What do I even say about this place!!So many flavors, all tasting top notch, fantastic service, clean environment, etc etc... So this ice cream parlor is located in the midst of downtown Milton.I have been here a few times and so far have tried three flavors that include coconut, cookies and cream and black cherry. Ahhh and black cherry will now be my most favorite, a flavor pre decided for each visit!Problem solved.LOL. The pricing is pretty reasonable too for two kid size scoops with waffle cone it comes close to $7. Each time I go there I make sure I try a few flavors before picking my ice cream and the staff is very friendly and generous in making customers try patiently before ordering. There is a long bench inside the shop and I believe a couple of tables right outside, they also have a city bench next to the shop. If in Milton do try their ice cream, you won't be disappointed. Cash or debit only read more

Jay's Ice Cream - Black cherry amazing!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milton, Ontario

They have lots of flavours available from regular ice cream to gelato. I got a scoop of their pistachio gelato. It was solid and even had small pistachio chunks in it. They are also dog friendly and we were able to get our pup a baby come as well! read more

Jay's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milton, Ontario

Jays ice cream: J: a big joke A: absurd ice cream named Y: No your welcomes S: slapping people around My ice cream melted as soon as I left!!! The place reeks of cologne and the lighting is blinding. read more

Great ice cream!!!! Jaydens a great worker!!!! fast and efficient!!!! Overall great experience!!!

Amazing ice cream in a wide variety of flavours. The staff is always on the ball and they need to be because the store seems busy all the time. It is worth the wait though. read more

Jay's Ice Cream - a display of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milton, Ontario

Every town's downtown has a little local ice cream shop. For Milton, that's Jay's Ice Cream! They offer over 26 flavours of ice cream, plus gelato, espresso, something for everyone! My bf and I had just finished eating at Mama's pierogies and needed a sweet treat after. And by sweet treat this does usually mean ice cream. Jay's ice cream was exactly what we were looking for. Service was quick and friendly. Prices are hella cheap. My bf and I both got single kiddy scoops. This came up to a totally of $5.55. Portions were just right. Just enough to satisfy my sweet tooth. I got the espresso flake (duh, anything coffee flavoured is my go to) and it was perfect. I thought the dark chocolate pieces were gonna get in the way but they were surprisingly tasty and did not interfere with the ice cream. I usually don't like nuts or chocolate chips in my ice cream, but the flakes were ok. My boyfriend enjoyed the strawberry ice cream. It's made with real strawberries! This place is the perfect place for a sweet treat. They're probably super poppin on hot summer days. Can't believe we're walking outside eating ice cream and October is almost over! read more

Jay's Ice Cream - Espresso flake. Single kiddy scoop. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milton, Ontario

Fantastic ice cream a lots of flavors and selections of cones.The stuff is very friendly and they were very polite and helpful to attend us.

Checking out Downtown Milton and I see a crowd of people flocking to Jay's Ice Cream. Quick Yelp check assures me this 4 1/2 star establishment is a safe bet. Lots of choices from ice cream, yogurts, sorbets and gelatos (which they can all make into cakes). They also serve coffee drinks from fair trade organic coffee beans. Epresso over gelato is one of their options that I'm definitely going to have to try next time. Most popular flavors according to the young man helping me: ICE CREAM - Chocolate Fudge Brownie - rich and decadent that's why I only got a kiddie scoop ($2.25) GELATO - Hazelnut Donatella - "A Ferrero Rocher inspired gelato with hazelnut, chocolate fudge & nuts". SORBET - Mango Family friendly ice cream shop decorated with bright colors and lots of chalk art. Benches inside to sit and wait for your order. One table inside and two outside to sit and enjoy your treats. A great place to grab something sweet! read more

See all

WHITE CHOCOLATE WONDER BLACK FOREST DREAMS Gelato , soft serve , milkshakes & any wayyy to many ice cream flavours to pick, this is definitely the place to fulfill that ice cream craving. Jay's ice cream shop is definitely must try while walking down main st. its definitely a fan favourite. SERVICE well staffed on a fairly busy summer evening with employees that have a great friendly attitude. They even brought out a bowl of water for all the pups outside ICE CREAM **** Pretty generous size scoops and pretty reasonably priced. The white chocolate wonder I definitely preferred over the black forest dreams but they were both pretty delish. Gotta have ice cream in a waffle cone , there's nothing better. PRICE The portion sizes are super generous , I think its well worth the money. read more

See all

Ordered a cake. It was just ok. Nothing special. Kind of small. It was not exactly what I ordered. I was told by the lady working there that she didn't make the cake. She didn't really care. Would not order from them again. read more

Wow! Found this place via google after apple picking and it was delicious!! Definitely want to come back. The kids tried bubblegum and tiger flavour which were good. We had the shire chocolate and Nutella which was really tasty! I'll be trying to come back sometime for sure! read more

Jay's is the perfect place to use up all that change that's been filling up your purse/pockets/drawers. $2.25 will get you a single scoop of ultra rich ice cream. Try the Heavenly Hash (aka Rocky Road). The taste lives up to the name, but there is something almost sinful about how much I love my ice cream. Haha! Quick tips: -Open till 8:45. -Cash only -The cones are ridiculously good. -One scoop is generous. You can't go wrong @ Jay's read more

The ice cream is pretty good wish there was more peanut free choices they dont take cash which is inconvenient because waiting in that long line on a summer day only too get into jays and have cash decline it and having to go home get my debit card and wait in that longgggg line again. read more

If you get the opportunity to meet Jay, you'll understand why his business is successful. Not only is he very friendly, he is also a very hard worker. In the short time I was chatting with him, I learned that he runs back and forth between two locations and does a lot of the work himself. My first few experiences were on hot summer evenings downtown Milton, when you can't say "no" to ice cream. The wide selection makes it difficult to decide on your flavour of the night. Whether you choose the cone or the cup, you'll get a good-sized portion. The location is great for taking a stroll, as the park is not too far away. There are benches outside if you don't want to stay inside Jay's to consume your treat. I ordered a birthday cake from Jay for an 8-year-old. The cake is purely ice cream, your choice of any flavours. Jay was more than helpful with his recommendations for combinations and size (depending on how many mouths you have to feed). Be sure to give Jay enough time to prepare the cake as the layering requires freezing in between. The decoration on the cake I ordered wasn't fancy, but was appropriate for an 8-year-old. read more

Amazing customer service, some of the ice cream cones are over priced like the baby one is $5 and it really small i can just take one bite and its gone i dont even need to chew it read more

Once again, my son, the yelper helper, and I went out looking for something to yelp about, and he had directed me towards Jays Ice cream. I suppose he spotted it when we were at the farmers market. So, off we go, and its not that big but its a busy little spot, so kudos on the main street traffic and bringing them on in. Well, the decor is inviting especially for kids, the selection is anything from gelato to conventional ice cream to some exotic flavors. Lots to choose from, thats for sure. Anyhooooo, we both had the chocolate brownie ice cream and it was awesome. Maybe next time on to one of those more unusual specialties they have but so far, we are getting off on the right foot, and i cant wait to go back read more

Jay's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milton, Ontario

Nice ice cream place! They have tons of flavours and many big fans ( mostly are kids) Jay's ice cream read more

Jay's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milton, Ontario

Every time - perfect ice cream. Helpful staff let you sample if unsure of flavour. On those summer days the line can be a little long- but so worth the wait! I have had milkshakes, ice cream in cups and their waffle cones. All delicious every time. My favourite is birthday cake and it feels like a present! read more

We were here visiting our friends and they took us to this ice cream shop as the kids were craving ice cream. It's a local ice cream store that is totally worth checking out. I had the white chocolate raspberry swirl ice cream and oh boy I was on cloud 9! It had chocolate chip bits with white chocolate ice cream and swirl of yummy raspberry flavor. I had it on a waffle cone. The shop he a nice atmosphere and it's great for families. If you have a sweet tooth, you definitely have to give this place a try. read more

Amazing ice cream! This cute little ice cream parlour in Milton is way better than any chain store. A wide variety of the flavours and friendly staff. Definitely a must try in Milton and will be going back! read more

Jay's Ice Cream - Nanaimo bar ice cream. Amazing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milton, Ontario

Great ice cream place. It is so popular here in Milton, I'd say everyone has been to this place several times. I love there cookies and cream ice cream! It's a classic and they do it so well. It's my favourite ice cream place to go to in the summer when I need something sweet and cold. Only cons is it's expensive! Worth it tho read more

Took the kids here on Monday. Ice cream tasted great. Tons of flavours. This is my go-to ice cream place in Milton.

We have been there a few times and it is really great. Lots of fantastic flavors.... superman / rum and raisin family favorites.... a must when in Milton read more

If your an ice cream fan and like big scoops, Jays is the place to go. Many flavors await you and after you score your delight, stroll the main street of downtown Milton and enjoy the various shops. Note: free parking is plentiful in our town. read more

Jay's Ice Cream is well priced, and very tasty. It's very good for kids and appealing and colorful. Love it!