Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Katheryn's On the Square

    3.3 (4 reviews)

    Katheryn's On the Square Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Katheryn's On the Square

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    This is a hidden gem! Great good, nice atmosphere, wonderful service, BYOB and great prices! Will definitely be going back.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 3,948 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Snappers Bar & Grill - Generous portion of hot apple pie with ice cream. Enough to share----or not.

    Snappers Bar & Grill

    3.9(166 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    What an unexpected treasure. Was on the hunt for a good fish sandwich and found do much more!…read moreSteamed clams in scampi sauce, fried haddock dinner and meatloaf was good. Save room for that hot apple pie alamode!

    TBH, IT'S ABOUT HOW YOU TREAT PEOPLE…read more.. If you work there you have to listen to Tom disrespect his wife Athena and the other employees and sometimes he'll go off swearing in Greek. He's not really a good person. He lost 2 really amazing chefs and THEY WERE CERTIFIED, not the I run the kitchen so I'm a chef type of guys. One was named Nick and I'm not sure what he ended up doing down the road, I think he went back to Snappers honestly, and the other guy was Tony and he went to some Italian Restaurant where things seemed to be much classier. They also had this badass bartender named Tom who had an outgoing personality, so much so that he could light up a room. Things were a lot better when Gus was around. He was an elder Greek man that would come into the bar and order one shot and one beer and he'd sit there for a good bit of time just soaking in the ambience. He'd then come back to the kitchen and bring A REAL, LIVE SKINNED GOAT into the back of the building and chop it up. I've never seen something like that until him, and he was one of a kind when it came to culinary arts, not just having a knife in your hand. He was a master like no other. There is an ongoing pattern in these comments. We all see what we see. You'd be better off going up the street to Sals and get yourself a 10 or 11 dollar sub and it's like 1ft and a half long.

    Photos
    Snappers Bar & Grill - Pizza and breadsticks

    Pizza and breadsticks

    Snappers Bar & Grill - Bacon Jam Shrimp Burger without the top bun!

    Bacon Jam Shrimp Burger without the top bun!

    Snappers Bar & Grill - Glimpse of huge menu

    See all

    Glimpse of huge menu

    Men In The Kitchen - Crabballs, jerk chicken quesadilla, Brussels sprouts with sausage, crab fries and chicken with collard green eggrolls

    Men In The Kitchen

    3.9(17 reviews)
    7.2 mi

    The Review: Men in the Kitchen…read more My reviews are different. I do not announce myself or tell anyone. I am here to do a review!! It was a rainy Sunday, and I was working up a hunger while driving Uber for content. I went to three different spots before I finally found the place I should've gone to first. The food and atmosphere at this restaurant are so good that I want to find another establishment just like it, but so far--at least on this day--nothing in the area can beat it. I don't know why I treat this restaurant like a good wife that a man might constantly cheat on but always returns to. I'm not saying that I actually cheat; I'm just using that for context! So, I found myself once again at Two Men in the Kitchen. Since it was Easter Sunday, they offered a buffet or a special limited menu. There was fish and chicken wings available, and I chose the wings. Since I don't eat meat often, I asked for their "House Sauce," and it is by far amazing. I paired the wings with the 3-cheese baked mac & cheese and sweet potatoes. I went for the sides first because I wanted to save the best for last--I already knew that house sauce was going to be incredible, especially on the chicken and greens eggrolls they have. The mac & cheese was great; it had a crunchy outside yet remained soft in the middle, and the cheese pull was amazing. The sweet potatoes were definitely homemade; I could tell because every slice was a different cut, which I appreciate because it proves they didn't come out of a can. Now for the best part: the chicken wings. They were cooked perfectly--neither overdone nor underdone, with no pink on the inside. Everything was pure. I did happen to taste a little bit of Old Bay on the wings, so I asked the chef if that was part of the secret seasoning. He said no, so maybe someone slipped some in by accident, but it didn't stop me from indulging. I also ordered one of their house special drinks--a Hennessy and rum cocktail. It was a very pretty drink, but unfortunately, I am not a fan of Hennessy. Personally, I think it tastes like house keys or licking a brass knob when you're a kid. On my scale, the drink was a 2 out of 5; I just don't think rum and cognac should mix, but that's just my opinion. The atmosphere was amazing and the bathrooms were clean. I will definitely visit this place again and again, although sometimes it is hard to tell if they are open because of the heavily tinted windows. For those who know the area, this is the old firehouse in Harrisburg. I was told that on the weekends, they clear some tables to create a dance floor, which is a nice touch. There is plenty of bar seating and booths, making it a kid-friendly environment. The only thing I don't like--which applies to every restaurant on 2nd Street--is that it's very hard to find parking. The Scale * Location & Parking: (3/5) * Staff & Engagement: (4/5) * Food Consistency: (4.7/5)

    First off... love the name of the place and the menu looks great!! I did get confused on which door…read moreto come in. I don't see it properly posted. I also couldn't pay for parking. You have to do it online, via text, and it won't allow you to purchase any time less than an hour. Kinda sucks for those carrying out. Totally not the restaurant's fault though. I got the jerk quesadilla without the jerk ranch sauce. They don't serve this or their regular quesadilla with salsa or pica de gallo so it does taste a little bland. The jerk flavor isn't coming thru for me. It's a little disappointing but it's also just a quesadilla so I don't expect much. I'm not deterred though. I'd be interested in trying more on the menu. It seemed like a cozy place to sit and eat. I'd also like to eat there on my next visit. I'll update my review when I do.

    Photos
    Men In The Kitchen
    Men In The Kitchen - Chicken and collard green eggrolls

    Chicken and collard green eggrolls

    Men In The Kitchen

    See all

    Thea - Pork Chop

    Thea

    4.3(178 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$

    It's been about a year since we were at Thea's so we decided to dine there again for our 10th…read moreanniversary. And again, the experience was absolute heaven. AnneMarie actually remembered us from last year and came out to check on us several times. This time I had the veal saltimbocca, the Mrs. had the crab cakes, and the son had the shrimp and pasta. All of these were the best we've ever had. In my humble opinion AnneMarie is the best chef in the world and one of the kindest people on this planet. She had even written a happy anniversary card for us. Our server, Fotini, was excellent as well. Friendly, professional, and took very good care of us. And dessert, gadzooks! AnneMarie put the raspberry cheesecake on a large platter and spelled out Happy Anniversary in the raspberry sauce (see photo). The son and I had the peanut butter oreo pie. All are fantastic. I'd give her ten stars if I could. I cannot recommend Thea enough. If you visit Mechanicsburg you've GOT to dine at Thea. The best food and the best service. Thank you, AnneMarie for making our anniversary special.

    I'm updating my review but not lowering the rating. We've been here a dozen of times and pretty…read moremuch always had a good meal. However, I've recently noticed their health score is not good. I think that is an important thing to point out and I hope they take improvements in their kitchen as back of kitchen is just as important as dining room appearance.

    Photos
    Thea - Lobby area

    Lobby area

    Thea - Pork Chop

    Pork Chop

    Thea - Strawberry Burrata

    See all

    Strawberry Burrata

    Katheryn's On the Square - newamerican - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...