Jimmy John's

Some of the best sammiches in the city!! Love both locations, they're accommodating & the food is…read morefresh

Passed by this spot several times but never gone in. About to become regulars. I got the Philly…read morecheesesteak and it was the comfort food I needed. We'll be back.

Order at the counter

The chopped cheese

See all

Outside signage

Shapiro's Delicatessen

4.0(1.2k reviews)

1.8 mi•Pogue's Run

A perfect pastrami sandwich. A perfect rye. This was a fantastic dinning experience. I would…read morerecommend Shapiro's Deli to anyone .

Another fabulous visit to Shapiro's! A friend from out of town wanted a local fav so we came here -…read moreand she was blown away by the flavors and offerings! I ended up getting several pastries and some bagels (as why would you not), as well as their broccoli salad, cheese sandwich and some cherry pie. Yum! We sat for a few hours to chat and I love how it feels like you are in the middle of a community endeavor. Like everyone here is a friend and you can chat and meet up and feel at home. She wanted to take a Rueben home to her husband but it was a flight away, so the staff let her buy all the fixings and then make it at home. Amazing! It traveled well that way and got to be enjoyed by others. Will always go back to this spot as it has a special place in my heart as my Dad loved it, and it is an I su classic!

The Pastrami on Rye with swiss cheese, onion and spicy mustard

See all

Goose The Market

4.6(810 reviews)

1.7 mi

There's a reason why this place is consistently voted as Best Sandwich winner in Indy!…read more Goose the Market is a deli/market, selling cured meats and cheeses and fresh produce and much more! They also have a cellar with wine and beer. There's even gelato! But I came for the sandwich! I tried the Batalli sandwich, which was spicy and so flavorful with the perfect balance of textures! I also tried the special Tayaki, which was a good sweet counterpoint! Absolutely delicious! I'm still thinking about these sandwiches a week later! There is a gravel lot across the road and street parking. There's minimal seating indoors and some tables outside. Service was quick, and everyone was so kind and welcoming!

No, just no, an absolute no. Almost zero protein sandwiches, soaked and drenched in some kind of…read more sauce. The "other" location builds pretty decent sandwiches with plenty of protein, chips included for the same or lower price. I'm was a big fan of Goose Island, but this was my first and last visit to this miserable location. Honestly, read the reviews. These people are idiots. They have never been out of the country and maybe the state of Indiana. "Scrumptious, delicious, delectable,tasty, and something about textures are ignorant responses for incredibly cheap, beyond cheap, almost non existent portions of protein.

Cashier area

Gander sandwich - vegetarian no mayo

See all

Yelp sandwich week!

Hoagies & Hops

4.4(381 reviews)

3.5 mi

If you want an authentic cheesesteak go no further. Their meat is tender, juicy and flavorful…read more The bread had that authentic chew you get from a real Philly and stands up to the meat and cheese The customer service was spot on. The only thing I would change is to add mushrooms to the menu to put on my sandwich We will definitely be back

Giant hoagies, many options including vegetarian, hot or cold! The staff were friendly and there…read morewas plenty of seating inside. My only complaint is that the bread was tough unless you chose the toasted hoagie. Next time I'll definitely get the cheesesteak.

Dining room

Cheesesteak n fries

See all

Adjoining bar

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

4.2(195 reviews)

9.9 mi•Allisonville

Absolutely LOVE Capriotti's. It's one of very few places where we are regulars. The sandwiches are…read morea little pricier than your typical sandwich chain, but they are so worth it for the quality of ingredients and taste. The bread alone is worlds above what you'd expect. Great spot to hit for quick bite when you're running errands around Castleton. They have a variety of meat options, quite an assortment of veggie/plant-based options, sweet and hot peppers, and cold and hot options - so there's something for everyone. The Bobbie is their award-winning Thanksgiving-inspired sandwich and it is wonderful in the winter with a side of mashed potatoes and gravy. They roast a whole turkey fresh every day! For a time they had a chopped cheese, like the classic in Brooklyn. Staff here is kind, friendly, and quick. Ambiance is standard. Our favorites include the chipotle crunch, the Italian, the veggie (plant-based turkey) Rachel, and the impossible cheese steak. I'm excited to try the slaw be Joe and the veggie chick'n next...

Stopped in here for the first time at about 1145 this morning had a really nice Italian salad…read morebacked up with good friendly quick service in a nice setting. I especially enjoyed that this wasn't one of the larger types of sandwich shops I knew of and seemed more like a local business. I will certainly return.

Photo 6

See all

Photo 3

Love Handle

4.2(415 reviews)

1.5 mi•Chatham Arch

Great little brunch spot with mimosa and movies on Saturday mornings. Revisited for Mother's Day…read moreand they expanded their hours and menu! They have an evening menu on Friday & Saturday that includes some interesting selections like Poutine. They still play old classic movies like "Mrs. Doubtfire". They have expanded their selection of beverages. I can't wait to try them again in the evenings.

Love Handle is in the best neighborhood right on Mass Ave! It's super close to amazing shopping,…read moreand the vibe inside is vintage diner with an artsy twist. The food just needed a little fine-tuning to really shine. The catfish seemed to have a beer-battered coating that felt a little soft and held onto some extra moisture instead of having that classic light crunch. I would love a bit more flavor baked right into the waffle and biscuit dough--though the gravy flavor was definitely a win! Also, the grits lean heavy into jalapeno notes rather than a creamy, cheesy base. It's such a cute venue with great energy, and a few little kitchen adjustments could make it amazing!

Coffee Station

Waffle and Pork Belly

See all

Joe's Next Door

4.8(98 reviews)

13.7 mi

Great place and totally enjoyed the food and service. Definitely going back and taking some…read morefriends.

I ordered the meatloaf sandwich. It was huge but I did not care for the flavor of it. My friend…read moreordered the also huge pulled pork sandwich and thought it very good. There are lots of sides to choose from. The price is a little high for just a sandwich with no sides. You have to wait in line to order at the counter and then the food is brought out to you at the few tables in an adjacent room. There is little ambience but just good and quick food. I took the opportunity to stock my freezer with good meats from the butcher shop when I left.

1.2 mi•Mass Ave, Renaissance Place, Mile Square

Dining room

Evan's IPA Braised Beef Sandwich - best ever!!!

See all

Spacious and cute

Fat Dan's Deli

4.1(319 reviews)

This is the kind of place that you only know about if you're truly familiar with Indy and not…read moreafraid to venture off the main drag of Mass Ave. As a cool little sports bar patio, Fat Dan's seems like the kind of place you might miss if you're not looking too closely. However, you'd be remiss if you didn't make a stop in at some point. They primarily have table service but also a small bar "inside" - when the weather is nice, they open up the garage doors to make the entire establishment be outdoors. The staff that we encountered were all very friendly. Food is fantastic here, we ordered from the Devour menu back in August and got the burger and pulled pork sandwich with fries. They bring your food out on a giant sheet of butcher paper, so you're more than welcome to make a mess at the table! Everything was scrumptious, and the fries home as leftovers are as delicious as when you get them fresh. Perhaps that's why they're called the Best Fries in the World! I'm sure if a good sports game is on TV, you'll find me here soon enough!

Stopped in with my family and had a good experience. Our server was friendly. I thought about…read moregetting a beer so our server gave me a sample of the Upland Brewing's Petal to the kettle sour, it was good but I decided to go with a cocktail instead. I went with a Malibu and ginger ale, and it was served in this cute glass, I loved it! We were all so hungry, so we started out with a large order of fries, and they are a standout. They disappeared fast, came served on paper, and were crispy, hot, and delicious. We ordered the 2 10-piece wings (the biggest order available), including one batch cooked extra crispy. The wings were good, and I especially enjoyed the Fat Dan's hot BBQ sauce over the regular BBQ. I really liked the extra crispy wings. My boys also wanted burgers. One ordered the Wake N Bake Burger and the other got the Fat Dan's Burger. Both looked tasty, and neither of them complained. The ambiance strikes a nice balance between sports bar and family friendly restaurant. There is seating both inside and outside, and when the weather is nice, they open the large doors to create an open-air feel. That's where we sat, and I enjoyed it. Service was quick and efficient, which was much appreciated since my family arrived hungry. This is a solid spot for burgers, wings, and fries.

Bar area

Candy by the host area

See all

Find it near Mass Ave, outside seating available

Don Juan V's Sandwiches

4.8(195 reviews)

4.6 mi

This was my wife & my second time here. The first one was a loooong time ago, but we both recall…read moreeverything was excellent that time. We both remembered getting the salchipapas & they were great for something so simple. This time my wife got the lechon & I cannot remember the name of mine (it was a sandwich with steak, onions & fries on it It's new & our server said it was her first favorite & my wife's was her second.) Both of these were outstanding!! I don't like soggy fries, but these didn't get too soggy, but did have a lot of flavor. We are seriously get back here sooner rather than later. The service was great! Everyone was friendly & the prices weren't too bad. I struggle with becoming a grumpy old man who thinks everything costs too much, but this was very good for what we paid.

Amazing restaurant tucked away on Raymond! Quite possible the most charming ethic cuisine in Indy!…read moreFood is top notch, family owned spot, service is very warm.

Decor

Don Juan platter

See all

Storefront

Amelia's -Stutz

4.9(78 reviews)

0.4 mi

Good luck stopping in here for just one item. I tried the croissant cinnamon roll, cheese Danish,…read moreand a sub they had (I forget what was on it!), and every single thing tasted fresh. The croissant cinnamon roll was buttery, flaky, and perfectly glazed, while the Danish had a rich, creamy filling without being overly sweet. Don't sleep on the sandwiches either because the bread alone is worth the trip. The Stutz location is bright, cute, and there's great outdoor seating scattered around. The staff was friendly and helpful, and everything in the pastry case looked as good as it tasted. I have an allergy and they were able to easily answer questions. My only advice is if you want a specific pastry you should go early. The best items sell out fast, and for good reason. Easy 5 stars.

This has to be by far the largest Amelia's location. The selection though mirrors the other stores…read moreand it is delicious. I come mostly for the breads and the cinnamon rolls made from croissant dough. I do have to say I preferred the 'old' way these were made which was with a lot less icing. But I get that the change was probably done on request as folks generally prefer the extra sweet things here. Don't get me wrong, I will still continue to devour my fair share of these delicious works of art. And you cannot go wrong with the bread around here. I tend to freeze quite a bit of it since I don't live near an Amelia's. I have to say it does freeze well, especially if you toast it a little after thawing it.

There is a small area to sit in for a number of guests

Front counter

See all

Tiramisu latte with two cinnamon rolls

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Phoenix L.

11 years ago

This is the best Jimmy Johns that I have eaten at. Fresh bread, fast service, and they charge me a quarter for water which I don't mind paying, it's a large filtered water. I prefer other places charge me a quarter and give me a large. I don't drink coke, I shouldn't be punished with a small drink. read more

Jimmy John's - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Restaurants near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Coffee near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Things to Do near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Desserts near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Breakfast near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Pizza near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Lunch near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Parking near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Shopping near Jimmy John's

BEST of Indianapolis, Indiana Smoke Shop near Jimmy John's

People found Jimmy John's by searching for…

Best of Indianapolis

Things to do in Indianapolis

Browse Brands

Jimmy John's

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Jimmy John's also viewed

Potbelly

3.6

(244 reviews)

This place is slept on but so good. They have the best veggie soup in the game. Sometimes it has a…read morelittle too many white beans for my liking but I think that's a function of getting a random scoop. Also, I love spicy food but I strongly discourage getting the "hot peppers" on the sandwich when it's made. They come in an oil or something and because capsaicin (the molecule that you taste as "hot") is water soluble, it hits you so hard and makes the sandwich WAY too spicy. Instead you should get them on the side and put one on each of the bites you want, as you eat the sandwich. You'll thank me later. Also, don't go to this location between noon and 1. They are just way too busy

So on weekends it's half off milkshakes and ice cream. I come in with my client and when we ask…read moreabout ordering a banana milkshake, the worker tells us "So we're not doing milkshakes or ice cream here because it's a lot of work to take out and clean up." I then joke and say, "Just not feeling up to it today, huh?" And he goes "every day, pretty much." What the heck? Why have a huge sign that says "half off milkshakes on Saturdays and Sundays" and decor center around sandwiches and milkshakes ("order your shake now!" Signs) if you can't be bothered to even serve them? Very lazy.

Penn Station

3.5

(34 reviews)

Great philly cheesestake, home made fries, would go again if I ever travel hear again.read more

This Penn Station location is AMAZING. Everything made is always perfect and the staff enjoys…read morehaving small talk with the customers which makes me feel more of a human and less of a dollar sign. I tried the Italian sandwich instead of the sub and it was very good. I asked for the vinegar and oil on the side so I can add it as I go which made it less soggy.

Firehouse Subs

3.1

(33 reviews)

I stopped in about 30 minutes before closing with absolutely no idea of what I wanted, and Samuel…read morewas nothing but patient and provided exceptional customer service. I decided on the Medium Smokin Honey Melt Steak Sandwich, and I'm so glad I did! The shaved steak was tender and flavorful, and the chipotle honey sauce and mayo combination added another layer of flavor that took the sandwich's flavor profile to another level. The caramelized onions, bell peppers, provolone cheese, tomato, and lettuce complemented everything perfectly and made this an exceptional sandwich. Great sandwich and outstanding customer service by Samuel made this a five star experience.

The new Steak and Cheese sub is the bomb! Have probably tried all of their subs over the years and…read morethe new one is the best. Plenty of parking, restaurant was clean. Used the app to order and sandwiches were ready by the time I arrived at the Brownsburg location. Did not interact with staff as they have a carry out section and store was busy with customers. I consider Firehouse a good value for the money even though it's slightly more in cost than their competitors. The steak and cheese was prepared accurately including my customized changes. The beef, cheese, and peppers is a trifecta of fresh flavors.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.3

(12 reviews)

Had already ordered from app but it wasn't ready when i arrived. Was greeted when I walked in…read more Mike's is always hit or miss whether it will be ready. Relatively clean but busy. Lots of in and outs. But it's always a long way even if you order it friendly staff, though that makes it a lot easier.

This new location recently opened in my area, and they advertised with coupons. For this location…read moreonly, I used my coupon for half off of a giant sub. I decided on takeout of a giant sub of #55 big chicken sandwich included provolone instead of American cheese, banana peppers instead of jalapenos, and on (whole) wheat. I believe it was the first time I ate their wheat bread. They have Udi's gluten-free bread with an additional cost. The staff was patient and willing to explore with me the ingredients of the meats.

Which Wich

3.2

(17 reviews)

Came in here for my son who LOVES this place. Crinkle fries always hit AND their banana shakes?????…read moreYUMMO!!! This place is also now managed by the nice husband and wife who really know how to treat their customers. Always friendly and always helpful.

A coworker suggested we try Which Wich. I'd never been there before, but I'm always willing to give…read morea new sandwich shop a chance. Unfortunately, this experience was disappointing enough to ensure I'll never be back. I hope this review reaches potential customers before they waste their money on what, in my experience, was an overpriced and seriously underwhelming sandwich. I ordered the "Wicked," advertised as a sandwich loaded with five meats and three cheeses. I even paid an extra $1.50 for avocado. What did I actually receive? Two meats, one cheese, and, at best, half a teaspoon of avocado mash. That's not a minor disappointment; it's a complete failure to deliver what's advertised. For the price, this was an absolute rip-off. When you pay for a sandwich advertised with five meats and three cheeses, you reasonably expect more than a sad, skimpy excuse for what's pictured on the menu. The lunch rush was practically nonexistent. There were only three customers in the entire place, including my coworker and me. After seeing the quality and portion sizes firsthand, I can't say I'm surprised. Take a look at the pictures and judge for yourself: what they advertise versus what they actually serve. The difference is hard to ignore, and the photos speak louder than any review ever could. This was my first visit to Which Wich, and it will absolutely be my last. There are plenty of other places willing to serve a sandwich that actually lives up to its description. I'd suggest taking your money somewhere that gives you what you paid for.

Culver's

3.1

(85 reviews)

As always. Good food. Fast friendly service This is in a…read moregood spot with a lot of other fast food places near by. So many choices I suggest trying the Ruben sandwich so good

Either gets my order wrong or gives me half the stuff but don't worry I still pay full price…read more Workers dont care and they laugh while I'm sitting waiting to order and have had to wait 35 min in a little spot to get my food before I just left. Just go to dq right next door.

Arby's

3.3

(32 reviews)

A great burger joint for meat lovers. Very reasonable menu and deals during the day such as the $1…read morefor a burger or fries or a drink. Quite tempting indeed. We went to arbys with an empty stomach and luckily arbys did a good job in leaving us stuffed to the brim . The overloaded curly fries were damn cheesy and had bits of bacon too. I ordered the chicken with bacon burger which was super delicious with two strips of bacon on top of a chicken patty,garnished with honey mustard. The fish burger was also a good option here for those fish lovers. They generously serve a huge patty of fish with tartar sauce. The mint chocolate chip shake was the highlight of our meal here. We saved it for the end to serve as a dessert. Huge quantity just for $2. It's like having a icecream with drizzled bits of Choco and mint. This definitely is in the top 5 burger places on my list and I suggest you go try it out too.

They have 3 signs out for $10 parking the morning of Colts game and they are trying to charge…read moreeveryone here $30. Not acceptable.

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

4.2

(195 reviews)

Chick-fil-A

3.7

(86 reviews)