Hello! Can't say enough about how cozy and delicious this little gem of a restaurant is in Sunbury. The apple fritters are amazing! Their creamed chipped beef is delicious. Portions are generous and everything is fresh. The retro counter inside is adorable. Everyone is very friendly. I have eaten dinner here in the past and it was always delicious. read more

Here's a firm but fair review that makes it clear the wait wasn't the problem--it was how you were treated: I normally enjoy coming to Jay Tiffany's, and the service is usually very good. I also understand that the restaurant gets extremely busy, so waiting to be seated was not the issue. Unfortunately, the hostess was unnecessarily rude and dismissive toward us. When she finally approached, she said, "Okay, so what are we doing?" in a very unpleasant tone. After I explained that we were waiting to be seated, she walked away without saying anything, quickly cleared and wiped down a dirty table, and waved us toward it. Because the table was directly beside the register, my friend politely asked whether we could sit at another available table. The hostess responded, "Yeah, I guess," rolled her eyes, and walked away. Her attitude made us feel as though we were an inconvenience simply for asking to be seated. I understand being busy and under pressure, but that does not excuse treating customers disrespectfully. This was especially disappointing because my previous experiences here have been positive. I hope management addresses this because one employee's behavior can really change the entire experience. read more

Whenever I'm visiting I always make sure to stop by this place for breakfast and dinner. The food is great and the service is top notch. They also have some very tasty dessert pies like lemon meringue and pumpkin custard. There are two team members I'd like to give special recognition to: Jayme and Melissa. They are very friendly and really enhance your dining experience. read more

See all

Server was pleasant, got the Meatloaf dinner which was good in flavor but a little dried out and serving size was on a smaller portion side, got fries with my dinner was only like 10 fries, applesauce was very good. Restaurant is a older eatery was clean. read more

Excellent staff. Great service. Good prices. This place is a staple of the area. Even short handed the staff delivered a great dining experience. Took my mother who is disabled and handicapped. They made her feel welcomed and the food was cooked to perfection. read more

Jay's Tiffany's Northside - Cornedbeef hash and eggs - American Near Me - Sunbury, Pennsylvania

Best diner in the 570. Delicious, home-style breakfast with a warm, comforting ambiance. Best bang for your buck.

Always liked their breakfast, went for dinner last night and won't be trying that again anytime soon. My wife and I each had the haddock, french fries, and coleslaw. The haddock portion was very small, the fries were cold, the slaw pure mayo. We asked for ketchup for our fries, eventually asked another table if they were done with theirs since the waitress never came back. Will go back for breakfast, no more dinners. read more

Their food is usually pretty good. I was a regular there when I lived in Sunbury, but the place is getting worn down and needs remodeled and lately the food doesn't seem as good. They need to take some pride in the restaurant and fix it up. Maybe they don't have the funds to do so. read more

This location is in a great spot in town, has great potential and would be a wonderful restaurant if these things changed. 1. Endure all crew are using and following food safety policies and procedures - I watched our server grab my toast with her bare hands. 2. Endure said toast isn't burnt. 3. Make sure the burgers being sent out are done to the specification of the guest. 4. Work with the chef to ensure the scrambled eggs aren't watery. Otherwise, it wasn't a bad experience. But there is definitely room for improvement. read more

Really wanted to find something good to say about the food since it took 45 minutes. Had the Biscuits and gravy meal, eggs were rubber, potatoes undercooked, biscuits very dry, and the sausage gravy should come with a warning regarding the sodium content as it was inedible. Decor is outdated by any standards, and if you even think you may have to use the restroom, do yourself a favor and hold it as they are abhorrent. Coffee was good and cup kept full though. read more

Jay's Tiffany's Northside - Biscuits and gravy. - American Near Me - Sunbury, Pennsylvania

We are not from the area. So we stopped in for breakfast. We had immediate seating. The restaurant is very dark and outdated. However, I did like all the antique pictures on the walls. The waitress came over pretty quick to us but we did wait at least 30 minutes for our food to come out. When it finally came out, it came out in stages. Mine was the last to come out and it was probably 5 minutes after everyone else's food came out. They were half way done eating by then. The portions are small. The prices were excellent. Food was ok. Not delicious but not terrible. My father frequents this place regularly on the weekdays and has never had an issue and likes it. I'm sorry to say I cannot recommend this restaurant and will not visit it again. read more

Worst server, worst food, worst out dated bathroom. Bathroom has no locks, with old torlets. The food is cheap, but not worth it. The server never cams back to help us, or anything. The portions are so small. read more

The restaurant is old, has an interesting smell and the decor needs updated, but the seating was immediate for our family of 6, and the service was really nice. We came for breakfast before church. I've lived in Sunbury for all my 32 years and this was my first visit here. The food was WONDERFUL! Our kids all cleaned their plates, which never happens, ever. I had the most amazing strawberry Belgian waffle, and my husband had the sausage gravy and biscuits. He said it could have used salt, but it was really good and you can add more salt. I will definitely be coming back again. read more

This place is a fantastic little mom & pop breakfast joint. No pretension. No fuss. No muss. Just solid food American menu, plentiful portions (and coffee refills), nice servers and lots of locals. Their pancakes are great and the omelets come with home fries, toast AND an apple fritter! Best breakfast in Sunbury! read more

Jay's Tiffany's Northside - "Tiffany" style stained glass adorns the walls and windows at this charming local breakfast nook. - American Near Me - Sunbury, Pennsylvania

See all

Ive been here a few times. This is a typical American diner. Bad food. Nice service. Old musty interior is desperately in need of updating. Breakfast is tolerable. Burgers are ok. Overall this place makes me feel sad. Really wish I had something positive to say. read more

Decent menu and food. Best thing about the entire place is that it is cheap and usually pretty quick. About what you'd expect out of a diner. Service is hit or miss. Sometimes they are really nice, other times they can be rude. But it's a good place to stop for a quick lunch on a work day. read more

Close this place. No value. I take it back I respect the family or owners too much. Fire the entire staff and get professional courteous people who want to be employed. Ignoring the customers and gabbing at the bar or playing with their cell phone is not what we come there for. Lazy, no motivation. The manager was nice and apologized. She needs to authority to make changes as she sees them. Sorry I had to vent I've been going there my whole life and I see it going away because of lazy worthless employees. read more

Mediocre food. Salad was good but everything else was obviously frozen entrees heated up. The floor was carpeted and dirty. There was a hint of animal odor or urine where I was seated. The service was friendly and prompt. Pricing was on the low end. This place has a lot of potential if the right people managed/owned it. Definitely needs a top to bottom cleaning though. read more

Stopped in for breakfast while car was being serviced across the street. Corned beef hash raw and cold eggs undercooked..Service was great coffee kept hot but they for sure need new cook read more

My salad and soup was ok. My wifes open faced sandwich was not on bread but on a ? made from hot dog buns. Pie was not fresh. Need a better cook. read more

Ate there for breakfast. Waited to get waited on for about 10 minutes. When my food came it was cold, and totally greasy. I used my napkin to get some of the grease off of my eggs and bacon. Never again !!!!!! read more

Never spectacular, never terrible. I have been going here since I was little and it's good food for the price. You can't order outside of the essentials really. The service is prompt and the waitresses are nice. read more

While Tiffany's is not a gourmet restaurant some of the reviews for Jay's seem a little harsh. Yes, it does need updating, but that adds to the charm a little. For those of us that know Sunbury, know that Jay's was once a Dutch Pantry Restaurant. The food is home cooked,and while it is not gourmet cooking it is PA Dutch cooking; red beet eggs, and they offer a salad that is a little different with a sweet and sour dressing. Many of the foods are made from scratch, mashed potatoes and soups, and many other dishes. It is a nice place to stop for breakfast, a quick bite for lunch or dinner. I have never received poor service and have always found the servers to be enjoyable. I have been visiting from out of town for many, many years. read more

needs cleaned! friendly server, salad was good and fresh. soup was canned or frozen, not very good.