Do you know when you're dying for that hamburger I haven't had a long time so it was very disappointing to come here. Ask for medium rare and get well. Done dried out burger. Service was great woman was pleasant, enjoyable, constantly coming around asking if need anything but we were so hungry. We didn't want to return the burgers. We just ate them very disappointed. We should've returned them as if they make new ones medium likely asked read more

See all

Incredibly friendly and helpful bartender. Very attentive, got a couple complicated orders correct and made spot on suggestions.

Food quality / price (value) rating 9. The atmosphere is roadhouse tavern. I had a Grilled Buffalo Chicken Wrap with a side Caesar salad. It was excellent. The wrap had a generous amount of grilled chicken and the salad was a decent size. The wife had a Tuna Melt with Waffle Fries, which included four good sized pieces of tuna on toast, and a generous serving of some very good waffle fries. They have eight draught beers to choose from. We sat at their 9 seat bar where our personable and attentive bartender Gina took very good care of us. The menu is pretty typical for this type of place. The men's room was a little rough and in need of a remodeling, but it was clean enough. They have several tv's in the bar, and typically have sports playing. read more

See all

Good food (plastic was found in the sour cream but I can let mistakes fly) Well serviced Then came the bill. The check had tip recommendations at 18%, 20%, and 25%. All were up charged by 1% (so actually was 19%, 21%, and 26%). Yes that's not by much. But don't deceive patrons by "making it easy by providing the tip total" and lie about it. read more

I love the barbecue wings and the hot wings. They have the specials half wing Wednesdays so good also the Reuben and the French onion soup is good. read more

Everything gets a thumbs up. The burger with mushrooms and Swiss cheese cooked to perfection! Husband had pulled pork sliders he just loved! Curly fries done well, dirty martini in a martini glass was perfection. Kayla our hostess and waitress was attentive and super sweet. Place is easily accessible, clean, warm and fuzzy! Don't wait! read more

Food was delicious. I had the bacon cheese burger and the bacon was nice and crunchy. Not limp. Because of the bad service of the restaurant down the road, The Carriage House, e we immediately left and called Kelly's Corner to see if they could accommodate 6. They said yes and had the tables pulled together when we got there. They showed that they wanted our business. read more

Casual place with a relaxed comfortable feeling. Food was great and staff attentive and friendly.

The food was amazing. The service was super quick and helpful. The place was a nice quiet area with not a lot of people and noise.

Food is fresh and tasty. Service is fast and friendly and they get it right. The setting is pub style , clean and cozy.

Kelly's Corner serves food that's a bit more high-brow than your average diner -- so if diner-quality food is your expectation going in, you'll be pleased. The menu covers a lot of ground. Our recent, large order for a crowd included: * Eggplant rollatini -- This was easily my favorite dish of those we tried, made with very thinly sliced eggplant, lightly breaded and fried, and rolled with fresh basil leaves. The two (and a half) generously sized pieces were topped with too much mozzarella for my personal tastes, but the cheese was nicely browned and toasty -- and I know I am probably in the minority when it comes to preference for cheese-to-eggplant ratios. Although the dish wasn't attractively presented when ordered by delivery, it ate beautifully, managing to be both delicate and hearty at the same time. * Ribs -- You know the packaged ribs you get in the supermarket? Think Lloyd's or Plumrose. The ribs at Kelly's Corner are just like that, but warmed through. Basic, oversauced w/ something corn syrupy -- but tender and not unenjoyable. * Cheeseburger sliders -- Three generously portioned sliders, dense patties well done and covered with American cheese, were served on egg-washed Parker house rolls w/ lettuce, tomato, red onion, and dill pickle spears on the side for garnish. Nothing to write home about, but these were kid friendly. * Grilled octopus w/ mashed potatoes and avocado -- The octopus (a lone tentacle) was well grilled and quite tender where it wasn't crispy. It was a touch fishy, but the slice of lemon that came with the dish helped mask the fishiness. Avocado was excellent and perfectly ripe. The mashed potatoes were, to judge by the texture, probably made from scratch. * Grilled scallops over salad avocado -- We received three large, grilled sea scallops alongside a few pieces of grilled shrimp, served over chopped Romaine; more of that good, ripe avocado; with a vinaigrette dressing. The seafood was, again, a touch fishy, but good enough. * Pulled pork sandwich -- Again, the quality of the pulled pork was about on par with what one might find packaged in a supermarket, supersaturated with overly sweet "barbecue sauce." Not unenjoyable -- but if you're a snob when it comes to barbecue, you are advised to avoid. * Potato salad -- This were made from scratch with new red potatoes and dressed with mayonnaise and a touch of mustard. I found the salad to be a bit bland and the potatoes a touch undercooked -- but I'm sure that's a stylistic preference. * Onion rings and curly fries -- Sysco goodness at its best. Gorgeously well fried and, in the case of the onion rings, well battered. * Cole slaw -- This was a very mayonnaise-y rendition, with a good amount of texture and bite left in the cabbage and carrots. I personally prefer a more vinegar-heavy dressing, but still enjoyed this. * Fried zucchini -- I think this could've been amazing fresh out of the fryer, since the batter was thin, the innards tender. But it was extremely over-salted (in the opinion of a true sodium fiend) and sadly, it was delivered cold and soggy. Given the lovely textures in this dish, I'd give this another try, dining in. Le Bernardin this is not -- but we'd gladly stop in for an eat-in meal, again, especially while in transit. Another meal by delivery is probably not in our immediate future: All that Styrofoam packaging weighs heavy on our conscience. (Sorry, great, great, great grandkids.) read more

See all

Good part Food above average as I'm a hamburger efficienado fresh meat cook as I asked medium with flavor not frozen. Service way below standards as we dined at off hour and had no one around to get water after my beer. Ambiance was old but it was clean read more

Old school Irish bar and restaurant. Big portions and solid pub grub menu. Wings were great.

This place is everything you want for delicious appetizers and meals. The soups are great, wings terrific, burgers are 100%. A great menu of tasty food that looks great in a comfortable pub atmosphere with Irish flare. Welcoming and never disappointing. read more

I was returning to my office and passing through Patterson, at lunch time. I was having a minor knee surgery on Friday so I wanted to stay on schedule with my meals. So "Kelly's Corner" is more of a Tavern. Seemed like a regular crowd for lunch so must be pretty good, right? After reviewing the menu I settled on a pasta dish with a "pesto sauce" and of course shrimp. If there's Shrimp on a menu I'm probably going for it. Of BTW, comes with salad and choice of dressing. I know I have a problem with patience and I'm working on it, but seemed like a long time for my meal to come out. And although my waitress seemed very nice, she was handling every table and rarely could be found. Not her fault. So the food, because most of what it's about, right? The ziti was cooked well, and the sauce was pretty good, but there was only s few small shrimp, and with the tail on. So I have to go with 3 Stars. That's it. There's a lot of restaurants along Route 22, and I've eaten in many of them but there are still more to try. So I'll be trying them. read more

Kelly's Corner - Lunch - American Near Me - Brewster, New York

Average spot to grab a beer and a burger even some wings (if you're not vegetarian). Came out with some friends that really wanted to come here because they love it! I have no reason to complain about this little cozy place, after all, you get in, you order and you get our. The staff is friendly, service is speedy. Ordered vegetarian burgers with curly fries (fries were the bomb!) and enjoyed it. Price was decent, everything was great. Will it be a food experience I remember forever? Probably not. Was the food what I ordered? Yes. Did it taste good? Yes. Point is, this place is average nothing more. Again, if you're here to just eat food something quick, go for it. You will enjoy it! If you want a food experience, this won't be the place for it. Bottom line: the place is good, environment is nice, staff is kind, place is clean, food is average. read more

Stay away! I was a Kelly's fan from way back. It was a great burger spot, wings, a beer! Service was great and the servers attentive. Then Kelly sold and new owners took over (2 years). I have so wanted this place to stay the same... but... alas.... First 2 visits sent my burger back 3 times! What part of Medium Rare is complicated? 3rd visit was for the rubber corned beef! Returned and than not eaten. Last visit more of the same, wings dry and stringy. Servers clueless and unapologetic. I reached out to the owner, he told me if I didn't like it, don't come back. Can you imagine?? Needless to say, avoid Kelly's! read more

Not being familiar with the area, I stopped in for a quick bite. I ordered a hot open turkey sandwich for dinner, and my friend ordered a French dip. We got a small order of garlic Parmesan wings. The wings are very crispy and good. Nice flavor. The sandwiches, however, we're a bit disappointing. The French dip was better than the open turkey.. really disappointing gravy on the mashed potatoes and turkey. Had no real taste. French dip was overdone and dry. The gravy was a bit better on the French dip, but nothing outstanding. I did however enjoy my cocktail which was served in a pint glass. Our server was excellent, and very nice. This place may be good for wings and drinks or maybe it's a burger kind of place, Just not hot Sammys. My suggestion is that they take their extensive menu and narrow down and specialize in fewer dishes and do them right. This place has potential to have much higher ratings. read more

See all

Amazing place, good service, good people AMAZING food and for really good prices 100% recommend.

Do not even look over, just keep driving. Management needs to pay attention to the food being served. The waitress was friendly and tried to make us happy, but with the food being served, doing that would be an impossible task. read more

I've been to Kelly's Corner about 6 times now and I've never had a complaint about the burgers or wings. The flavors are always great and service is reasonable for the area. Nothing that stands out, but not terrible either. There's always good seating and the noise level is low enough to have a comfortable conversation. My biggest complaint is that they never give me ranch dressing when I ask. It seems like blue cheese is the only sauce on site... read more

Appetizer plate was horrible. We didn't eat most of it, not appetizing at all. Fish was over cooked.,one plate of noodles and seafood was good. Maybe other dishes are better but I would certainly not come for dinner. Maybe come back for lunch, sandwich list is extensive, read more

I had to delete my first review, I talk-text without editing !!so half of it sounded as if I had one too many beers here! Lol!! 2017 I was super happy the first time I came here the second not so much but it was 10 o'clock at night and in their defense they've probably been serving soup of all day so when I ordered clam chowder in a bread bowl instead i ended up with was the chowder minus the clams! I was so disappointed because we actually came here two days in a row bc of our 1st experience. The next time I ordered chicken wings !! which I was unhappy with !! and each and every time after that we always have our go to chicken back jack sandwich with waffle fries sometimes a side of onion rings super delicious! not so the onion rings individually are huge but a small order brings three rings the large I can table share. I guess depending on the cook "fries are greasy" but I for the most part I have left here happy 80% of the time Update *** Now we order the same meal each time we come chicken bac jack on hard rolls. Waffle fries & side of onion rings! Chicken is delicious cooked on a grill w. The charred taste! Super perfect. & don't forget the tomato pesto mayo that brings it to perfection! The onion rings are super sized, Big, crispy, so Yummy! There's outdoor seating for 6ft of separation as well as indoor seating w. Chairs on table that suggests you cannot sit there! Definitely helpful in keeping the public safe w. Covid! read more

See all

Nice neighborhood place with Irish pub food. Wings, burgers, steak sandwiches always good. Fish and Chips, as well as Shepard's Pie, are hit and miss, sometimes better than other times. read more

I'm torn on this place... The wings were pretty good and the steak sandwich was solid. However, the burger came out underdone and had to be remade. I will say we had the nicest waitress I've had in years and I think she comped the soda's to make up for the underdone burger. But please, DO NOT leave the front door open when you have a smoking area outside. It comes right into the dining area and it's super gross. read more

Solid, tasty bar food. This joint gets super packed & stays that way. There is a dinning room & a bar/lounge area. The clientele is mixed but the bar is mostly blue collar worker guys throwing back (more than) a few. The wings here are really super good. The waffle fries, onion rings, burgers are all way better than average fried bar food. Didn't care for my chicken quesadilla though. If your hankering for this type of American comfort food & your on Route 22- stop in. read more

Kelly's Corner - Very medium pub burger - American Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

I send my food back 0% of the time. Ordered a $15 chicken fajita wrap but they put literally 1 sliver of chicken on one side.. so halfway through I opened the half of the wrap I had bitten into just to make sure I was biting into all onions and peppers.. sure enough, no chicken. So I opened the other half of the wrap to see if maybe all the chicken just got put into one side.. no chicken in that side either. Sent dish back for first time in my adult life. I hate sending anything back... but this seemed to have been done incredibly intentional to rip us off so didn't feel bad about it and didn't trust them to bring a new dish. I'd recommend avoiding this place. read more

Didn't expect much as we were driving through and looking for a place for lunch, but happily surprised. Food was good and service was excellent. Would stop by again. read more

Disappointed. I went in for a late lunch the place was empty. A couple of younger girls working the hostess stand and waiting on table. Placed my order it came out wrong. The First waitress said no it's correct and I said that's clearly not what I ordered and she brought it back. Another girl came over to apologize re did my order and it was still wrong..it's on the menu I did not customize the order at all. Maybe if they stopped yapping so much and fooling around they would have gotten the order right the first time. When another table left a tip one of the waitresses got it and started like cheering for her tip. Grow up and teach your staff how to act. read more

The bar lady is very rude. She said if I want curbside then i can go to McDonald's and then hung up.

We go here regularly and have never been disappointed. The food is very good, the service has always been spot on. Highly recommend!!!

We were really looking forward to wings today for the game. Ordered medium, well done. These are BARE and burnt. Dry as dirt. Really disappointing and will never order wings to go again. read more

Kelly's Corner - Wings - American Near Me - Brewster, New York

The food here has gone way down hill since the change in owners. I've gone several times in the last year, ordering take out and the orders are constantly wrong. Tonight I ordered a hot open turkey sandwich with mashed potatoes and carrots. In the past all items have been packaged in one tray, this had all items separate and was missing the turkey sandwich. When I brought this to the attention of the person at the bar argued that it was there and rifled through my order. The manager came and did the same thing. I was then given some slimy turkey on 1/2 a hero roll. Not wasting my money and going there again. Also no masks in a small bar area. read more

Well ordered to-go and had moldy bread giving to my wife for her Guinness stew. So check your loaf.

We came in for an impromptu lunch meal. I ordered a Cheeseburger with a side of waffle fries and coleslaw and I was impressed. The burger was cooked perfectly and was flavorful. The waffle fries were crispy and seasoned well. The coleslaw is clearly homemade and creamy. Service was great too. read more

Meh, Nothing to brag about. I came here for lunch with my hubby and daughter. Service was slow and the food was just okay.. read more

Went here after snowboarding at Mohawk and some Yelp reviews. Started off a little awkward since we waited a while for a table, not realizing the waiter thought we wanted a booth. A minor hiccup. I got the chili in the bread bowl based on another Yelpers recommendation and it really hit the spot. It's a hearty meal. I took advantage of their Monday night Wing special, which capped off a good ski day. Also ordered the balboa, which I thought was good too. read more

Kelly's Corner - chili bread bowl - American Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

Had a nice dinner outside under the tent tonight. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The menu was extensive and our meals were very good. We will be back!! read more

You might call Kelly's a "roadside" place but it is pretty spotless inside. This is a pub food place but it feels like a neighborhood place. Quaint bar crowd where everyone looked familiar with each other. We came for lunch (four of us) and they had space without hesitation. The waitresses are cheerful and helpful and seemed like they were letting us move at our own pace with reading the menu and ordering. This is an ideal burger and fries place with an abundance of additional choices if that doesn't suit you. Everything tasted freshly made on a stove and not from a microwave. Booths are sizable and clean. The waitress made multiple table visits to check on us and refill waters and sodas. With the Texas Taco long since gone and the Red Rooster having zero indoor space, Kelly's is a really pleasant surprise and I hope that it lasts. read more

Update never had a problem before but I heard it changed and there is new management. First time we went my open faced turkey sandwich was like a huge salt lick and totally inedible. Second time I thought it tasted good, ate everything. A couple hours later I became very sick and puked my entire dinner in the toilet. I used to love Kelly's under the old management. I don't know where they went wrong. Very sad to give one star. read more