Lickity Split

My family always loves anything we eat from Palermo's. Sometimes it is take out and other times we…read moresit down. Most of the time we get cheesesteaks there and they are always enough for 2 full meals! Our son either gets a personal pizza or a burger and always loves either! We have had pizza, stromboli, and other hot sandwiches. All are yummy and plenty of food!

They have excellent food and service. We have tried a variety of things on their menu and we are…read morenever disappointed! I would highly recommend this restaurant .

Small cheesesteak calzone

Large cheesesteak

See all

Side salad

Coffee Co - New Holland

4.0(49 reviews)

0.6 mi

Everything was homemade and local grown. We bought two huge loaves of sourdough. Everything was…read moredelicious.

Was in the area for a party. The hotel we stayed in gave us vouchers for breakfast at this…read morerestaurant! It's been a few weeks but I remember the service was great! And the food was all freshly prepared! It felt as if you were visiting someone's home! The pancakes were memorable! My vegetables omelet was awesome! The coffee was fresh and flavorful! I would definitely return when im in the Lancaster area!

The sit down bar and to go pastries/drinks.

Jammy Sammy

See all

Exterior room! Super bright and clean.

New Holland Coffee Company

4.3(146 reviews)

1.8 mi

•$$

You fall in love with this coffee shop as soon as you walk through the doors! This shop is so…read moretastefully and beautifully designed with texture, warmth and beauty. The gorgeous hanging baskets are everything! The food was delicious and I appreciate the sourdough option. Service was friendly and fast. Will definitely visit again if I'm back in the area!

I would have to say I am not disappointed at all! Super friendly staff delicious coffee and they…read moremake some amazing sandwiches and some other fun, delicious treats as well! There is a mix of older and younger, it is a pleasant brightly lit space that feels clean, inviting and warm. I was very pleased with the experience overall and I would definitely come back!

Strawberry Cheesecake French Toast

See all

Vanilla Iced Coffee

Carini's Italian Restaurant

3.0(41 reviews)

2.3 mi

•$$

Food was prepared in a microwave and it was coldddd! Service…read morewas not good, it seemed I was doing them a favor by being there! I don't look to be treated like a King BUT when I pay for NYC food I would like NYC food, not microwaved food. My wife does better er in the RV!!!

Waitress was rude and couldn't get anything right. Steer clear of the chicken parm it's frozen…read morechicken patties with sauce and cheese. Best thing we had was the 20 oz bottled Pepsi. Still tipped and didn't even acknowledge us or say thank you.

Melted plastic, yum!

Clams covered in raw tomatoes that I'm allergic to

See all

Bruschetta!

New Holland Family Restaurant

4.0(18 reviews)

1.3 mi

My first dining experience was at New Holland Family Restaurant in New Holland after a rainy…read moremorning shopping the major greenhouses in East Earl. With an impressive extension menu, I opted for hot tea with honey (they offer a selection of herbal teas), chicken corn soup, and a Patty Melt, all of which were delicious. Excellent service and timely check-ins for an enjoyable meal to dry out for the next greenhouse visit. There is plenty of parking and a welcoming diner atmosphere, and I will definitely come back in the future.

The food here was really good diner food and I loved it. I had the turkey dinner with stuffing,…read morebaked potato and baked corn. Finished with their jello salad thing that was so country delicious. The downside was the service. It wasn't busy and the server left all the empty dishes on our table even through dessert. We weren't offered drink refills once. They didn't check on us at all except to move the meal along. The server seemed to not have the answer to some basic questions along the way as well. If it were busy I could excuse this but she was 'busy' talking to the busser girls who were all hanging in the corner not doing anything. We were in the area visiting for the weekend and come to the area often but probably won't be visiting new holland family restaurant again.

Broccoli salad

See all

Corn bake

A Slice Of Brooklyn

3.2(30 reviews)

1.3 mi

Very great customer service. They didn't have the plum tomato pizza. So I ordered a different pizza…read moreand got free garlic knots and he was very kind and understanding:) made it worth the wait. Pizza came out wonderful.

My boyfriend and I were on a mission to get some crispy thin crust pizza somewhere. We always pass…read moreby this place in Lancaster and decided to try the New Holland location because it was closer to where we live. I didn't know that they have a drive-thru window which is kinda cool. There is a parking lot in the back of the building or the side. The inside was a little dim in some areas coming off more dingy than cozy but interior was all clean and cozy other than that. We were the only people eating there on a Saturday night at 6pm which is fine by us. TV had NASCAR racing on so it wasn't so quiet and awkward. The staff were nice; the girl who was our waitress checked on us and was kind. We ordered at the counter then sat. Service was not very quick to get our food considering how many orders they had for pickup/delivery/door-dash happening. We got a grandma pizza, garlic bread, chicken Caesar salad and two soft bottled drinks. The star of the show was the grandma pizza super delicious!! The chicken in the Caesar salad was cooked very well. That's a big thing to me is if the chicken is overcooked, undercooked, pre-frozen etc. This chicken tasted pretty fresh and not frozen. Overall, I would give this experience a 4/5 stars. We would come back.

Chicken Soda - 2 Liter

See all

Sal's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

3.3(40 reviews)

2.1 mi

Place was so hot inside we had to order to go. Cheesesteak was awful- tiny and no meat. Go…read moreelsewhere!

We were looking for someplace to eat on Memorial day and a lot of places were closed. After calling…read morearound thankfully we found this place was open. We received a welcome greeting by a very friendly lady who gave us menus to look over. We got a really good feeling about who is running this spot. Ordering is at the counter and then you seat yourself. Drinks and table ware is self serve, but they do bring the food out to you. Everyone working there is very clearly out Italian so we expected very authentic authentic meals. The decor is nice, but the booth seating is fast food like. After a short wait the salads arrived, which were very good. I appreciated the sweet marinated peppers on mine. The dressing isn't homemade, but it is Ken's, which is close enough. We also received warm toasted garlic bread. We each ordered pasta. My spouse got the angel hair with marinara which she enjoyed. I had spaghetti with clams which were plentiful, although the whole thing was swimming in olive oil. Way to much for me. At the end of our meal a man brought over some complimentary fried dough balls rolled in sugar which was a nice touch. All in all a nice experience.

Garlic bread comes with dinner!

See all

Hayloft Ice Cream

4.6(25 reviews)

2.9 mi

We found this place closeby to an Airbnb we were staying in and now we have visited 5 times during…read moreour last 3 trips! The pretzels are delicious and they always have a new flavor of ice cream or a food item on special! We've tried the strawberry, blueberry and peach soft serve already! (Peach is my fav so far!) They do meat filled pretzels as well as pretzels sticks and various treats! They also have hard ice cream and food on their menu. My little one enjoys the pretzels, ice cream and the fun playground and pond with ducks! The playground is great and they also have little machines where you can grab some food for the ducks (the fish eat them too !). The general feel and vibe is so comforting and warm - my husband loves going there for that reason alone. The bathrooms are spacious and the women's bathroom has a changing table. They have information for tourists and local things to do as well. One of the best parts about Hayloft is their mission - they work to support at risk youth in the community and all the people who work there are volunteers! Tips left for staff show appreciation and they are very nice. Since we found Hayloft, it has become a "regular" stop on our list of places to visit when we come to PA :)

Very nice place! Service was quick and organized! Try the pretzel. They have beefsteak and cheese…read moreand chicken ranch. I had the beefsteak. The ladies were baking them right in front of you! They were juice and yummy with cheese! They're served warm which was great on a rainy day. There's a pond outside and ducks, a produce stall across the street. I also tried their ice cream which was very creamy! Free water, too. The proceeds go to the Allegheny Boys camp, and I asked the staff about it. Seems like a very worthy cause.

View of playground

See all

Cheesesteak Pretzel Log

Sheetz

2.4(10 reviews)

1.5 mi

•$$$

After my gut busting meal nearby I had to make a quick stop to use the facilities and get some…read moreliquids to help flush out some of that food. I was so full that I knew I was going to be uncomfortable for the rest of my evening. Knowing Sheetz to be accommodating I was in good hands. I don't remember much of this place in terms of the lot. I had one objective when I pulled in here and I wasn't going to pay attention to anything than what was on my mind. I parked, walked in and made my way to the facilities. After I was done there, and listen I needed that, my hands felt sticky and greasy from the meal I had, I made my way to get a drink to take with me on my way. As always, I got myself a sweet tea and merrily went on my way. I made sure to stretch my legs a bit outside before getting back into my vehicle to go on my way.

We had the beef sliders, and the meat was very gross! We both just talked about it and it was a…read morenasty texture and just not tasty. We've had sliders at other sheetz that were great.

Sheetz

See all

Subway

3.8(4 reviews)

1.8 mi

Excellent subway branch. Clean fresh atmosphere, excellent location in New Holland and friendly…read morequick staff. Easy plaza parking.

I'm here every week on Friday afternoon meeting with a client of mine. He buys something every…read moresingle time we are there. I buy something almost every time too. We also tip each time we buy too. Yesterday, my client and I were talking at an table and this lady comes to our table with an attitude and tells us "If you guys want to be in here you need to be a paying customer. You can't conduct business in here." If she used her eyes and brain for even a split second she would have seen that my client had Subway food on the table. Not to mention the damn dining room is ALWAYS empty, filthy, loud with half static country music, and freezing. Don't waste your time or money. I feel bad for the younger women who work for her... you can tell she feels like she is king sh*t of turd mountain. Congrats you your career choice & attitude.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kenneth S.

12 years ago

Who doesn't love ice cream? Lickity Split is one of the best ice cream joints in the county. Scoops are very generous, and there's a wide variety of flavors and items to choose from. The prices are a little on the steep side though; it'll cost you about 5 dollars for a milk shake. read more

Lickity Split - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Restaurants near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Parking near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Desserts near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Things to Do near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Coffee near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Breakfast near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Lunch near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Pizza near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Shopping near Lickity Split

BEST of New Holland, Pennsylvania Smoke Shop near Lickity Split

People found Lickity Split by searching for…

Best of New Holland

Things to do in New Holland

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Lickity Split also viewed

The Udder Choice

4.0

(109 reviews)

Enjoyed a shared sandwich (grilled tuna) with my partner, soups and ice cream. Very interesting…read morespot with lots to look at around the beautiful open barn like building. Would definitely go back when in Ephrata. Arrived at 11:30 and a small waiting line started forming when we left. I'm sure it gets popular during the busy times. They did have counter seating as well.

My first titled Yelp review, Good cake, cold food & a trip…read moreto McDonald's It's Ice Cream for Breakfast Day; Yay!! Oooh Bananas Foster is on the board and their homemade, fudgy chocolate cake and of course - Ice Cream!! Oh heck, I'll have what I usually get: scrambled eggs, rye toast, bacon, hashbrowns, a side of cake (cause it's that good) and a shared scoop of oatmeal raisin cookie ice cream. Our waitress was lovely. Our food came out, surprisingly quick and the coffee/tea refills, were constant. Udder Choice, did you just serve me cold, lumpy hard eggs (as if sitting on the counter for 30 minutes) and bacon, that had been sitting around for too long. I believe you did and I'm not happy about that. I made a special trip for this occassion and I ended up at McDonald's, afterwards.

Boehringer's Drive-In

(139 reviews)

This place feels like a flash in the past! The staff were lovely, and the menus were still from the…read moreoriginal opening, I believe. The menu is a great grabbing go or to sit on the edge of the river and enjoy a beautiful summer day. Sadly, we were not able to try any of the ice cream because we went for lunch however it looked delicious and the menu was large

First time here. It won't be the last time. Good food. There are picnic tables on both sides of the…read morerestaurant. Next time I'll get the ice cream.

Ice Shack

4.3

(22 reviews)

This is a delicious bar-b-que and fast food spot that is all freshly made as ordered! Located in…read morequaint Myerstown, PA, enjoy a scenic farn view while sitting on the covered patio with indoor and outdoor seating. Alot of flies in the summer on the outside and expect to spend $30-40 for a lunch of for 2, but worth every buck! Also, expect to wait for about 15-20 minutes for your food, but it will be delicious and piping hot! The servers are all friendly and pleasant and always service with a smile!

Burger was over done, tomato was tasteless but no worse than any other fast food place, fries were…read moreok waffle fries are not my favorite, but they ran out of ketchup !, Spouse had the pulled pork and loved it, of course she had extra sauce! The brisket is next on my list, since they smoke there own . Over all worth a revisit to this Mennonite run establishment, lots of ice stuff ( like Italian ice ), ice creams , malted and shakes to try

Tin Roof Cafe n’ Sweets

4.0

(24 reviews)

Love the Christmas decor! Stopped in for breakfast and was surprised by how much decor they already…read morehave put up for the holiday season. I ordered and got my sandwich quickly as did my friends.

I have passed this cafe probably hundreds of times and never knew it was there. A hidden little gem…read morein Ephrata for sure! My kiddos and I order food and drinks. I would recommend to friends & family in the area! The staff (including owner) were beyond friendly and the food was delicious. Don't let those 1 star reviews fool you. It was a great atmosphere and they serve ice cream. We will be back!

Griddles Malt Shoppe

(34 reviews)

Bus ride to Columbia for breakfast and the river. Meat lovers omelette , toast. Delicious! Service…read moreis always friendly and surroundings comfortable. And I love the cutlery. Fits my paw nice.

Such a cute old fashioned soda shop. Decor is on point and they even serve old fashioned sodas…read morehere! I got a cherry coke made with the cherry syrup just like the old days. Food is typical of what you would find at any diner. I got a grilled chicken sandwich and fries. Everything was made fresh to order and delicious. Our server was super friendly and service was quick. Give this place a try if you are in town, you won't be disappointed.

Griddle and Grind

(59 reviews)

Stopped here with my daughter on a Wednesday morning. There was only one other table occupied when…read morewe arrived. I didn't know this place existed before today, but I'd definitely come back. I had the Signature Breakfast Crepe, and my daughter ordered the Maple Bacon. We both got the hash brown side. Everything was delicious! The hash browns didn't have the texture I was expecting, but the flavor was a pleasant surprise. The location is unique -- set inside an older home with a fun, quaint atmosphere and relaxing background music. Overall, a great spot for breakfast. 10/10 recommend.

Great cappuccino and pumpkin muffin. Building is listed on the National Register of Historic…read morePlaces. Would be great if an explanation of why were posted in the building. Nice fellow who made the cappuccino didn't know any of the building's history. Great that place is occupied-- with good food and beverages. Let us love it more by celebrating the place's history.

Manheim Twin Kiss

3.9

(47 reviews)

For me, Twin-Kiss has always been about the ice cream, which is always delicious…read more From a simple vanilla cone with rainbow jimmies (I'm a Jersey Girl) to a milkshake to a sundae or even a banana split to go, everything everything is of the highest quality I have been known to grab a Hollywood Burger now and then as my first course before my Cherry Sundae. There is plenty of seating, which is nice when going out with a group of friends.

While waiting in line for my food, no less than 3 customers came up to the window asking for their…read moreorders fixed. The ice cream was good, the service was definitely teenagers. Take that as you will, they did mostly fine, but the biggest takeaway to me, other than the dirty outdated building was the fact that so many people had their orders messed up in such a short time.

Lapp Valley Farm Creamery and Cafe

4.6

(27 reviews)

The restaurant is truly an inviting place that looks homey and like a country style store…read more They have a place for kids to play, ice cream, baked goods, souveniers, and an amazing popcorn place. Apart from the really nice location I feel like this place could really work on the seasoning of their soup specifically. It reminds me of cafeteria food which isn't all that bad but just an average place to eat at. The servers here are all very nice and make you feel at home. Overall it's a chill spot to come and hang out. I am currently sitting on a rocking chair next to a fire place inside the location writing this, come enjoy the atmosphere.

What a great atmosphere! The exterior facade made a great first impression and was a great…read morereflection of the interior space. It's like walking into a farmhouse-inspired shoppe with many local treats including their famous creamy icecream, a delightful seating section of rocking chairs by the fireplace, a full cafe, and a farm-inspired playplace for the kiddos! It's a great spot for friends, community and the entire family! I had the rotisserie chicken noodle soup, and while the thicker consistency is true to the area, I'm used to and prefer a thinner consistency with diced chicken. I've been here on multiple occasions and the service overall is good. On this particular day that I went, the young lady at the counter was very pleasant, sweet and helpful.

Kountry Korner Drive-In

3.9

(22 reviews)

This is my first time here on 6/21. Ordered a hot dog, fries and hamburger bar b que and banana…read moresplit for dessert. The food was good. The cleanliness and the service was very poor. All of the tables were dirty and stayed dirty as we sat there and ate. I had to ask one of the girls if they can clean our table. They bring the food out to you so you would think they would clean the tables and sweep the floor since their in and out of the dining area. One girl was wiping a bigger table behind me and all she did was wipe the crumbs and food on to the floor and seat. After we ate, the dining area was just as dirty then as we when we first sat down. They have all what seems to be high school kids working but they don't seem to be energetic. I may come again if I'm in the area, but definitely wouldn't go out of my way.

On a chilly day it's still a good day for Kountry Korner. My husband enjoyed their homemade chili…read more Service was friendly and quick as always.

Fireside Cafe