This was our first time here at Kelsey's. We always seek out local fare when we're out of town (we're from Fl west coast). We ordered the Salad/Large Pizza special. Our waitress said it was a salad for one. This salad could have fed four so we ate what we could and left the rest. We had the Greek salad and it was great with lots of ham, cheese, olives, etc. our pepperoni pizza was excellent with thin crust and just the right amount of meat and cheese. The service was excellent. We will be back. read more

Horrible Meal & Service!! Sub was served with Cheetos???!!! Blonde Chunky Middle age server, slamming the food down, very short when speaking. 30 yr seasoned server here having worked for Nic, Sam & Maria - in Titusville she wouldn't of lasted one hot minute & food WOULD never be such poor quality. Disgrace!! read more

Great family restaurant. We've tried many of the dishes and nothing disappoints. I will say I crave their Greek Salad. It's the best I've ever had! read more

Greek salad alllll day! We drive 25 minutes for this Greek salad. Price is right, ingredients are fresh, and it tastes amazing! Pizza is ok, but that is not why we order so 5 stars for the salad! read more

We used to go often but we went one night and it was awful. The pizza was salty and had no taste due to the heavy salt. Their Greek salad dressing also was salty. Service was bad. I now only go to the one in port Canaveral on A1A. It's the original and still tastes the best. P. S. The list of the 10 dirtiest restaurants came out and this restaurant was on that list. read more

The service here was great!! The food wa amazing, especially the pizza. My friends and I ate an entire pizza. Anytime before 6:00, the dining area isn't very crowded but after 6 it is. Overall, the food was good, the service great, but I had to wait a while for the food to come. read more

Kelsey's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Rockledge, Florida

The pizza crust is consistently great here. But they're skimpy with the toppings IMO. Recommend you ask for double if you want a decent amount of anything on your pizza. The dinners here leave much to be desired. Boyfriend's spaghetti and meatball dinner was tasteless. A lot of filler was used for the meatballs, and the sauce was bland. The garlic bread was crusty and delicious though. They use finely shredded lettuce in their salads that's normally used on subs. It's sort of like not getting lettuce in your salad. They loaded the Greek salad with feta cheese, which is great, but hardly any olives, and the only vinegar based dressing they had was on the table, and it's not very tasty. We'll be back for the pizza, and maybe try the calzone, but not much else. read more

Picked up a catering order for my son's birthday. The whole process was simple and reassuring...competent and friendly staff. The food was so delicious! We received so many compliments from our guests. We were all blown away by the flavors and quality of the food-Highly recommend for your next event or dinner! read more

Excellent catering fed 80 people at the Center for Collaboration. They delivered a little early, which helped a lot, and the food was perfect! Thank you, Kelsey's! read more

Went here with my wife. Everyone was very warm and welcoming. I had a calzone that was very good and filling. They had a bluepoint brewing beer on tap so that was a plus. The wife had the Penne Gorgonzola which she thought was fantastic. Overall this place checked all the boxes clean, friendly staff, good food,reasonable prices, everything we look for in a restaurant read more

Came in for lunch, and no one helped us. We waited at the door while many others were waiting as well. My boyfriend went up to hostess and asked her how long it would be and that we had 2 people. She looked around and said "I don't know people should be getting up soon" and walked away with her blue yeti (to fill it up) without writing us down. Another hostess comes up and starts helping 5 ppl who were after us. Long story short, we left. Foods good but not worth dealing with people who hate their job. read more

Love the family atmosphere and welcoming staff. The food is prepared to perfection. I've been there often and never had a bad meal. My personal favorites are the Greek salad. Calzones and the spinach pie. Their homemade salad dressing can't be beat. Their take out service is also great. I ordered a large Greek salad for the memorial service of a fallen Brevard County firefighter when I picked up the order I was told that the bill had been taken care of. When they heard what it was for they donated everything. Kelsey's is #1 in my book. read more

This location has really good food as well as great service! we'll be coming back over and over again, I'm sure! I had the pizza and it was fantastic and my wife had the number 6 calzone and it was perfect also, both items size was impressive in the food was delicious we look forward to the next visit. read more

We ate lunch at Kelsey's on 6/2/18. I witnessed our waitress throwing her head back and stuffing mozzarella cheese in her mouth and licking her fingers.....all on the front line. Then she grabbed someones food order. How many health code violations can you count? The salad dressing (which is usually yummy at our Merritt Island location) was nothing but vinegar. We switched bottles several times while waiting for our meal, but they all tasted like vinegar only. The sauce on my hubby chicken parm tasted like Chef Boyardee and my spinach pie was so burnt I couldn't cut it. We will never go to this Kelsey's again. Made me sick to my stomach having to pay $20.00 for this. read more

BEST. GREEK. SALAD. IN. THE. WORLD. I don't like around here, but every time I come to visit family, I have to come here because I love it so much! I also get the calzone and it's great, they have lots of opinions! The staff is really nice as well and seem to really care! Love, Love, Love!!! read more

A very good pizzeria. Excellent crust and toppings. They have a really excellent greek vinaigrette dressing on the tables that goes really well with their chef salads. My family quite enjoyed their chicken marsala, too. The staff is very friendly and waited on us promptly. Will definitely return. read more

Came here for Father's Day and truly enjoyed ourselves. Our party of six was greeted immediately and attended to by Krystle very well the entire visit. The pizza was great, the Greek salad just as great, and the calzone rocked. Did I mention that the beer was as cold as it is supposed to be? Don't hesitate... Give it a try! They are clearly well-managed and doing something correctly. read more

Excellent pizza and friendly service. Clean dining room and bathrooms.

I've been to this particular Kelsey's Pizza several times and each time I leave wishing I had gone to another location. The food at this location does not have the same flavor profile as the others unfortunately. I also found that the wait staff at this particular location is not nearly as pleasant as the PSJ, MI and Cape Canaveral restaurants. read more

How does this place stay open? We have tried it twice - both times lousy. There will be no third time. You would be better off with a frozen pizza from Walmart or Dominoes.... and that's saying something! read more

Real food made from scratch with fresh ingredients and heart in the kitchen. Warm, friendly staff and comfortable atmosphere. All Kelsey's locations vary and this is by far the best after trying all of them in Brevard over the years. read more

I read good reviews and thought I'd give it a try since I was working nearby. Service was good. I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs. Salad had shredded lettuce, which is just wrong and it was room temperature. Toppings were good and so was the house dressing. The sauce was on top of the spaghetti instead of having been incorporated and the pasta was over cooked. The meatballs were tied for the worst I've had. No flavor and gray. They had not been seared in a pan or baked, probably just added to the sauce to cook. The sauce was bland and had a brownish red color. The two slices of garlic bread were nicely done. I hope they read the reviews and make corrections. read more

I personally haven't had a bad experience here, but my parents both got sick when we went the last time. We used to frequently go for dinner and order a salad to split (very large salad portions) and a pizza. I wouldn't recommend the marinara, but I make my own spaghetti sauce so I may just be picky. The fettuccine alfredo is very good. Wait staff generally are very good and make sure to keep your drinks full and dirty dishes off the table. read more

Shared a meal with my husband, Greek Salad for one and the eggplant parm. Everything was delicious! Large portion and great meal:)

Good food, good service-that's what you can expect. I've not been disappointed the two or three times I've eaten here. It's a great place to have a nice lunch. read more

Decided to stop and so glad we did. In back of shopping center so you have to look for it. They had a nice variety of craft and regular beers. We got the deluxe pizza and it was excellent. Loved the cheese ! read more

This place is phenomenal! Great service and generous portions. Good place for lunch or dinner. Nice ambiance and family friendly. The Bruchetta is delicious. The Calzones are really big and the prices are just right. I highly recommend this place for a nice Saturday dinner with friends and family. read more

JK I didn't eat here! I tried to review a different Kelsey Pizza. If its owned by the same manager then I'd like to say: deal with clientele when their order has been messed up. read more

The food here for as many years as I can remember, has BEEN "EXCELLENT!" :) Their GREEK salads "ROCK!" and the salad dressing is absolutely the BEST! HUGE portions of food are served, and is EXCELLENT! Kelsey's, HAS TO BE ONE OF THE "CLEANEST," RESTAURANTS IN FLORIDA! I've NEVER been in any Kelsey's restaurants and seen one un kept or dirty, ever! The wait staff are professional, friendly and fun! read more

Love eating at this place I do however feel the servers are not as good as they could be...they are more like order takers . They are all kids they should hire some more experienced and older servers read more

Awesome food, great service, and reasonably priced! I went in here to order wings but then was told that not all Kelsey's have wings so I went with the calzone reluctantly and didn't regret it one bit. It was huge and even though I was hungry I only ate half of it but the other half warmed up great the next day for lunch. I also got a mini salad which was big enough to fill me up before I even started on the calzone. Can't go wrong here, great quality! read more

Ordered a pizza. Told to wait 20 minutes before pick-up. Went to pick it up...they had forgot about it?? There was vey few customers there at the time? Wanted me to wait there for another 20 minutes while they make it??? Poor service!! read more

I've actually never eaten in...have always ordered to go or delivery. Great service, overly generous portions, and FABULOUS food! Would definitely recommend! read more

After last night I'm going to have to take them off my top 5 pizza joints in the area. I like them to cook their pies well done otherwise by the time I get home they're a soggy mess. Last time I ordered, about 3 weeks ago, they didn't do it. Yesterday not only didn't they do it but there was so much cheese on one of them it overflowed the crust and was pooled on the box. The normally delicious Greek salad was a small handful of lettuce covered in meat. They do still have the best salad dressing. read more

Greek salad is awesome, wholemade greek dressing is out of this world good and I'm from buffalo and I rate the pizza pretty dam good and if ya all know anything about Buffalo pizza that is saying a lot. Definetly glad we came. Much better than other local pizza places, won't mention them by name read more

Good food reasonable price and normally very nice friendly service. Recent visit had a "snippy" server which was very surprising. We will be back but hope we don't get the same server. read more

My girlfriend and i love this place. The servers are always friendly and attentive, food has always been great. Although a pizzeria I cant get enough of their pasta dishes with the chicken marsala being my favorite. With their pizzas its one place that puts a good deal of toppings and cheese compared to everywhere else. It is very reasonably priced and overall one of my favorite restaurants in the area always had great experiences here best pizza in rockledge read more

I've had the pizza at the Rockledge Kelsey's plenty of times in the past. Always very good. But I just purchased 1 LG to go and it was crap! The crust was spongy and flavorless. Absolute disappointment! Obviously the pizza dough has been changed to a cheaper version. And I for one will not be purchasing pizza from this establishment in the future. Please bring back that original chewy style crust!!! read more

My wife and I shared a Greek salad for two. It was delicious and filling. The salad dressing is awesome! Great service.

This is the first review I've ever felt compelled to write on Yelp. My husband and I decided to try this place out tonight, as I've heard through the grapevine that Kelsey's has great food. We opted for carryout. When looking at their menu online, I was baffled at their prices. $13 for a 10" 3-topping pizza?... I brushed off the hiked-up price by telling myself it must be good food for how expensive it is. We ordered the 10" 3-topping pizza with a Greek salad and Alfredo sauce on the side. Our total came to $22.45. The Greek salad was good, I find Greek dressings can be hit or miss, but Kelsey's has a decent one. The pizza however, was atrocious. I would honestly rather have eaten a Totino's freezer pizza than this thing they call pizza. The crust was stale and strangely "airy". The sauce was lacking, both in taste and quantity (literally it didn't seem like they even used sauce). We ordered chicken, olives, & garlic as our toppings. We got a pathetic amount of olives thrown on the pizza for us, & there were TWO nickel-sized pieces of chicken on the WHOLE pizza. They were placed under the cheese, with the olives, so looking at first glance we did not know we were duped out of our toppings. The garlic was the only topping that was prevalent. I feel so ripped off right now. This is the worst pizza I have EVER tasted, and that's saying a lot considering it's hard to f**k up pizza! I almost wonder if it was an old one they had in the fridge and just threw in the oven to heat up for us- that's how it tasted! The Alfredo sauce was runny and tasted FISHY, like anchovies- I couldn't believe it. SO disappointing, as I was hoping the Alfredo would be the one saving grace for Kelsey's crust. Honestly save yourself the money and order from Bzarro's, Marcos, Little Caesars, or Dominos (ANYWHERE but Kelsey's). I would even suggest frozen pizza over this blasphemy that Kelsey's calls "pizza". Seriously, Digiorno or Freschetta frozen pizzas are 50 times better than Kelsey's pizza, and also a third of the price for a lot more food! The salad was the only thing my husband and I could actually eat.. The rest of it went in the trash... I wouldn't eat there again even if someone paid me to! read more