Granny's hands down has the best icecream!! My absolute favorite is the cake batter; they're never out of it and it always taste amazing. The have such a welcoming staff there, especially Olivia. She was so sweet and helped me with my order over the phone. I will always be a customer :) read more

This use to be my favorite icecream place.. the cake batter icecream is my absolute favorite. But Not a fan of the service and the attitudes I've experienced at times. Sadly, I'll be finding a new local ice cream place read more

Very great selection of ice cream, and it tastes great. If I lived closer I would definitely come more often.

I had a very bad experience tonight. I went in with my sister tonight to get milkshakes. We were given our large milkshakes and went to our car and tasted them. It was all milk. We went in very nicely and told them that we were sorry but it was all milk and the girl remade them. When she handed us the second ones we picked them up and noticed the large cups were only half full. We were very annoyed and pointed out that we had paid for two larges and were only given half of what we ordered. Each time we brought something to their attention they just laughed and had no concern that their customers were unhappy. I will not be going back. Granny's used to be the best but recently they have went downhill. read more

I want to urge you to read all the other reviews. There are all right on target about the quality of the ice cream and the number of different types of ice cream and flavors. However the other reviews don't mention the price. Cheaper then Baskin & Robins and Carvel and they also have a punch card. Buy 10 and get one. The down side of Granny's is reflected by my excessive weight. This is where I get my fix which I guess is better then drugs or alcohol read more

This place always has a a great selection of STOGO vegan ice cream, which is the only reason my girlfriend and I ever go. The staff is always very pleasant and you can sample any flavor before purchasing. It's great to see a local ice cream shop offer vegan options. I think it'd be even better if they offered a vegan milkshake option, using the STOGO ice cream with say, almond or soy milk. And vegan whipped cream! Those are really more suggestions than complaints though. Tasty stuff nonetheless! read more

Tried Granny's for the first time. Have heard really good things about their ice cream. Tasted the Mint Chip & Dbl Choc Chip. Both tasted really good (creamy texture & excellent chips). Got a small size of the Dbl. Choc Chip ($4.18 including Tax). Was a good amount for a small. The ice cream was really, really good. They have a lot of flavors all homemade. They also have Soft serve, Vegan & Gluten free. Will definitely go back to try other flavors again. read more

I don't even know where to begin. Everything was so delicious. I probably "sampled" more ice cream than I should have but they just all looked so good. I have always been a big fan of pistachio and I can honestly say that it was the best pistachio ice cream I have ever had. Definitely worth paying a visit. The owner, Rob, is a great and personable guy! read more

Was traveling through and wanted ice cream. I found this place online and the reviews were amazing so.......It was delicious! We started tasting a gluten free, then a diary free, both of which were exceptional. Ended up with coffee chocolate - YUM! And doublemint another YUM! Owner was very nice and we appreciated he was working his own store. Next time we're in Commack, we are sure to return. read more

This is the place to go to! Great customer service and best of all their ice cream selection is out of this world. The rainbow cookie and raspberry chocolate chip was to die for. I can't wait to go back! read more

Their ice cream is good as always but only gave 3 stars instead of 5 because the previous owner gave much much more ice cream in the cup size you ordered. read more

Great ice cream! I have a dairy allergy, so I enjoy their nondairy ice cream selection. They are very careful about using vegan spoons to scoop them out, so I trust coming here and getting their ice cream. read more

The prices alone at this place will already have you coming back from more. Less expensive than your average ice cream shop, and double the tastiness! I love to come to this place with my mom because she can actually enjoy herself by ordering their gluten free goods! Granny's has really set themselves apart by offering soy based products. They even have punch cards!! Great incentive for when I come back... because I can assure you... ILL BE BACK :) read more

Been going here for years. Never minded paying a little extra for ice cream . It was always worth it. Now, with the new owner the ice cream is still good, but he is filling the cups half way. Cannot justify paying that much for a half cup. The old owner used to fill the cups all the way. He is going to lose business by trying to save a few cents. read more

This place has delicious treats I go there every week and there stuff is so cheap and the employees are so welcoming.

I've been quite a few times before I saw this on Yelp, I always assumed it was in Southern Commack near Motor Parkway. But its actually located in the Northgate shopping center between Campa Pizza and a Haircut place. This place has a lot variety in ice cream as well as non dairy ice cream. It's relatively cheap and better than a Baskin Robbins. I believe their's a $10 minimum for cc's. I did get the Coffee Mud Pie coming off my Coyle's ice cream high in Islip, it was good but Coyle's is really on another level. read more

My whole family has been going to Granny's for years. This was my first time back in a while. I love their ice cream and frozen diet ice cream. It's very rich and creamy. I had a chocolate and vanilla swirl in a wafer cone and loved it. read more

Best ice cream around. Linda and her staff do a fantastic job. We order cakes from Granny's for all occasions and they use the most fresh tasting flavorful homemade ice cream to make them. All the flavors are awesome. Make sure to try the strawberry shortcake and cake batter flavors read more

Love this place!! Family run, small business with amazing selection of ice cream flavors. They also have vegan and sugar free ice cream for those who need it. The hard ice creams are my favorite here but the soft serve is good as well read more

Cake batter was dope... however service was slacking. Didn't appreciate feeling like a burden walking in at 7:50 and getting rushed out. Felt bad about asking to try a flavor and ultimately had to settle for the only choice I was allowed to try .. :( still will come back tho lol read more

Stogo vegan ice cream. Thats all you need to know. That and waffle bowls. Winning.

Not terrible, but definitely fell short of my expectations. It was pretty basic ice cream, even though the flavors looked interesting & tasty. The service was also OK, since the cashier was mostly awkward. The prices did not reflect the quality of the ice cream. It doesn't even compare to places like Kilwins or even Baskin Robbins ice cream. I came here for the small-business homemade feel but it was disappointing since the flavor was almost nonexistent. Most definitely will not be going back here again. read more

EXCEPTIONAL! Any type of frozen treat you want, they have it: soy options, gluten free options, lactose-intolerant options, sugar free ice cream, full on creamy ice cream in a large variety of delicious and unique flavors, very good and rather authentic gelato (based on my experiences in Europe), fat free frozen yogurt, and pre-made frozen dipped cones, cookie sandwiches, mini mini mini cones, and tiered ice cream cakes. But my absolute FAVORITE option is one you can't get pretty much anywhere else on the island, or even in NYC -- the elusive frozen-yogurt product called "Only 8." Only 8 is special because its preservative free, good for lactose intolerants, doesn't use refined sugar OR sugar free sweeteners, has natural flavors, and is undoubtedly lower in calories than any other "low calorie" froyo on the market: roughly 8 calories per ounce, meaning 32 calories per 4 ounce/half cup serving, as opposed to 25-30 calories per ounce, or 100-120 calories per half cup as found at Red Mango, Pinkberry, Tasti d'Lite, Sixteen Handles, or almost any other place. But the real reason for Only 8's name is that it's made using just eight all- natural ingredients. BUT BACK TO GRANNY'S! Granny's makes it special because they always have three to four cool flavors. I always try to get something new, but my favorite is Chocolate Banana. The last thing I'll say about Granny's is that the service is so friendly and personal. It's family-run, and the owners take the time to remember you and learn you're name if you're a regular. Try it out as soon as you get the chance - and definitely bring your friends. read more

Delicious creamy Ice cream place that has a lot of varieties. They also have vegan ice cream and chocolates that look great.

I have to say that when I first found out about this shop a few years ago, I was so excited. As a Vegan - there really aren't many places to get something refreshing on a hot day while you are out and about. I live about 40 out of the Commack area - but at first I thought it was worth it. The last 3 times that I have gone there, I have been very very disappointed. They don't make the Vegan Ice cream all of the time. The first time, the Vegan barrels were completely empty - the 2nd and 3rd times the barrel has very little left. When I asked the girl behind the counter about it - all I got was an "oh well". I will not be going back there again. read more

Used to love going to Grannys and enjoy their selection of ice cream but this summer the owner and workers are not helpful. 3 workers and owner in store but only one helping the customers while the owner and other 2 are sitting in the back talking!!! read more

Friendly staff serves a wide variety of ice cream, gluten free products, yoghurt, gelato. Wonderful neighborhood ice cream and candy parlor