When I think Keys Cafe, I think Pie and Breakfast... and I was pleasantly surprised to find they have nice curds and make a delicious Rueben sandwich! Hubby had the Black & Blu Burger and thought it was flavorful. We had great service from Catherine M.! read more

See all

Food is excellent atmosphere is excellent but I am giving five stars for atmosphere food and service, I feel that coffee is a little expensive though! And the only other thing I'd like to see is some nuts on top of the caramel rolls, but otherwise five stars at ya! read more

I love Keys cafe and I'm loyal to the Robert Street location. However, I had to go to this location for the mini tiered cake as I don't believe any other location carries it. Talk about ADORABLE! I absolutely love how this Stillwater location has a parking lot. It's located in a strip mall. Easy peasy! Lots of staff behind the counter and ready to help, but I was browsing the dessert display for a bit before i decided on what I exactly wanted. I also ended up getting one of the cosmic brownie macarons. Restaurant was definitely busy, but staff were attentive and it was clean. Mini tiered cake and cosmic brownie were delicious and I'd definitely get both again. read more

Keys Cafe - Mini tiered cake - Bakeries Near Me - Stillwater, Minnesota

I came at 8:25 pm and the doors were locked. I just asked and pointed to the person that works there behind the counter & when the lady came to open the door i asked if I can get a piece of pie to go and she replies "well we're closed.." and I responded with. "Oh I thought you guys close later"... she had nothing else to say so I just walked away I don't even know why businesses post their hours on yelp or on their website to be at 9 PM if they're not even gonna follow it.. especially if I'm only asking to cut a piece of pie from what's already there and take it to go when there's still several booths of people eating. read more

What a great new addition to the Stillwater area...our very own Keys Cafe! It's family owned restaurant and very beloved in the twin cities. The menu is extensive and you can order breakfast at anytime. This specific Keys even has a bar which is unique from other Keys I've been to. The staff are friendly and the food comes out FAST! This evening I got the Loon Omelet which has this delicious gluten free mushroom sauce and it was delish. The rest of my party was happy with their meals as well. read more

See all

Our second visit to the new Stillwater location since it's soft open. The full menu has a plethora of options to meet anyone's culinary preferences. Again, loved the decor (ship lap is gorgeous) and photos. Very well done! Had the Rachel, and hubby had the GREAT deal soup/sandwich with a salad AND cookie for $15.99. He had Chicken Salad, Chili and of course an oatmeal raisin cookie. I prefer the sugar cookie with lemon icing! So nice to be able to eat amazing comfort food and not feel guilty about spending too much! Our wait staff was super attentive and amazing. Definitely stop in! You can even catch a game on the large screens over the bar area. Yum!! read more

See all

First time at this location (4/10/25)! Had breakfast! Love the pancakes! They were delicious! I've been to other Keys cafes but first time at the Stillwater one! Great service! Love the ambiance! Will come back again! read more

See all

When this place first opened our family decided that we had to try it eventually, but unfortunately it was not as good as we hoped. Food: Not good. Their soups were incredibly salty and came with stale bread, the oil used to make the onion rings was straight up rancid, and the sandwich was oily with hardly any meat on it. Service: Our waiter was wacky in the good way and was the only thing we enjoyed about the meal. Ambiance: Its loud and a bit cramped but not much more than your average busy restaurant. My family and i will not be eating here again. read more

Couldn't wait to get over here. My great server Emily took great care of us. They use the same tasty Morningstar coffee and I was given heavy cream on request. Roast beef hash, my old standby was off the menu . My friend loved her cheese omelet and I have to admit it was pretty. A Keys anywhere is always fantastic, but it was especially welcome here. Of course I got the signature piece of house chocolate to go. It's inside a strip mall, yet there is a bathroom inside the restaurant. Friday and Saturday they have dinner and I will bring Basil on one of these Fridays. read more

So I wanted to stop in to see if this restaurant was going to be a great addition yo the Stillwater area and I wasn't disappointed. The food was great, service was especially good considering it was busy and newly opened. I will definitely return, there are other items on the menu I would like to try and as long as the service stays great I will keep coming back. read more

We went New Years Evening for dinner about 6pm and the staff was vacuuming the carpets while we ate dinner. That was not only inconsiderate but annoying. Can't imagine eating dinner here again. read more

Ordered eggs Benedict for breakfast. The Eggs were hard yolk. The hollandaise sauce was more like cheddar cheese with lots of flour mixed in for creaminess. Zero butter or lemon zest flavor. The server said: ok. No need to care. Terrible 16.00 breakfast. read more

$28+ for an omelette and coffee? Seriously? And it was average at best. I understand inflation, but this family is gouging their former customers. I'll never be back. Guess what keys management? Stillwater offers many options with realistic prices. You'll have the same outcome as everyone else that tried in that space. Byeeeee ladies. read more

Had lunch. Food was not even mediocre. Soup was tasteless. Had the Robert St. Salad with grilled vegetables. Couldn't find the veggies. Maybe a teaspoon of chopped tomatoes, green peppers, onion and 1 broccoli spear. Just lettuce for $15. Waitress never returned to ask how the meal was. We were hungry so we ate it. 2:00 and not busy. The real kicker was our bill was $50 and the manager gave $4 off. This is the second time I have tried. I will never go back. Can't believe they will ever make it. Very poor customer care! read more

First and foremost the quality of the food : Hash browns are not little pick up sticks - there should be some softness and all not burnt. What you order should be on your plate. Secondly the wait staff should come back at sometime to check on your food and not when I'm ready to leave. ( I should have known from the start when we had to flag down the waitress to even put in an order) Thirdly if the wait staff has to supplement something when they bring it to you the quality should be good NoT garbage Lastly I am not giving them a second chance - they didn't earn it read more

Came here for key lime pie, but unfortunately they were out of it! We then decided to get the raspberry lemon tart... one word... ELECTRIC very good, highly recommend :) Big Ups read more

For some reason this Keyes restaurant just does not match up to the others in the chain. I've tried a number of times wanting to like it. The food is mediocre and expensive with nothing I have had yet that has that special taste of something unique. The various desserts are heavy on flour and tasteless. Service is average, even when there's not many people in the restaurant. read more

Good home cooked meals with superior service! Try and walk by the bakery case without drooling! Beautiful baked goods yummy warm soups and chili... a full menu and breakfast anytime! read more

Some of the best customer service I have ever seen- everyone is so friendly and the atmosphere is very nice and clean. i'll be a regular here from now on, don't hesitate! be sure to go! i saw them get famous on tik tok for donating to the homeless and they have some of the best food in the area! read more

I tried Keys Cafe and Bar for the first time today, much to the chagrin of the others in my dining party. After eating the food, I can understand why! I had the blackened salmon burger with fries and it was probably the greatest thing to ever touch my tastebuds. The salmon was cooked perfectly and the bun was divine. The fries were crispy and delicious with just a touch of seasoning. I decided to take home a house cake for my boyfriend's birthday and it is the most delectable chocolate cake money can buy. The staff were all friendly and service was outstanding and fast. I honestly regret trying keys cafe because now every other restaurant I go to will never be able to compare. I would give them a million stars if I could! read more

Best breakfast anywhere. I always look to see if there's a Keys Cafe nearby when I'm in the cities. Please open one in Rochester!!!

My guest and I ordered omelets. The ends of the omelets were thin and dried; about 2" on each end! half of the omlet had promised ingredients, but the blob of cream cheese was not spread throughout. One of the worst omelets I've been served. read more