Lizzy is FULL of informtaion. She asks you all the right questions to ensure you're getting the…read morebest bang for your buck. She has 3 dogs herself and will share all the tips and tricks she uses for Training, meals, toppers, treats and enrichment. ALSO FREE DONUTS AND COFFEE!

We are so fortunate this store is right down the street from us!…read moreLocally owned and operated. Great selection of food and treats and litter and toys. It has a dog wash station. They give discounts to neighbors and have a program where you buy ten get one free. I love them so and will never go anywhere else for my cat. (We get his food, litter and toys there on the regular and also got his tower, bed and harness there!)

I have been ordering bird seed from Arcata Pet for many years. Always delivered quickly.read more

Friendly staff. Very helpful owner…read more I bought a cage and supplies to help save the family and friends of "Marty Mouse" who took refuge in my apartment. When Marty Mouse wouldn't enter the have a hart humane mouse trap and taught his friends how to let him out of a larger capacity have a hart mouse trap, I gave up and returned their emergency relocation home. The shop workers were very obliging. I highly recommend this pet store also.

I cannot say enough good things about Myrtle Avenue Pet Center. During one of the most difficult…read moretimes of my life, Melanie, Ryan, and the incredible team, stepped in and cared for my cat and dog with a level of kindness, professionalism, and genuine compassion that I will never forget. Every interaction I had with them was thoughtful and reassuring. They treated my animals as if they were their own, attentive, gentle, and incredibly patient. The staff sent me pictures every day. Knowing my pets were safe, loved, and well cared for gave me peace of mind when I needed it most. The owners, and staff here are truly exceptional humans. Their dedication to animals and the people who love them shines through in everything they do. I am deeply grateful for the comfort and support they provided my family, and I will always trust them with my pets.

The grooming is the very best. They pointed out a symptom that pointed to a life threatening…read moreinfection for my dog. She (and her sister) both had surgery and are fine now. But i owe both my dogs' lives to these good people. And i love my dogs sooooo much, so i am extremely grateful! thank you, thank you thank you, Myrtle Avenue pet grooming!!!!!!!! Also, the store staff has been very helpful and supportive as well! ! We are very lucky to have this business in our community.

Hello I'm esme and one thing about me is I love my fish I have a 10 gallon tank with 2 bettas and 1…read moreguppie and today I went to this petco to get my guppie a friend (btw I bought all my fish from this petco) and when I asked for the fish I wanted they started pressuring me about a water test and refused my service because I did not have one and they were very rude I'm very disappointed

Feeling scrutinized and judged.... My girls and I were…read moreexcited to purchase a couple of goldfish. The fish specialist began drilling me on what type of tank I had and then refused service. Even though I have had goldfish my entire life and currently own a 10 gallon tank, 15 gallon tank, and an 80 gallon outdoor tank on my deck. If you're interested in purchasing a fish, I recommend anywhere but there; Finn and Feather(Eureka) and Arcata Pet Store. They are locally owned with excellent service and a great selection.

Was looking for a cool corn snake and found one here. They've got some really cool fish and…read morereptiles. The staff were friendly and helpful. There's also a lot of other pet accessories. Great shop, highly recommend.

Had everything I was looking for and great customer service. I get my flee spray hereread more

Had not EVERY place in the world to do my PHYSICAL Christmas shopping; found the self and a good…read moreChristian friend on premises sipping hot cider from the warmer. Ooo, so warm and friendly! Farmers and dogs are welcomed by the local on-sight denizens. Plenty of supplies for the dogs. Farmers can find the top of the good things that we all need; fence posts and wire, hay, and pipes of all kinds, all tools, all friends, good vibes; and all help for all great dogs and friends!

Was recommended to buy feed for my chickens recently. Bought 150 lbs. for about $60! I was amazed!…read moreThey had a huge selection! Since I am a NEWER chicken lady, one lady answered questions I had, no problem! The woman knows her stuff! I can also say, if you have a love for cast iron.... they had a huge selection of super cool pots and pans! I will definitely go here again!

I have been going here for over 40 years. Love the place…read moreWhen I was a kid I discovered baby chickens in a drawer and my dad bought me some. I still remember the experience like it was yesterday.

Think customer services is dead? NOT! Just had a wonderful experience at the Arcata store. I had…read morea warranty issue and as fate has it my item was a month over the warranty period. Still I thought it was worth going in. Carey called the manufacturer and got a response back to me the same day. I hadn't shopped at Nilsen much because we typically need items more like the lumber yard stocks (lumber, sheetrock, etc). But after looking around and realizing Nilsen has basic cleaning products, boots, socks, Yeti products and even cute home decor I will definitely be giving them more of my business! Shop local!

Great spot to support the local town. Our dogs are happy, wide selection, friendly staffread more

Best pet store around has it all and ao much more! Check it out…read more But they close at 6pm Not 7pm! Yelp needs to change

We have had the most amazing experience working with CAF! We initially became volunteers to foster…read more(which was very simple), then we connected with our foster dog and were able to adopt. Both processes were organized and informative with tons of support. The facility was clean and the staff was kind and compassionate. Any questions I had were answered with kindness and patience. Our new dog had excellent medical care and she is absolutely the sweetest little lady! Thank you CAF for all that you do to support our community, and your community loves and supports you!

Love this place! They always have lots of great treasures to buy. The staff are always so nice…read more We just adopted a kitten named Jazz. Thank you Brittany and Kim. He was worth the wait and a wonderful addition to our family. You are wonderful. Highly recommend!

Great collection of everything pets. Good, Toys,Food, outerwear, leashes and clothing collors, and…read moreetc.

I was taking my dog here to use the self serve bath. I had good experiences until the last time I…read morewent there. I was treated rudely by three young women I had never seen there before. Despite the fact that I paid extra for shampoo because I really liked the shampoo they sell, they kept giving me bottles with 99% water diluted shampoo. Upon request for an alternative bottle I was told, "That's just how it is." And "it's diluted." Yes very diluted. Don't waste your money. I suggest you use the self use dog spa in Arcata where they are friendly and never dilute the shampoo and try to gaslight you into paying for a bottle of water. I will never return to this pet store.