1. Jersey Mike's Subs

0

Sumter, SC

Cancel

Open app

Search

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.2 (43 reviews)
InexpensiveFast Food, Delis, Sandwiches
Closed • 10:00 am - 9:00 pm
Updated a few days ago

Order Jersey Mike's Subs Takeout or Delivery

Jersey Mike's Subs Photos

Business Info

JERSEY MIKE'S SUBS ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Quiet
Outdoor seating
Good for kids

More like Jersey Mike's Subs

Recommended Reviews - Jersey Mike's Subs

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Human Hair...

First and last time eating Jersey Mikes in Sumter, gotta love when there is hair on your food. Do better!

Jersey Mike's Subs
Chaz C.

Please bring Jersey Mike's Subs in Florence!!!! Hopefully will come by this fall or next year. Cold SUBS and Hot SUBS are really good!!!!!!

Awesome subs regardless of choice. Would give 5 stars only if they learned to not let the slicer build up so badly (SEE PHOTO)

Who orders half the meat??

See all

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Jersey Mike's Subs

Review Highlights - Jersey Mike's Subs

“The GF bread is soft and doesn't crumble, and the meats and cheeses are sliced fresh.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

Palmetto Subs - A 6" inch #5

Palmetto Subs

2.9(19 reviews)
0.6 mi
•$

Palmetto Subs has been open for a few months now but I've never seen any business there. We were…read moreout this morning and decided that we were in the mood for subs so we stopped to check it out. Wowsa! The only reason I can imagine this place doesn't get more business than they do is because people just don't know... Owned by the same lady who owns Busters, the baked deserts and some other items are made daily and brought across the street. The prices may seem a little intimidating at first but you should expect to pay a little more at a deli in the first place, and once you see what you get for the money then you'll realize the deal you're getting. The food is frickin' awesome. The honey wheat bread on my Palmetto Special was soft and warm amazingly good. My wife got 8 grain bread on her Carolina BLT and usually doesn't like "wholesome" breads but was really impressed with it. Not to mention the pile of meat on her sandwich was about as thick as my fist. My daughter got a ham sandwich and even she seemed pretty interested. None of us ate more than 1/2 before we were full, so not only did we get great food, we also got leftovers! The meat is sliced to order on the spot and the veggies were fresh and crisp. You have to ask for pickles on the side and it's worth it because they're quite delicious, too. When we were leaving another couple came in for lunch. The husband had a sub but the wife got a salad and as they sat down, both of them could do nothing but sit and stare at how much food she was given. That thing was HUGE! This place is probably going to be one of my favorites and I can't wait to go back and try so many other sandwiches (and one of those salads). I just hope they get enough customers to stay in business because this is a hidden jewel.

16 dollars for a chef salad over rated doing so much talking she forgot to give my extra egg i paid…read morefor salad ok nothing special

Photos
Palmetto Subs - Dirty ceiling grill.

Dirty ceiling grill.

Palmetto Subs

See all

J O' Gradys - Sammy Burger w/Texas Toast

J O' Gradys

4.1(184 reviews)
3.4 mi
•$$

Always great for a sandwich or burger or tacos or onion rings or fries or beer and beer and beer!…read moreCan not recommend more when I'm downtown area. I always like the Chicken Fire Ant on Texas Toast, not sure why I capitalized every other word eit

Charming Pub located in the heart of Sumter on Main Street just a short walk away from the Hyatt…read morePlace where we were staying while in town. My party of 3 arrived around 5pm and decided to sit at the bar. The ambiance was casual and comfortable, very clean. Our bartender was amicable and attentive. We started off with drinks my husband and I decided on margaritas, they only offer classic no flavors but there were a few tequilas to choose from. Our cousin drinks red wine and they only offered a Cabernet so she went with that. The drinks were ok. I would not come here solely to drink since I'm into handcrafted drinks. Like most pubs they focus on beer, their selection in beers was fantastic. My husband ordered a burger and fries. The burger was huge and he said it was delicious and the fries were ok. Our cousin and I both ordered the Buffalo Shrimp Tacos. For my side I had the beer battered onion rings which came with a jalapeño ranch sauce, they were crispy and really tasty. My cousin had the coleslaw which she mentioned was average. The tacos were exactly as described but wasn't as flavorful as I was expecting, they were not bad but I wouldn't order them again. We had a great experience, customer service was stellar and if ever in town again I would come back.

Photos
J O' Gradys
J O' Gradys - Christian's Mainstreet Melt

Christian's Mainstreet Melt

J O' Gradys

See all

Bi Lo

Bi Lo

3.8(11 reviews)
2.6 mi
•$$

The prices at Bi-Lo are probably 15% higher than they are anywhere else in Sumter. Couple that…read morewith the fact that they're nearly all the way out in South Sumter and it's no wonder that the place is usually empty. We usually stick with Food Lion or Walmart for shelved and cooled/frozen goods but if we're in the mood for some produce then we'll make the drive out and pay the extra costs for the freshest in town. As a side note, there is a new Super Bi-Lo in Sandhills and it's amazing. There's also a Publix in West Cola and we've made that drive (55-60 minutes) a few times just for produce and their bakery (while SB-L has a better section for cheese and wine).

My first visit here I went to the deli to get sandwich stuff... The woman behind the counter WAS…read moreNOT very helpful. She hands me the first thing I ask for and doesn't bother to ask what else I want before talking to the next person. I'm still standing there watching this... The other woman wanted chicken and the person behind the counter was all "Oh, well that's going to be like 20 minutes because I have to go get it, come back and prep it and make it"... Then she sees me and says "you want something else" I said yes and she's all "Oh man, well that means that chicken is going to be longer now that I have to help her"... Really? WTH? So it's my fault that you didn't even finish with me first? I said the hell with it and walked away, told her to help the other person. THIS IS YOUR JOB, if you don't like it... Go find another one. Disgusting. The rest of the place is clean and has a decent selection... Check out usually seems to take to long. I'm not impressed with any of it...

Jersey Mike's Subs - hotdogs - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...