Order pickup all the time. Always ready when they say. The employees are always nice. The sandwiches are always good. Also, I use my points all the time. It's one of the few points programs where the points actually matter!!!!! read more

- Large parking lot with plenty of spaces available; was quite busy on a Sunday during lunch, with a steady flow of customers; dining area was clean, bright, and welcoming, with a few tables and counter seating available - Ordered ahead for pickup, and our food was ready when we arrived, making the pickup process quick and convenient - Unfortunately, the manager and staff were extremely loud throughout our visit; it's great to see employees enjoying their work, but the constant shouting--combined with the echo in the open dining area--made for an uncomfortable dining experience; we also noticed other diners reacting to the noise, so it didn't seem like we were the only ones affected - Food quality was consistent with other JM locations; however, the kids' ham sandwich had noticeably less meat than the turkey sandwich, making it feel like a less generous portion read more

See all

THE FOOD ---------------- + Good cold subs like any location. + Menu is a replica of any location. THE SERVICE ------------------- = Was handed my pickup order by the manager (or a gentleman who seemingly was), but he wasn't really courteous and pretty much just handed me it without any further exchange or "you're welcome". THE SURROUNDINGS ------------------------------- + Clean, spacious interior with quite a few tables and seats. RANDOM OBSERVATIONS -------------------------------------- - This is where I knock off 2 stars. The manager and his staff were obnoxiously and unnecessarily loud. The manager kept making these odd, loud sounds with a yell. We thought it was just us being the old "get off my lawn" foggies while trying to enjoy our Italian sub, but we noticed other customers also staring at the staff like there was SERIOUSLY something off with them. And, sadly, it all started with the manager setting a bad example for his staff, in which they followed. = Was surprisingly realllllly busy during Sunday lunch time. I've seen Jersey Mike's locations that are busy, but this one was extradordinarily busy with pickups and dine-in customers alike. read more

See all

8/13/26 -- To the short fat meatball behind the counter at the register, muttering under his breath, talking about customers, giving dirty looks, what is a middle aged man doing behind a cash register anyways? If you're a manager you need to do better big man, this is the worst experience I've ever had and I didn't even say a word to him... just wanted to pay for my food and leave... read more

This is one of the worst Jersey Mike's in the state. Stale bread last 3 times and they can't even cut it correctly. Spent 35 minutes in there today waiting for 2 sandwiches and they're snippy. It's also dirty inside. I'm done. Will go to Ramsey JM even tho it's further. Do better. read more

I just tried their reg. super sub f0r a 8 inch sub what a waste for $11.68 you can get 12 inch sub for the tastes much same price you can go to a pizza place get a sub like Primos Pizza in Wayne read more

Sandwich's are always amazing. Staff was very polite and the meats, the cheeses, and the veggies are always fresh. There definitely are other Jersey mikes that are better than this one because this one in particular there bread is a little bit on the hard side 75% of the time. Overall good place for a quick lunch. read more

I ordered a chicken salad sandwich with extra meat and a chicken Philly with extra meat bowl. Neither came with extra meat and how they bagged the order, they put in a smaller bag and had the bowl vertical so half the cheese and chicken was on the roof/top of the bowl. When I was trying to fix the bowl and asked for a fork, employee said it's in the bag. Zero concern, empathy or customer service. I've been a loyal rewards customer for years and tip generously. Never even an acknowledgement or sorry ... just excuses. read more

About 11:30 on Monday morning, my friend and I walked in and ordered a giant Italian sub intending to split it later at our destination since it would be slightly cheaper than ordering 2 regulars. We asked for onions on one half of the sub only, and we were adamantly told by the worker that it wasn't allowed and we'd have to order 2 separate subs due to "company policy." This info was delivered in an extremely abrupt, aggressive, and rude manner. The dude even had his coworker, who actually put the sandwich together, verify it in much the same manner. My friend and I decided it wasn't worth a scene, and it certainly wasn't worth ordering 2 sandwiches over onions, but the customer service and attitude from the staff was appalling; condescending, and downright obnoxious. They even had the nerve (I was thinking of another word here) to ask if we were a club points member (or whatever they call it) when I paid. Sub was good, but they lost two customers. I get it that they want to discourage people from trying to save a couple of bucks by splitting a sandwich, but aside from whether that's a smart policy in the long run, there are ways of conveying a message to a paying customer that doesn't require petulance and unprofessional borderline hostility. Plenty of other family-run places to go that actually give a damn and are way better. read more

Slow. Careless, bread stale half the time. Hired a bunch of teenagers and no training. Won't order from JM again.

My second time visiting the newly built Jersey Mike's in Wyckoff on Godwin avenue. Let's first get by the price. We all know Jersey Mike's is a buck or two steeper than everywhere else. Then again, so yiu really want a cold cut combo from subway or a freshly sliced sub? Don't get me wrong, in a pinch, Subway is ok, but I'm taking the drive when hungry. Today, my buddy got the cheesesteak. The picture really doesn't do it justice in this particular shot. I had a strong hankering for tuna. Cheesesteaks in the past never disappointed me from Jersey Mike's, so let's concentrate on the tuna; which is my first time getting from Mike's. Now, I was really craving tuna today. I got a shmear of mayo on the new parmesan rosemary bread, little extra shot of the "juice". My day is now fulfilled. Fresh, hit the mark with the extra dressing. I love dried spices and had just the right amount of oregano and pepper. Not too much salt, which is good since the tuna is salty enough. Employees are great. Very friendly and attentive. Little weird that you have to go to the right for your hot sandwiches and then to the left end for cold, but if that's the worst of my worries, then I'm doing ok in life. Regular size sub will set you back about $9... Well worth it in my opinion. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Regular cheesesteak. I usually get the Big Kahuna, but my buddy didn't want to go spicy... - Fast Food Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

i love jersey mikes and go all the time. i had my birthday thing to use and i went in to this location to ask how to use it and what i get for free on my birthday. the guy looked at me and goes "we don't do anything for birthdays here" and i was like "online says you get a free sub and a drink" (i have an account and everything) and he told me "yea our owner at this location isn't nice enough to do that". this really annoyed and upset me because i had never been here for my birthday freebee and was excited to use it. i still got the sandwich but it was an unpleasant experience and he was very rude. + he didn't even wish me a happy birthday lol. just very frustrating since i shop here all the time, will not come back to this location and will continue to go to the one in mahwah cause they've always been nice. read more

This location is NASTY the trash cans are over flowing with trash the napkin holders are extremely dirty with food stuck to them there is Dust sitting on the overhead lamps old food under every table in the place and be ready to clean your own table . The Owner or the manager only seem to worry about making money and i would hate to see what is behind the counters. NEXT TIME YOU GO THERE LOOK AROUND AND SEE WHAT YOU CAN FIND THERE ARE MORE ISSUES. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH SHOULD GIVE A VISIT. i will attach photos next time i go im sure it will be the same. read more

I think my answer is more of a me thing then a Jersey Mikes issue. I got the Italian sandwich, and while it was OK there was nothing special about it. Very limited toppings and bread choices, and honestly it might've been cheaper to get it at a regular deli. It tasted good, it was just very basic. read more

Walking in I was expecting a normal experience. Ordered the food and this is where it goes downhill. Watching the person cooking my food, I started to believe no one cares anymore about food safety. The gentleman that was cooking the cheesesteaks had a well grown beard with no beard guard, as well as 2 others performing various tasks, having beards with no guards. So I get my drink, and it was so sweet I think the soda company needs to come in to adjust the syrup. Having the need to use the bathroom they are now only for the employees, they are blocked off with delivery and pick up tables. I am never to return here. read more

My boss bought me lunch and Jersey Mike's delivered a delicious sandwich to me. He ordered it on grub hub and had it left on my front steps. I'm so sorry I didn't get to leave the driver a tip so I have to write a review! I promise not to exaggerate how much I enjoyed my sandwich. I've been here a couple times for subs. All the ingredients are fresh and the sandwiches are made with care. I appreciate freshly sliced meats that are put together nicely with the toppings so every bite is consistent and your sandwich isn't falling apart. They have a variety of cold and hot subs. You can't go wrong with an Italian, Turkey or roast beef sandwich with whatever cheese and toppings you want. I also like their meatball parm and Cheesesteak sandwiches. They got something for everybody with a bag of chips. All their workers have always been very courteous and professional. If your ordering for delivery please make sure you give the driver a tip! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Turkey with provolone and chips. - Fast Food Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

I have frequented many Jersey Mikes and always had a good experience. From the outside of this building I was expecting a lot more. Unfortunately the cleanliness was not up to Jersey Mike standards. Honestly I would've walked out, but my family was very hungry. We visited on May 5, 2023 and the restaurant was empty. We were there around 5pm and half of the dining area was blocked off with chairs on the tables and tape blocking the area. There was no outdoor seating. I had to squeeze through the blocked off area to use the bathroom and wished I didn't, it was not clean. We had to ask an employee to clean off the high top table so we could eat. The tables, floors, bathroom and prep area were very dirty also. I think with a little more attention from management this could be a good establishment, but I don't think I will be visiting again. read more

Staff was happy to see me, fast, friendly and attentive. They made my sandwich exactly as I had requested and checked me out quickly. Plenty of parking available and plenty of clean tables inside. Food: 5/5 read more

It's like they are allergic to getting an order right. Today, 2 simple turkey with provolone sandwiches + lettuce and tomato. Couldn't get either of them right. 3 times in a row, haven't gotten a sandwich right yet. Love jersey mikes hate this location. read more

Every single time I have come in for food whether it's pickup dining in or to go, the staff is always so friendly and will accommodate you in any way. The inside of the store is always immaculate and very clean, providing a great experience when ordering your food. I would highly recommend Jersey Mikes as a company and especially this location in Wyckoff. You will feel at home and receive great service and food! read more

Do yourself a favor and order at least 35 minutes before you arrive if you go there for lunch. They tend to take forever to fulfill take out orders. Seems like they only have one person handling those. I had to wait an extra 15 minutes while I saw everyone that just hummed online leave withing 3 minutes. Otherwise sandwiched are pretty standard. Staff is really friendly but they need more help during lunch hour for sure. read more

Update: Owner called his employees and called me back saying "they said you came in at 10 minutes to close and you were using your phone". Uhh so you're saying I came in while the store was still open.. OK. read more

It's new and it feels like it. The place is bright and crisp. The employees were eager to help and happy. The sandwich that I got was really delicious. They post the calories on the menu so you can make an educated decision about your meal. There were plenty of seats for smaller groups of 2 or 4 and even some tables together that could have supported a group of 15 people, but I got my sandwich to go. It's a little more expensive than other shops which shall not be named, but their cold cut sandwiches are piled high with toppings to make up for it. read more

See all

First time here today and was completely disappointed. Stay consistent guys, it will do wonders for your future. read more

See all

Very inconsistent for a Jersey Mike's. Sometimes the bread is stale sometimes it's good. Sometimes they barely put meat on the sandwich, sometimes its ok. Also found hair in my sandwich twice. I rarely write negative reviews but I've been frustrated to many times. I won't be going back. read more

Been to Jersey Mikes Wyckoff location a few times, the service I think is ironing out the kinks. Its very confusing to order and check out, not sure why, it seems like alot of people behind the counter and not enough coordination to move from ordering to register. People have to either move ahead of line or behind line due to this. Suggest manager review this process and train as necessary. read more

The skimpiest Jersey Mike's sandwich I ever had! I normally order from the Fairlawn location on Rt208S, but ordered through Uber Eats for local delivery this time around. Was looking forward to my Italian sub but it was so dissatisfying. The meats, cheese and toppings are more generously served at the Fairlawn location compared to what we got tonight. Both sandwiches ordered were "light" so it wasn't just a "fluke" occurrence for my sandwich. read more

Jersey Mike's in Wycoff Nj ,thank you for a phenomenal stimulating explosive palette grabbing sub , a special thanks to Sarah who remembered my crazy loud ass , and thanks to the crew at Jersey Mike's . Angelo B. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Jerseys mike subs! - Fast Food Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Good quality food for the $, good service, have done both dine in prior to COVID-19 and take out during. We just moved out of state and miss their subs as they are not in our area as yet. read more

The personnel is attentive and spot on. They make a good sandwich. During nice outdoor weather they have clean outdoor tables for dining. I have been to dozens of other Jersey Mike's (Emerson being the absolute worst) and the Wyckoff location does a good job. read more

I placed an order for delivery through the Jersey Mike's app. The timeframe for delivery was somewhere in the range of 27-36 minutes. After approx. an hour and 15 minutes had passed, I called the WYCKOFF store to check on the status of my order. The person who answered my call was curt, unfriendly, unapologetic and expressed that he had no idea when I would get my order if at all. He was very short and seemed to care less about the delay. Given the demeanor of his response, I asked if there was a manager I could speak with. He expressed that he was the manager. It takes Just a little bit of care when handling inquiries, expressing a sense of care and urgency and managing expectations when things are not going as planned. I was surprised that he was the manager and had no sense of basic customer service skills. When the order was yet to be delivered an hour and 45 mins from the time I placed it, I went to the store and picked up the order myself. read more

Girl making sandwiches stopped, answered phone, wrote an order, answered her Apple Watch rang the order through the register and continued making sandwiches with the same gloves. Then the sandwiches come (2) and one is wrong. Perhaps focusing on the customer should be priority over your Apple Watch. Sanitation and concentration is not a priority here. read more

When it comes to Subs, this is the last place I would ever go. First of all it's all bread and lettuce. All the cold cuts are pre sliced. The tomatoes are terrible. The rest of the "Sub" is loaded with a bunch of salad stuff. The variety is limited and price wise they are no bargain. If you want one of the best Subs in Bergen County, try Ikes Big Mouth in Waldwick. Not only do they make incredible subs, their wraps are also very good. And when it comes to Wings, they are the best. read more

Order ahead and pick up has been excellent! Staff is always friendly and have not had any problems with orders. Def recommend!

Was very excited for this shop to open up as i would drive past it everyday on and from my ways to work. 1st time walking in and i felt my eyes widen. The atmosphere was fantastic. Got a "chipotle" cheesesteak.... to absolutely die for. And as for the cold subs, had to get 2 of those as well. And again to die for!! I live literally around the block from another location but i will without a doubt take the drive to this one for those SUBS!! read more

My friends and I visited Jersey Mikes new store and were greeted by very pleasant and helpful employees. The sandwiches were delicious, and well worth the price! read more