Food is great quality for the price! The service was friendly and food came out in good timing. Pancakes were soft and fluffy, everything tasted very fresh. A nice hidden gem read more

See all

Stopped here for breakfast on our way to our nieces house. No joke when I say this was THE BEST breakfast I have had in my 47 years on this Earth! Every bite was deliciousness in my mouth. I got the fiesta omelette and added the home fries. We can't wait to visit on our next trip down from Rhode Island! read more

Jimmy's Diner - Fiesta omelette with a side of home fries - American Near Me - Mastic, New York

Food is excellent and the prices are great. The place is small and there is a limited parking. Get there early..definitely worth it! Happy customer read more

I would definitely recommend 10 out of 10 for food and service. Seems like a woman owned business that I love. The only thing is that they are cash only or Venmo. Luckily we had cash with us. There is an option to use the ATM the gas station next door (if you're comfortable with a gas station ATM). They really should have that on the door. It says no outside food or beverages. Twice. I think that should be on there too. read more

Had a quick breakfast and was surprised It's was not glitzy but the food was good, the help even better read more

The food is great! The staff are really friendly and easy to connect with, even with Deaf folks like me and my family. I really appreciate that they know how to communicate with us. read more

Good food exceptionally nice and professional service. It was mobbed, which is always a good sign!

Cute little place. Doesn't look like much from the outside but give it a try. All freshly cooked on the spot. Great people. Excellent service. Glad we stopped here. read more

Great little spot full of local color. Inexpensive tasty food. Well worth stopping in

This is one of the best small local restaurants to have breakfast, homemade style , great portions and good price. I wish they had more natural juices options instead of can juice or soda . read more

Jimmy's Diner - American Near Me - Mastic, New York

See all

Service is very nice. I have the hungry man breakfast that is tasty. Haven't tried anything else. Small place and bathroom is in the back next to the kitchen. Would go back for breakfast for sure. read more

Jimmy's Diner - Hungry man breakfast. - American Near Me - Mastic, New York

first time , not last Great food, great atmosphere, great prices! The diner is small and cozy. The staff is friendly. Brings back fond memories of how Long Island Use to be. read more

Yup... 5-stars! This is a/the quintessential "diner"... Danielle and Rosie are fabulously nice people and (if you go there) they will begin your experience... wonderful! Traditional diner food (note that I didn't say normal... their food isn't normal)... their food is great... ! ... no flashy decor, no overworked stressed out wait staff and no pretense... just honest Diner Ambiance! if you are looking for a choice of 17 different juices, 23 choices of ooo-long tea or non-dairy cappachino this ain't your place! If you want hot sauce your choice is "Frank's Hot Sauce" otherwise bring your own... the superb team of Rosie/Danielle will be happy to keep your bottle in their cooler for you... Value... everything on Long Island is expensive, this isn't Jimmy's Diner's fault... BUT... if you are looking for value this place delivers... this is my new "goto" diner... it should be your's as well... oh, another thing... it's small (say cozy) so get there early or try to beat the rush... Cheers read more

It's the best! The girls are great and always offer up service with a joke and a smile.. by far the best breakfast on Long Island

The best food and service in this part of Suffolk! Please go there and try them! Montauk Hwy.

The food here is absolutely delicious!! I had corn beef hash and eggs and it was perfect!! Staff is super friendly! Such a great old school diner feel with yummy food! We will definitely be back! read more

I don't venture this far out the island often but when I do I try to find places to eat that I can add to my "go to" list. This is one of them. Simple diner food with a nostalgic old time feel. This place was opened in '68 and you can tell some people have been coming here since then. Breakfast was good, no complaints. Everything came in a timely manner, was hot and fresh and tasted great. Coffee was good, juice was good, staff was nice. It's a very small place, maybe 5 tables and bar seating but there was no wait. It was great for a quick breakfast which is what we were looking for. read more

See all

A small homey place $ A local favorite ...crowded, noisy, friendly very friendly...GOOD STUFF! ask for Rose read more

This place so reminded us of another "diner" similar in size located in a small town in Vermont....What a great find on a strip of Montauk Hwy loaded with commercial enterprises. Linda, the prop was a sweetheart and took care of us like a mother would, making sure we were happy and well fed. It was so comfortable being there and everyone was enjoying their vittles. We had a brunch time breakfast. Great coffee and Bon got the French Toast with Bacon and I got Blueberry Pancakes with magnificant sausage links. You cant compare this place to anything else cause theres nothing else like it in the area. Comfortable, Great food, warm service and clean....a 10/10....we look forward to returning soon! read more

See all

A great hidden gem. Reasonable prices and home cooked meals make you feel like you're at your grandmas or something. Overall it's solid diner food. I cant believe I waited so long to go. read more

This has been my family's go to place for breakfast. I've been searching for a great place for breakfast that was as good as and upscale restaurant like Bills cafe in California. and finally found this place eventhough it's not the same atmosphere or menu as Bill's Cafe. Restaurant is a small place but the employees are so nice, food came out fast and really good. This has recently become my family's go to restaurant for breakfast every weekend now. I would recommend this to anyone that enjoys a good breakfast. Prices are also really good. read more

See all

Everyone around here talks about the nostalgic Jimmy's Diner..... I was not too impressed. It's back woody style, it needs updating ... food was average... Nothing to brag about. It's just a spot for the older locals, to hang out in catch up on their weekly events and grab a quick bite. All the best. read more

Well the hype is really hype... not downplaying the food. It is a local place that fits not a lot of people. There are 5 tables and a counter to eat. The portions are small but they the price is inexpensive. I had the special, fried chicken sandwich with bacon cheese on bread. It was good, nowhere near great. The fries are great. But they are precut, frozen seasoned. I am glad I went but if I don't ever go back I will be fine. I am not a breakfast person and everyone in our party ordered breakfast with the exception of one of us who ordered a Ruben. The place is neat if you want a 1960 Alabama atmosphere!! read more

See all

First time visit. Only cash so we had to walk across the street to an ATM. Place is super tiny. I had soggy French toast that I could not eat. Our food was cooked so quickly that it was . Basic eggs and bacon, not bad. We truly enjoyed the biscuits and gravy. Personnel is super friendly. Coffee was good. Bathroom is weirdly placed as you have to go through a fort and the across the kitchen. read more

This is a gem, a diamond in the rough. Nearly all of the diners on Long Island sport fancy chrome facades and overly complex menus. That comes at a cost, the bill. This tiny diner that looks like an aging shack on the outside and has "dated" decor is serving up a modest menu of classics. The food is delicious and affordably priced. Donna is a breath of fresh air. She gets it, as does all of the staff here. The service is excellent. read more

The best dinner on the Island. It just cannot fit a lot of people, it is a very small eatery that may hold 20 people. Those women who do the cooking are so cool, so New Yawk, and can cook like it's nobody's business. I don't care what you order, it's just freaking good. Get there early because I do believe they close around 2Pm read more

Best breakfast, best service, best prices. They do not make places like this anymore. Even the coffee is outstanding. A find.

The food is really good here I love the pancakes and French toast! Especially the blueberry pancakes they are fluffy and really great with a side of bacon! read more

Have been coming here 5 months now . It's a small place , but the service is great. It gets really packed because is so small

Let me start if with the fact that I have finally found a Diner that does not have pre prepped dry cardboard bacon. Jimmy's fried my bacon right in front of me and I was very pleased. Ok back to the review . Jimmy's is not a Diner at all. It's a hole in the wall with a gravel driveway , minimal seating and the decor is nothing to brag about. And this is just the way I like it. What Jimmy's does and what is so important is they forget all about the other stuff that Yelpers get caught up with and focus on what's important. FOOD and HOSPITALITY. The food was fresh and tasted great. The service was quick. The staff worked well together and were top notch . I came in 10 minutes before closing and no one rushed me or had an attitude. Jimmy's gets a rare 5 star from me. I will be coming back very soon. Advice to Jimmy's. Don't change a thing. read more

Jimmy's Diner - American Near Me - Mastic, New York

Great service , food comes out quick, chef has his game on , owner above all hires the right people with great personalities that are attentive to you with a smile that has a family oriented atmosphere .The food is cooked to perfection , Pancakes are a must have , There is a wait at times but we'll worth it as you will have seat pretty quickly . read more

Small, old school, good prices, good food! Highly recommend, friendly service. Nice place overall

Great breakfast... good size servicing ... pancakes are really big stack... ordered as side for sharing... excellent customer service... read more

Jimmy's Diner - 2 any style eggs; sausage on the side and pancakes to share ... this stack is 1/3 rd... - American Near Me - Mastic, New York

Tasty tasty tasty. Great customer service. I had a blt with cheese and a short stack both were delish. Although there are some Trump signs and a sense that "others" may not be welcome, I felt comfortable enough to sit inside and enjoy my brunch with my friend. read more

Great all around joint. This place would crush DDD on the food network! The pancakes are a must try!

We ordered three eggs three waffles and bacon to go with that with some coffee it came out to $50 and they still didn't give us the whole order they left out some eggs. read more

Very comfy, homey little place with great food and service. You really do feel like you're in the country! If I ever find myself out there again, I would visit another time. Bring your cash as they do not accept cards. read more

Jimmy's Diner - Yummy, fried comfort food. - American Near Me - Mastic, New York

Biggest disappointment. My wife and I really wanted to love this place, but unfortunately it fell so far short. You know you had a bad meal when you ask for the check, and the waitress asks you, "Was it even edible?" Having a car worked on nearby, I thought I had found a hidden gem. A nostalgic looking diner with an extremely friendly staff. Unfortunately it went downhill from there. About 25 minutes after we had ordered we were informed that the chef had made the wrong dish and they were remaking our order. Fair enough, but another 20 minutes later (45 in total) they served the corrected dish in addition to a cold omelette that had been previously prepared 20 minutes earlier. Cold eggs did not appeal to my wife and I can't blame her. Although my omelette was newly cooked, the toast and potatoes were also from the previous attempt, but not even reheated. A small sample from my wife's dish proved that both dishes lacked the flavor of their ingredients other than (what seemed like) Velveeta cheese. We quietly noted our disappoint with our waitress and she was sympathetic. She apologized and said it was a new cook. Her best advice was to try on a different weekday. Again, super nice staff, cool aesthetic but falls very short in the food department. Nice spot to meet a friend for coffee.. read more

I've been going to Jimmy's since I was really little and only have fond memories. The food honestly reminds you of a home cooked meal after eating nothing but fast food for a long time. This is a great place to eat breakfast and reconnect with family members. You will also greatly appreciate the wait staff's sense of humor, as displayed my their many comical plaques behind the counter. I will gladly rave about this place for the rest of my life! read more

Delightful little diner with locals and truckers. Great food and fast and friendly service. Open for breakfast and lunch only.