I came here yesterday for lunch with friends (it was by accident - we'd intended to go to Grand Dakar, but that restaurant was mysteriously closed so we walked a few blocks over to Joloff. We found this really funny because we had the same mysteriously closed experience with Joloff a few months ago when we tried to go). This was my first experience with Senegalese food, so I can't opine on whether Joloff serves authentic food, but I can comment on how good the food tasted and try to explain why.
Joloff is a cozy shop. The exterior has an interesting mural painted on one of its walls. The interior is a cross between a restaurant and a lounge, with chairs and tables taking up most of the real estate, but when you enter, on the left are couches, chaises and coffee tables; a nice place to relax and read a book while sipping a cup of their fairly strong ginger tea. They also have a couple other interesting drinks on the menu, including a cold hibiscus drink and booye, a drink made from - somebody correct me if I've got this wrong - baobabs - we got sidetracked talking about them being the planet-wrecking trees from the Little Prince, which would have made a cool drink - but unfortunately they were out.
As you may expect from such a relaxed atmosphere, the staff is in no rush to hurry you through. Although you may need to chase them down for the bill, they are very nice and obliged us by turning off the music when one of my friends wanted to record something. I went with a group of eight, so the leisurely pace of the meal was fine because we were busy talking, but I understand why some Yelpers complain about the wait. We got there around 1:30 and did not leave until 4:00. If I were in a hurry I'd think twice before eating here.
We started with the fish pastels, yucca fries and plantains. The pastels were tasty: the dough was buttery and flaky, but the fish was very fishy, so watch out if that's not your thing. They came topped with a little tomato sauce/onion chutney, which added a good bit of flavor. The yucca fries weren't anything special on their own, but they were served with a peanut sauce that really hit the spot. This thick, mildly spiced sauce is made from ground peanuts and shows up in many dishes on the menu (mafe). My only complaint is that I wish there had been more sauce to coat the fries; we went through it fairly quickly (I really like sauce!). The plantains were regular plantains - we probably should have ordered them as a side dish instead of an appetizer.
For the main course one of my friends and myself had the tiebou jenn, Senegal's national dish, while most ordered a mafe dish. All of these were served with rice - there was white, brown and, particular to the tiebou jenn, a kind of either very short grain or crushed rice (it was too big to be couscous) - and usually with stewed root vegetables, including carrot, yucca and sometimes cabbage. The mafe dishes were good - the peanuts mixed with tomatoes, onions and some spices came together in a rich and soul-warming, but not overwhelming, sauce. The tiebou jenn is fish baked in a tomato and onion sauce, served with root vegetables, also cooked in the same sauce, and the aforementioned rice, which added up to a nice dish.
This sauce has inspired some difference of opinion among Yelpers, with some decrying it as bland and others extolling its virtues. Often when we have a dish with sauce - tomato, curry, brown butter, whatever - the dish tastes like the sauce, not like the main parts of that dish. By comparison this sauce is not overpowering - you could almost describe it as absent, even though you can detect the flavors - and you can very clearly taste the constituent parts of these dishes. I don't think that's a bad thing, but, although I appreciate the subtlety, I'm not blown away by it. It's simple and good.
For dessert we had the best options - the only options; most of the list had been crossed out - beignets and thiakri. The beignets were shaped like donut holes; they tasted crisp, sweet, fluffy and not oily and were served with vanilla ice cream, a nice contrast. Thiakri is similar to rice pudding; it's made with couscous and yogurt, and also had some raisins mixed in. This was a really nice dish. I'm not crazy about most rice pudding - it's too sweet - but the use of the slightly sour, not too sweet yogurt and couscous, a mouthful of which has a more consistent and creamy texture than grains of rice, sets this dish apart. I really enjoyed the desserts.
For someone who had never tried Senegalese food before, I left Joloff with a favorable impression. I didn't have any wow, 5-star dishes that would cause me to gush, but I was happy with what I ate. The total bill for each of us came to $20, which was pretty fair for the amount of food we ate. However, if I go back I'd probably skip the appetizers. read more