A nice spot in Montoursville. Went here a few weeks ago, wasn't too busy the day after a holiday. Staff was very friendly and service was good. They have a cool bar area with a bench. In my opinion, the menu is limited but maybe it's something that changes. I had the Santa Fe Cobb Salad. I did not like it at all, big chunks of cold carnitas. Dressing was off too. I would not order it again. Prices are reasonable. I would definitely go back though and try something else. read more

Johnson's Cafe - Santa Fe Cobb Salad - Diners Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

Our immediate family gathered in our hometown for our youngest sister's burial at Wildwood. We chose Johnson's for our meal. What a charming place, a locals favorite, no doubt. Very comforting ambiance. My cabbage rolls were delicious, along with the scalloped potatoes. Very legit and not too much rice rather than beef in the rolls. I wish I would've gotten the roasted veggies; I hardly ate mine. Mike liked his stuffed pork chop meal and my sister enjoyed her fish dinner. Service was good and fast, not that we were rushed. Would go again! read more

Johnson's Cafe - My meal - Diners Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

Nice space, friendly staff, big bar, I need 85 characters to post this good grief, how many more is that?

We have been long time customers. We ordered tonight for takeout through their site that's on FB. The order came up with an error message, BUT our card was still charged. I contacted them right away and the manager/owner was not there, so a girl called her to figure out what to do. I received a prompt call back and was basically told they couldn't do anything and perhaps I ordered from an incorrect restaurant, which was not the case. I told the girl that this looks like theft because they took our money without any product. She called the manager/owner back. They requested screenshots be emailed to them and then they would call me either tonight or tomorrow - note this is almost $60, so not small change. I even gave permission for my number to be shared with the manager/owner so she could call me directly. My husband got on the phone and was very firm. The girl on the phone talked over him. When he asked for her name, she said that doesn't matter. We have been long time customers and not out to scam anyone, but we are out money, a decent amount and nothing to show for it. In this economy, having almost $60 out of service is not acceptable! We have no dinner, the money is unavailable, and your customers are screwed! We will NOT be back. read more

I ordered a Santa Fe Cobb salad. it was not a cob salad, the menu described it as having pork carnitas but the pork was unseasoned, greasy meat. I am not a picky eater but I could not eat more than a few bites. The waitress never even asked me what was wrong when she picked up my full plate. She was young so maybe she was new at serving and I didn't want to hassle her so I didn't say anything. I wish I had. read more

I would give 3.5 stars if I could. My 3 siblings & I ate here yesterday & when I think of a "cafe", I don't expect entrees like this. Most of the meals were good. My Seared Sesame Tuna Steak was delicious! No complaints at all. However, there were some issues: My brother's sweet potatoes were cold & had to be taken back for reheating. Thankfully, they were in a separate bowl, so he could still enjoy the rest of his meal while they heated them. Now for the major problems with the meal served to one of my sisters: The description from Johnson's Facebook page reads: "Filet and Shrimp Scampi-Petite filet mignon lightly marinated in butter and garlic, flame grilled and served with shrimp broiled in butter and garlic, and a side of angel hair pasta." What she really got: 1) The steak was a filet mignon wanna-be. It had too much gristle to be authentic. 2) The pasta was spaghetti, not angel hair & did not have butter on it. 3) There was a smaller portion of shrimp than what they show on their Facebook page. My sister wouldn't place any complaints. She was traveling back to VA after our meal and probably didn't want to wait for a replacement. I have posted both her meal and the one they posted on their Facebook page to show the differences that are apparent to the eye. Of course, you'll have to take my word for it about the meat. The waitress was very attentive w/o being a pest. We were very happy with her service and her demeanor. Look up the history of this restaurant. It's very interesting. It's been in existence for over 60 years. That's saying something when a pandemic happened a few years ago and it had to shut its doors for a time. read more

I just had lunch at Johnson's café. I've eaten there before and I've always enjoyed my meal. If you like things a little spicy they're spicy chicken sandwich with crispy fries is awesome. I highly recommend it. We ate outside in the back. It was a beautiful day and our server was amazingly friendly. Definitely the place to go for a good meal read more

A wonderful restaurant with a large menu, great weekly specials, and a nice selection of craft beers on their rotating taps. I've tried many items on their menu and all have been great. Most recently the meatloaf--spectacular! read more

My family and some friends went to Johnson's for new years. The portions were small for the price. I could have gotten a TV dinner from the grocery store for much less, and it was basically the same thing. I tipped the waiter cash in advance but apparently she didn't think it was enough because they also added "gratuity" to the bill. Then the waitress argued with my mom about the tip and said "13% wasn't enough" and it should have been 20% and that's why they added gratuity charge to the bill. This is why I don't eat at restaurants much, and I definitely won't go back to Johnson's. read more

Delicious, American fare. Small inside, cozy atmosphere with tables reasonably spaced apart. There is a bar located behind the restaurant seating area which is located right when you walk in the front door. I noticed on my way back to the restroom that the restaurant offers a back room that fits long banquet tables. read more

See all

Was looking for a diner that I've never been to and decided on this. Was amazed with everything. The service, food, cleanliness and size.(it's ALOT bigger inside than it looks from the outside. One of the best breakfast I've ever had. Food was absolutely delicious. read more

Johnson's Cafe - Egg, avocado, bacon and tomato with homefries. - Diners Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

This place has been around for years. Always great to come home to the place you went to in high school over 20yrs ago and it's still around. Server was very polite. Refilled my drink when ever it got low and was on top of bringing out our food right when it was ready. Prices are perfect! Inexpensive for a local small restaurant! Better than any fast food! read more

Johnson's Cafe - Menu front - Diners Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

See all

This little gem of a restaurant turned out to be a great find. We were looking for somewhere to celebrate our son's birthday (he's attending college nearby) and decided to take a chance based on all the good Yelp reviews. Johnson's Cafe did not disappoint! First of all, the menu is extensive. From coffee rubbed pork chops (outstanding!) to burgers and salads, this place has a lot to offer. Service was good, and the food was delicious and fresh. We all loved our meals and would definitely revisit on our next trip to the area. Johnson's is clearly a local favorite, and though we didn't hang out at the bar, we were told they have a great selection of beers. read more

We are from out of town, and wanted a nice sit down dinner. I ordered the Homestyle Chicken and Biscuits. My wife ordered the turkey dinner. We started with salads, which were okay, and her meal was fair, similar to a TV dinner in quality . The chicken and biscuits, however, was inedible. The dish consisted of a large lump of dense biscuit in the middle of a very basic pot pie filling. The chicken was stringy, the peas were hard, like pebbles, and the broth completely bland. I picked out the chicken as best I could, but the peas were dominant. Considering the prices charged here, one would expect better quality. This would have been a one star review if not for the awesome wait staff. Thanks to the nice waitress who helped us. read more

Visiting town for work. First time here, nice, cozy spot. Cobb Salad was huge, delicious, fresh and great value. Waitress was great and helped me get in and out quickly. Wish I had more time to linger! read more

Fantastic handcrafted food with regular specials and huge wings! The perfect environment for a group dinner or a quiet night out. So much variety that it never gets old! You will not be disappointed! In years of frequenting this casual atmosphere with fine-dining quality food we have never been disappointed. Excellent beer selection with constantly rotating selection of fine beers. Full bar. read more

Amazing salads; a lot of quality ingredients with house made dressing. Went to pier 87 yesterday for a salad and they should stop by a get a lesson. Super fast service cool interior. Will be back. read more

First time eating here while in town visiting friends. I had the vegan sausage vegetable sauté with vegan mozzarella cheese. It was so tasty. My husband had the veggie burger and fries. Also very good. We will definitely be back when we're in town again. read more

Walked into the restaurant yesterday asked for a cusher seat due to have a hemrroidhectomy last week and I was told by some guy that these are the seats and this is what you get. It was a man in grey casual work clothes I believe and I know it wasn't a waitress. I have been going to this place for a long time and was very happy. As of yesterday I will no longer visit this establishment and will not recommend this to anyone. What ever happen to courtesy in a restaurant? How about instead of saying what he said you can say I'm sorry but these are the only seats we have. read more

Driving from Toronto to Philly and stopped by for lunch since they had the largest salad selection of anywhere in the area. Let me tell you, this place was awesome. The salads were fresh and well prepared. Also, if you have time, visit the bakery across the street after! read more

Best salads in town! Salads are large and plenty. Always accommodating with changes to dishes. I just had the special- blue blue salad! And it was better than I thought! Great combination of salad blueberries, pecans , chicken , apples and more! The value is great as well as service. Love Johnson's ! It's our go to restaurant now. read more

I had the fried Haddock in this small town near Williamsport, PA and near the West Branch Susquehanna river. It was a Saturday evening and the place was packed to the rafters and loud. It came with French fries, coleslaw, some vegetables and a small roll. It was very good I thought. Although this is a bar the food is quite sophisticated. Not sure how many bars would put gluten free raviolis on their menu. Requesting medium well or well done steaks is apparently not done here as the menu will try to make clear to you. Recommended. read more

Johnson's Cafe - Diners Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

A step above diner. I had the gluten free chicken kale raviolis with a salad and GF warm roll. Yum! Husband had the roast turkey dinner with stuffing and mash potatoes. He was offered salad or applesauce but passed. Large portions good food and friendly staff. Clean bathroom! We are traveling from NY to FL and was skimming Yelp for something other than a chain.. Well worth it! read more

Johnson's Cafe - Gluten free chicken kale raviolis, salad and a warn gluten free roll. - Diners Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

I've been here countless times throughout the years. Food is great. I've only had one bad experience here. On my most recent visit it was Valentine's day and they have a special for that weekend. Selections are awesome. However, not sure if the food was ready before the server was available because the food was lukewarm at best. Taste was good, just not very hot. We were also seated just inside the door. I do not recommend this location. Since you are greeted and need to stand there until a table is cleared, it was not a treat to have people standing right at our table as we were trying to enjoy our meal. Best bet is to call ahead for reservations and don't think you're just going to swing by on a special weekend and be seated right away. This place has a great reputation and fills up quickly. I definitely recommend you stop in. I'm taking this past experience in stride and it will not stop future visits! read more

We had a wonderful surprise 70th birthday party for our Dad at Johnson's cafe. The owner was very helpful with menu and party planning. The private room set-up was classy and accommodated 30 people easily. The food was delicious especially the wings and bacon wrapped shrimp! The servers Rae and Tiffany were extremely attentive and were great with our kids. We will be back! read more

Johnson's Cafe - Diners Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

Have to say, value seems to be going down here. Several visits now and each seems to get worse and worse. My wife and I started off with soups. She got broccoli-cheddar, which was good at best and the soup was barley warm. I got the clam chowder, which was pretty good, I've had some better and a bunch worse, but it was SCALDING hot! My wife got the turkey wrap, it was good and sizable for the money. I got the fish sandwich, a little pricy at $13. It was good. When I placed the order I was asked for a side, thinking it came with one, I ordered fries, ended up seeing the charge for them on the bill. Really, a charge for a single side with the meal???? Drinks, just got unsweetened tea and a raspberry tea for me. Turned out, MY tea only came with ONE refill, a 3rd drink cost me an additional charge. Quality seems to be dipping here at each visit and you get nickel and dimed in the process. It's gonna be a while until I return. read more

Steak was asked for extra well and they brought it out three times and then when it was bearable to eat the mashed potatoes were cold. Now why would they not warm them up after all that. Then they charged for the whole meal and I told them the potatoes were cold. Really bad experience. I will not be going back again. I was not impressed with the service at all. The one time they brought it out a fly landed on the steak and they still served it. So gross! read more

Cozy small little spot, just stopped in here for lunch on a road trip. Great service, seemed very attentive to cleanliness and appropriate safety measures. We got a few things, some of it ok and some great! Loved the spicy chicken sandwich and onion rings! read more

Holy Grail??? I'm always searching for the "best" hamburger & have had some really great ones, but Johnson's Bacon Jam Burger is one of the best I've ever had. The 1/2 lb. burger was cooked to a perfect medium-rare, squashed, not formed with seared edges and juicy, pink middle. Perfectly seasoned for great burger flavor. The "bacon jam" was a uniquely delicious sweet counterpoint to the savory bacon strips and tangy blue cheese. I didn't even put ketchup on. A first for me. read more

Locals who stopped here for lunch. Nice selection of salads. I had the fajita chicken salad and my wife had the chicken cranberry walnut salad with poppy seed dressing. Both very good. Will stop here again. read more

The jalapaño cheddar tots with sriracha dipping sauce are really good! The burgers are also really good! (build your own). Bacon wrapped shrimp were just OK. Bacon was a little soggy. But overall, a great place! So many different kinds of beers - too many to count!!! read more

This place has the best apps I like that you can go inside and outside. The staff is very friendly. The good is great I had a great meal here. thank you very much!!!!! read more

I can't say enough about this place. I had grilled Haddock with onions and bacon with sweet potato fries and steamed vegetables with a salad. Service was exellent read more

We are swinging through the area and this was recommended by the hotel. Amazing!!! The service was great, friendly atmosphere, and perfect food. I would go back here in a heartbeat and would recommend Johnson's to anyone. Had a big variety of food and great beer selection! read more

Super friendly staff but the steak was as bad as I've ever had. No seasoning, cooked over the finest gas flame and more gristle than meat. The sides were also bad. Cold rolls, tasteless garlic potatoes. I have low standards but a $30 steak should have a little flavor. read more

I've had a few dinners here, and everything was absolutely delicious. They have different specials, but I really enjoy their Italian specials that they have every Saturday Night. Their Seafood Alfredo is the best Seafood Alfredo that I've ever had, and ranks among my favorite Pasta dishes and meals in general. The atmosphere is nice, it's like a little hole in the wall place that actually has a lot of room. However, I did notice that if you're in the backroom the acoustics of the place is really weird, making it difficult to hear the people around you, and if there's a big party in a thinly walled off section it can be a bit obnoxious. Still, I was amazingly impressed by all of the food I've had here, and I would definitely recommend it. read more

Fantastic wings at a family style restaurant. Be sure to get the homemade red blue cheese dressing for wings or salads. When the weather is nice, enjoy a meal and drink on the back patio. read more

Stopped here on a Sunday night passing through town. Service was a little slow to start as the place was packed - probably more than expected. Our server did a good job explaining that there was a fundraiser promotion that was open ended and that the place was crowded because of it and it wasn't a typical Sunday night. He also did a good job working through the menu and guiding suggestions. Food was fantastic. Shrimp Mac & Cheese, Ham & Cheese on a Pretzel Roll and a couple of kids items. My 3 year old was in a talkative mood and the server did a really good job talking with her, which is always nice as it made her feel special as well. All in all a really good stop once it got moving. Set us back a little bit on our schedule but glad I stopped and it's a place I've shared with family & friends in the area. read more

Absolutely worst experience with a "restaurant" that I have ever had. The beer was over priced the service was downright awful and very slow. The food came out and literally everything about it was just the saddest excuse for such a hyped up restaurant....everything was cold the mashed potatoes were not mashed at all the gravy was flavorless the chicken was over cooked and dry and the waffles were super soft....needless to say I would never recommend a place with that bad of an experience to anybody read more

A great place to eat. The salads are delightful, the sandwiches are amazing, and the servers are hospitable and competent.