing are better than any I have ever had!! Try their pumkin doughnuts...mmm good!!!: ) Melissa read more

Ever since i remember my birthday cake has always been from this little bakery. It simply has the best cakes, donuts, cookies, and pretty much anything along those tasy lines. Im giving this location a 5 star because its amazing in taste and value, and has a friendly enviroment. If you ever come through Circleville, OH, stop and try it. You will be pleased that you did. read more

Great pumpkin donuts! Fresh and homemade. Great service. I only took off one star because the sugar cookie was very dry but everything else was great read more

Love the old-time bakery feel. Pumpkin Donuts are good, but we LOVE to get cakes made for birthdays and special occasions. Bottom line, they just taste better than the big box stores. read more

For these yummy donuts be prepared to stand in line especially if you want to go into the bakery. They did have a small cart set up in front of the bakery that had just the pumpkin donuts, pumpkin pie, and thumbprint cookies. You will still have to line up but not as long as the bakery building. read more

I love this bakery! The PUMPKIN DONUTS are the best!! You can't just buy one or eat one!!

I have a friend that lives in Florida that loves there white cake with butter cream icing so much,that I hand carry it through the airports

PERFECT! Love everything they have! The best cakes around make sure you add buttercream icing, its amazing.