The BEST place to get your vehicle taken care of O'Conner Automotive Palmyra, New York Honest and…read moreReliable Car Service value quality are above and beyond

4 new tires and an oil change. Quality work for an affordable price. Great small business that I…read morewill continue to support and recommend.

I highly recommend Chris at Mac Fleet. He's prompt, reasonable, knowledgeable and very…read moreaccomodating. He figured out what was wrong right away, even when roadside service missed it entirely. His invoice reflected a fair price and the ability to pay online was very convenient. Superior service, superior value.

Mac Fleet agreed to send a mobile technician to perform a pre-purchase inspection on a classic car…read moreI was considering buying. This normally involves everything that is checked during a state safety inspection, but with additional checks on the functionality of the vehicle and its systems (electrical, cosmetics, etc). I requested an engine compression test, and was told it would involve more time, which was fine. What I received: 10 photos of the undercarriage and two lines about the seller being old and needing to sell. No start. No compression test. No other photos. No evidence anything else had been examined. Chris was polite and apologetic, and he did adjust the invoice, but I was left with no clear idea about the vehicle, despite paying for exactly that service.

I am surprised by all the negative reviews. I had a leaking tire last weekend and this Firestone…read morewas the closest tire store around me. They are open on Sundays and fit me in the next day. I have an all wheel drive car and they didn't try to oversell me multiple tires (although it's probably recommended to change tires in pairs). But I told them I was planning to sell the car soon and they said it was reasonable to just change only one tire. Employees were friendly and cost was reasonable (-under $200) for a single tire. I have nothing bad to say about this place.

Even after seeing the negative review, I made an online appt to get my AC checked out. They asked…read moreme the make and model of my car and told them what the issues was. I was given an appt. I took time off of work to make this appt just to find out that they don't have the equipment to service my 2019 Equinox because it's too new! Why was I even able to make an appt online if that is the case??? The manager at the store said the call center doesn't know anything about cars so they wouldn't know to ask. I voiced my frustration to her about taking time off to have this appt and not being asked upfront what the refrigerant code for my car was ridiculous! She said, "well I am telling you now! When I called another garage in Fairport, the first thing they asked me was to check the number tag under the hood to make sure they could service my car! I will never use Firestone for anything and also tell my friends and family about my experience!

Kevin was exactly the person needed for the service today. My car's check engine light suddenly…read morecame on and I need to drive five hours tomorrow. He got me in quickly and assured me everything would be okay. Highly recommend!

DANGEROUS AND NEGLIGENT WORK - DO NOT BRING YOUR FAMILY'S CAR HERE…read more I had brake replacement, tire service, and wheel alignment performed at this Monro location in December 2025. Shortly after, my wife and young child were driving to Albany in a winter storm when the brakes started making a loud banging noise. She was forced to drive in fear for an extended period before finding another Monro location, where a technician discovered one brake caliper bolt was MISSING ENTIRELY and a second was dangerously loose. My wife and child could have been killed. I contacted Fairport manager Kevin, who was completely nonchalant and actually said "the advantage of Monro is you can stop at their other locations." He eventually offered a partial refund -- which was never paid -- then became completely unreachable. I filed a BBB complaint (Case #24733045). In their formal response, Monro corporate ADMITTED the caliper bolt was not properly secured and acknowledged filing an insurance claim for rim damage caused by their negligence. Despite this admission, they are refusing a full refund. The tire pressure light is also still on after their tire service, and the rim was scratched. This is a documented safety failure that endangered my family. Full complaint on file at: https://www.bbb.org/us/ny/fairport/profile/auto-repair/monro-inc-0041-6000929/complaints?sort=recent&status=answered&type=serviceorrepair Avoid this location. @MonroAutoTire @monroauto

Best place in town! Even if you don't live around, you need to give this place a try. You won't…read moreregret it. Satisfaction guaranteed. I'm totally happy with Ernesto's great job, he's reliable, and his focus is excellent work to keep the customer happy and coming back. You can trust that you will come back for more.

Highly recommend! I took my son's car in to be detailed and asked to have a diagnostic assessment…read morefor the brakes etc. The mechanic promptly called and told me that the brakes were fine and all it needed was an oil change. I appreciated the honest customer service and quality of work. The car looks fantastic! The detailing really made a difference!