I've been going to this Jimmy John's for over a year now and they've never disappointed. The ambiance is great and all the employees always seem to be having a blast. They just added toasted sandwiches and they taste amazing probably one of the best sandwiches I've had. read more

We've loved coming to this place regularly for the last three years.. until today. They were out of medium cups and said we had to order a large if we wanted a drink.They forgot to ask for our phone number for our points when we paid. Then the bread was burned see pic. Looking for a new Jimmy John's :( read more

Jimmy John's - Burnt bread :( - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

When I asked for extra jimmy peppers they did not disappoint and they made sure it wasn't soggy read more

Delivery driver refused to 'leave at door' because I failed to do an online tip. Ringing the doorbell 3 times, I was met by an aggressive while male, early 30's, with a crew cut driving a white 4-door vehicle. He bullied me by refusing to leave my food or my home until I tipped him. Female living alone and to have a male show up, keep opening my screen door and pushing a tip signature sheet at me, shouting 'you didn't leave a tip!' was unnerving. He was angry, and I was fearful, gave him a 25% tip on a $20.00 order. Order from another store, or request a female driver. read more

Service was good. ordered a veggie sub (comes with double cheese, tomato, cucumbers and avocado spread). It didn't come with the avocado spread, just mayo. Pretty disappointing and costly sandwich. read more

Jimmy John's - Veggie sub, sans avocado spread. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fort Collins, Colorado

By far the best location of Jimmy Johns. Let me start by saying that we rarely eat fast food. But sandwiches are hardly a fast food, so we prefer to order those if we are in a pinch. Jimmy John's is one of our favorites, so we go there once in a while... this location is by far the best, and most professional. I have told this directly to the people who work there, including the manager. Whatever they are doing to retain good customer service personnel is working. They are always courteous, prompt, and attentive. Please remember to bring a cash tip, too!!! I learned the hard way when I had no cash with me and my online order gave me no option to tip! You CAN request to tip with your Credit Card if you pay onsite, but you HAVE to ask to do it! Do it - those guys work hard, and deserve it. Management/Owner: Please keep up the awesome job! And thank you. read more

The manager today really tried to fight with me about the fact that I had paid for my order on the app when I had my receipt. Rather than accepting her failure as a team leader she continued to argue with me about what location I ordered at when she literally was reading my receipt. The teenage boys who are usually working are so much better at running the store than this woman. This was my first bad experience at this location and coincidentally it was also my first time dealing with a female manager. read more

This store is amazing. They provide world-class customer service and the subs are always the best. Thank you for being there on my worst days. Jimmy Johns till the end read more

The cashier was nice and the line moved quickly. The employee who called out my sandwich was unprofessional. I asked where one of my side items was (and questioned if I had bought one or two since I'm exhausted these days). He added it to my order and snapped at me to "just take them" which embarrassed me in front of several people who were also waiting for their orders. I was fumbling to find my receipt and would have paid for the second one if I had only paid for one. I checked my receipt and sure enough, there were two. He had just had my ticket... why not double check it for accuracy? My sandwich was fine, but I don't think I'll back to this location soon. read more

You want a sandwich. You're so hungry, you wanted it five minutes ago. You also want chips, a drink, and don't want to fork over a $10 bill for the whole thing. Oh, and you're too lazy to get up and take your lazy butt to the store to get it. Call Jimmy Johns cause they'll have it to your house in 10 minutes - no joke. Even in a snowstorm, hail storm or Russian attack, I assume. 1 star off for only having mayo as a schmear of anything - sorry not a fan of the white stuff, unless it's in the middle of an Oreo cookie. But great service both in store and delivery. And their brand of salt & vinegar chips is awesome. Eat it. read more

Lightning fast delivery didn't deliver or follow instructions from door dash. Waste of my money. It'll be a waste of your money. Sandwich's aren't that hard to make anyway. Be smart and stay away. Caveat emptor read more

I travel to Fort Collins a couple times a year and always end up at Jimmy John's while Im there. I had to write a review for this particular Jimmy John's because they are very consistent with their service. The staff is always polite, tentative and amazingly quick. The food has always tasted very fresh and for the price, that's a sweet deal. If your looking for a quick, tasty, healthier alternative... I highly recommend this Jimmy John's. read more

Ooooooo I love this place. Never had any issues, freaky fast just as they advertise. I've ordered in the shop and my sandwich is always made before I am even done paying, and I've also ordered delivery which takes 10 minutes tops. One of my favorite sandwich places, they get it right every time! read more

I'm on the keto diet and found the "unwich" to be quite satisfying. Very good for my diet.

made a delivery order 10 minutes before they closed. got a phone call from them saying they wouldn't deliver my order because they had already packed up their meats and basically closed up shop. now I know its not exactly a nice move to order 10 minutes before closing time but as a past delivery driver, I know that you still need to deliver the order. you are open until 10. not until 9:50. was planning on giving the delivery driver a large tip but now I think I need to have a talk with the manager instead. read more

The sandwiches are good, but I really don't know what the hype is all about. Good sandwiches, good service and people are nice that work there. They are just an average sub. I will go back if I am in the area. read more

Freaky slow delivery. Thanks to these guys I don't eat lunch today. They took more than 45 minutes to get here and I missed my lunch break. I'll never order from here again, and neither should you. Terrible customer service, terrible speed. Get a pizza instead. read more

I love Jimmy Johns. So simple, yet SO delicious! Oh and their day old bread is EVERYTHING! It's so cheap! And although they talk it up as day "old" so people think it's no good or stale, it is soooo yummy! Cmon, we all eat out loaves of break for like weeks after we buy it, rightttt?! And we pay triple the price. read more

These guys are awesome. I placed a large catering order and it was ready on time when I went to pick it up. I even got nervous I didn't order enough and called the morning of to order more lunch boxes. They were so accommodating and even helped me bring my order out to the car. Great service. I will definitely use them again. read more

Always fast and love the food. The delivery people and people in store are friendly and smile all the time. They forgot a cookie for my wife, and ran it back to us in 5 minutes! Great service, prices and food... read more

We ordered over internet to be sent to my son in law working...they delivered so fast and great food!

I had the Vito today and I like to add alfalfa sprouts. Today something tastes odd. It's kind of a bitter taste but hard to describe. I mention the sprouts because it's the only thing I add but also because I know there have been problems with sprouts before. I just wanted to let you know. I love your sandwiches and this won't have any impact on that. Holly at Tolmar 08/03/16 read more

1.5 stars at best. I went in and ordered and during the ordering process, I was asked if I would like cheese. There was no mention of an upcharge although they charged me 50 cents! It would not be that big of a deal except the sandwich ended up costing $5.60 for about what you would get on a 6 inch at subway or for a torpedo at quizznos (both of which cost about half of the Jimmy Johns equivalent). Basically, I was suckered into paying $5.60 for processed lunch meat, about a half a square of cheese & some lettuce on dried out bread; all stuff you can buy from a grocery store for about 50 cents. I was not impressed. There is no value here. read more

OMG! We just discovered Jimmy John's and my whole family is addicted. We've ordered it three times in the past five days! Each time the food has been consistently flavorful and delicious. The 1/4LB roast beef sandwich is my favorite. It tastes like perfectly cooked and seasoned steak. I am going to go ahead and say this is my favorite sub sandwich place, it blows everything else out of the water. Delivery is fast! 10 minutes and it's here. I know we will be ordering again really soon. Also, make sure you try their pickles. I don't know what they do but their pickles are the best we've ever had. read more

Amazing service tonight for an event co-hosted by the City and CSU at the Fort Collins Senior Center. Not only did the Jimmy John's crew bring us an additional platter of sandwiches in case we ran out, they offered to make additional sandwiches for special dietary needs AND ran to the store to buy us paper plates for the event. Wow. Customer service like this is rare these days. Thank you for your hard work! read more

This is a great Jimmy Johns. My sandwich is always ready by the time I finish paying. The sandwiches are always fresh and taste great. During my last visit I had to wait 5 minutes for the fresh bread to cool so the manager gave me a coupon for a free sub. read more

I love the subs but I cannot understand the inconsistency. I would say more than 50% of the time I do not get what I ordered. I had sent a note to HQ, and nothing changed. This is a review of the Jimmy Johns on Shields. Too bad I cannot order from another Jimmy Johns for delivery, their system defaults to the closest one. read more

I regularly eat from Jimmy Johns and almost every time they deliver I am disappointed by the sami but still always tip well, I ask that the delivery person call when they arrive and not to knock because we have two dogs in the house and they get sent into barking fits easily and almost every time the delivery driver still knocks on my door, also slow delivery, most of the time the bikers get here faster then the cars. Yesterday I called and they forgot my drink then took over thirty minutes to get it to me. Today I have an $11.50 order and was paying with a $20 when the driver arrives he doesn't have change, realizing because of the drink thing that happened to me yesterday I knew that I could order from somewhere else and have it faster then I would get my sami back so I tell the driver he can take it and go. When I call to complain I say "I get Jimmy johns almost everyday" because I want the guy to know I'm a loyal Jimmy johns customer. The guy on the phone starts reading me off many times I have ordered from my cell which is a few times a month...not every other day (I walk in mostly because I work across the street) as if because I only order delivery a few times a month it is okay for them to do the job incorrectly. He then says that I should have told them I needed change and that Jimmy johns drivers only carry $20 in change at a time so it was my fault. I had an $11.50 ticket and needed $8.50 in change aka less than $20 while I wish I could have resolved this over the phone I came to the conclusion that nothing would be solved by talking to someone so rude soooo I had to come here make an account and write this long a** review just to stay...I understand that people make mistakes but these guys at this jimmy johns make a lot, then blame the customer for it and deny accountability. I would recommend Jimmy johns just not this one read more

I've always been a fan of JJ's freakishly fast delivery until last night. I called the store on Shields and was told they don't deliver to my side of town anymore.They've delivered here for years and then they hung up on me. Freakishly Rude! Luckily I called Silvermine Subs got a polite answer,fast delivery and a great sandwiches! read more