If you haven't made your way to Jersey Mike's in Deer Park yet, consider this your official invitation. Let me start with the bread, because it deserves its own moment. Baked fresh in the store throughout the day, it's the kind of bread that makes you realize you've been settling. Soft, slightly chewy, with just enough structure to hold everything together. The cold cuts are sliced to order -- not pre-packaged, not pre-portioned, not sitting in a tray since Tuesday morning. My personal go-to is the Turkey and Provolone, built Mike's Way: lettuce, tomato, onion, olive oil, red wine vinegar, oregano, and salt. It's simple, it's fresh, and it's exactly right. For something a little different, the California Chicken Cheese Steak is a must-try. And if you're a tuna fan, their Tuna is the real deal. I can't write this review without mentioning the BLT. The bacon is cooked perfectly -- warm, crispy, and impossibly satisfying alongside cold lettuce, ripe tomato, and a generous smear of mayo. My advice? Pair it with a bag of Original Lay's and a Pure Leaf lemon tea. You'll thank me later. The store itself is spotless -- genuinely, consistently clean -- and the staff is the kind of friendly that feels real, not rehearsed. They move fast without making you feel rushed. Pro tip: Order through the app when you're 10-15 minutes out and your sandwich will be waiting for you. We're talking in-and-out in under two minutes. Whether you're grabbing lunch for home, packing for the beach, or hunting down a quick bite before life gets busy again -- this is your spot. Two thumbs up. No hesitation. read more

Never had Jersey mikes until I moved to Long Island and wow! The closest thing we had in the city to Jersey Mikes was Subway and Subway is super trash. What I really love and appreciate about Jersey Mikes, is all the cold cuts are fresh cold cuts and not processed cold cuts like Subway. They have a great selection of condiments you can add to your sandwich to make it phenomenal. I ordered the number 4 and the sandwich came with Provolone, prosciuttini and cappacuolo, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pepper relish, oil, pepper, and vinegar. I paid 20 dollar for the sandwich but it's well worth it. Sandwich is cut into 4 slices and it's the size of a whole Italian loaf of bread. They offer the regular size for 7 dollars but I they offer a larger option where it's pretty much 2 sandwiches. Overall I'm obsessed with Jersey Mikes and this is my new spot for sandwiches. Definitely not the best, but great for when I want a good sandwich and don't want a travel far. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Deer Park, New York

See all

I used to love Jersey Mike's. It was my go-to. But the last time I ordered through Uber Eats, that love turned into one of the worst experiences I've ever had with food. After just a few bites of the sandwich, I was violently sick--throwing up, nauseous, completely miserable. Still, I tried to give them the benefit of the doubt. Maybe it was me. Maybe something else was off. But a few hours later, I took another bite... and it hit me again. Same reaction. That's when I knew--it had to be the sandwich. I called the store, hoping for some kind of accountability. The manager's response? Dismissive. He said he's made thousands of sandwiches and has never had a single complaint like mine. I told him something must've been wrong with the meat--there's no way I'm the only one who got sick. Still, he denied everything. The best he could offer was a refund and a casual "check your account in a few days." Well, it's been over a week. No refund. No follow-up. Just silence. And now? I won't ever step near a Jersey Mike's again. read more

Staff is always friendly. My food is always ready on time when I order online. Clean seating areas too. I get a long sub for my son sometimes and slice it for two school lunch meals and he loves that! read more

Always a great experience at this location. I come in on Saturday afternoon with my mother and autistic brother and the girls there are always super patient with him and every once in a while give him a cookie or chips on the house. We will always be back!! read more

Great establishment, staff members are extremely friendly and knowledgeable. The dining area is always clean. would definitely recommend this place. read more

usually i love going to jersey mikes but this time the workers were lazy rude and didn't want to make a hot sandwich 20 minutes before they closed. was going to leave with no problem until they turn around to each other and starting laughing about being lazy and not wanting to do their job. this is absolutely disgusting that these are the people they have representing their locations. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - the lazy workers - Fast Food Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Convenient location near work. Also nice they are right next to Starbucks! I've ordered from this location a handful of times. Each time the employees take the time in making my sandwich or sub in a tub. They never rush and listen as to what I want. Everything is always super fresh. I prefer Jersey Mike's as everything is freshly sliced, and not just sitting there in a bin. My favorite is a #7. Turkey and provolone. Turkey and provolone is such a lovely marriage. I get it "Mike's Way" for the most part...just no onions...and I add pickles and banana peppers. "Mike's Way" is onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices. Prices are a bit high, but totally worth it. Recently, during Covid, all procedures are followed. read more

Sky High Hero prices $25.50 for a sub soda and chips. The Subs get smaller by the week as prices go up constantly. Also the cold cut quality is clearly not great at all! Pretty much done with this place! Not going i for lunch takeout with three Heroes for near $80.00 read more

Ordered three cookies a few days ago with our subs. Told my partner how great they were. When they arrived they were burnt and tasted burnt a where hard as a rock. I have had Jersey Mikes cookies before and they have never been of this poor quality. Makes me wonder if they were giving the burnt ones to people that ordered through Uber Eats so they could get rid of them. I know I would have never bought them if they looked like that on the counter. If you burn a batch throw it out and don't try to hand it out to paying customers that can't see them. read more

The staff is too young and inexperienced to run the store by themselves. It took 25 or more minutes for 3 sandwiches. 2 regular & 1 giant. Several people after me left with their sandwiches as I waited and watched all the confusion behind the counter and mixing up of food. They did not know what sandwich was what once it was wrapped and let my sandwiches sit on the line. One worker even mentioned it to the other that the food was dying, "he said yeah so" I was patient and understanding up until this point. I wanted to redo my whole order fresh. However just wanted to get out of this store. Food dying is restaurant industry talk for food getting cold. My sandwich was saturated through the bread, cheese was not melted anymore. Will not repeat at this time due to bad experience. Hint to staff: keep track of the food better Hint to management: train your staff. With 9 employees and 6 customers behind me online, it's not rocket science to cook some steakems on a flat top. As for price it is around $9 for regular size, and $15 for giant. I would wait another month for them to get organized. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Deer Park, New York

This is the most unsanitary and dangerous place ive been to in awhile. I 2as picking up food for doir dash. I watched the person handle money then touch food while wearing the same gloves. When i told him about it he said nope your crazy. They also make your sandwiches on the same counter they place tickets and other items on. Eat here at your own risk read more

Won't be returning, I never had jersey Mikes so I figured I would try it. Prices are insane for what you actually get. Even with double meat a regular portion at a real deli is still more and cheaper, $18 for a hero with ultra processed meat that definitely was not double meat is ridiculous. It is not even boars head. Stick to a regular deli. I didn't even add lettuce because it looked to be browning in the bin. read more

I don't think I'll go back to this location because of the employees. There didn't seem to be a manager present, just the 2 guys working who looked and acted like they wanted to be anywhere but there. My biggest issue was how dirty the prep area was. The slicer had so many scraps of meat and cheese on it and the counter was a mess with scraps of the toppings. I can't imagine the store is constantly busy that the employees have no time to wipe down the slicer or counter. When I walked in there was no one on line and I would have happily waited while they took a few seconds to clean the prep area. read more

Love Jersey Mike's. I always think the Mini is not going to be enough but it's really perfect. I got the Italian combo with pepperoni. The "works" includes lettuce, tomato, onion, Italian seasoning, oil and vinegar, salt and pepper, really makes this sub DELICIOUS. Plus everything is made to order. So they're not pre-sliced like Subway. I'm a fan even though it was just a little bit too much ham in mine. No worries, I took it out and it was the perfect ratio of meat to cheese to all the Fixin's. It was exactly what I was in the mood for. Is it as good as my local deli? No but it's way better than Subway IMHO. I too came when this location first opened and the staff was definitely getting ramped up. The young man who dressed my sandwich did an awesome job. Sorry, I didn't take his name. But all the staff seemed very knowledgeable and professional. read more

II am a big guy and the Giant size was really Giant. By that I mean a lot of bread and not much meat. The Big Big Problem I have is all the extra fees. The cost is pretty high to begin with and almost 50 bucks for 3 hero's is not really worth it. Won't be going back 5.00 Delivery Fee 2.99 Service Fee. ( what is that exactly) read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Lots of Fees and Very Overpriced - Fast Food Near Me - Deer Park, New York

Customer service is the worst i have ever seen both employees 6/1/22 8:45pm had such bad attitudes felt as if i was doing something wrong when i asked for a second Sandwitch on my order. The older employee even got into argument with another customer, if i wasn't so hungry I definitely would have just left and went elsewhere. I will not be returning. read more

Customer service was terrible and employees are sooo rude!! They messed up my order. When returned to get order fixed AFTER calling to make them aware, they had a attitude and tried to charge me again !! Absolutely not. I work in customer services and they have none!! Need new employees and better management. Will not be returning to the deer park location. read more

Done with this one.... I order the same sandwiches every damn time, for a year and they only get it right 1/2 the damn time.

I absolutely love this place. The sandwiches were huge and worth every penny. I was able to get as many peppers and toppings as I liked and it was amazing! If you're in the area and you like a subs id suggest you go to Jersey Mike's and get a one. My boyfriend had their famous cheesesteak and he said it was amazing. I didn't get to taste it because he ate it all LOL. I wish they did have more toppings...only bad thing I have to say. read more

I stopped in the other night with a friend. Walked in with no expectations of any other than a another subpar hero joint. You know the guys with the 10 inch footlong subs, where if you call the stuff in there cold cuts, you might severely misguided. I was greeted by a gentleman who asked if I've every been to a Jersey Mike's. He gave me a quick rundown of the menu and a suggestion or two on what to try. I get my sandwich and my friend and I looked at each other and at the same time said 'this is a really good sandwich'. Fresh real cold cuts, great quality bread and super fresh toppings. This place is a homerun. From now on this will be a regular stop for me. read more

Every time I walk in here, I feel like all the employees just woke up from a nap! Usually one employee comes out, and after a few minutes there's 5 or 6 of them. Like another reviewer said, no hello, welcome they just look at you and wait until you speak. I guess it's hard to find good help. I don't care so much about this because it's a sandwich shop, but they should be better. I also asked that my sandwich be cut in half (reasonable request right?) The guy making the sandwich said "yup", but he didn't. I actually had to ask 3 times to get it cut, the last time after it was wrapped up. My main issue with Mikes is the price though. I went in one day after the gym and I had just $20 on me. I was unable to buy just 2 regular sized sandwiches. They showed me the size of the mini and it looked so tiny, so I just walked out. Also I didn't know they had different types of bread, until I heard another customer ask, because they don't say anything when you walk in. They ask at Subway, which is right across the street, better customer service and a better value. read more

I enjoy jersey mikes Philly cheesesteak and their club supreme sandwiches. They are much better than subways but the cost is very expensive. It's $10 for a regular sandwich so generally I would not say it is worth it. The food is decent but the staff is not the most friendly. there is one manager who always seems like she hates it there. She sighed at me while I was placing my order and just isnt very welcoming read more

Giant is really giant. Nothing spectacular. But again, not bad. It's a chain. It's average. Should I be going to a locally owned deli? Yes. Could I find one open on a Sunday afternoon in that area in a pandemic? No. Again, it was ok. If I'm in that situation again, I'll go again. It was ok. But sometimes you need nothing crazy, just ok read more

Alright here's the deal- I do realize this is a brand new location so they still have to work out some of the kinks. But the price is really driving my 3 star review. The service is very friendly, but I can not justify paying $15 for a large sandwich. If you want to any other deli you would not pay nearly as much, and you would probably get a massive hero that you couldn't finish in one sitting. I got the famous philly cheese steak, which again tasted great but the price just isn't there. I've ordered it twice, and the second time I found pieces of the meat that didn't seem to have been cooked all the way, which has also turned me off. Everything definitely does look fresh and tasty, it's just not enough bang for my buck. read more

I stopped by yesterday and ordered a chipotle chicken sub, just regular to go, reached home and it was beef or steak. Either they mixed up the orders or the guy who took the order made a mistake. Anyways - spoilt my lunch. How do you mix up chicken with steak ?? Not happy. read more

I've been going to jersey Mikes for 10 years. I'm from the west coast moved out here a few weeks ago. If this jersey mikes would have been the only one I've went to I would never eat here. The service the quality the lowest even worse than subway lol. The man making the sandwich gave me so much attitude I wanted to leave than the bread seem old and hard. After getting past that the lettuce was brown I asked if I could please get fresh lettuce I thought I asked for gold the way I was looked at. I specifically asked for yellow mustard got some idk spicy mustard or something I guess it's traditional out here but I specifically said yellow mustard. I politely ask not to put prosciutto on my sandwich, I can't pronounce it properly so I said pros which I was told is the most common way to say it. He looked at me and said what! His co worker new exactly what I meant. Don't go this location but jersey mikes is the best sandwiches I've had in my life. Lastly all the employees seem like they hate there job I even walked in on a manger scolding them for closing early!!! Hope the owner see this and get it together NH read more

I had never been to a jersey mikes before, but i am now obsessed! the roast beef sandwich is so good! i will definitely agree with the other reviews the staff needs to be trained better. They seem very young and goof off a lot(when my husband ordered a philly cheesesteak one of the workers said "that's going to take a long time with _____ on the grill" as everyone behind the counter is laughing. We werent sure if they were being serious or not but i just hope they don't joke with someone that's hangry and not in the mood for childish games. when the two older gentlemen are there everything runs properly. can't fault them for new staff- they'll work out the kinks with time as most businesses do! read more

Think the girls name is Vanessa, what a disgusting attitude while taking my order and even more when I told her I i didn't waNt a mayonnaise.... The place was super empty and again when I asked her to speak to her supervisor she made a smirk and said " I am the manager " Ugh Never again , overpriced and just not a pleasant experience. read more

First time here. Ordered the supreme club, neither of the workers making the sub remembered the bacon until I mentioned it. No big deal. Average amount of meat, average taste. I would say a step above subway. The price was significantly higher than one would expect for the quality. With delis all over Long Island you can get a far better sandwich for 4-6 dollars less. read more

Blech. White bread, iceberg lettuce, over priced. Maybe this is a sub in NJ but by NY standards its SUB-par. The place was empty and now I know why. read more

Manager very rude and rushed ordering process, even though my boyfriend and I were the only ones inside. Little to no customer service.. no "hello" or "goodbye"... just stares. Felt very judged and never have had a negative experience at a Jersey Mikes before.. disappointed and will not return to this location again. read more

I stopped into Jersey Mike's to give their subs a try. I ordered a 6 inch turkey provolone ham lettuce tomato banana pepper oil and vinegar on whole wheat bread service was great the young staff or friendly sandwich was very good read more

Who closes 30 minutes early on a weekend I don't know ‍ if your employees want to clock out early and not work until the time on the door AND online maybe CHANGE it so I don't waste my time and gas driving to your establishment. Subway will do! EDIT: they never responded to my email btw guys!!! They're faking "good customer service" for yelp LOL read more

Love Jersey Mikes and Love that they opened a local one for me. Great job!!! The place is clean and well staffed. The sandwiches are always good and very filled. read more

Love Jersey Mike's Subs but this location has problems... the staff is young and seems to have no idea what they are doing and in most cases don't seem to understand I am spending money on the product they are making me cause its done with such disregard (Poor training) I had an interaction with a owner and I realized that the disfunction comes from the top. I stood there and waited while he cleaned the entire slicer for a customer with "allergies" who ordered he half a sandwich and paid with a coupon... when he was done helping her after I waited 15 minutes.... he just walked away...didn't even make eye contact with me. read more

I was in the store on a Sunday afternoon. Only one other customer on line, not busy at all. The three young employees who were working at the counter were all clueless. They couldn't cut the bread, almost dropped one of my sandwiches twice, and screwed up the order of the other customer. I wouldn't recommend this location read more

As a proud Jersey girl I'm not really clear on why there are more Jersey Mikes in Long Island than my home state. However, I love me some jersey mikes. Their sandwiches are always fresh and tasty. They have some special seasoning that they put on them to ensure quality! I'm a huge fan of the different sizes which are large enough to share. The only down side is that a bag of chips and sandwich here can get very costly. As much as I love the fresh deli meats (roast beef, turkey, bacon, cheese) etc I don't love paying fifteen bucks for it. read more

Literally the slowest service ever. I ordered on door dash and it took about an hour for them to make 2 half sandwiches. Someone needs to get Chick fil A's manager here bc a snail could move faster omg. And my order is wrong, when will I start getting the drink i'm asking for, if they do this they should notfity me at least and ask my preference read more

Well let's keep in theme, time for a compliment sandwich... the staff was very nice and the store was clean. (also brand new) I had high expectations when I saw it advertised. it was good for its category. I had the California chicken Phili. I wouldn't rush back but I'm glad I tried it, was a lot like subway but double the price 1 foot long by itself was over 15 bucks. The decor was cool makes you feel like your on the boardwalk somewhere. read more