5 stars on entrees. 1 star on the Ruben balls appetizer. Mushy in the center and smelled like dog food. It was not appetizing at all. Service was excellent. read more

I love the food at Kelly's. The Rueben sandwich is my favorite. They even have some great sushi.

Feeling hasn't changed much. Very reliable neighborhood Irish bar. Now has a nice covered enclosed patio area even in cool weather. Love the classic Irish tavern. Just wish the food was more enjoyable. Bowl size for soup is very lacking. Wings (buffalo) this time were meh. Not cooked enough. Pastrami sandwich had the pastrami crumbling out of it. Could not even pick up sandwich to take a bite without it falling apart. Service is very fast, way too rushed. Literally minutes after order taken. Did not bode well for the food read more

See all

I went with a friend of mine today to get the large Reuben and oh my God it was out of this world. I highly recommend anybody that wants to get a real good Reuben go to Kelly's.. the dessert I had was an Oreo cake. that was great.The service was great. We had Jesse as our server and I recommend anybody going to Kelly's ask for Jesse.. I highly recommend this Irish pub style restaurant. Great menu. read more

See all

Went with four of my friends on March 13 to hear the bagpipers. The place is packed. The parking lot is filled over onto other lots. The food was good. For friends had the prime rib. I had the very bland, corned beef and cabbage with boiled potatoes, which the potatoes weren't peeled completely so it was very hard to cut open. Yes I'm talking about the potatoes. Very festive place, the bagpipers go around the bar and play and stop at each corner, which was great then they took a break. Then they put the jukebox on then the bagpipers started to play and the jukebox was still on. Service was very good. Upon asking for a to go box, she handed it right across my girlfriend's face, then walked around her and picked up a plate! We were a half an hour out called. They do not take reservations, but for a table of five there was two left and they had one ready for us. Took my corned beef home, added some pickling spices in it and it was delicious! The bathroom was extremely tight. They did have a handicap bathroom, but everybody was moving around like we were on a chessboard. read more

See all

Looking forward to returning to Kelly's on our current trip to Ocean Grove. Pretty quiet on this off-season Monday evening. We were promptly seated on a "high top" near the bar and enjoyed a couple of drinks while studying the menu. The Honey ordered the French Onion Soup to start and the Caesar salad with grilled chicken. I chose The German Sausage Platter - the Octoberfest special. The soup came and it was burnt! The cheese was actually burnt! It was replaced promptly but why was it brought out this way? The rest of the meal was better, the sausage special was impressive and delicious. Definitely a winner! Will ordered again the next time we're in town. read more

Kelly's Tavern - Octoberfest Menu. - American Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

See all

I'm a regular however bring my out of town guests they are now fans as well. I dine there frequently as I am now retired and always feel comfortable going there alone. . The wait staff is friendly, I know them all by name. Kelly's vibe is such it's easy to meet other bar flys. Food wise, great menu with creative specials. soup is always terrific and OMG order the stuffed clams. read more

Very cool Irish pub. Huge bar area and they have outside seating if you prefer. Personally I would much rather sit inside with the bar area they have, just for the atmosphere alone. The food was very good.....I had the open meatloaf sandwich which was good and there was zero chance of me finishing, it was huge. My friends got the Reuben and they both enjoyed it. The service was great. We were seated and served very quickly. If you're on your way down the shore and want traditional Irish food and a quick drink this is a great stop. read more

See all

Great Rueben's. We got the big ones so we enjoyed them for lunch and dinner. Nice service. Good pub vibe. Will be back. read more

Hands down the best Reuben in Jersey! Never disappoints and never leave hungry! Bar staff are always pleasant and quick to serve you. Definitely a Jersey Shore staple. read more

food/service was great. outdoor patio was nice and very spacious. Our waiter was great and the food came quickly. read more

Kelly's Tavern - stop rock and roll - American Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

See all

Perfect breakfast hash , better then any diner I've had in years. Extremely clean and manicured facilities. Tons of great stuff on the walls to catch your eyes. Service was spot on multiple people asked if i needed anything, wanted anything. Truly a solid spot read more

The best Grilled Reuben and Turkey Sligo open faced sandwiches, no place can compare. Also, the best corned beef sandwich no place can beat the quality and quantity of corned beef. read more

Came with a bunch of friends and it was my first visit. We stopped in for a drink and load up on food before hitting the next spot. We shared a bunch of appetizers; loaded nachos, blooming onion, grilled wings with Thai chili sauce, pretzels with super hot mustard and spinach and artichoke dip. Always very good and the service was great. Unfortunately we left just when the guy was going to start playing but seems like a great spot to sit on the patio and spend some time. read more

See all

Been coming here for about 40 years. Always get the Reuben which is excellent. And good breakfast for the hangover.

Another great meal at Kelly's Corner Tavern. Kevin was our server and he was excellent. The food was delicious as always. I had the French onion Soup and the mini Reuben which hit the spot. My husband enjoyed his food as well. They also had live music which was a lot of fun. I need to come here more often. If you haven't been, it's a must try for good Irish pub food. read more

See all

Just a fun place with great food and friendly service. Go for the Reuben, can't go wrong.

First time getting pizza not bad at all and well it's the platter .just wish I had butter with the rye and cooked a little less. read more

Kelly's Tavern - Platter - American Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

See all

Reuben looked fabulous but was very dry. Other than that, the Bar service was excellent and ambiance was nice. Great spot to drink I'm sure. read more

I really don't know how this place stays so consistently good year after year. Great again tonight. Get the Rubin!!!! My wife also loved the Shepard pie! read more

Kelly's Tavern - American Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

The food is excellent and the service inside EXCELLENT, went today with a friend and sat outside and the service was horrible. I didn't catch the bartenders name( red hair ) but he obviously would have rather have been somewhere else . I would give Kelly's a 5 star rating for inside and a one for outside . I even hesitated to say something to the nice gentleman at the door on way out but changed mind as he is always a good guy and I didn't want to anger him . I will definitely be back but never ever will I sit outside again. read more

Service was good. Waitress was on top of things. My turkey Rueben was good; $17.00 for a half sandwich and doesn't even come with fries. I saw on their menu they had an "award winning Bloody Mary". Who was handing out these supposed awards? Seriously? Not even a stick of celery, a slice of lemon or lime. I was going to tell them to hold the olives bc I don't eat them & I wouldn't get them anyway! The drink was so lacking & disappointing. I didn't take a picture but just imagine a glass of Bloody Mary, plain with nothing in it. Maybe the award was for the plainest drink. Who knows. read more

I said "PLEASE. NO mayo. I HATE mayo!" And they still put mayo on it. Ughh Ceaaar salad was too fishy But it was good besides that the fried chicken was fire so was the daiquiri read more

See all

Food was horrible. I ordered chicken wings and cheese fries and first of all the chicken wings had no flavor and really did not taste that good. The fries were not bad but the cheese was probably the most disgusting thing I have ever been served. It was so gross and most of my family did not like it at all. My stomach hurts after coming here and I will not be coming back. read more

Kelly's Tavern - This is the cheese I got - American Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

I wanted to share a concern from a recent visit at this establishment. My friends and I, all under 21, were asked for ID at the door by an older male manager. When we asked why, his response felt unnecessarily rude and made us uncomfortable. We've visited many times with our families and have never experienced this before. We simply came to enjoy dinner, and the interaction felt unwelcoming and completely uncalled for. read more

Great old school bar with good service, cold beer and good food. Plenty of tv's for your favorite sports teams read more

See all

I have been going here since I was 18, great shore bar. Food has gotten better in the last 3-4 years, it had gone way down hill over the years. Wait staff is quick and always ready to get you a refill on your drink. They have a picture of Ireland over the bar, and as the night progresses you can notice the inebriated looking and pointing at it, trying to figure out where they came from. This is a real blue color type bar except on weekends in the summer when the northern crowds wonder in. read more

Kelly's keeps their tradition of good food good service in a clean friendly eatery alive and well. As the seasons change it's great to enjoy a burger and beer at the bar, just as much as dinner with family and friends. read more

This place never fails us Great way to watch the Giants game in London With an amazing pour of Guinness and a Ruben read more

Kelly's Tavern - American Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

See all

True Score: 4.25 Stars A real bar with great employees and patrons. This bar saved our trip during the COVID battle. They took the bar outside and turned the bar into a large table. It was a brilliant strategy. We spent hours and met so many nice people who like to have a good time. What a bar is supposed to be. If you find yourself in Central Jersey and are looking for a place to truly maximize your Jersey Shore experience, you've got to check out Kelly's Tavern. Multiple beers on draft and in bottles, amazing memorabilia on the walls, and sports all over the place not to mention very salty heavy popcorn, all add to the imbibing pleasure. Plus there's a nice outside region which also often has little bands playing While the beer is cold and amazing the food is even better. Huge menu with multiple options all of which are excellent. Better yet, prices are reasonably affordable. It will be crowded and there will most likely be a wait in the summertime. But that is with very good reason! Thanks read more

I recently stopped in for a quick bite to eat with a few friends while I was in the area. Authentic 'old school' Irish pub. I LOVED it, the menu had lots of great options! I went with the Blarney Roast beef, which was simply delicious, and a great splurge. Just thinking of it is making me hungry. My party also shared an order of nachos. I'd definitely stop in again if I was in the area, actually I can't wait. read more

Kelly's Tavern - Nachos - American Near Me - Neptune City, New Jersey

See all

I can't really complain about Kelly's: it fits the mold of a corner tavern well. It just feels right having a cocktail or two made with a well vodka, then downing it with some corned beef--which works wonderfully as a sandwich. I enjoyed their house chili bread bowl as well, which was executed really well. It was pleasantly surprising how spicy their mustard was, and how each item feels like it's prepared house-made in the kitchen. The decor too is unassuming and looks like an Irish pub that's maintained reasonably well. Service is good, with the bartenders knowing how to make a majority of trendy drinks and ensuring that even some questionable patrons have a good time and dealing with when they've reached their limits. Pricing is on the high side for some items, although it's not too bad considering the quality and authentic feel. I do quite enjoy Kelly's for a quick drink or a night out at a tavern. The food and drinks were good enough that I wish I had some images to cap off this review, but I suppose I was enjoying the moment. read more

Fun atmosphere, friendly staff and great food.live music is a great bonus! The merch is fun too!

not good. the chicken tenders are "fried" aka they don't bread them and throw raw unseasoned chicken into the fryer and drench in buffalo sauce with wilted celery. I couldn't even eat the EIGHTEEN DOLLAR "boneless wings". the soup is boring and bland. it was edible at least. super overpriced for garbage. at least they have enough crackers? read more

Place is funky casual- very loud but lively. Caesar's salad was good and nice size. Black Russian was also very good although they serve it on a ridiculously small plate. Meatloaf was very good with mashed and gravy- nice size potion. We only drank beer so it was fine. Prices were average. Wait staff were very nice and friendly. Will be back when looking to eat pub/bar food. read more

Great French dip as always! Nice outdoor seating. Servers always amazing. The bar to visit at the Jersey Shore for a corned beef sandwich/Reuben (or any sandwich!) chicken quesadillas also delicious! read more

We've been going to Kelly's for over 25 years. Primarily for their Ruben dish. The first time I went I ordered the Ruben not knowing the size of the dish. I was overwhelmed by the size of it. It was enough for 2. From that point I ordered the mini-Rubin. We haven't been there in 2 years because of COVID. We went this last week and again ordered the mini-Rubin but was disappointed as it was much smaller than the last time. Maybe, they should call it micro-Rubin. My wife ordered the crispy chicken sandwich which was fine, But, the FF's that came with it was much smaller amount than before. Hint, don't skimp on food. You certainly charge more so keep portions the same. People don't mind paying more and expect the same size portion. Finally, at 5 pm the place should have been packed with the beach crowd. It wasn't. Possibly, more competition from down the road or things have changed. read more

Has anyone ever taken off all the melted cheese under those Black Russians ? It's like chipped beef , that's not pastrami .... Real disappoint. read more

Great dive bar!!!! I felt like the place was trapped in the 70s. I could of hung out there all day, awesome vibe. Mini Reuben was delicious, happy I went with the mini, the large I never would of finished. French onion was so so. This irish joint also random sells sushi, I ain't gonna lie it looked pretty good too. read more

See all

Love love love!! Wednesday night bingo is my jam!! Food is always delish and the bartenders are great