Sandwiches are always fresh and made how I ordered. The staff is incredibly friendly and have a smile on their face. I've not dined in so I can review that, but I will continue to order from here when I'm craving a good sub. read more

Did an online order pick up since I had a coupon for online order only. I was in the area so I decided to go ahead and order a sandwich from here. I got a free drink and chip with my sandwich order. The restaurant was very quick with my food. I didn't have to wait long since again I had ordered while I was in the parking lot . My food took maybe 5-7 min for them to make once I went inside. The inside was very clean and the staff was very friendly. Make sure you download the app to earn points for free items and you can make an online order. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Service is always excellent. I've visited here routinely and am never disappointed. This is favorite sandwich shop, because the food is excellent - both cold and hot subs. Ambiance is good, too. read more

Excellent sandwiches today at Jersey Mike's! Very friendly service, fresh sliced meats and cheese, fresh and soft bread and a nice and clean restaurant. Really nice staff working made this a nice visit! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #7 Turkey and Provolone mini - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I was next door at Staples around lunchtime when I heard Danny Devito's voice in my head. That usually only happens when I'm sleeping or in the shower, so I decided to get a sandwich at Jersey Mikes. I got the Jersey Shore Mike's Way. It was a solid sandwich, way better than Subway and the veggies were fresher than Jimmy Johns. I'll definitely go back. read more

Fast, helpful and pleasant staff. On a busy Friday lunch hour, these folks were amazingly efficient. Turkey sub is pretty awesome.

Amazing service, friendly staff, and great sandwiches make this a must try. My favorite is the Italian. Way better the Jimmy John's. More ingredients and better taste! read more

Food was great and very friendly. What bothered me was the tall skinny young man who kept eating from the containers of food with gloves on and then proceeded to make the sandwiches. I plan to contact the manager read more

Amazing service and the best Philly for a fast food chain. The bread is top tier and the toppings all in incorporated

Stopped by to pick up lunch. It was a relatively long line, but thanks to he training and the staff that bought in, it only took 6 minutes to get through. Each person knew their role and they were very nice at each station; a well-oiled machine for sure! Special shout out to the expo guy. He was running point, turning chaos into Vivaldi Four Seasons. read more

The food was great! The service was great too. The ambiance was kind of stressful with everyone standing around everywhere. The workers were not wearing hair nets while making food so I would not be surprised if you find a hair in your sub read more

Do NOT place an online order!!! We were quoted 30 minutes for 3 sandwiches. We got there a little early and sat there for more than 20 minutes after our quoted pick up time and asked about the status of our order. We were told that 1 of our 3 sandwiches was ready, they were working on the other 2. Ten minutes later we checked on the order again and found out that they were still working on the other sandwiches and that the one that had been sitting there for 10 minutes was one of the hot sandwiches, which was no longer hot and would need remade. At that point, we asked for a refund. They had already wasted a lot of our time and we were done! Also, while they were busy, they had plenty of staff and the people who ordered in the restaurant came and went while we waited for the online order. There are plenty of other places around, don't waste your money or time here! read more

Two things I love about Jersey Mike's: outstanding customer service and excellent food. I appreciate that the employees take pride in their sandwich-making abilities. They ensure that each customer receives a delicious sandwich, created as ordered. There are a large variety of sandwiches, wraps and salads (Sub in a Tub) all with high quality ingredients. The bread is fresh baked, in-house. No skimping on toppings either: generous portions of meats, cheeses, and veggies. These are substantial sandwiches for sure. Order your sandwich "Mike's Way" to top with veggies and "juice." What's in the "juice?" Crack, I think, or at least something equally addictive. The dining room is bright and always clean. Comfortable chairs and benches, plenty of seating. Join their club (all it requires is a phone number) and receive free subs. read more

See all

As close as you can get around here to a true East Coast sub or hoagie, as we called them in Philly. MY PERSONAL RANKING Jersey Mikes then Penn Station then Potbelly then Jimmy John's then ........ Subway (in a distant last place). Love Jersey Mikes bread, oil and vinegar, oregano, and meats and true Italian Provolone. The owner's Giving Day ... where ALL profits on a particular day are given to charities... is a wonderful idea. read more

Second time I've ordered online arrived as instructed and had to wait 20 minutes to get one sandwich. Customers came in off the street and got their order before mine. Won't be ordering online again. read more

Very frustrating experience. Disclaimer.. I've been to this location multiple times, and each time I have a similar experience. The biggest complaint is the service. They tend to have people there aren't customer focused. During my last visit, there was some confusion with someone else order. Due to the cashier helping someone else, the person who made the sandwich, just set my finished sandwich in there same area where I saw them unloaded boxes. When asking why my same was just sitting on the bare table and not on something to protect the bottom, I got a response of "it'll be alright". I could have asked to remake, but since this type of experience wasn't my first, I really didn't have the energy... I took my sandwich and discarded the bottom bun... I know in these times it's hard to find good workers, but it's unfortunate that's a norm there. read more

My review is for today. I have always had a good experience here. I love the tuna. But today we drove from our home in Fishers and it wasn't open! So we had to go to another place. So if you're going to close, ok. But post that so we don't drive all the way over. read more

Nice change of pace from Jimmy John's or Penn Station. Assembly line lunch shop, chase it with a bag of chips and soda. Costs more (generally) than Jimmy John's and the quality is maybe a tick higher. I like the juice on the sammich, better taste. read more

As I sit here, for the last hour waiting on my online order, the crew of 8 EMPLOYEES have put about as much effort into getting orders out the door as you'd see a 15 year old dog walking, minimal. It's one thing if orders were moving in and out, but half of the employees are just standing around not doing anything. Their demeanor is terrible, no leadership, and no care about customers. DO NOT ORDER ONLINE, you will be waiting 60+ mins, absolutely stupid read more

Subs are decent but customer experience is horrible. Just picked up my sandwich and not one person out of 5 said welcome. I finally asked if I could order (I was the only person in line to order). One worker was sitting down and got up to make the order. 2 people went in the back to be on there phones. Least welcoming I've felt to order food. All the workers seem to hate to be there or something happened between them. read more

Had a good carry out experience here today. Firstly, subs are a steal at 50% off so my boyfriend is in heaven. Jersey mikes is quite expensive, so 50% off is a HUGE deal. Anyways... we ordered online ahead of time and the sandwiches were wrapped up and ready right when we walked in. We walked in and walked right out. The store looked exceptionally clean, and the packaging and presentation was very professional. We get the italian, mike's way, and it has so much meat. It had an excellent flavor and tasted so fresh. It is my favorite sandwich there and I've had 3 others that I didn't care for. I'm giving 4 stars just because there wasn't any hand sanitizer, or way to open the door without potentially contaminating your hands. You may consider purell wipes just in case people leave the store and plan to eat right away. Normally I wouldn't probably care, but I am hypersensitive to this due to the current pandemic. read more

There's no better cold sub in town. I get the Turkey Provolone... Mike's Way add mayo. It's crazy good. More than I want to spend, but the taste is unmatched. Subway is gross compared to Mikes. Jimmy Johns is good if you can bite through the brick bread. If you want a soft delicious loaf, go to Mikes. read more

We frequently visit this business about once a week. For three sandwiches is almost $40. However we just recently had a problem in regards to the content of the sandwich which was a bolt found in my father's sandwich. And we contacted the business and just wanted a refund for the sandwiches however we were denied.. which was asinine because we are regular customers and my mom is not a liar. We will never eat there again here's a photo of the screw/bolt. read more

I see why this location is a 3 star. Walked in to get a sandwich the only customers there were leaving. One employee was cleaning a sandwich machine one was leaning up against meat counter looking at me and I could hear a couple in a side room. I stood there for about 5 minutes and finally ask if someone could help me, girl leaning against counter ask do you want cold or hot sub told her cold and she just stood there and looked at me. No one including the girl moved to help me after I stood there another 3 or 4 minutes. I said thank you and walked out. Terrible Terrible Service or lazy employees. Will not be back read more

I'm giving us five stars for what it is, not because it's a five star establishment. The food is really really good here, it's very authentic to where I grew up with in Philadelphia. I feel like the prices of the sandwiches are a little bit expensive and are borderline sit down right restaurant prices read more

Ordered gluten free sub, paid and was waiting for the food. After watching six customers who came after me leave with their food, I asked about my food. I was told it was not started yet because they had to clear the griddle due to gluten. This involved scraping the griddle and using the same utensils that are used for non-gluten free subs. Extra twenty minutes for no real benefit read more

Absolutely ruined my Birthday mood. Let me start by saying, my family and I have visited this location before and the service and food has been outstanding. My birthday is on 9-11 and despite being on a somber day, I was in a pretty good mood. Jersey Mikes ans Denny's restaurant are some of the few chains the have a "legitimate" birthday promotion, as I have partaken of on past birthdays with no problems and I ALWAYS TIP well for the service. I visted at approximately 4:00 pm and the there were NO customers in the restaurant, and I observed about three employees including an middle aged female wearing a uniform that indicated she was management. I was greeted professionally by everyone as I approached the ordering line and I cheerfully announced, today's my birthday. To which, she wished me happy birthday, then I replied, thank you. I told her, I'd like to order the free birthday sub, and PAY for the additional two. Management lady, askes me if I registered via the website? I replied, that YES, I registered last night. BEFORE, I could even reach for my phone to pull up the website to proove that I did in facf registered, she responded, sorry, it takes up to 48 for you to get a confirmation blah. Blah I didn't get angry, emotional, argue or questioned her treatment of a PAYING customer. I just said, okay, I suppose, I'll need to come back. Sorry for the angry essay. Just needed to get this off my chest. read more

last time I went I got an unsweetened ice tea, mainly because there choice of pop is so poor. I asked for some artificial sweetener to put in my tea because I can't have sugar. I was told they are no longer providing sweet and low that she can give me sugar packets if I like. Not sure how that makes it different from the already available sweet tea???‍. I will not there again for this reason. anyone know if this is company wise or just this location? read more

These guys are awesome! Such happy friendly guys!!! They sang Happy Birthday to my niece as they filled our order!! Thank You so much!!! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love their chipotle cheese steak sandwich. Store is always clean and the staff is always friendly. Not a fancy place but a great place to get a sub. read more

Update: the owner contacted me and listened to my feedback, which was much appreciated. I am so disappointed with this location. I have been here several times because my husband loves the cold cut subs, but I doubt I will return. I came in today and ordered a chicken parm sandwich. What I received was a sloppy, disgusting mess. It doesn't help that every time I have ordered a hot sub from this location, it always is served messy, with toppings that get all over the place. I can handle things being a little messy but when you leave sandwich is haphazardly slopped together and falls apart while eating it, it really just doesn't do it for me. The employees who put together my sandwich today should be embarrassed to serve something the way they did. Clearly, this crew of employees today just didn't care about their jobs because the restaurant was dirtier than I had ever seen it (hair on my table!), there were no straws for drinks, trash cans overflowing. I should've just asked for a refund and left. For $10 I expect better quality. My sandwich also had no flavor and was not visually appealing whatsoever. I'm also pretty sure it was microwaved. Blech! Attaching a picture of my tasteless sandwich. read more

I had never been to a Jersey Mike's but when one opened up near me, I thought I would try it out. I stopped in during lunch two days after they opened. It was super busy and the line was out the door. They were doing a great job of keeping the line moving and getting food out in a timely manner. I ordered the regular Chipotle Philly Cheese Steak along with chips and a drink. I was a bit surprised by the price. I think I paid around $11 for lunch, pricey in my opinion. But I didn't care because I was hungry and craving something beefy, cheesy and spicy! I got my order to go and when I arrived home, I found that I had been given the wrong sandwich. They had given me the Chicken Philly Cheese Steak. I ate it anyways. I was so disappointed when I dug in and realized that the chicken was dry and there wasn't much flavor. I'll give them another shot since they are still working out the kinks and hopefully I will get to raise my rating from 'A-OK' to 'Yay! I'm a fan!' read more

I had been to Jersey Mike's once before and was not overly impressed. This is a brand new store so there is that in its favor. So it better be clean and smell good. The workers in the store were friendly and greeted us. They were patience as we ordered. They told us about our options and made great looking sandwiches. They made sure to ask if we have a Shore Card and got us signed up. The lady that signed us up explained how the program worked. Now having eaten those tasty subs, we will be back. I had the mini #4 with everything but onions and jalapeño. we also got to sample the cherry pepper relish. Its sweet with a whole lot of kick. They were kind enough to give it to us in a sample cup with plenty to add to our sandwich at home. If you are looking for a better sandwich than subway.....Jersey Mike's the place. read more

Stopped in for a late lunch (around 2:30) on a Thursday for my first Jersey Mike's experience. Employees outnumbered patrons, which isn't uncommon for this time of day. The service was friendly, but nothing over the top. I got the Chipotle cheese steak on wheat, which was pretty spectacular for the price. However, i did NOT find this location to be well-maintained. I settled for the least dirty table in the place and looked around at all of the diner detritus on the floors under the surrounding tables. Let me say that it was not filthy, but it was not as clean as it probably should have been between lunch and dinner rushes, especially considering the staffing levels at the time of my visit. I'll come back, but I'm hoping that someone in management or ownership promptly addresses the constant need for upkeep that can make or break a fast casual restaurant. read more

Nice staff, small space, and all you have come to expect from a Jersey Mike's. The turkey sammy is my fave go-to. I'll take this over other sandwich shops any day, since they slice it all right in front of you. Old style like. I'm a fan. read more

While I'm not a habitual reviewer of chain restaurants, there is something a bit special about one's first visit to a new chain. This is what happened today as I finally got myself inside a Jersey Mike's, a sub shop with a history that goes all the way back to New Jersey and 1956. The history is kind of cool - in 1971, the current CEO was a 17-year-old employee of the original Mike's who caught wind that the owner was thinking about selling. With his football coach, also a banker, as a backer, that 17-year-old bought Mike's and continues to be the chain's CEO to this day. Amazing stuff. I wish I felt as in awe of the experience I had today during my first visit to Jersey Mike's. Located in a small strip center in the parking lot of the Meijer on East 96th Street, this location is a relatively new spot with beautiful accessible parking and terrific curb cuts. As you go in the glass doors, the dining area is immediately in front of you (with a handful of tables also to the left). You go toward the back of the restaurant to enter a line somewhat similar to the Subway concept. Jersey Mike's offers subs (cold and hot), obviously, along with wraps, combos, desserts, sides, a kid's meal option and, generally, what you expect from the growing number of sub shops. They will ask you if you want it Mike's Way - this means with Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Vinegar, Oil and Spices in addition to any toppings listed with each individual sandwich. They do not freak out if you choose to detour from Mike's Way. The sandwich sizing comes in "mini," "regular" and "giant." While no one explained the differences, other than pricing, I was later able to look online and find out that a "mini" is designed to feed one, a "regular" to feed 1-2, and a "giant" to feed 3-4. You can make it a regular or large combo and they carry Pepsi products, bottled water and Luzianne Iced Tea (both sweet and unsweetened - brewed, not bottled). So, how was it? I arrived during the lunch hour on a holiday (Okay, Columbus Day. It's almost a holiday). The restaurant was pretty steady in terms of business and having a couple people ahead of me allowed me to check out the menu at a leisurely pace. As tends to be true at Subway, Jersey Mike's had a person take the order, another person handle toppings and someone at the cash register (whom I'm guessing was either owner or manager). The crew was friendly, though problem #1 became just exactly how to hear them. While I heard the first employee fine, the second one had to repeat his question (Did I want it Mike's Way?) four times. The acoustics in Jersey Mike's are just plain awful - it's super noisy when it's crowded and because I sit closer to the ground in a wheelchair, I had an even harder time hearing. They offered help with the drink and also offered their rewards club - which I joined as it only required I surrender a cell phone number. The sandwich was decent sized, though didn't strike me as a 2-person sandwich. If you stick with mini sandwiches, you can easily eat for less than a ten spot even with a combo. If you go above a mini, you're going to likely end up right around $10. The other thing that kind of bugged me was that the credit card machine is one of those set up to ask you to tip (10, 15 or 20%). That would be just dandy if you were actually serving me, but the food is already on the high end of sandwich shops. How about if you just pay your employees a living wage? They aren't the only one to do this, but it always irritates me. I had a bag of Miss Vickie's BBQ chips that were fine. The iced tea was great and I was able to get my refill. The sandwich struck me as most similar to Jimmy John's, though my understanding is it's lower in sodium. The taste? Pretty darn similar. I'd put it in the middle-of-the-pack for my sandwich shops. The bread struck me as fairly ordinary, though it didn't feel processed like Subway. It was a good meal, but not a great one. There's no way that Jersey Mike's is destined to end up on my dining rotation. The price point is a tad higher, the restaurant less comfortable and the food middle-of-the-road. This location really isn't in my neighborhood anyway, so I don't know that they're really losing any business. Usually, when I hit this area I find myself at Project Pie (in the same strip center). This is a fine option if you're wanting to go healthier, but I'll probably return to Project Pie. read more

I don't know why people are hating on this new location. Really? Posting reviews during the opening week? I went to this location for the first time a week ago and it was firing on all eight cylinders. It has only been open a couple months. I got my usual order, #13 Mike's Way no onions and it was spot on! Plus I don't have to fight the traffic down 82nd St. to the other location closest to me. These guys are slicing everything fresh per order. If you want something assembled in two minutes go to Jimmy John's. Frankly the sodium content of their meats (Jimmy Johns) gags me. Mikes is my go-to sandwich shop. read more

Stopped at this sub shop for the first time during lunch last week and was pleasantly surprised. Sandwiches were very tasty and had that Jersey oil and vinegar taste of them. The prices aren't that much different from any other sub shop, this is a place I'll make additional lunch time stops. read more

This is the store I come to most frequently and I never have an issue! They are polite and make sure I'm happy! I loooooove the #8, i get pepperoni in substitute of ham with everything on it. Ever since I have discovered this place, I do not expect for any other sub place to amount. Thank you. read more

Nadia was amazing! I am gluten-free and go to so many different restaurants where people don't take my allergy seriously. Nadia did a wonderful job, cleaned the surface, changed her gloves and made sure my food didn't touch anything with gluten. I greatly appreciate this type of service and will be back! read more