Finally got to stop by this local ice cream shop. It was nice not having to track down the truck…read morethis time. The store itself is simple, with no seating inside. There's a small merchandise area where they sell hoodies, T-shirts, and even a toy ice cream truck. I noticed they had a large selection of ice cream and really appreciated the assortment of cones available. The prices were a little higher than I expected, but the customer service was good. They also offer a BOGO sundae special on Tuesdays, which I definitely plan to take advantage of in the future. For such a nostalgic company, though, I do wish they had some seating so people could sit, talk, and enjoy their ice cream with family and friends. Overall, it's a fun stop for a sweet treat, but adding a small seating area would really make the experience feel more complete.

Came for a late night sweet treat to celebrate my moms birthday! I was surprised how small the…read moreselection of ice cream is considering this is an ice cream shop. I went with the ice cream burger which comes with 4 kinds of ice cream so I did Cookie Monster, biscoff cheesecake, chunky monkey and I forget the last flavor but it's sandwiched between two waffle cone 'pattys' dipped in chocolate with sprinkles-it was huge and very tasty! My mom went with the ice cream nachos which was waffle cone 'chips' ice cream and she chose peanut butter sauce. This was just ok-the pb sauce tasted like skippy pb-it does not compare to Ralph's peanut butter sauce at all. There's no seating so we took it to go but the prices seemed ok for what we got.

Milky Ways is a dessert lover's dream! Not only is the ice cream top-tier, but the endless array of…read morepossibilities makes every visit feel like a new adventure. With so many cereal mix-ins, toppings, and flavor combos, you can get as creative as you want--there's truly something for everyone! What really makes this place special, though, is the fantastic staff. From the moment we walked in, they were welcoming, patient, and super helpful in guiding us through all the options. You can tell they genuinely love what they do, and their enthusiasm is contagious. The ice cream itself? Absolutely delicious. Whether you go for a classic combination or something totally out of the box, every bite is packed with flavor and nostalgia. If you haven't been to Milky Ways yet, you're seriously missing out. Great treats, amazing people, and endless ways to customize your perfect dessert--what more could you ask for?

My daughter absolutely love Milky Ways, if you not familiar with their style of ice cream let me…read moretell you. You pick a cup, cone or shake. Then you pick an ice cream, next you pick a cereal, which they blend the ice cream and cereal together after it's blended you pick a topping then a drizzle. The Staff is super friendly and very nice. Sometime the service can be slow but that's because they making the ordered to perfection. The store is very very clean. And each table has a game on it like, Guess who, connect four, tic tac toe and uno. Which makes the wait extra fun. It's not too pricey. Oh, and for my non dairy peeps. I was told today that they have a non dairy vanilla options.

I've been coming to Papa Mia's since I was a child (it was the closest spot we could safely ride…read moreour bikes to and spend our $5 weekend treat allowance) it was always here, Wendy's, or an ice cream truck. So every time I get to come back (which isn't as frequent) it's a throwback to my childhood; but the water and cream ices still hit the same. My go to is the mint chip. I mean for a couple bucks you can get a taste of youth. It's a small hole in the wall style shack off Montauk Highway across from the golf course, with outdoor only seating if that, but just has this must stop at vibe to it. There's always some high school or college students working there who are fun to talk to and have great personalities (and they have to with being in a non air conditioned shed for hours at a time haha) For what it is, a simple ice hut, it's exactly what you need it to be. The furthest thing from fancy, but the closest thing to the 90s.

Big ass bomb ices yo this place slaps always has always will classic ass flavors water backed ices…read moreso know they orginal as hell!

I got a swirl with plain and the cappuccino. M I normally go to Forty Carrots in Bloomingdales for…read moremy frozen yogurt. This was not the worst frozen yogurt I've had but definitely not as good as what I'm used to. It's also extremely expensive for what you are getting. I paid $0.86 cents per ounce or $9.82 for a small cup that I didn't even fill up to the rim. Forty Carrots doesn't charge per ounce so you always get a full sized cup. Unfortunately, they do not offer a kids sized cup or small sized portion at all so it's not possible to buy anything smaller than a 12 oz. Cup. Ir would've been nice if they offered a 6 oz cup size let's say if you didn't want to blow a full days worth of calories on this.

Gotta say I love the marshmallow and cotton candy twist. Those flavors go amazingly together and…read moreit's not something I would've thought of on my own

BIRTHDAYS are special. My husband surprised me with a once favorite B-R cake. We have never had…read moresuch a horrid version of an ice cream cake EVER. The cake was "days old" hard. The filling was supposed to be ice cream. It was thick and gummy. The knife would not cut through the mess even though it was out of the freezer for almost an hour. $40.00 down the drain for nothing. We will never go back to the bohemia baskin robbins again. Beware.

Our ice cream cake was extremely fresh and was exactly the way we ordered it! A little pricey…read more(around $70) but did not disappoint!

Amazing -- I absolutely loved it! This is the best ice cream I've had in a very long time, if not…read moreever. The flavor, texture, and overall quality were outstanding. If you're in the Islip area, I highly recommend stopping by and giving it a try. It's definitely worth the visit!"

service is amazing. Ice cream is homemade and so good. When i come into coyle's i feel like i am in…read moreice cream wonderland.

Came to try out the new ice cream place and it was pretty good. There is a LARGE selection of ice…read morecream to choose from and the menu is large and very easy to read. In addition to just regular ice cream, they offer crepes with or without ice cream and waffle boats and waffle yachts. A waffle boat is essentially 2 fresh made waffles with a scoop of ice cream and your choice of topping and a waffle yacht is 4 fresh made waffles with 2 scoops of ice cream. My husband and daughter got the waffle boat while I got the waffle yacht (because I am a Queen and demand the fanciest of items). I had vanilla ice cream with cookie butter sauce and crushed biscoff cookies on top and whipped cream. They use actual real whipped cream from the can not like cool whip or dairy topping and the waffles are made pretty much on demand. This combination was absolutely dynamite and I recommend it to anyone and everyone. The ice cream was rich and delicious and did not melt instantly even though it was next to freshly made waffles. The scoops were a great size and the toppings were premium. The waffles are very dense (almost like the density of a zeppole) and are like a log shape. Different that what I am used to but very, very delicious. My petty grievances: the waffles are so thick you really need to be able to cut them with a knife but there were only forks available. The packaging is a large plastic container regardless of if you are eating there or taking it to go and overall as a vessel it is too large for the product. Also, if you close the lid with fresh baked waffles, condensation is going to form and melt the ice cream quicker. I had the employee leave mine open for this reason but we also dined in. Last but not least, the waffle to ice cream ratio is off. For 4 waffles, you need more ice cream. It should be more like 2 waffles 2 scoops of ice cream in a boat and 4 waffles and 3-4 scoops of ice cream in a yacht for optimal ice cream to waffle ratio. Petty grievances aside, I will absolutely be back all summer long because the ice cream was great. They also have a coffee shop inside the same location so you can get caffeinated as well before or after your ice cream adventures.

Not a great experience. They refused to make us espresso drinks (30 minutes before closing on a…read moreFriday night) and gave my daughter the wrong order and then reminded us they were closing soon. Not an overall welcoming feeling

The owner is a thief. I went in on the weekend and bought flying saucers and asked about the…read morespecial on the 6pack. The special was for March 21,Saturday and Sunday the 22 buy a 6pack and pay $7.99. I asked about it and was told there was no special. After paying $16.99 I came home and surprised my wife. She told me about the special and that I should have gotten for that. I went back to carvel and showed her. She said NO that I need a coupon for that price and tried showing me a coupon. It wasn't a coupon, it was the carvel website with the special on it and she was made aware that it wasn't a coupon. All of a sudden she couldn't speak English. She would not give me the difference in the cost and just kept on shaking her head as if she didn't understand. I tried to give her the benefit of doubt after hearing bad things about them but learned a valuable lesson.

I ordered via Uber Eats. Peanut Butter Cup Dasher. It was 99% ice cream. I called and spoke to…read moresomeone. I told him what happened and he said call Uber Eats. I asked him if I come down there, can u make it right? He said, "call Uber Eats." I asked him again, You would rather I call Uber Eats when you can make this right?" He replied, "Yes." I asked him his name and he said, "I am not allowed to give out my name." I sent a review right away and never received a phone call. Customer Service was awful and the employee didn't even care....

Came here while i was visiting long island and everyone was so nice! Wish we had one in Florida,…read morethe Java and Vanilla was delicious!!!

A typical pick your own frozen yogurt place tucked in a strip mall. Employees keep the place pretty…read moreclean. There are quite a lot of flavor choices and toppings. The frozen yogurt is pretty good.

Strong Island Ice Cream is one of those places that keeps you coming back. From the moment we…read morewalked in, the smell of the fresh-made bubble waffles filled the shop, and we knew we were in for a treat. We loved everything we tried. My favorite was the Bubble Waffle Sundae, while my bf is always a fan of the Peanut Butter & Jelly Milkshake. You can really taste the quality because everything is made in-house--from the rich, creamy ice cream to the warm bubble waffles and even the whipped cream, which I was absolutely obsessed with. What really made the experience stand out was the people. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and happy to answer questions. The owner was working in the shop when we visited, and he was incredibly kind, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about what he does. It's always nice to support a local business where the owner is so involved and takes pride in every order. If you're looking for homemade ice cream and desserts on Long Island, Strong Island Ice Cream is definitely worth the stop. Great desserts, great service, and a great overall experience. We can't wait to come back! By the way, there is plenty of parking, the walls are very insta-worthy if you want to take photos with your beautifuly constructed sundaes, and there's some seating, and very clean as well.

Homemade ice cream in the heart of Nesconset. Finally came by tonight and got a few ice creams to…read morego. Got the Burgundy cherry, Reese's cookie dough and cookies and cream. Very good ice cream but not a very strong flavor profile. The Reese's cookie dough was definitely the best out of all of them. Definitely worth it to check them out!