Anne, the proprietor and teacher extraordinaire, has a breadth of knowledge re knitting that is unsurpassed. There is not a problem she can't explain, and fix, nor is there an exasperation she exhibits. The yarns are a candy store of colors, textures, samples and prices. There is a feeling of homeliness that just permeates her shop. She really does have the perfect yarn shop. read more

Wonder service and selection of beautiful yarns. The owner is very knowledgeable as well and always happy to help.

I absolutely love this yarn store. The owner was very helpful. I wasn't sure which yarn would best suite my project and she showed me several options that she thought would work. There is a great selection of yarn and I would highly recommend stopping in to check it out. read more

How this Infinite Yarns place gets the ratings it has here is beyond me. The owner is brusque and snobbish and will only help you if your in her clique. Why I returned this often is because I haven't learned my lesson, hoping she would have some redeeming quality and stop this "you are not worthy of being in my presence" behavior. Don't believe me? Join any knitting group on Facebook and ask. I visit my family near here often and that makes it so convenient and that's where I get sad and upset. Why can't she just be nicer to everyone, newcomers? Here are some reviews I read that confirm I am not the only one in FB knitting groups that have felt attacke: ‍. Why do I go into that knitting shop? Ugh. I need to find another. She drives me nuts!! It's not worth it. Really. You can if you wish. My friends and I stopped in and became victims to the abuse. I am new to knitting. Her snobbery seems to stem from cliques. Meaning she only has time for you IF you're part of her group. New to knitting here and asked her about signing up for a class which cost about $60. You'd think she'd be happy to have a new student. She told me how she didn't have the time, if I come Thursday's, she has others there, and wouldn't have the time to really sit with me. WTH? They are closed Mondays, and I forget about the issues with other nights. Thursday's best for me. Ugghhhh. I wish there was a place closer, or just someone else nicer. I may post in Farmingdale Bulletin Board group and ask if anyone has suggestions. read more

Patience in explaining instructions especially to left handed knitter! Large selection of yarns, books, and patterns to choose from.

I normally don't write reviews ever but I felt like I had to because the bad review from the lady saying "the owner is snobbish and not nice to newcomers" couldn't be more false. I just went in there for the first time and I know nothing about types of yarn and knitting/crocheting and the owner was so nice and explained everything to me. She was super welcoming and extremely kind and understanding. This place doesn't deserve a single bad review! read more

The owner is incredible!! patient and a great teacher!! The people there have obviously knit together for years but were welcoming and supportive to a newcomer like myself read more

I've been to this store several times before, but my recent visit made me stop and write this review. I'm working on a baby blanket for a friend having a little girl, who has specific colors she wanted. I found an awesome pattern, but the yarn they called for I could only find online, and when I'm making something I like to feel the yarn to make sure it's the texture/softness I'm looking for. When I came into the store I explained my conundrum to the woman who was working there, not knowing what to expect since I was asking about a product they don't carry. Instead of turning me away, she asked the yarn name, pulled up an app on her phone, advised me of its basic details (yards, gauge, etc) and then went on to advise of all the equivalent options I could pick up that would be almost identical. The baby blanket is turning out amazing thanks to the lovely ladies at this store, and their willingness to work with me!!! read more

This is the greatest store. The women there are so helpful. Great selection of yarns. I hope it never closes! I will be lost without this store. read more

See all

I was visiting from out-of-state and stopped by to check it out. Had a lot of crochet patterns which isn't the usual experience. May have to visit Farmingdale more often. read more

Nirvana for knitters. This is what all yarn shops should strive to be when they grow up - amazing selection of fabulous yarns in every color imaginable. Vast selection of patterns and books and samples galore, presided over by a friendly owner and staff so you can feel welcomed from your first visit. Flexible arrangements for classes and they are open on Sundays! I can't recommend this shop highly enough. Feed all your yarn cravings at Infinite! read more

I started going to Infinite Yarns after another yarn store closed. The store is cozy and inviting. There are high end yarns, and more moderately priced yarns. I like that there is something for everyone here. read more

I love Infinite Yarns for the exquisite quality, variety and selection of their beautiful yarns, trunk shows and guest artists. What I appreciate most of all is the invaluable knowledge, guidance, the sincere kind patience of the owner and her team. There is no attitude or judgement about what you do or don't know. All are happy to teach you anything you want. From beginner to expert, it is a joy to shop and learn. Every time I go there, I learn something new. It's a toy store for knitters, crocheters, you name it. Nirvana. read more

Beautiful store with a large variety of yarn. The owner is a sweetheart and is very knowledgeable. I will be going back many times. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Popped in there yesterday. The place was packed with knitters and I received help within five minutes! Awesome!

I'm a beginner and I found the owner very helpful when I went to check out the store tonight. She helped me find a compatible yarn for one suggested in a pattern that was discontinued. She also gave me tips on how to do cable knitting. I will definitely be back!!! read more

Very nice and helpful owner at this shop. I was looking for a particular, hard-to-find color of yarn, and tried to order online. Not feeling certain of the yarn weight or the color on my monitor, I e-mailed and called the store. The owner was very knowledgeable and friendly, in describing the yarn weights, colors and options. She was able to find exactly what I needed and shipped it out the same day. VERY NICE yarn shop! Highly recommend! Would definitely order from this shop again. read more

check all your dye lots. when buying three balls of debbie bliss baby cash merino, they sold my friend three balls. two were different dye lots, one was a third colour altogether. snooty, slow service and old inventory that's been sitting there for decades. read more

I love going to a good yarn shop. Knitting is a hobby I have just picked up after many years. There are so many things I don't know and when you are paying good money for yarn, It is so important to get help putting your projects together. I love that Anna and the other ladies are so helpful and nice. read more

its a wonderful shop, the yarns are beautiful. But the proprietor is a horribly rude woman!! just because i dont knit the same way she does means; i "don't know how to knit and i never should have taught anyone to knit at all." as much as i love that shop, its not worth the insult to go. read more

This is as good as it gets when it comes to exquisite quality yarn from all over the world. My mouth waters when I walk in there just thinking of the possibilities while looking at all of the gorgeous colors and textures. The owner & staff are incredibly knowledgeable & very friendly. There is an amazing wealth of information available from the patient, enthusiastic and supportive ladies who teach knitting & crocheting for all levels. Everything you ever wanted to learn about yarn or knitting is here. You will think you died & went to heaven. Infinite Yarns is not a snooty place, like other knitting stores. You will feel right at home, as if you are sitting in your own living room. It is relaxed and comfortable & a great place to learn & to meet new friends. read more

great store w/knowgble staff. got my eldest daughter school project yarn here. very happy