I was in town on business and was in the mood for some pizza. This was nothing special. It had decent reviews so I gave it a try. To be honest, I didn't care for the taste. The crust flavor was just ok and the sauce was marginal. It's not an actual sit down restaurant. You walk up and order, get your own drink, and find a seat. It was clean and seemed busy, but I wouldn't drive out of my way to eat here again. If I was with friends who wanted to eat here then I'd go again. I don't want to sound like a horrible person, I just didn't care for it. read more

Johnny Tomatoes - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

My wife and I stopped in midday and split their two slice with soda special for $7.99. Good deal and nice to have slice options instead of a whole pie. The cashier was friendly and helpful, too. We liked the dough with its crispy crust (an added treat when rewarming a slice); however, we found the sauce uninspiring and began tossing on our slices extra cheese, seasonings, and garlic to amp it up. I would be willing to try them again especially since they have more items in which I'm interested. Oddly, I cannot get delivery to Monroe even though Jet's Pizza next door delivers without hesitation. Hmmm. read more

Johnny Tomatoes - Lunch special with a 20 ounce soda, $7.99 - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

Delivery was pretty quick- Garlic knots were fabulous! My Stromboli was very good - needed a little more sausage . The Hot Hero with grilled Chicken was good but alas the Broccoli Rabe was not cooked enough and had to be removed. Chocolate Mousse was delicious. So were the Zeppole!! Just a couple Tweaks and it would have been perfect! read more

Johnny Tomatoes - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

See all

Johnnys is a constant. Great pizza, great service. The white pizza is amazing. The cannoli are the best in town.

I loved the pizza and the fact that this place sells by the slice! I tried the regular slice, the barbecue chicken and white slice -- they were all delicious! You can't take this review lightly, I'm from Long Island and am very picky about pizza! On top of the food being good, I love the energy in this place. They had lively music playing and they were friendly as well. I will definitely be back! read more

Johnny Tomatoes - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

Great pizza and a very inexpensive lunch special for two slices and a drink recommend it to anybody The staff is very friendly and they have beer read more

First time back since they expanded the joint and was impressed with the new layout; more importantly the food was great, had the chicken balsamico sandwich and it was so big I took 1/2 home for lunch the next day, the wife had the chicken parmigiana sandwich and same story, great food and surplus was lunch for the next day..... Give them a try if you are in the area, you will be glad you did read more

Some of the best Pizza in the Charlotte area. Definitely one of the only ones that doesn't allow their sauce to overpower the whole pie.

Decided on a whim to try Johnny Tomatoes. Went in and ordered a chicken Parmesan Sub on the homemade white bread. My wife and I shared the sandwich and fries. They actually served it on 2 plates. The service was quick, the sandwich was delicious and we thoroughly enjoyed it. The price I thought was very fair for the amount of food you got. I will definitely be back . read more

The pizza and food is delicious. Service is really really good. Ambience is comfortable.

We usually order pizza once a week from Johnny Tomatoes, and they have always really. However, tonight they really dropped the ball. We always order a large plane pizza with a crispy crust. I got the pizza home and it tasted as if it wasn't completely cooked, let alone crispy. Very disappointed. read more

Ordered 40 wings (mild,hot,hot honey, garlic parm) for my family cookout. The wings were delicious! I live in South Carolina, but next time I am near Johnny Tomatoes I will definitely stop in and get a few items to take home. read more

The food wasn't worth it, coming all the way from Charlotte. The salad itself was cut up into almost two smaller pieces. It was hard to fork all of it. The cheese pizza was decent, nothing to rave about or drive all the way for. read more

See all

We went here on a whim to try something other than Pizza Hut. The pizza was good and the garlic knots too. The service well that left a lot to be desired. They take your order at the register and bring your food to the table. That's it for service. I was disappointed that they pass the surcharges of credit cards on to the customer. This is probably why we won't come back. Not the food but passing fees to your customers. read more

Always delicious and the best....by far, in Indian Trail! Pizza is great...sides are good. Subs have the northern flair...great choice in this area!!! read more

Best pizza around. Thin, crispy crust, good sauce and a decent amt of toppings. Wouldn't consider any other delivery pizza in Union County.

Our first time here and we liked it a lot. We shared an antipasto salad with a balsamic vinaigrette dressing. The sell pizza by the slice as well as whole pizza and a variety of other items. They will add condiments to the pizza slices. Everything was great and the staff is Uber friendly. read more

Outstanding customer service and great pizza local, 5 out of 5 stars. The resturant is comfortable and clean inside.

Great Sicilian pie. Haven't had a Sicilian pie this good since leaving NY. Definitely my Ney go to place for pizza.

Pizza is close to NY style. It's very tasty and reasonably priced. The Cannoli are good too.

Not only is the pizza really good, the staff are very friendly and attentive. I will definitely be back.

Johnny needs to get back behind the counter and start making these pizza's like they use too roughly a month ago. Not sure what changed but it's different and not for the better. read more

Johnny Tomatoes - Burnt garlic knots, hard as rock. - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

Our most recent experience at Johnny Tomaties left me with mixed feelings. I specifically asked not to over bake our pizza, but unfortunately it was over baked . The flavors are there but the execution fell short. We did add to our order a Meatball roll which was absolutely delicious and baked to perfection. We also indulged in Buffalo Chicken Calzone that every bite was enjoyed. Staff has always been pleasant and friendly. I won't walk away saying I'll never go back and hopefully Johnny will have a chance to redeem himself. read more

Man... this PIZZA IS AMAZING! And to make it even better, the STAFF AND SERVICE was also TOP NOTCH!!! I found this place by chance... or what had to be an angel at the pool in Brandon Oaks. We were both thinking pizza to feed our children who had a blast at the pool. After hearing her talk about JT, I decided to make a run. When I arrived, everyone was happy, friendly, and they were playing great music! Loved the atmosphere. Even during a rush (they were super busy), I was greeted and welcomed quickly. Unfortunately, I didn't get names or pics of the staff members but I'm moving to this area and they've got me and my family for life! I'll definitely be back! This is REAL PIZZA. If you've never had it, stop by today! You will not regret the decision. Enjoy! read more

See all

This is our go to pizza place. Jonny's is a no frills pizza place, they have a few seats for those that want to eat in. However, they are known for takeout and you won't be disappointed. Coming from the north and going to college in the northeast you learn about great pizza. The Charlotte area comes up short on great pizza places. Johnnys is the only place we've found to be consistent each time we visit. Their tomato sauce has a sweet hint to it that I can't put my finger on. They take the time to make sure the pizzas aren't smothered in too much sauce. Highly recommend trying johnnys you'll be pleasantly surprised!! read more

It's nothing like the NY pizza I've had. Crust under cooked, sauce was blah and a ton of tasteless cheese Sorry it was a waste of time and money read more

JT's has the most amazing food and you can tell that Johnny puts his heart and soul into his business. We are so lucky to have NY style Pizza in Indian Trail. read more

Pizza was amazing vodka pie and regularly cheese with spicy sauce on it nice thin crust definitely would recommend Johnny tomatoes

This is really good pizza! I'm a NYer. After one bite I said, "finally some real NY pizza!" It's all about the crust. Great staff, and Johnny the owner is a good guy. Whenever I'm in the area I pick up a couple of pies. read more

Delicious pizza and prompt service! Friendly service to boot. This is our go-to Friday night pizza option.

Omgdn !!! The food is amazing. The bread for the subs are home made and fresh. Pizza and Sicilian is amazing. So good I don t add any toppings. True NJ/ NY Pizza i can t say enough or eat there enough. Yummy! read more

Johnny Tomatoes - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

I'm a pizza snob if you've ever met one. This place is one of my favorites. It also helps that it's local. I've tried a few slice selections as well as the calzone . The sauce was pleasant with a hint of sweetness. I'm from NY so I base my pizza on the crispness of the bread and the authentic taste of the sauce. The cheese to bread ratio checks all of my boxes. I'll be a repeat customer for sure. Definitely worth a try. Might I add the salad selections are just as tasteful. Don't be shy, give this spot a try! read more

I've been here a few times since Pizza Palace moved out. While I do miss the lunch buffet from Pizza Palace, I do enjoy the "by the slice" options from the new management. The interior could be fixed up....it seems to be still falling apart from the Pizza Palace days on the inside (bathroom light switch falling out the wall, ceiling gross, etc) but this place deserves a chance. Stop in for a slice and keep them in business, the pizza is really good. Get the buffalo chicken slice and dip it in ranch. Yum. read more

Under new ownership and the food is delicious. I am very picky about my pizza and hoagies etc but this place is legit. Glad.to are the new owners took over because this place is great. The sicilian pizza is great and the dough is amazing. We.also had the stuffed wheels and the ricotta cheese is some of the best we've had. You have to eat here. read more

Johnny Tomatoes - Best sicilian pizza in town - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

Great local pizza place. I personally think it's the best pizzeria in the area and stop by once or twice a month.

Saw this place mentioned on a Facebook foodie page and thought we'd give it a try. It's a small shop with only a few tables. They mostly do takeout but since it's a drive for us we opted to eat in. Started off with mozzarella sticks and they were good. I ordered the clam pizza which has a garlic oil base. It was delicious . I'm still thinking about it 3 days later. My bf stuck with traditional sausage mushroom & pepper. The crust was crispy. Again another winner. The gal behind the counter was super sweet and checked on us several times to make sure our pizzas were to our liking. We will definitely be back. read more

Johnny Tomatoes - a pizza with mushrooms, peppers, and onions - Pizza Near Me - Monroe, North Carolina

See all

Huge shout out to the awesome folks at Johnny Tomatoes! I was planning my son's grad party & Julianna and Ms Jackie were fantastic to work with. Even when the day before the party my guest list grew from 100 to 125+ they were so helpful & accommodating to make sure I had enough food for all my guests. The pizza was ready precisely on time & enjoyed by all my guests. Many wanting to know where I got the pizza! Hope this sends lots of business to this wonderful pizza shop! Thank you for helping to make my son's party an epic success! read more

Pizza and customer service were great. Crust was tasty and had great "snap"! Enjoyed a delicious white pie with chicken broccoli spinach and ricotta! Also recommend the pepperoni and ham, very delicious. read more

We decided to try a different pizza place than our normal two go tos. Unfortunately will not add this to our rotation. We got a family deal with 2 pies- one Sicilian and one just regular cheese with knots. Neither pizza was great. The Sicilian was doughy in the middle and when reheated the next day, a layer came off. Neither had much flavor or good sauce. I had high hopes but it just didn't do it for our family. read more

Johnny tomatoes went above and beyond for my order that a food delivery platform really messed up. A huge shout out to Jen...she was awesome while we both tried to figure the mess out. No shout outs to the delivery agent who really wanted nothing to do with it, but refund 5 dollars on a 30+ order. I do still feel bad of the lost order that was made way before it should have and I hope my review helps others to choose johnny for the needs/wants of an amazing pizza experience. read more