I was gifted a six pack of Insomnia Cookies, so really, who am I to complain? If you haven't had late night cookies, available for carry out or delivery, you need to try this. I rate four stars instead of five because there is a truly 5 Star cookie delivery in town. For awhile Insomnia Cookies was the only game in town. But we're a couple years into the Crumbl experience and it is my preferred cookie shop. Insomnia has the edge if you like consistency of flavors, rather than the weekly rotations à la Crumbl. Insomnia Cookies are flatter and to my mind serving size manageable. One cookie (I hope) is a serving. Whereas at the other place, one cookie is multiple servings and you gain weight and take in too much sugar real fast! Insomnia Cookies is the originator of late night cookies in Madison and worth it especially near campus and downtown. Delivery beyond the local area is available so you can even gift your friend! From this insomniac and the company's college student insomniac founder to your eyes and taste buds, try it. Don't sleep on the oatmeal chocolate walnut. read more

I ordered online at 5:45 and by the time I called the store for the third time at 9:45 I was told by the manager on duty that "I needed to understand that there was a block party going on." There was no communication from the store that the delivery would take over half a work day to be delivered. We have the option to spend our money at so many places, and I will absolutely discourage anyone to patronize this establishment. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Company policy of delivery times. - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

They stole my order 3x in a row never delivering it this place is rancid and horrible read more

Took well over two hours for the order to arrive. Cookies were not warm. Will not order again.

Order was delivered two hours after order was placed. No option to cancel and when I called the phone number provided there was no answer. read more

I don't say this lightly--this cookie was unreal. Perfectly crisp on the edges, warm and gooey in the center, with just the right balance of sweetness. Every bite melted in my mouth. It tasted homemade in the best possible way, like it was baked with love. I've had a lot of cookies in my life, but this one raised the bar. If you're even thinking about getting one--do it. You won't regret it. read more

These are good cookies. Not amazing. Taste like homemade cookies, nothing to me in awe of. Crumbl has a little bit better cookies. The place is tiny and when it is a little busy, it's hard to get in or work my way around people. Coat isn't great for the not so amazing cookie. read more

Very sad chocolate chip cookie. Other cookies weren't better. Sugar cookie was also lopsided and small read more

Insomnia Cookies - Chocolate Chunk - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

Do you like cookies? Hot gooey cookies and brownies. And can't forget about the ice cream too, then you must stop in at Insomnia Cookies. When my husband and I went there, we met Logan that works there. He was the only one that was working there and he rocked it! I would have a picture of the whole brownie but before I could take the picture my husband ate some... My husband does not eat sweets so for him to eat and love this brownie was awesome read more

Insomnia Cookies - Chocolate Chocolate Chip Brownie - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I stopped through insomnia cookies to fulfill my late night munchie cravings after catching a comedy show on state. The servers were not particularly helpful in guiding me to cookie heaven, but I found my own way there none the less. It was the confetti cookie, peanut butter cookie, and Carmel cookie that took me to cookie heaven. These cookies aren't as good as Levain and some of the other cookie spots that we have in Chicago, but they sure did cost the same. I would recommend insomnia cookie for a single cookie, but if you're looking to feed a group of guys looking to get cookie wasted then I'd recommend trying somewhere else (cheaper). Overall, the cookies are good and worth a (one) try. read more

See all

The cookies tasted fine, but were served to us cold. We tried the original cookie, white macadamia, and m&m cookie. They didn't have that "ooey gooey" feel that the signs promote. They were good cookies, but nothing you couldn't get from baking at home. On top of subpar cookies, the service was horrible. The man who took our order was rude and made us feel rushed to order despite us being the only customers in the place. He tossed our cookies across the counter to us and did not make our experience as tourists pleasurable at all. After rushing us for no reason, he directed his attention to his phone. The ambiance was fine. No one was in the place except us. The colors and neon signs inside are cool but there is only seating for four people. After placing our order, we sat in there for a few minutes to people-watch and chat. Overall, cookies were average and service was poor. We definitely will not be returning. Take your dessert cravings anywhere else! read more

Best cookies ever. I'm not a fan of the huge, extravagant cookies like Crumbl. Insomnia does classics and they do them with perfection! I'm a huge chocolate fan but I always get a warm sugar cookie at insomnia and ugh so good, just melts in your mouth and is the perfect size for an after dinner sweet treat! read more

Had some cookies delivered to my mom and aunt. The first delivery kind of went missing but they fixed it and sent another immediately. Great cookies, great delivery, excellent customer service! read more

I love it here. I love the staff, they are so nice. I always stop outside the window and wave at them when I pass by, even when I don't order anything. They always wave back :3 it's great here, the cookies are always warm, so warm. And so good. Delicious. Mmmm. The s'mores cookie is my favorite, and then the confetti cookie is a close second. Also the chocolate chip cookie and double chocolate cookie. And the brownies. Anything you get here will be good. There is also seating, which is really nice. They also have giant cake cookies! Like, they're large cookies with frosting. The frosting is soooo good. Mmm. Yay. Yippee! read more

Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. We had cookies delivered to our hotelafter a long day exploring the city and holy chit these are some of the best cookies we have ever had. They are so damned good we ended up ordering the next night so we had some then and some to take back home with us. The double chocolate chunk and the peanut butter are out of this world good. Hell every one we tried was amazing. A little crispy on the outside and oooey googy soft and smooshy on the inside. If we ever go back to Madison this will be one of our first stops. If you haven't tried them you are really missing out. Ps. The strawberry ice cream was really tasty also! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Cookie delivery! - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

See all

They were good; I got the m&m And the chocolate chunk. They were melty, had a good flavor, but smaller than I anticipated. Would i purchase again? No. I have to be honest- if you are looking for cookies that will blow your mind, just go to Crumble. Crumble still has the best cookies I've EVER had. And worth every dime. Sorry Insomnia. read more

I don't even know where to begin. These are advertised as ooey gooey and FRESH cookies. Soft and melted and warm. These are anything but soft and warm. These cookies are burnt/old. I ordered the 24-pack minis. I cannot even get ahold of the store to talk to them about it. POOR customer service. Poor quality. Do NOT recommend. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Mini 24-Pack - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

I've been to this Insomnia Cookies location a bunch of times and I've always been satisfied with their cookies. They're always served warm and gooey which I love, and the service has always been great. Today I ordered a cookie cake for the first time and it exceeded my expectations. The printed picture and icing around the edges were executed perfectly and the cookie itself (I ordered a chocolate chunk base with buttercream frosting) was one of the best cookies I've ever had. It had a perfect ratio of chocolate chunks to cookie and the frosting really made it feel festive. The six inch cake was the perfect size for my three friends and I to share as a birthday treat. Also, they have a bunch of cute images that you can put on the cookie cakes that pretty much cover any occasion. I will undoubtably be ordering cookie cakes from here again! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

We placed an order online for delivery to our home. The order we received was not the order we placed. When we called Insomnia about the mixup, they immediately made it right! No hassle whatsoever, they resent the cookies quickly. And their cookies are wonderful! Thanks, Insomnia, we'll be back. :) read more

While I was waiting for a nearby store to complete my to go order, I had to wander. Luckily this place caught my eye. I tried two of their cookies - a PB Cup chocolate chip cookie and a double chocolate chip cookie. Both are as advertised - warm, gooey and delicious! This made the 20-30 minute wait I had worth it. Thanks Insomnia! (Cookies eaten too quickly to snap a picture) read more

On one hand, the cookies and ice cream are delicious. There is simply no denying that. They have plenty of flavors. On the other hand, they really are not worth the price. The production costs for cookies can't be that high because other similar establishments charge far less. Also, you definitely are not paying for the ambiance, because the inside is a little sad. Overall, it was pretty good, but not great. If you're in the mood, go ahead and stop by, but don't go out of your way to come here. read more

Great cookies with a taste of ice cream. This is a chain cookie restaurant traditionally located near college campuses. The price point for their cookies tend to be a bit high, but they truly are unique cookies. I would recommend trying Insomnia Cookies at least once. The service tends to be fast as the cookies are kept in a warmer. This location is right off State Street which makes it an easy grab and go read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

We had cookies delivered. They were hard as a rock, stale, and dry. We ended up throwing them away. Definitely not the warm, soft cookies that are pictured. read more

I mean you cannot go wrong with a warm cookie at 2am. I ordered the chocolate chunk cookie. It was delightful. I loved the giant chunks of chocolate amongst the dark chocolate bitterness of the cookie itself. I would stop in again for sure. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Never again! Those cookies smells so good and had no flavor! I'm sticking to Tiffs treats! read more

Insomnia has a certain place in the cookie world. Would you go out of your way to purchase a lot of these during the day? No. Is it good for when you need a warm cookie or two at the odd hours of the day? Yes. The only perk of these cookies compared to others is the warmth and gooiness that they offer. That's basically what your paying for when a single cookie is $1.35. Without that, it's nothing special. So either eat them in the first 30 minutes of purchasing or save your money and go get some from the store. The flavors taste as expected- my favorites are the white chocolate macadamia, sugar and the classic chocolate chip. I've used they're delivery service once or twice but it's really not worth it. Unless you're ordering a lot of cookies, the delivery isn't a good option. The delivery fee can be more the half of the order price. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Love the cookies they keep in the oven to keep them warm and fresh. Kids loved the ice cream sandwiches and yes, they post the calories. One traditional cookie about 250 calories. read more

I used to eat insomnia cookies all the time in college. So when we saw one in Madison, we had to stop. The store itself was very taken care of. There are multiple places to see the cookies and pick the one you want. I chose the Peanut Butter Chocolate cookie. The cookies are decent size and most of are very rich. The best part of insomnia is that they warm up the cookies. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Chocolate peanut butter cup - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Right next to Sencha tea bar! Warm cookies with hot tea is a great combo too!! Open late. Making Madison a better place to visit! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Madison, Wisconsin

Amazing place! Everyone is so friendly and the cookies are delicious. I always have a smile on my face when I walk out of this place. I would recommend it to anyone based on the service, friendliness, deliciousness, and overall greatness of this place read more

Came here at 11pm and got the peanut butter chocolate chip cookie. First of all, this cookie was great and the fact that its open so late for those sweet tooth cravings...two thumbs up. Add on top of that, that the cookie was warm when i got it. gosh how can you have it any better! The only issue I had with it was that for my one cookie..it was about $3.50! I'd rather make my own for that price...but if you're having a late night craving, ians pizza line is too long, and its 2am...this is the place to go! happy sweets eating! read more

Delivery driver decided to not complete the delivery and instead dropped it in the lobby of my building directly next to a sign saying not to leave deliveries there, then complained to me that I didn't pick up the phone. I am sick right now and have completely lost my voice, and they gave me no way to communicate this (it is important to note that this complaint was sent via text, so clearly they could have texted me if they really needed to reach me and chose not to do so). I shudder to think how truly disabled customers are treated by the workers here. Great cookies, repugnant customer service. read more

Went here to try some cookies and they were amazing! We ordered a six pack to go! So many flavors and choices.... Served fresh and warm! My daughter's favorite and one we said that is a must try would be the smore's! Cheers read more

I am developing a love/hate relationship with Insomnia delivery. LOVE: Cookies are still warm when they arrive, ice cream is still frozen when it arrives! The website and app are super easy to use! Wide selection and variety. HATE: the way I feel after I stuff my face. The only reason for the 4 stars was the attitude of the delivery driver. We ordered around 10pm, so not super late, but we were treated like we ordered after hours. He was pretty short with us when he arrived. I understand being tired and having a bad day, so his attitude won't prevent me from ordering again! read more

Quick and friendly service. Warm and soft cookies. Cold and tasty ice cream. Straight to the point...Best cookies ever! read more

Let's be honest. The cookies are reminiscent of the chain cookie places that used to be housed in the local shopping mall-I'm looking at you Mrs, Fields, Famous Amos or the Great American Cookie company. They are soft, warm, and contain enough sugar to bring on a sudden case of diabetes. But its after midnight, you are slight buzzed and need a sugar fix. You've come to the right place! read more

I ordered cookies online to surprise my son for his birthday. After the website stated that the cookies had been delivered, I called him and asked about the cookies. He did not receive them and of course the surprise was ruined. I called customer service (since you can't connect the store directly). I was told my son did not pick up the phone when they delivered the cookies. My son had his phone with him and had no missed calls/texts. Same thing on the second attempted delivery. The store claims my son didn't pick up the phone despite the fact that he was waiting for the call this time and had no missed calls/texts. As the buyer, I also did not receive any notifications that the delivery was unsuccessful (other than the charge on my credit card of course!) So while the concept of fresh cookies delivered to your door sounds nice, you may end up with the cookies NOT being delivered (despite a website saying it was delivered ) and a charge for the cookies. So I suggest you don't order cookies unless you can verify delivery! It's been 3 days and I'm still waiting for my credit! read more

The cookie was pretty good. I was just disappointed because I went all the way over there to use the spring deal which was a free scoop of ice cream with the cookie and they would not do the deal. They said it was only online orders even though the coupon said any purchase in store or online. It was a disappointment read more

My thoughts on Insomnia Cookies is that they serve a need. Everybody needs a warm, gooey cookie now and then - especially on a college campus. I went to school in Philadelphia, and we had one or two of these there, as well. Good for a chain, and the cookies never fail to disappoint. The cookies themselves are pretty well perfect. They are buttery, gooey, chewy hockey pucks filled with chocolate, peanut butter, and nuts. They are a little bite of heaven, if you are a cookie fan. There are normal sized and deluxe sized cookie variants available, as well as warm brownies. If you are going to go here, though, I recommend that you stick to the cookies; the brownies don't really compare. There are also ice cream sandwiches available, which are made to order and comprised of your choice of ice cream between your choice of normal sized cookies. The ice cream sandwiches are good, but again, I'd recommend sticking to the warm, gooey cookies. You can still get better ice cream next door at the Chocolate Ice Cream Shop. Oh, and did I mention that they deliver? Great option for late night study sessions, for those college students out there. read more

Can't complete a birthday delivery without making customer jump through hoops. After placing an order, with delivery instructions included, the company's policy of calling instead of knocking on a door of a small business (open to the public) was ridiculous. With no voicemail and a "delivery complete" on its online tracking, I was horrified when I found that it had not been delivered. No notification of delivery failure, instead I had delivery confirmation. (After calling "customer service" there was still no 're-delivery' after an hour, to a location less than a mile away, when their site boasts delivery times of 30-45mins. What was supposed to be a planned and completed treat for my mother at her work on her birthday turned into a frustrating and time/money waste from this so-called "business." If I could give this company 0 stars I would. Over two hours of this company's incompetence. Done with Insomnia. read more