I love this pizza place. Good for big groups. We usually get the salad bars and a bunch of pizzas. The service is fast and the food is hot and fresh. I haven't gotten pics yet but next time I will. The salad bars are stocked, good for kids because they have some arcade games, and the parents can sit for a few mins. Bring change, the cashier does give change though. read more

This is definitely a unique spot in Caldwell, but unfortunately the overall experience was disappointing. The dining area has some seating, although the layout feels a little awkward. The cleanliness also left a lot to be desired--the dining room and bathroom were not very clean, and the bathroom was low on toilet paper and completely out of soap. The biggest issue was the wait time. We waited over an hour for just two pizzas, while several tables that arrived after us received their food first. We eventually had to go to the counter ourselves to check on the order. It seemed like a high volume of takeout orders was causing major delays for dine-in customers. There were also problems with the soda fountain, leaving only Country Time lemonade and water available. Unfortunately, even the water had a strange flavor, so we avoided drinking it. The pizza itself was decent and had a nice crunchy crust, but the service and cleanliness issues outweighed the positives for us. read more

Keystone Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

This place is pretty good. You could get all you could eat pizza buffet for six bucks and for three dollars more get the salad bar that's pretty cheap. I would definitely come here again. The people here were friendly too, and that counts now because a lot of places that I go to there's bad attitude guys and girls that work there. read more

Keystone Pizza - Salad bar - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

The cashier was rude, the pizza crust wasn't fully cooked and the lettuce on my taco salad was brown and soggy. I will not be back. If I want to be treated like crap and get nasty food I know right where to go though. read more

This place is in desperate need of improvements. It's not the worst pizza place I've been to but it's not great. The plus side is they have claw games and a pool table. However the pool table is broken making it hard to actually play. The service isn't great. Multiple times we had to wait for employees to finish gossiping to ask for something. If you don't mind mediocre food and broken games it's alright read more

Keystone Pizza - Taco pizza - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

seems to be very popular, great location. I wasn't impressed with the actual food yet it has pool tables, large room for groups, overlooks the creek. read more

I have been a few times. Pizza is okay, and service is typically younger crowd working that don't care whether you're there or not. Tables are often dirty with dishes and not wiped down from past customers. Maybe a remodel might be nice to get rid of the carpets. I typically will choose any other pizza place unfortunately. read more

Went there last Thursday and the pizza was delicious. The atmosphere was very inviting also.

Looking for an old school pizza place. So excited to see a pitcher of tap beer at a great price. Ordered a salami, pepperchinni and mushroom pizza. Beer was cold and great 5 star. Pizza looked okay but just not the best. Service good with pleasant servers. Not very crowded. Probably not going back as nothing special here about food. read more

Best pizza I've ever had out tastes every spot in Idaho no questions asked so if your looking for a very good pizza spot this is the spot

Lunch buffet is excellent deal. All you can eat pizza & salad bar for $10. If you're familiar with Idaho Pizza buffet, this is virtually identical. I even think the ranch dressing is the same. Now quality-wise, it is not going to be the best pizza around but it is decent to good pizza. They provide a wide variety along with cheesy breadsticks, dipping sauce, and cinnamon breadsticks. Salad bar has everything you need with two types of cheese and cut turkey squares. From other reviews it appears parking can be an issue but they have a ton of signs to inform customers so don't wander off premises and you won't have a problem. 4 stars but giving 5 to offset the dinkuses that give bad ratings for their own stupidity. read more

This was my first time here. The pizza had way too much cheese on it where I could barely taste the toppings that were underneath the cheese. I could only eat one piece and threw the rest away. read more

Ate there with the family in September. The location looked like the original carpet and furniture from the 90s and felt kind of dirty overall. The pizza was mid and they booted our car a few weeks later when we visited another business before planning to eat lunch there. Needless to say we didn't eat there that second time and will never visit their business again. They had Yelp remove my last review somehow. I guess they pay money to make sure no one knows they hit their customers with $270 booting now and then just to spite them for visiting another business first. read more

Good pizza, although no covid precautions were being taken in the restaurant as we picked up our order. We had masks on and none of the workers or other customers. It seemed odd to me, but we're visiting from out of state and I've noticed multiple spots in Idaho not using recommended precautions. read more

See all

Good pizza, good ingredients. Loved the sauce too! Crust is a little thick for my liking so next time I'll try thin crust. Friendly and helpful staff. Nice nostalgic location. read more

These as are always very friendly here and the food is always really good. We recommend anybody to come and sit and watch the weather rush underneath the busit's definitely a Blast from the past read more

Met wife for b-day dinner, arrived early and parked in the Keystone Pizza lot. While waiting, I crossed the street and bought movie tickets. I returned to my car in less than 10 minutes and it was booted! I talked to the manager at Keystone Pizza (all of about 20, female) who told me I needed to pay the man in the parking lot. Sure enough, a man with a card reader from DJ's was there demanding $150.00 to remove the boot. I explained I was waiting for my wife, didn't matter. Needless to say, we didn't stay for dinner. In case you cannot read it: DJ's Parking Enforcement 208-606-0330. UPDATE: Just an update. Called the bank - it was 8 minutes from the ticket sale to the boot heist. Just to let you know, you can reverse the charge on your credit card as "Dissatisfied with Service" and leave it at that. VISA has to remove the charge. If this happens enough, his credit card processor will shut down his processing. read more

Keystone Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Pizza is terrible and now they have parking lot enforcement which boots your car the second you walk out of the parking lot. The price to take it off is $150-$200. It is utterly insane that they get away with this. I will never order from them ever again. read more

Parking was terrible I got a boot on my car in there parking lot and there was no sign saying no parking or anything

Probably my least favorite pizza place by taste... I like Torino's pizza rolls better than their pizza. Also, finding a strand of hair embedded in the pizza didn't help read more

Keystone Pizza - Found a hair embedded in the pizza under the cheese - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

pizza was really good just thought it was funny I knew the owners from when my ex and I used to swing

This place is a local favorite, has been around forever, and is very family friendly and is consistent. The food is good, they make a pretty good traditional thick crust pie, better than the Pizza Hut down the street. The place, however, is a little run down and the COVID precautions are not there. That balances out that there's not many places you can take a family of five where the wait staff is going to be as patient and tolerant in helping you serve food to your family of five. This is an old school neighborhood Pizza joint, with all the good and bad that comes with it, but we like having it around. read more

Had a great pizza on Wednesday night. Nice place with an old school pizza parlor vibe. Air hockey and video games for the kids. Great location right on the creek too. We loved the crunchy crust while still having a thickness that was chewy. Great blend on the crust, perfect balance. read more

Overal, great experience! The food is very creative with different groups of toppings from standard pizza joints. I'm really not a pizza fan but I actually enjoyed the ones my party ordered. The customer service is great and friendly! It's a cute little restaurant. The music could be a tad quieter because when it's busy it gets loud and a little difficult to hear what my family is saying across the table. I definitely recommend! read more

Always our go-to for pizza in Caldwell. Excellent pizza...loaded with meat & veggies, just the right amount of sauce and cheese, perfect crusts. We always order to-go and the wait time is usually only 15-20 minutes. The building could use an upgrade, but the pizza is wonderful! read more

Be careful when visiting establishments downtown Caldwell. The now have individuals sitting around watching for people to park in the wrong spits so they can boot your car. I usually get teriyaki and a pizza. Do not order in advance as i like thongs freshly cooked. By the time I picked up ky teriyaki NY vehicle was booted. Did not get a chance.to get ky pizza as I was told it did not matter unless you pre-ordered. Well keystone I hope it was wort it. You lost my business for life and I wi let others know also​ read more

We come in from Dallas once a year to Visit, family took us to Keystone in Caldwell. Pizza was AMAZING best bread sticks ever! We loved it, place was great for the whole family. Prices are excellent food is delicious, staff is FANTSIC!! Kudos to Keystone for having such a great team and awesome establishment. See you next yr! read more

I'm sorry Keystone but we will probably not be back. The interior is old, dusty, very outdated. The service was good. No complaints there. We ordered a half and half pizza and it tasted pretty darn good UNTIL!!!! the sugar ants started crossing our table top trying to get our pizza! That was rather gross for a restaurant! I did enjoy the view of the creek that flows underneath the restaurant and the water wheel. That's a very nice thing to see! Looks like they have a pretty nice arcade gallery, but we did not use it. I don't know......I just wasn't real thrilled with the place. read more

I have to say the best pizza in Caldwell. Great service very friendly. I wouldd recommend go giving it a try. read more

See all

Nobody wants to talk down about the little guy but I'm sorry, can't give any sympathy stars here. The pizza is terrible. Crust sucks, toppings have no flavor, sauce is also flavorless. If they could make halfway decent pizza I'd take my family here all the time. Just can't. DiGiorno or even Totinos is better. Just really crappy pizza. Sorry. read more

Best pizza in Caldwell by far! Try it and you will most likely agree. Signed: A pizza conisuerrier read more

This is a very good spot for pizza I always have a blast here with my family. It's affordable and have a great selection to pick from. They have a cool vibe inside as well. read more

The greatest little college dive pizza joint there ever was! Seriously you can still get a dinner for 20 bucks here! And they have old 80s arcade!!! read more

Just had takeout last night around 5pm from Keystone and Wow! We have been missing out! Everyone in the family enjoyed the pizza. From the toppings, to that surprising yet pleasing crunch of pizza dough! The final price was a good deal as well. We will certainly bring the kids to have dinner & play the arcade games sometime in the near future! We are glad to have Keystone as there are not a lot of yummy options in Caldwell. I was quite surprised at the other reviews here! (bad/low star) The Only bad thing our fam can say is that the breadsticks with cheese reminded us of that stuff from school lunch - hence the 4 stars. P.s. -Check Google Reviews.- This place is Loved and to Not be missed out on! read more

I just went in to keystone and got the gem state bbq and it was literally the best pizza I've ever had if you haven't tried it you don't know what your missing you better go get one read more

Grungy, dark, and a to-the-point local pizza joint. They offer a decent selection of domestic drafts with reasonable prices on pitchers. A daily lunch buffet is advertised on the front of the rundown building for the mere price of 3.99. They have specials on Wednesdays to take advantage of. No frills and nothing fancy at Keystone. Just good, greasy pizza to satisfy your pie needs. read more

Keystone Pizza - Garlic Chicken. Personal favorite. - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

Just based on the customer service and hard working employees, I highly recommend this pizzeria! Local and amazing! Keep at it!

I absolutely love this place!! Keep in mind I order one thing and one thing only. Pepperoni pizza. Not the buffet, not lasagna. Pepperoni pizza. It ranks as one of the best pepperoni pizzas you can get (certainly the best by a landslide in that area) It has a certain spice that is so good and unique to Keystone. Every time I come back to Idaho, I make it a point to hit this place up. If it closed I'd probably never have a reason to go to Caldwell ever again. Love the pizza. Ps. I always take it to go but the view midday out the back window of the stream is pretty read more

This is our new favorite pizza place. The sauce is mild and delicious, not too overpowering or rich like some. We love their combination and they are very well priced! We also just call our order In and it's ready when we get there. The building is outdated but we always get it to go anyways. On Wednesday they have really cheap large one topping pizzas too so if you want something cheap, it is! read more

Great salad bar and pizza. Reminds me of an old style pizzeria. Interior could use some updates but food is excellent. They have a daily lunch buffet. read more