I got the steak and fries which was good, not sure about the rest cause I didn't try it but it looked great! The services was good as well. The place was really nice I didn't know whether to dress up or down but a lot of people had regular clothes and some dresses tf up . read more

Ketchy Shuby - New American Near Me - New York, New York

My friend and I walked in on a busy Saturday night around 7:30pm, and we were fortunate enough to get a table right away. Although, I do recommend making reservations. It was a bustling scene, quite loud with the people and the music -- it was definitely a vibe. We ordered the eggplant to start and then had the salmon and rigatoni entrées. We enjoyed the meal, which was very flavorful and filling. The portion sizes were pretty substantial, so sharing would definitely be an option if you would like to try multiple dishes. About halfway through our meal, we had to relinquish our table for another reservation, and the staff was kind enough to move us and our plates, etc to a nearby table. They had warned us in advance that they would need our table for a later reservation, so we were very understanding since we had walked in without a reservation. If anything, I appreciated the communication and transparency upfront. Overall, I'm glad I got to try the spot after it had been on my list for a while. It's definitely a popular hotspot and great for date night or group celebrations (bday, etc). read more

Ketchy Shuby - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

GREAT AMBIANCE! So fun for a friends dinner. Low lit, fun vibes. Their club in the basement is a must see after dinner. House music, lots of girlies. Good food, but particularly loves the vodka rigatoni! Top tier drinks! Friendly staff! Expensive! read more

See all

Came here for drinks at the bar on a Friday night, small place, but nice atmosphere. It was pretty lively and busy, noticed it was a lot of large groups and birthday celebrations. Service was good although I was double charged on a cocktail and good thing my friend checked the receipt and the bartender removed it. We came back later around midnight to check out the club downstairs. It was ok, we didn't stay long since we did not like the music. Also, I was surprise there was not a lot of people ordering drinks at the bar and that they charge 20% tip included with the drinks which I noticed later. I probably won't be back at this spot. read more

See all

*this review is for the bar/club below* This is a busy club, not super huge. They have a long bar, small dance space, DJ booth, and some reserved tables. The music was good, it got busier/more crowded as the night went on. Got some dancing in, then I was ready to head out when it got really crowded. read more

Ketchy Shuby - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Went to Ketchy Shuby for a birthday dinner with 17 people. It was great that they were able to accommodate such a large group. We were given a prix fix menu at $85 pp. However, after drinks the price ended up being closer to $200 pp so do what you will with that info. The vibe is very fun. It's a great place for a night out with friends. They had a DJ playing, lights out, and sparklers for the birthday girl. People stood on chairs and twirled napkins. Overall it was extremely exciting to go! As for the food, it was unfortunately pretty mid. The best thing I had was the yellowfin tuna tartare. The rigatoni is mentioned in many reviews on here but unfortunately it was flavorless. Not sure if our huge table was a factor there. I wanted to love the food because the place was fun, but for the price it was just not worth it. Overall, it's a nice place for a celebration or girls night. Not sure I'll be back, though. read more

See all

Definitely more of a sceney place. Great for birthdays or celebrations if you want to go somewhere you can dress up a little and enjoy the downstairs bar/club area. Groups of more than 8 will be required to follow a set menu banquet. We were originally told we could order a la carte when we booked but when our group arrived they told us we would need to do the banquet. The change in expectations from the staff was a bit frustrating and initially they were quite dismissive but eventually came around. They have an extensive set of cocktails and wines. The food was okay, nothing special - standard American style. The line for the restroom was consistently long throughout the evening. read more

Racist and discriminatory experience. My friends and I arrived at around 1:30 a.m.--a group of five Asian women--and were told by the hostess that the venue was reservations only and that we would not be allowed in without one. I explained that we were visiting from California, that it was my birthday, and that reviews online did not mention a reservations-only policy. She still refused entry. What made this situation unacceptable is that another group of five women behind us--who also did not have reservations--were allowed in without any issue. When I pointed out the inconsistency and asked why they were allowed entry but we were not, the security guard told me to "just leave" and to "keep my comments to myself." I was calm but upset, and I believe I had every right to question why we were treated differently. The only noticeable difference between our group and the one allowed in was race. This experience was humiliating and unfair. I hope the owner or management sees this review and seriously reflects on how guests are being treated at the door. read more

It was good! Not great. The ambiance is wonderful from the moment you walk in, it is a truly gorgeous space. The service was impeccable as well with a friendly host and an attentive waiter. Now onto the most important part, the food. It was very good but nothing stood out. I don't have any complaints about any of the dishes we got as they were all adequately cooked and seasoned but there was just nothing special. We had the crispy rice, tartare, dips, Burger, Branzino and rigatoni. Each were very good but again, nothing blew us away. In a city of incredible food it's imperative to offer stellar items. read more

See all

Food was so amazing! One word to describe it is spectacular and unique in flavor. The chicken was cooked to perfection, it was flavorful and luckily not dry! Drinks are on the stronger side so I guess that's worth it! Service was great the hostess found us a table despite us having missed our reservation spot. This was amazing considering it was a Saturday night . Our waitress was attentive and sweet. This is a nice chill spot they have a lounge downstairs from them however it's pretty pricey to get in there . read more

See all

This place gives Tulum vibes in SoHo. Recommend reservations as the place is small. I recommend dressing it up as everyone was pretty dressed up on a Saturday night. The service was solid and attentive. They were trying to flip the table quick so I thought it was a bit obnoxious the servers trying to clear a dish when almost empty or drinks. I get it but it made the experience rushed. However, the rigatoni was flavorful and cooked well. The cheeseburger and chicken sandwich were also a big hit at the table. The ding in the stars is also the club partner below. They have a basement club underneath and we went to the bouncer inside after eating and said they are open just need to get a stamp from the front. We go to the front and the bouncer said they are not opening for the night. So it was misleading and seemed like judgement on our party. Whatever the case, the place left a sour taste in my mouth. I wouldn't recommend. read more

See all

Ketchy Shuby is a trendy spot in SoHo that is mainly known for having a club beneath, but we came for dinner in the restaurant. Love the vibes and interior design here. I started with the SoHo Bay drink - it was decent. They make their drinks strong here, but needed a tad more flavor and "oomph." We tried a variety of food items Things we loved: -Rigatoni Vodka: this was DELICIOUS and very flavorful. Vodka pasta can be a hit or miss, but Ketchy Shuby makes a good one. -Curly Fries with truffle cheese: hard to go wrong with a curly fry, and we don't see a lot of these on menus! -Chocolate Lava Cake: a must, we ordered the dessert platter and this was the star of the show. I could have passed on the Heirloom Carrots (needed a bit more sweetness), the Baked Bread (it wasn't bad, but nothing outstanding - too seed-y for us), and the other dessert platter items. I also would not suggest ordering their Espresso Martinis - they have too strong of a vodka flavor. Overall, we had a solid experience at this spot and would love another plate of the rigatoni! read more

See all

We fell victim to the TikTok influencer scams with this one. The bouncers are on a power trip, only letting the young, blonde, 18-year-olds in. After the bouncer made a whole show of looking us up and down, he wouldn't let us in until he "got a look" at the rest of the girls in the group. We had to wait until he personally looked at all of us to assess if the whole group could go. Finally, we get in... and we leave after an hour. To the people who get turned down from this place: you're not missing out on anything. The bouncers must get off on putting girls down because they're no lookers themselves. read more

Ketchy Shuby is a great place for groups. I came with a group of 4 on a Friday at 7:00pm and the restaurant was about half full. The restaurant picks up around 8:30-9:00pm and is filled with larger groups. Most people dressed pretty casual but some were dressed up. The restaurant is well staffed with pretty good service, but once it got busy service took a bit of a turn. Drinks were fine, not great. The bartender gave me a hard time about modifying a drink so stick to the basics. The food, however, is really good. We loved everything we had, especially the Rigatoni, Tuna Tartare and Ricotta. read more

See all

This is apparently a sceney spot with late night dancing! BUT I'm old and had a 6pm dinner reservation which was still fantastic. Service was prompt and always there to help. The food was incredible! Highly recommend the rigatoni read more

Ketchy Shuby - Roasted Eggplant - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Had a horrible experience. The fish had so many bones I almost chocked. Service was not good and generally rude staff. The inside has a dim vibe which could be enjoyable to some. I'd go elsewhere. read more

Ketchy Shuby - Sea Bream - watch for bones! - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I would give this place 0 stars if I could. My party went in and had dinner at Ketchy Shuby and then asked to go down to the lounge - we were told to go back outside and get stamped, fine ok two different doors. The bouncer Richard was insanely discriminatory and literally saw our party of 8 - majority were not white - And would not let us in. He let a group of 4 white people in before us with NO minimums with 2 guys in the party. We had three guys in the group and he quoted $200 a guy. I've been in NYC a long time and that's a price to get you to turn away, not a "oh yes this is a standard minimum" The even more concerning thing is this is their response from a supposed Supervisor. He literally says "the claims are unfounded" and tried to gas light me on my own lived experience. Honestly the worst place I've ever been to, clearly doesn't know how to handle customer relations, and has zero remorse around this. Literally walk down the block to a true self respecting club and go out at Gospel or Jeans rather than this shit hole read more

Ketchy Shuby - New American Near Me - New York, New York

A trendy restaurant and lounge tucked into the heart of SoHo. The drinks are good and bartenders are fun. The music here in the downstairs lounge was great. We stopped by for dinner before and I didn't feel particularly strongly about the meal, was a little on the salty side. read more

Ketchy Shuby - Local Whipped Ricotta - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I came to Ketchy Shuby for a dinner date the other night. The vibes of this restaurant were super cute - it reminded me of Tulum. We were seated in the back and started off with some drinks. We both preferred the espresso martinis which weren't bad. As for food, we ordered a Caesar salad, the branzino, and the salmon. My personal favorite was the salmon. It was cooked just right, with the center being a bit rare, and paired with lentils, greens, and a sauce. The branzino was also yummy and a large portion. I thought the Caesar salad could use less dressing as it was quite salty. The servers were also a bit slow at times. We had tried to order another drink and it never came. Once we finished our dinner we headed to the speakeasy downstairs. It was still early so it was pretty empty when we were there but the vibes were again cute and I could see it popping off later in the evening. read more

Ketchy Shuby - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Amazing food, terrible hospitality. My friend had reserved a table for her birthday dinner but some friends that initially said they couldn't make it changed their minds. My friend had tried to email and call the restaurant to notify them and couldn't get in touch. When our group arrived, we were told by the hostess that we wouldn't be able to get a larger table for our group of 9. We would either have to split into two tables or squeeze into one small table. Half of our group also arrived late and she told us we had to give up our table by 9:30 for another reservation. All of this is fine, but the delivery of the news and the attitude of the hostess was rude. She didn't attempt to apologize for the inconvenience at all, just gave off a "this is how it is", snobbish vibe. We actually managed to squeeze into the smaller table with some discomfort. That was when the hostess informed us that we would have to do the prie fix menu since we were such a large group. The food itself and the wait staff serving our table were great!! We didn't have much real estate to work with but we made do by stacking plates and consolidating. The prie fix is actually a great deal! There was so much food. We started off with a vegetarian beef tartare, that was actually made with beets, quinoa, and finished with dollops of yogurt sauce. It was a delicious, juicy start to the meal. Next we had a garden burrata with figs and berries. This was perfection as well: so creamy yet refreshing. For our mains, we had a oyster mushroom ramen and a rigatoni a la vodka. The ramen was so umami, rich, and comforting. I wanted to slurp the thick noodles but of course, that would not have been very demure or mindful in front of a group of girls. The pasta was one of the best I've had recently! Italian grandmas everywhere would have approved. As if this wasn't enough food, we also had platters of curly fries, and dessert! Dessert was a decadent chocolate lava cake and an earl grey creme brulee. Both were flawlessly made and the perfect cap to a very balanced, diverse meal. I loved the creme brulee so much, I cleaned out the ramekin! Did I love the food and feel of dining in a lush tropical paradise? YES! Would I return? Only time will tell. read more

Perfect ambiance for a dressed-up night out! Enjoy loud music, strong drinks and great food. The service was fast and a great place to celebrate a friend's birthday (complementary sparklers and a loud group of employees that come and sing). Overall a great place to dine in the city for a special occasion read more

See all

The food was hit or miss. The drinks were not tasty. I did not like the chicken, but the pasta was very good. Everything for the table was to share. Including the drinks we got additionally, it ended up around 140 dollars per person. The ambiance was nice and good for large parties. However, the staff do not treat their guests well. So that's a huge no go for me. We had staff members taking pictures of us without permission. We were denied entrance to the basement after dinner while another party was let in with no conversation. We were told we needed to buy a 2000 dollar table to go downstairs. It's unfortunate because we came all the way there for a birthday, ate dinner and THEN was told this information. If we did non have a large party we would be let in without the table. Very odd. It was not mentioned during booking. I don't know if the other party paid for downstairs but they weren't asked to leave the restaurant, get stamped, and come back like we were. Which I thought was odd. We were asked to go through hoops they were not asked to do. Why would one party need stamps and the other does not. Very upsetting to the birthday girl. I would not come here again. Also, charging 9 dollars for a ginger ale is silly. read more

Ketchy Shuby is a good spot for dinner. We needed to change our resy last minute and the staff was nice and let us when we arrived. Our waitress was also very nice. The inside has a fun vibe and there is plenty of seating for large groups. We started with the bread and it was a bit hard and not worth $11. They also asked if we wanted to add burrata but didn't realize it was an additional $20 which is cray. I ordered the spicy rigatoni and thought it was great! Everyone really enjoyed their food. read more

See all

Celebrated my best friend's 40th at Ketchy Shuby and had the best time. Our server was so friendly and offered a bunch of great suggestions. Our drinks hit the spot, the appetizers, especially the beet tartare, were standout and I loved the branzino. As the evening continued the lights dimmed and the music amplified. The entire restaurant got on its feet to dance to provide a prelude to the dance party below. We ended the night with bubbly and a celebratory dessert before dancing the night away and loved every minute of it. read more

See all

We had made reservations for 10:30pm but were not seated until closer to 11pm. When were were finally at our table the service was good and the food was yummy as well. The atmosphere is fun and they have a club downstairs which we wanted to checkout but the cover was $250 a person. They told us the restaurant and club are run completely separate so if you thinking eating dinner before will get you free entry to the club you are mistaken. read more

See all

Not just a going out spot!!! Originally I just came here for my birthday after dinner since Ketchy Shuby is known for their downstairs bar. You should definitely come here for the food as well. While the menu is small and limited, there is something for everyone. All the dishes we ordered were so unique and delicious. Started with the butternut squash soup and beet tartare. Incredibly delicious. For mains we tried both salads and the spicy rigatoni, a must! Chefs know what they're doing. Do yourself a favor and come check out Ketchy Shuby read more

Ketchy Shuby - Butternut Squash soup, Beet Tartare - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The ambience was stunning, the service was great, and the food was delicious! We started with the appetizing whipped ricotta, its flavor beautifully balanced with a subtle hint of lemon. While a bit more ricotta would have been welcome, it was a pleasing beginning. Our main courses, the Branzino and Rigatoni alla vodka, were both delicious. The Branzino, in particular, is a standout dish that I highly recommend. Overall, a delightful experience; I would certainly recommend dining at Ketchy Shuby. read more

See all

From the moment we stepped in the ambience was absolutely incredible. I felt as if I had stepped into the garden of Eden set an a Parisian wonderland. The hostess was incredibly kind and very welcoming. The staff was all genuinely incredible. The first round of drinks was excellent and the food was absolutely phenomenal highly recommend to all.. Top Notch all around.. read more

Ketchy Shuby - Restaurant and bar area... - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I came here for a party of 8 people. We had a pre fixe menu with tuna tartare, burgers, penne vodka, desserts, and a few other things. The food was really good and the best thing i had was the penne vodka. I would go back for the penne vodka alone! The price was about $100/pp for all the food- this included entrance for the nightclub downstairs afterwards. read more

Absolutely unacceptable experience at Ketchy Shuby. I brought a group of 12 friends here to celebrate my birthday, and from start to finish, the service was rude, slow, and discriminatory. Drinks took 45 minutes to arrive, and the bartenders and manager were incredibly disrespectful the entire time. When we tried to go down to the lounge--even after spending heavily on food and drinks--the manager tried to stop us due to ratio (we had 8 girls and 6 guys) and only relented after arguing with us for nearly an hour. It became uncomfortably obvious that the only three people of color in our group were unwelcome--once we got downstairs, they were the only poc in the entire lounge. We ordered a bottle of champagne, and instead of proper bottle service, they lazily poured it in glasses and brought it out with zero presentation. We also brought our own birthday cake and candles, and they refused to use the candles we brought, for no reason. We had the largest table in the restaurant and were easily among the biggest spenders that night, and yet we were treated like a nuisance. The staff was lazy, entitled, and racist in their attitude. It was embarrassing and insulting. I will never be coming back to this place, and I'd strongly caution anyone--especially people of color or large groups--to avoid it. This place does not deserve your business. read more

I'd been in the bar / club below a handful of times and always thought it was great. I finally ate dinner here and thought it was amazing. Great service, similar cool vibes to the club, and great food. read more

I had a lovely dinner with my girlfriends here last night. We were all big fans of the fries. We split all the mains, and the Korean fried chicken sandwich and both pasta dishes were notable favorites. I love their shredded kale salad with cheese, and I was a fan of their Catch A Fire cocktail with mezcal. The servers are so sweet and attentive. And it's a beautifully lit quiet spot on a Wednesday evening. read more

The food was mediocre. The hostess was very rude and after paying a 600 dollar table they kicked us out before we could even sign the bill and finish our drinks. When it was time to go downstairs they played games with us to make us go run around for a "stamp". They would then proceed to stamp "white" girls right in front of us. I've been to many clubs and this is just a waste of time. I wouldn't ever come back!! read more

Nice spot. Came here for dinner on a Saturday night. Reservation is a must. The rigatoni and caesar salad were the best dishes. The fish dorade was alright. Our waitress was awesome, super sweet. read more

Went downstairs to the clubby area. Music was fun! Crowd seemed to skew a little younger.

We were 5 guys having dinner - dinner was lovely - food was decent - good service - out although not super creative - wine list is pretty poor but we were having a good time and could not care less we went there a few times but today was the last . After spending 1k$ for dinner ... We asked to get a drink downstairs - first they said it is 3500$ min to get a table with a. Bottle - then came back and said to open a tab for 5 drinks it is 2000$. So I thought I misunderstood so I asked again ... and yes they told us if we wanted to have 5 drinks it is 2000$ + tip + tax Adios - there are better spots to spend that kind of money read more

I came here for a birthday dinner and it was really nothing special. I'm amazed by all of the positive reviews. The menu is odd and doesn't have a good flow. We started with the tuna tartar, the whipped ricotta, baked bread, and fried calamari. The tartar was delicious. The whipped ricotta was nothing, almost like eating air. Not worth it. The bread was well, just bread and the fried calamari was no different than anywhere else. For my entree I had the steak frites. Couldn't have been saltier. A chef friend once told me that if the meat is over salted it's probably not very fresh so that was concerning. Came with weird curly fries like at TGI Fridays. Others in my group had a fried chicken sandwich which they didn't like and the squash which was $29 for a large badly seasoned vegetable. Desserts were good, lava cake and a bread pudding. The staff was nice. The place became an absolute scene, which was unappealing when trying to enjoy dinner. Patrons and staff packing the place and constantly bumping our chairs. There's so many good restaurants in the area, you can skip this one. read more

Literally scammed me and my friends. Forced us into a minimum amount and then lied about the minimum forcing us to pay more... on my friends birthday. Furthermore they lied saying we can go into club.. which was why we chose this spot. They tried to get us to pay an additional 200 a person after already paying 100+ for dinenr and drinks... bruh. Sketchy Scammy is not worth the money... also food and drinks were mid. IF you wanna go out, go to brooklyn or anywhere else! I also don't write reviews but this place eats your money and poops you back outside with no good mems :( read more

My girlfriend and I found this place on Instagram for date night. We thought, dinner and drinks and then we have an amazing club downstairs? How perfect! ..WRONG. I'll be honest, the food was good. But this place left us with a bad taste and ruined our night out in the city. The waitress hyped up the club downstairs while we had dinner and told us we can get our stamp from the front desk. The staff also performed a show at 10:30pm to get the "party" started. It all looked great and we decided to get more drinks. We then pay for the bill and head to the front desk for our stamp. The front desk tells us that we need to talk to the bouncer outside. My girlfriend is wearing a short dress and we are now both outside waiting in the cold to find out that even though we just had dinner at the restaurant, we cannot get into the club without another set of reservations. We never felt so disregarded after literally just spending $250+ on dinner and on top of that, being hyped by the staff for the club. In such disbelief, we decided to walk back to our car in shock and go back home. We have been to other places in the city with a similar concept of dinner and club (TAO Downtown) and were not treated this way. While the food is good here, there many other places in the city with great food that will not ruin your night out in the city and leave you with a bad feeling in your gut. Wish I read the reviews of this place earlier as many seem to have experienced the same. I hope this review saves another couple's date night at this venue. read more

Service was Terrible most of the staff are jerks, food was decent though but for the same price you can go to other places in the city for much better food. read more