We've been to Jersey Mike's at this location before and I just had to write a rave review for the beautiful way our giant, roast beef, provolone, mikes way, with banana peppers and mayo was made by Jamiyah the other day. She was attentive and you can tell she had put love into it and made it as if she was making it for herself. So much so that I had to write about it. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #6 Roast Beef and Provolone, Mike's Way, banana peppers and mayo. Yumm. - Fast Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The Hylan Blvd store depends on who is working. Some days you get a decent sub and others you get 2 slices of ham and 2 slices of cheese for $8. Not worth the stop. read more

Whoever was working at this particular location on April 21, 2026 at 4:30pm There was one girl working there and she was completely overwhelmed with in-store orders and mobile orders and no one else was there to help this girl. When she was asked if anyone else was there she said yes So presumably there's another employee/s and that individual is being a jerk by not getting their ass out there and helping out I'm not going back to that location ever again The poor girl that was working there was doing her best but she shouldn't be in a situation like that and whoever was supposed to be working with her should be fired for negligence Why would anybody wanna go to this jersey Mike's when the staff can't be bothered to work read more

When it comes to the sandwiches, I usually have no complaints. I like the combinations they have and the portion sizes. I think they taste pretty good. My complaint here, with this particular location, is the service. The staff member seemed pretty annoyed about me wanting to add toppings to my sandwich, isn't that what their selling? I noticed that he only took out a portion of chicken when I ordered two sandwiches, so I tried not to be rude, and just reminded him that I ordered two. He said he knows (in a very annoyed way) So I waited and didn't want to be a pain. And when I was told my order was ready, it was for only one sandwich. But I just paid for it and left, I did not want to continue an unpleasant experience. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Buffalo chicken sandwich - Fast Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The girls working behind the counter were amazing no one has made me feel like such a valued customer in a long time the smiles and welcoming was so heartfelt. They even gave me great compliments about my look and vibe I'm in my 50s so having all of them so kind to me was amazing even if they were humoring this old gal it made feel cool just like them please at all cost keep these girls on the schedule together they are energized and happy to work with the public and my sandwich was delicious because they made it with love. Stop by on Sunday afternoon for a sandwich and a smile read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Such amazing young ladies that are a rare breed, come visit them on a Sunday afternoon fast food with a smile - Fast Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I love the sandwiches here, but a few days ago, I had the worst restaurant experience I've ever had. So the issue here is the service. I ordered 3 giant sandwiches. From the get-go the staff member looked like he did not want to be there, looked annoyed when I placed my order. As he was cooking the meat for the sandwich, I told him that I want to add additional things like tomatoes and onions in the sandwich, he responded by saying he knows and he gotta cook the stuff first. I said okay, but before we know it, he wrapped up the sandwich and bagged it and I told him that I didn't get to add my toppings yet. He looked really annoyed and began unwrapping the sandwich, one of his coworkers saw this and took over while he makes the other 2 sandwiches I ordered, but we didn't know which sandwich he was making since we wanted different toppings in each sandwich, I guess he got annoyed at the confusion and just disappeared. There was a miscommunication between the staff that was making my order and the cashier, so the cashier charged me for 1 giant sandwich and 2 regulars, but we didn't figure that out till later on. But we were so annoyed already that we just left with whatever we got and didn't want to straighten our orders right anymore. read more

African American lady there at the counter seemed very annoyed and irritated when making my sandwich.. aThen preceded to say "merry Christmas " sarcastically like I triggered her, such a shame I hope she builds patience and better customer service in the near future. read more

Only ever order to go- never dined in. The order is always correct, tastes fresh and is exactly what you expect it to be. Never over or under filled - quite consistent. Definitely a good place to go if you want a quick good sandwich. read more

Easily one of my favorite sandwich places and i love it The philly cheese is to die for ! read more

I went into the location during lunch time around 12:30 and there were 4 workers that looked very stressed out and overwhelmed. One of the ladies snapped at a customer who just wanted to add mustard to her sandwich stating there was" a lot going on ". She made the customer feel really bad. I saw they had a lot of tickets for online order but with 4 people it seemed doable. There was one guy there who seemed extremely new, but he was doing a great job. I don't understand how they were so overwhelms and apparently understaff by their exact words. I won't be coming back to this location because of the customer service and the lack of maturity among the staff members. It seems that whoever this location needs to be 24 seven if they can't handle lunch, rush. read more

Good classic sub! Good bread too! Service is quick ! Point add up for free subs! Tables are available too if you're sitting in for a meal.

Went in this morning, about 10.30am. There was one customer ahead of me. I was looking at the menu trying to decide between the classic Italian and Tuna. The counter person was taking the order of the patron before me and asked what do I want. I said to finish the order of the person waiting while I decide. The young lady was very abrupt saying "I don't want to do things twice. What do you want?" I left. I do not like to be rushed, especially when there's only 1 other person in the store. I cannot abide attitudes so early. read more

Amazing customer service nice atmosphere food was delicious, manager tiff and the associate Ty were so welcoming. Glad I decided to come back and give this place a chance!! read more

Came in with my husband to get sandwiches. One of the employees was clearly under the influence of drugs. The guy was barely standing on his feet and acting very weird, falling asleep while talking to the costumers. He didn't know what was going on, took him 3 tries to cut the sandwich. The other 3 employees were joking and laughing about it. Very unprofessional, felt very strange being there read more

Great location. Super accommodating and friendly. Looking forward to this location succeeding under new ownership!

Organized, timely and delicious catering. The new owner is really making wonderful changes and proving excellent service. I will definitely be a consistent customer moving forward! read more

Terrible experience, time and time again. This place is extremely unorganized and messy. The last time I went to this place was 1 year ago and I had a really bad experience. I decided to try again and the place was a mess. Food everywhere and they couldn't remember who ordered what. The worker who was preparing my sandwich put the food on the grill, starting helping other people then walked away and let my food burn. Their food is ok, but the service is terrible. Overall, I highly recommend finding somewhere else to eat read more

Ordered a buffalo chicken wrap and they forgot the buffalo sauce. ‍ The guy making the wrap was to busy trying to show off how good his wrapping skills were to the other workers. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Supposed to be a buffalo chicken wrap. - Fast Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I would like to say the service is really really bad but......it's not their fault ! There are always a bunch of kids there with no supervision. I've been to this location a few times and if you can get over the fact that no one acknowledges you walking in And they are having personal conversations while you wait the food was ok. But today was bad ... worse service ever ..... I had to tell the kid not to put lettuce in my sandwich because the lettuce was brown. He didn't even seem to care he just moved on to the next sandwich giving that poor person brown lettuce. The place is dingy and dirty. A leak from the ceiling dripped water on my head. Not going back! Big turn off to Jersey Mikes. read more

Actually been here a few times and so far it's been fairly decent. I find it to be better than Subway and Jimmy Johns by far. Unfortunately I had a bad experience when I was paying for my food today. The bill was $41 and change but when I pulled out my money to pay I realized I only had two 20 bills. So I pulled out my credit card not realizing I placed the two twenties on the counter. As I'm going through the motions to pay via credit card, the cashier reaches over and tries to pull the money away. As she was doing so she began folding it into her hand. I luckily noticed it before she could pull it off. When I said hey I'm paying with credit not cash why you touching my money, she just said my bad. I was going to blow her spot up but I think she felt horrible as it was. She clearly knew I was paying with credit as she told me what button to press yet she reached for my cash. Take it how you want but I call that bad business. Revisited the said location on several occasions and was very satisfied overall. However on the last visit I noticed what appeared to be a hair on the tomatoes. I Told the manager behind the counter what I observed. He just removed the tomatoes that it was touching and continued to serve me with the same gloves and took from the same batch of tomatoes. After leaving with my order I decided to throw the meal out as I was repulsed. I just couldn't eat after that, period. read more

See all

Just as most of the other reviews state, the workers here & the service is absolutely terrible. The workers are disrespectful & messy. Someone from Jersey Mike's really needs to look into this location and who is working there. read more

I go to this jersey mikes all the time since the owners purchase this place , today will be my last day. No lines , ordered a turkey wrap one guy that was there didn't want to make it , then they ask another then they ask another , once the services drops this quick, I won't spend my money any more it's not worth it ! Get new worked minus the young lady! Good bye jersey mikes in Hylan Blvd! read more

They don't listen! Disrespectful! Sandwiches are dry as F! They skimp on everything! All they do is have personal convo and drag their feet. Not worth it! Just buy your own cold cuts and bread from the bakery. I can make 5 sandwiches for the price of one from this dirty lazy place! read more

Somethings just never change. I went in a week ago, and the girl with orange, frizzy, long hair was making my sub without a hair net. This store just has cleanliness issues overall. read more

Always very good. And better quality meat and bread than subway or any other chain sandwich shop. The shop is nice and clean and love How they have a rewards program. Staff is friendly and always on point. Hopefully more locations open up In Staten Island ! read more

The service is deplorable - only redeeming asset is the African American Sandwich maker, who frankly without him, I'd never order, never. The other zombies couldn't even ring up an order wrap a sandwich or interact with customers clearly will hurt throughput. It's clear no training standards or for that matter customer service protocols exist. read more

Stopped off for lunch here Have seen many of these all across Nj So I figured they would be good Guess what? I was wrong. I ordered chicken ceaser sandwich Ceaser dressing was awful Portion size is small for $8.00 plus tax Also they serve Pepsi products which are the worst sodas around. I was very disappointed here Staff are very polite and friendly but I am now more hungry leaving here than when I walked in I was hoping this place was going to be a great addition to the world of delis and sandwich shops I will not be back here for lunch Next time I will just go to subway for lunch Amazing everyone tried to say they are better than subway but I see plenty of subway franchises around and no other sandwich shops You figure it out Sorry guys you just don't cut the Mustard read more

Absolutely love their sandwiches. Unfortunately this is the first time I ordered from this location. My sandwich arrived and I opened it to 3 hairs on my food. I called to make them aware and the guy seems very bothered. He did offer a free sandwich (basically to shut me up). I appreciated that but after seeing the hairs I definitely don't want to eat a sandwich. I did decline it stating I didn't want a free sandwich I just want to make you aware to avoid it in future. He then proceeded in a nasty tone ( again seemed bothered). No apology and rudely stated they wear hairnets. This is not my opinion on his tone because my co workers were their to witness the call. Poor customer service in my eyes. I didn't want to resort to review but the nasty tone on the phone made it easier to write. An apology would have been nice and appreciated. I hope this doesn't happen to anyone's food. Still hungry lol read more

See all

I ordered a giant turkey sub and I counted the guy at the slicer only put 15 pieces of thinly sliced meat on it. Thats just not enough for $14. read more

Went there one night for two sandwiches discovered the counter dirty and the slicer was filthy so filthy flies were around it we brought it to the attention of the employee and he just looked at us and said absolutely nothing will not be back at this location beware it's filthy in there read more

Reading the reviews and again the usual Staten Island haters out there. I was surprised to see that there hasn't been the "no Boars Head" comments to come out yet, but give it time. I've been coming here since the first day that they opened and probably a bit more than I really should, but the food is refreshingly good. They offer a good amount of variety on their menu, the sandwiches are very generous in size and portion. The first time in I made the mistake of ordering a Giant and it was way too much too eat and i'm not the skinniest person. The food is good, the people are friendly, and they remember faces. I prefer the hot sandwiches over the cold ones only because I think the bread tastes better in those sandwiches. I will say if you want food from your neighborhood deli you will not like it here as you will pay a bit more but the quality of the food will be fresher than your deli, but that will be reflective. read more

I love this place I just wish the person making the sandwiches didn't also do the cash register while handling money. They all should be separate. Money is the dirtiest. read more

Pretty pathetic when you pay 40$ for 2 "GIANT" sandwiched which would be a full sub they send half and tell you "oh the bread shrinks ‍ lmao youre gunna tell me that the bread shrinks back into a half sub then they told me they will not fix it because i could have eaten it when i had just received it with notifications and pictures to prove it... theyre confrontational, unprofessional, and all around pretty pathetic workers that simply dont wanna be there just collect a check, food tastes fine though i guess that was not the issue read more

Service is poor and staff is confrontational. I mobile order and arrived at the appointed pick-up time and my order was not only not ready, but not even started and my ticket wasn't even printed. I wasn't advised it was delayed or offered any explanation. Then looked for an argument because I looked annoyed for have to wait 20 mins for my order to be completed and having to stop another worker from putting an unwanted item on my sandwich. The entire staff is unprofessional and customer service is a foreign word. They have lost a weekly customer. read more

Yes this place deserves all of its stars. Great prices friendly staff high quality sandwiches for a chain. Subway who? I'm as shocked as you are to rave about this place but it's just a great sandwich so well made and great for lunch. So far I've had the philly cheese steak (I just ask them to leave the jalapeños off) love spice but this is weird on a cheesesteak. The buffalo chicken cheese steak also yum. The tuna with lettuce tomato red wine vinegar, seasoning, banana rings, onions and pepper spread. My personal favorite is the Original Italian with banana pepp, pepp spread, onion, vinegar, seasoning, lettuce tomato. To die for!!!!!! read more

See all

Excellent!!! I'm in customer service and people are always so quick to put in a bad review or make a complaint. No one ever takes the time to say good things about their experience and if they do it's rare. I walked into this store and was greeted with smiles and respect. Nedra, Meek and Kevin were all smiling and welcomed me. I felt like I've known them for years. They were all so pleasant and professional. Being in retail I feel happy employees make happy customers. In this case Nedra, Meek and Kevin were such great employees they made me a extremely happy customer. And the sandwiches were delicious. Thank you so much Nedra, Meek and Kevin. Keep up the great work and keep those smiles and positivity always. Thanks again. read more

The fact they offer GLUTEN FREE sandwiches is amazing! Not only that, they understand people have serious reasons for not consuming gluten, so they really go above and beyond to ensure there is no cross contamination. I have been to places that offer gluten free and do not bother to ensure there is no CC, which is HORRIBLE! However, if you are going to eat the gluten free sandwich, and you're not celiac, and CC is not an issue for you, just let them know that CC is not an issue, this way you can save them some extra time and work :) Four Stars because I found it a bit pricey for a sandwich shop, however the staff and food is good! read more

Stopped in to get two sandwiches on Friday night, it was 8 pm and the floors were all wet already and the store closes at 9.the place was empty basically with one lady in front of me, but they were working on all phone orders. I had to wait basically 25 minutes to get my sandwiches . And then the guy behind the counter asks who is next and a transit worker cuts me in line when the worker knew I was next and took his order. All young guys working, didn't ask me how I wanted my sandwich . Tomatoes were moldy. Took them off my sandwich . Took way to long for an empty store.with three guys working. Sandwich tasted overly salty. Won't be goin back. Workers seemed liked they didn't care and wanted to get out early read more

I walked in when noone was in front and my buddy brian was telling the other manager put less meat who cares about the customer then he walked out and smiled says hey buddy and I was like this phony guy and I was heart broken read more

Ugh. One of the guys behind the counter was wearing sanitary gloves BUT wiped his gloved hands on his pants and apron THEN stuck his hand in the lettuce and moved the lettuce around. He wasn't making a sandwich, just wanted to touch the lettuce, I guess. I usually like lettuce and tomatoes on my sandwiches, but not today . I had already decided against the lettuce today because it looked brown and wilted, now I know why. The guy who made my sandwich didn't do anything obviously unsanitary so I will eat my (nearly $10) sandwich after I add my own lettuce and tomato at home. I gave them 2 stars instead of 1 because the quality of the roast beef is better than subway's roast beef. I like that they sliced the meat fresh, but I won't be back. I wish Jimmy John's would come back to Staten Island. Until then, I'll stick with Subway. read more