This place attracted us for a dinner because of the high review score. However, It was…read moredisappointed. Both pastas are salty, all the foods are not comparable from what got during the last 10 day's stay in Italy. Be careful, it is over rated

The food was absolutely delish, staff was so friendly and helpful. It was just a lovely dinner with…read morea great atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Absolutely magical...from the family welcome to the ambiance, view, service, attention to detail &…read morethe food! You can tell that every item is hand selected from the olive oil on the table to the house wine selections. Nothing is unintentional & everything is chosen to enhance the menu. The family that runs the restaurant made us feel at home, the portions were generous, the service was so personal & the homemade limoncello was a divine way to end a spectacular meal. The baby squid on pumpkin puree was the best squid preparation I have ever had, the salads were excellent, the pastas were perfection, the fish was so fresh & the preparation with tomatoes & potato was delightful. My daughter had a "complaint" in that she wanted to see the fish head of our flounder... I told her that they cleaned the fish for us, but somehow, the papa heard her in a way that only a papa would & appeared with the fish head on a plate for her to see... she couldn't get over it! It's a smaller menu with each item perfected. I'll be dreaming of returning as I can't imagine coming back to Amalfi without dining here again!

Service was wonderful and food delicious. Nice place off the main square. I would recommend going.read more

Food was delicious and the service was friendly. Calming atmosphere of the hustle and bustle of…read moreAmalfi.

Pictures sum it up. Service was friendly and quick. The bread at the beginning was absolutely…read moredelightful (light, crunchy surface, soft warm inside). We did manage to throttle back and not eat all of it lol, as we wanted to still enjoy our starter and pizza. The oils provided were the perfect compliment for the bread, the salad (and the crust of the pizza). Salad was fresh and light. Pizza rolled out next and we still believe this to be the best pizza we ever had. Not heavy, but filling. The flavors were so rich and bright. Of course I had to have a local beer which paired well. The seating was outside, which was covered in an ivy like feel. It was lemon trees providing adequate sun coverage and of course looked beautiful. We would highly recommend checking out Donna Stella if you're in Amalfi.

Basically most restaurants in Italy get 5 stars because you just can't beat Italian cuisine,…read moreespecially when you are on the Amalfi coast overlooking the beach and water. We ate lunch here twice. It is a great place to find a little shade from the sun after hanging on the beach. We had a few different pizzas and all were equally delightful. Definitely recommend!

Great food and perfect drinks with low prices, glad I chose this place and will be back! Try the…read morecaffe Freddo and the shaved orange and lemon ice!!!!

We got lucky this evening! The restaurant was entertaining a very large group right before opening…read morefully for the 7 PM crowd, but my wife and I managed to sneak in a table around 6:40 PM. The owner -- a true gentleman -- called us back in and found us a spot, and that turned out to be an amazing call. Dinner was fantastic. We were served by a Cuban waiter (unfortunately, I missed his name), who took great care of us. We both ordered the same main dish -- chicken limone with roasted potatoes -- and I added the fresh homemade pasta on the side. What a combination! The bread was delicious too; I couldn't resist setting up my own olive oil, Parmesan, and cracked black pepper dipping plate. This place is an absolute gem and definitely a tough one to get into. I highly recommend making a reservation, even during the slower seasons. Don't miss out -- go and enjoy this truly wonderful restaurant.

We decided to eat at this restaurant because of the high rating. We were able to get a table for…read moretwo immediately because there was an open table outside but it was very cramped. The food isn't good. Below average. I had the seafood risotto which was very salty and the shrimp wasn't deveined. It still had a ton of black stuff inside its vein. My son had the pasta with meat sauce which he said he could make a better one. Tried their house white wine which was awful too. Tourist trap.

Made a reservation on a Tuesday for 2:15pm. They highly recommend reservations to be able to sit on…read moretheir terrace. We can see the city center from their balcony. They don't have anything marked GF on their menu but the server walked me through what I could have. My friend and I started with the La Caprese and they provided me with a GF baguette. For my entree I had the zucchini GF pasta. The pasta was good but the sauce was a bit overwhelming. It wasn't my favorite. My friend ordered the La Genovese with GF pasta and it was really enjoyable. They only had 1 GF dessert so we opted to get the lemon sorbet. They also brought out a few GF candies as well. Overall the service and views were really nice but I wasn't a fan of my entree.

We made a reservation at Da Gemma in advance, but due to unexpected travel disruptions--our…read moretransportation to Amalfi was suddenly cancelled--we spent the entire day rearranging our plans. We attempted to contact the restaurant via WhatsApp, which many Amalfi restaurants use for international guests. Unfortunately, Da Gemma wasn't reachable this way, and as international travelers, we had no reliable way to call them directly. The next day, we were charged a €60 no-show fee. Despite explaining the situation to Simone, the general manager, there was no flexibility or exception made. While we understand the need for cancellation policies, the lack of accessible communication and rigid handling of the situation was disappointing. International visitors may want to keep this in mind when making plans. There are many other welcoming and accommodating restaurants in Amalfi.

The people here are so nice, the food was homemade and soooo tasty, and the ambiance was such a…read morevibe. The lemon tiramisu was one of the best desserts I've ever had.

Fabuloso!! We walked in and had a fabulous time. Service was…read moreexcellent and food was well priced and excellent. this should be on everyone's list. Unfortunately, small restaurant a few tables, but worth happening in if you have the opportunity.

The best meal during our trip to Italy! The clams with linguine were amazing. This place is worth…read moreseeking out in Amalfi. Quiet and peaceful location away from the crowds. Wonderful service too!

The restaurant itself is beautiful and has a wonderful atmosphere, so we were really looking…read moreforward to our dinner, especially considering all the excellent reviews. Unfortunately, our experience did not live up to them. I ordered the shrimp for €26. I received only six shrimp, heavily battered, with nothing else on the plate. For €26, I expected considerably more in both quality and presentation. We also ordered a €9 salad, which was essentially just tomatoes. My wife's food was better, but overall we felt the food was significantly overpriced for what we received. The biggest disappointment, however, was the service. Our server took our order and essentially never attended to our table again. He walked past us several times without checking on us. We asked another server for water; he said he would bring it but never returned. Eventually, we had to get the attention of a third person just to get some water. The restaurant was very busy, and I understand that can affect service, but being busy shouldn't mean customers are virtually ignored throughout their meal. Beautiful setting and atmosphere, but based on our experience, poor service and very poor value for the money. With such high ratings, we expected much better. Unfortunately, this felt much more like a tourist-priced restaurant than the authentic dining experience we were hoping for.

Loved eating at this open air restaurant overlooking the sea in Amalfi. The service was so…read morefriendly and very attentive. I enjoyed the Fritto Misti and the delicious vine of the house. My husband has the ribeye steak and was thrilled with his meal. We already recommended to friends who will be visiting Amalfi.

This was by far our best experience in Amalfi :). The food was amazing and fresh, my mom and i…read moreshared the bolognese pasta and lemon chicken with a side of vegetables and it was very filling and 100% worth the price! Everyone there was also very warm and kind and they were great conversation too , we will probably go back again before we leave. The view is also beautiful, the restaurant overlooks the water and is very nicely decorated. We also had a small basket of bread with olive oil, and at the end tried a limoncello shot which was a new taste for me!