This place is the OG of Sheboygan Bakery!!! The upgrade is truly incredible and beautiful. Now they can make lattes and coffee drinks, their staff/service is super fast and friendly. All the locals and OG's come here for REAL authentic donuts, bread, milk, treats for special events like teachers day or customer appreciation day and a huge selection of cookies and everything is all homemade!!! and not made with all sugar like other places! This place sells out ASAP bc it's the best in all of Sheb with variety, flavors, and calling ahead is definitely worth doing to guarantee you get what you want. Only downfall is they are closed on Sundays. read more

Went for the first time today because I needed to get something last minute for a coworker's birthday. Was pretty busy with a pleasant atmosphere. Smells were amazing. You immediately see the large case of cookies, and then donuts. Great selection with some fun topping choices like butterfinger and fruity pebbles. The employee who helped me was very nice. I think she knew I hadn't been there before because trying to decide a selection of a dozen donuts was difficult (in a good way!), so I decided to just let her pick a random selection for me. Got an iced caramel macchiato for myself which was very good. I didn't realize that they had a case of assorted cakes that I could have got for my coworkers birthday after I had already bought the donuts. This is in no way the fault of the shop because it's literally across from the donut case. I just didn't notice because it's a lot to take in! Anyway, will definitely return. The only critique I have is that you cannot add a tip if you're paying with a card. I never carry cash so I felt really bad that I couldn't tip the lady that helped me. They should change that somehow. Other than that, great place! read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Assorted donuts. - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Tried the applesauce and chocolate frosted with sprinkles donut. Both were very good! Cute local bakery, would recommend this spot over Sunday Dough (it's mostly a gimmick). The raised doughnut was just a bit oily, but the frosting was a rich chocolate, not crazy sweet. The young woman who served us wasn't very warm, but it was a Friday morning so I know they were busy. read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Halloween sprinkle chocolate frosted donut - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

What a cute little bakery. You get free bakery smells! Yum. There are several areas: dining, frozen goods, coffee and hot drinks, and the bakery area. Bakery items are reasonably priced and so delicious. I got my first Sheboygan mud pie. I picked the cinnamon roll with chocolate icing. It was very tasty. We are inside snd they offer free wifi too. Service was quick and kind. read more

Johnston’s Bakery - These are the Sheboygan mud pies. Just a small part of all the bakery choices. - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

This is a super cute bakery located near downtown Sheboygan. I wish I could have stayed for a cup of coffee, as the restaurant area was welcoming with a huge picture window that just called to be sat by. I needed two dozen assorted doughnuts for work. The lady behind the counter was very polite and did a great job picking out a variety. The doughnuts were top notch!!! I will visit again. read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

We arrived at Johnston's Bakery after 9 AM on a Thursday. It has great parking across the street. I loved the nostalgic feel with a group of retired locals laughing at a table nearby. We were instantly helped by the friendly workers. A young lady recommended the cherry and cream cheese danish. It was a perfect ratio of pasty and filling. My sister enjoyed the cherry turnover, but she wasn't a fan of the crueler. The bakery has over 9 inside tables ranging from 2 to 5 seats. There is also a private room that accommodates a larger group. There is even more seating outside in the back. It seems like a nice place to relax and socialize or co-work from. read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Funny decore - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Was in here 2 times in the week we visited. Got a coffee the first time and wasn't very impressed with the young girl's working. No personality, not very welcoming or friendly. We felt like we were bothering them by stopping in. The shop itself is very cool. Love the ceiling fan system and the tin ceiling. The next time we stopped in we dealt with Amy for some cake questions and another woman that was new there. Both were great to work with, good personalities and helpful. If we didn't have the first experience it would have been a 5 star. read more

I've come here a few times per month when I can and I absolutely LOVE this place. It always smells great and the smiley face cookies are so so good. It is very quick to get my food and or drink and it's relatively affordable. I definitely recommend! read more

Love the donuts and cakes they make. Will always go there for my bakery. I recommend this place to anyone

Came by here after checking out Bookworms Garden. Got the raspberry elephant ear and cinnamon roll donut. Boy, the elephant ear was at least 5 lbs and delicious! I ate 1/3 and couldn't eat anymore. Loads of raspberries preserves and cream cheese for less than $3. The donut was fluffy and soft. They got the weekend special $1.2 for a dozen giant cake donut holes. Their interior, ceiling fans are so cool. Definitely must return when in area. read more

See all

I used to love Johnston's. They had fresh made delicious baked goods. I went this past week and was sorely disappointed. Every item I ordered was old, dry, crusty, stale. The lemon cream cake that I get because it's so moist had a hard crust all the way around. Not day old crust, more like week old crust. The pineapple upside-down cake had a hard surface where gooey caramel should have been and the cake was dry and crumbly, also very old. The jelly filled donut, which I would think is a safe, daily made bet, was also dry, stale, and barely filled tasteless jelly. Everything ended up in the trash. I want them to be the cozy hometown bakery with fresh, home baked goods they once were, but that was not the case this time around. The staff is friendly and the place is clean, so go for the coffee but save your calories for something better. read more

Great cinnamon roll from start to finish! Soft warm inside with perfect amount of cinnamon to glazed frosting! Would go back to Sheboygan just for this cinnamon roll! read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Cinnamon roll - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Food and service this is a real deal small town family owned bakery. The coffee is excellent and the pastries likewise

The assortment was great, lots of delicious pastries to choose from. The donut my wife had was great, and the Nutella bear claw was gone in seconds! Strawberry cake wasn't anything special, but still good. Had them make a peppermint hot cocoa that was perfect for the cold weather! read more

Amazing selection of pastries and friendly service! Will certainly be back and can't wait to try out an espresso drink read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Various pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

A cute little shop! Was very hectic this morning with the Senior Special, but service was still very good with friendly staff. The donut was delicious, and they kept most good separated for folks with nut allergies. The mocha was a little bit too sweet for my liking, but the Long John Donut was pretty good. Prices were cheap too! Was glad to stop by and definitely would recommend checking it out! read more

Great bread and cookies. They have a very nice looking seating area but we've never dined in. Friendly service.

I love everything about this place! The charm , the staff ,reasonable prices and oh my God the baked goods are amazing. We came the day before Christmas Eve and all donuts were priced half off got delicious donuts and other pastries for the same price we would spend at Dunkin' Donuts and everything at Dunkin from now on will taste like sawdust compared to this. read more

Super fun to "get bakery" at Johnston's. We over ordered every visit! Of course they have donuts. Normal delicious donuts, not doughnuts drowned in toppings, trying too hard to be special. Better yet, there are so many other delicious treats, many I've never seen before. The smile sugar cookies are the real deal. I don't even like sugar cookies. These have actual flavor (hints of spice maybe)! There's a morning bun with cinnamon and a little apple - delish. Famous Sheboygan hard rolls seemed to be flying off the shelves as locals picked up big quantities. The staff was also friendly, attentive and patient. One staff member saw our indecisiveness and did mention to us that we could safely come back after lunch! Apparently, they do another fry midday to ensure items are available in the afternoon. This was on a Saturday. read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Beautiful exterior of Johnston's Bakery on Superior Ave. - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

el pastels para muy sabroso y cafe para muy delicioso. Me gusta el cafe porous muy casas.

This is one of my favorite spots in Sheboygan. It's a great bargain, especially because the quality is so high! Their rye, rolls, and sourdough breads are absolutely delicious. I've never had a donut or a cupcake from there that I didn't like. Their mini tarts are adorable and one of my favorites. Their apple and cherry pies? Awesome. But the number one reason why we go there is for their cookies. They are addictive. They also have SO MANY adorable cookies, it's impossible to pick just one. Plus, on Wednesdays, it's crazy cookie day, so cookies are cheaper! I recommend their mini tarts and any of their sugar cookies, plus their honey bear cookies. But honestly? You can never really go wrong when it comes to Johnston's. read more

See all

Their specialty coffees are excellent and the donuts were perfect- so fluffy and sweet.

The seated cafe area was restored to look like the 1890's. really cool ceiling fixtures, tasty treats, good coffee, nice ambiance. Nice outdoor seating and while crowded early hours, by 1030 the counter line of customers slimmed down. read more

Awesome bakery. One of the best in the area. Great selection of breads, donuts and cookies. Serve a nice variety of hot beverages.

This gem is another place on my list of must-visits when I return to Sheboygan. I fell in love with the smile cookies when I lived here years ago, and I remain infatuated. If I'm being honest, I'm a wee bit of a frosted sugar cookie connoisseur and this place nails it. The peanut squares are another favorite and I also love the specialty donuts in the fall (pumpkin and apple cider). If you need class treats, a Saturday morning coffee and pick me up, a "thank you for being awesome" box of bakery or just a really good loaf of bread this is where you'll find it. read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Scrumptious! Got apple fritter, huge turnovers, chocolate donut, and coffee! The textures and flavors are Devine! We are saving the coffee cake for home. Wish we had a place like this at home! This place was recommended by family who live in WI. We are from out of town but the girl working there was very friendly. read more

Delicious!! Large, creative selection of tasty treats with high quality coffee drinks in a cozy and beautifully decorated environment. Love this place. read more

They had me at the mini pineapple upside down cake. O. M. G. !!!!! Glazed pretzel shaped donuts, apple fritters, jelly filled. I was in donut heaven. You can't go wrong with any choice. I walked out with a half dozen huge donuts and a mini pineapple upside down cake for $6!!! Heaven help me and my personal trainer!! I think I ate 3 donuts before I made it back to my hotel. I had no idea such an awesome bakery was located in this small town. The staff was friendly and I think they love their product more than the customers. If you're ever in Sheboygan or on your way to Green Bay make the stop here. It's well worth it. read more

See all

Always wonderful bakery at a great value. Wednesday the cookies are on special so of course two dozen is a must. So many great choices. The chocolate frosted custard filled bismarks are my favorite. The help is always friendly and fast This has the feeling of an old fashioned bakery with a cute atmosphere and room to eat. Definitely a must when in Sheboygan. read more

Excellent. Great old time atmosphere to enjoy coffee and great sweets. Get a card and enjoy a comp drink when the card is full. read more

Great bakery items at a really reasonable price. Filled donut and 4 decorated sugar cookies for $3.50!!! And the staff was so friendly. I will absolutely be back when I pass through town. read more

It's so cheap. Fresh bakery and nice atmosphere. If you want to eat donut you need to come early. We come around 11 am and all of donut is gone. read more

See all

I bought a birthday cake for my quilter wife. Not only was the cake artfully decorated but it tasted great as well. I highly recommend Johnston's Bakery for all your cake needs. Terrific job! read more

Johnston’s Bakery - a birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Looks great from the outside. Closed on Sundays. Would have planned better if I had known the hours. Not posted on yelp.

What can I say I grew up on this bakery as a kid and I love everything in the great place. The people are great, very very friendly! I get the chocolate mud pies (normally called Pershing) and they are mind blowing!! The cinnamon in the middle and chocolate together are just sooo good! I also like the cruellers sp? Like kind of glazed long Coffee cake doughnuts great also. And the hard rolls are the best in the city don't you forget about that. If your hungry in the AM don't hesitate to go to this GEM read more

Johnston’s Bakery - The best - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

This is the BEST bakery in Sheboygan! I have ordered several birthday cakes over the years and they are always the greatest! They also have a great coffee shop within this bakery and a very nice table area to meet for coffee with friends. Of course, the fragrance of the baked goods may get to you, and you'll have to treat that sweet tooth of yours, as well! read more

My wife and I visit Johnston's Bakery everytime we're in Sheboygan. She loves the cruellers, we can't find anything like them in L.A. read more

Johnston’s Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Their donuts are a work of art. When visiting my family in the Sheboygan area, I love to make a little pit stop here! The pirces are great.

I wish they could use better ingredients ( butter instead of margarine), everything has the same cheap dough aftertaste. Don't even attempt croissants, you won't find flaky layers, just a dough blob read more

This place is a gem. We stopped in during our trip to the PGA Championship. Walking through the door feels like a step back in time. So many delicious options, it was hard to choose! I highly recommend this place. read more