Simply the best. I tried this in New Jersey 25 years ago and never stopped going to this day. The prices are insane but the sandwiches are amazing read more

Best subs on the planet!!! No. 7 Giant Provolone and Turkey everything Mike's Way w/Jalapeño chips, #55 Hot Big Kahuna Chicken Cheese Steak, L fruit punch!! Family friendly - Energetic crew and great listeners! Never disappointed!!! read more

First and last time eating Jersey Mikes in Sumter, gotta love when there is hair on your food. Do better! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Human Hair... - Fast Food Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

The sandwich wasn't the best I ordered a chicken, but it's steak.The service was ok my sandwich is on the dry and over seasoned. It's always clean in this location. My tolerance for salt isn't great, but please try them out. Maybe I'll say know seasoning if I order this sandwich again. My favorite is number 13. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #42 Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak This is my first time here, but I wasn't pleased with this sandwich. I've had better - Fast Food Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

This Jersey Mikes is always dirty the three times I have gone in, there wasn't even a clean table to sit at and this wasn't a busy time at all as I was the only customer in there when I walked in. I got the buffalo chicken sub it took over 20 min to get it out, it was a hot sandwich so what ever, but the problem was when I took a bit into it less than 5 min later it was cold, not warm but cold. To top it off they didn't even mix the chicken with the hot sauce it was only what I assumed was squirted onto half the bread because the other half didn't have any on it. For an almost $20 sandwich they can do better. The only reason why I figured they did this is because I didn't leave a tip at checkout, let me say this again, I didn't leave a tip before I had received any service besides my order taken. What type of tip do they think they are entitled to at that point? If you want to eat at a place that is has dirty tables, is overpriced, provided bad customer service, a janky bad put together sub a at 630 pm on a Tuesday then this is your place. If not I would avoid this place and avoid the middle of the night run to the bathroom because you ate there and your stomach was upset. read more

One of the better subs I have had. Will be going back for more. One of the better subs I have had. Will be going back for more. The only thing missing is no black olives or even green olives. I like the cold subs better than the hot ones. Generous on the meat. Good choice of breads. read more

Jersey Mikes the sandwiches are always great .And the servers are always so nice .We order take out we eat at home .

I love Jersey Mikes but they completely messed up my order and unfortunately I live 30 minutes away or I would have taken it back.

Always a great subs . Employees very friendly. Our go to when we're in town visiting our family.

Please bring Jersey Mike's Subs in Florence!!!! Hopefully will come by this fall or next year. Cold SUBS and Hot SUBS are really good!!!!!! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

Awesome subs regardless of choice. Would give 5 stars only if they learned to not let the slicer build up so badly (SEE PHOTO) read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

Love me some Jersey Mikes!! The veggies are always so fresh and love that they pay attention to the special requests in the app when ordering read more

Still one star for service !! Was there and was waiting on there spot for social dist and the girl yelled saying for my safety and your stand on the marker . Well look down with a reply I am on it . I should of left as the employee's had there maskes down below there rude mouths . I wish the owner would find better workers . read more

This location sucks. Point blank period! They take forever to make subs, they have a list of 15 things to do to order from your car before you can order, and you have to wait for an absurd amount of time before they make your subs. I showed up 15 minutes after I ordered and they told me my order wasn't for another 30 minutes and it hadn't even been started. As if I'm going to sit in the parking lot for 30 minutes when I'm hungry at 7pm. How ridiculous, get out of town. read more

Jersey Mikes never disappoints - fast, friendly service and the best sandwich you can find.

Since when is Jersey Mike's Subs so darn pricey while selling day old bread!! #Crap . #2Stars/5 #DayOldBread #MikesWayNoOnions #ForgotTheMayo #ForgotTheMikesWay #ForgotToHoldTheCheese Now I know why they only have 3 stars rating!! It's certainly not Point Pleasant I was prompted to leave a tip, which I did, but I regret filling my drink and not watching them do what they do 100 times a day. I didn't think I needed to. $16.xx AFTER COUPON for drink and Giant Sub (made wrong) read more

I just came back from Jersey Mikes' on Alice Drive in Sumter,S.C. I ordered my 3 large subs (which was Giants) for $53.47 . when I went to pick up the Order, the girl had put my order in wrong. there was around 20 people in line which she took care of all of those people and the 10 people behind me that called in before doing my order. She kept applogizing to the other customers, when she should have appolized to me. I was so upset the way I was treated . If this is how your customers get treated and especially senior citizens, I won't be ordering any more from Jersey Mike's ps: she did not even give me the bread I asked for and cut in all the way through instead of half way read more

Needed a catering order at the last minute for a family in grief and the early morning crew stepped up to the plate and had ready even before I needed it. I am so sorry I didn't retain your name but whoever you are (you were in the middle of baking bread) thank you for making this happen. read more

Well, I'll be honest... Which Wich has basically stolen the best sandwich title away from any other place I've been/tried since. However, from Sumter the nearest one is quite a drive, making it rather difficult to grab a sandwich that's actually tasty. Till I found this place, which I would say comes in a very close second to Which Wich. The ingredients were fresh, the turkey was delicious, it was real cheese. Just a great made sandwich. Bread may have been made in house but wasn't out the oven fresh. Has some tough spots, but was still good overall. I can't complain about the cost, because compared to competition **cough-subway-cough** the meat is fresh cut and PILED on. PLUS, you get what you pay for, and I'd rather pay for taste/quality PLUS quantity, which is what you get here at Jersey Mike's. Thumbs up to a place I'd recommend! Good/fresh food, not a horrible cost, and convenient to Sumter (home/work). read more

You cannot beat fresh bread and fresh deli meat.. This place is great. A little pricey but way worth it, rather than worrying if you will get sick from deli meat sitting out all day (( SUBWAY )) Reccomended read more

Only leaving a 5 star review because Deborah was SO kind and nice! She's a breath of fresh air!!

Flat out, I love Jersey Mike's. While the sandwiches are a bit pricey, I feel that you do get your money's worth. No other sub-shop piles it on like Jersey Mike's. I usually get their giant sub. There's so much on it, I can get two lunches out of it. read more

Nothing exciting; nothing offensive. Put my sammich in a tortilla and I'll love it no matter what. I ordered the buffalo chicken wrap which should have contained chicken, buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, and a couple few vegetables...which it did. My wrap tasted amazing!. Only drawback is Sumter charges 10% sales tax which is an absolute buzzkill. Service was great! Wrap tasted great! Cost was a fail. Cost fail no specific to this business but specific to Sumter, SC. Buyer beware... read more

This has been and continues to be possibly the worst business in Sumter county for customer service. They hire inept teenagers and so-called managers who know nothing and care nothing for you as a customer. After repeated chances to get it right, the have failed me on many many occasions. The order is always wrong, especially a call-in order. And when you call to get it corrected, they act like you are the offending party, even as nice and cordial as I try to be. (I am in customer service, so I always try the sugar over salt approach). Being told that the only way to correct a vastly mis-made order is by bringing the food in to be re-made is impossible in my line of business. I have an extremely tight schedule, and just suck it up and eat the bad sandwich. But when I call in to possibly be repaid/made whole for the repeated mistakes, I get treated like I am searching for a handout. Absolutely horrible way to treat someone who keeps coming back for the wrong order. Note the lack of bacon, and half the meat that is usually on their subs. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Who orders half the meat?? - Fast Food Near Me - Sumter, South Carolina

See all

Love the GF bread and how good it is. Always love their sandwiches. They are fresh. The employees are clean and friendly. They change their gloves like 100 times. So love how they understand that. read more

This is the only place I can get a gluten free sub. The GF bread is soft and doesn't crumble, and the meats and cheeses are sliced fresh. They have to clean the slicing machine, change gloves, get a clean knife, and build the sub on a clean work surface to limit cross contamination, but the employees have never made me feel like an inconvenience. Thank you for giving those of us who are gluten free out of necessity a safer sandwich option. read more

Great subs. Good cold cuts. They make a large sub that will fill you. Very friendly staff.

Used to order from them at work. Owners kids forgot my order 2 times. Then the roach problem they had. Stopped eating there after that. It was bad. read more

I got so excited that they have a chicken parm sandwich but it falls apart almost immediately it tastes really good but it's not well made. I wish they portioned the ratio of the inside of the sandwich to the bread a little bit better I think that might make a significant difference in to how I feel about the restaurant. But I've been here twice ordered the same thing both times and both times it disappointed me because the sandwich just fell apart the bread was soggy. It just didn't hold together read more

Subs are mediocre, for the money they should be much better. Also, why do they automatically ask you for a "tip" when paying w/ debit card? Does Jersey Mike's not pay their employees enough? Very annoying when asked if I would like to give a tip. You didn't even put my subs in a bag, why would you deserve a tip? Are you carrying my subs to my car? Sorry, no tips for a sub shop that charges $20 for a large sub and drink! read more

Employees never change gloves after handling money and proceeded to touch toppings without changing gloves. Employees stated they cannot give out info about manager when asked. Will contact local DHEC who oversees restaurant about nasty employees and how they handle food for public consumption. read more

I LOVE jersey mikes....but this is the worst one I have ever been to. Flies ALL OVER the toppings and the slowest service.

I love Jersey Mike's. I've eaten at different locations in different cities for 15 years. This store however has irritated me for the last time. They consistently touch money and then touch food without changing gloves. There is cross contamination ALL OVER THE PLACE. They are also inconsistent with the amount of meat they put on sandwiches. Sometimes way too much and sometimes way too little, but rarely a good compromise. The bacon is also inconsistent. Sometimes it's as limp as can be and sometimes it's burned. Consistency is what people want from restaurants, and this place fails miserably. Sure, the ingredients are better than Subway, but the bread is no better here (hard and stale) and the other problems just piss me off. No more. I'll find lunch elsewhere. read more

All the employees at the Sumter location are fantastic and pleasant and make each visit a nice one and of course the food is always fresh and tastes great! Its always clean when i go in for my sub and smells so good in there! I love eating at Jersey Mikes! If you havent tried it yet i highly recommend you go! read more

I would like to start off saying we absolutely LOVED JMikes... Unfortunately our business has been driven elsewhere due poor customer service, employee attitudes and arguments with customers, and several DHEC violations! Such a great business and I can't understand for the life of me why the owner neglects it so. I have watched numerous people walk out on more than one occasion. Everything started going downhill about 6-8 months ago and I have just recently decided that I will not pay for the quality of food I love to have to put up with the employees and nastiness I have seen. Absolutely unacceptable! read more

Would give it a full rating but its pretty pricey. The meat is prepared right in front of you, not sitting in a can waiting to go on your sub. They really followed the KISS concept. Keep It Simple, Stupid. I didnt have to decide on a thousand different ways to customize my sub that would be eaten in 5 minutes, it was all an easy choice and well worth it! read more

Meh... $12.05 for a large roast beef? I could have gotten the same thing at Subway and saved 60% for the same quality.

I love this place! Staff is always friendly and its always clean! The subs are always made perfect and piled high! The customer service is phenomenal and im always treated as if i were family! read more

I went there last Monday n got a cold sub with ham, turkey n roast beef(instead of bacon). Thinking more meat!! The lettuce tasted funny. Very disappointed for $10!! It was not worth it. When they first open here prices was good I had got my money worth when I got the whole sub for that price!!. A piece of sub as they claim as half not!! Meat cut so thin couldn't taste it!! U go up on price we want our money worth Not Less for our money!! read more

I have been going to Jersey Mike's in Sumter for about 10 yrs. until about a year ago the service and food was great. Then things began to decline. The attitude of the servers, the cleanliness, consistency of quantity have all gotten to a point that I don't plan to return. Example, I usually order a mini turkey and provolone. In the past they put 5 thin slices of turkey on it; now they sometimes put 4 and sometimes 3 slices, leaving 2 inches of bun on each end with no meat. I don't mind paying for what I get and have no problem with the price but I do like to get a consistent amount for whatever I pay. Maybe they need to go up on the price. I can't suggest a remedy for the poor cleanliness and sour attitude of the employees, maybe a wage increase would help. read more