SUGGESTION - make reservations for lunch or dinner since it is right next to 2 theatres that show plays -- food, service, ambiance were first rate -- had the shepher's pie with caesar salad and coffee everything was excellent - would go there again - read more

Went on a Friday night before a show with a pretty large group and they were able to accommodate us without any issues. Service was efficient - we were able to order, eat, and pay in time to comfortably make it to our show without feeling rushed. I ordered the pan-seared salmon with mango salsa, spinach, and mashed potatoes, and everything was delicious. The salmon was cooked really well, and the mango salsa added a nice freshness. Some of my friends ordered comfort dishes like the shepherd's pie, which also looked really good. Overall, it's a solid spot if you're looking for something reliable and tasty around the Theater District before a show. read more

Hurley's - Pan Seared Salmon with mango salsa, sautéed spinach, and mashed potatoes - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

I work in the area. Used to go once a week for lunch. Paul, one of the owners recently retired. He was a true gentleman. Once he left, they wasted ZERO time in jacking up their prices. They went from a steady group of stagehands and business ppl in for lunch every day and basically said "screw you". They dont care about the regulars that made that place and keep it going when tourists arent there. Thats no way to treat loyal customers. I wont be going back and speaking to many ppl from my bldg, they will not be returning either. Chasing away long time customers to appear more upscale, corporate or whatever look they were aiming for is a slap in the face to the ppl who kept that place open during covid and days when it was slow. never thought id wish an Irish bar to close but they shot themselves in the foot read more

Out of all the places in NYC for a dive bar with food, this place is just not it for a number of reasons. Nine of us came in around 9:30 and there was a ton of room in the back with tables we were able to sit at. However, once we sat at the table they pretty much shoved the menus in our face and kept asking us what we want to eat before even having a chance to open up the menu. All of us wound up ordering drinks, I got an espresso martini (which wasn't good). I then ordered the pretzel with beer cheese to snack on (this was just buttery and kinda stale and the cheese was terrible). My friend asked the server for water because she wasn't in the mood to drink, he then asked her about food and she was still looking at the menu. He came back around and she asked for water again and he once again asked her for her food order which she said she was still looking at the menu - which idk what the problem was because she was snacking on my pretzels with me and everyone at the table was drinking. After 20 mins she got up and went to ask the guy for water and he got mad at her for not ordering food first- this was just crazy, what if she had a medical condition or anything for that matter where he would just deny her water like that because her food order has yet to be placed when everyone at our table was spending money. She eventually wound up ordering a buffalo chicken wrap with fries, the French fries were good but the wrap was mediocre at best. Our table also ordered buffalo wings that were well done and had no flavor. When we asked for the bill they tried charging us for extra items we did not order which was just the icing on the cake. Easily first and last time here. Check out the Playwright or the Mean Fiddler which is around the corner if you are looking for a pub to hang out at. read more

Cute little pub-like restaurant! Went for St.Patrick's day and service was still very quick! Great bartender and even better food! read more

See all

Guinness was good, bartender was very quick and nice. Unfortunately, they're charging $10 for a baby pint... beware. read more

Hurley's - 16oz Guinness pour... - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Needed a bar to host a big group and Paul hooked us up with a great area! The bar itself was spacious with a great sound system and reasonably-priced drinks. A midtown gem - we'll be back for sure! read more

The reuben was so good! Other people in my party got, different items, which they said were just okay. And would say the same for the fish and chips as I got that as well. But I was extremely happy with my reuben, and would get it again! read more

Service was quick and attentive. Its an old bar that's been open since the 1800s and looks nice. The food was pretty good. The cod didn't have much flavor on its own but with the tomatoes it tasted very good. The steak was cooked true to medium and it needed a little salt but overall he was satisfied with it. read more

Hurley's - Cod with spinach and mashed potatoes - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

In and out in 30 min with simple chicken fingers and fries. It was ok. Lacked flavor. Right near our Broadway theatre which was what we needed. read more

Hurley's - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

For a little bar/pub, I found it to be pretty great! There was no wait on a block with so many theaters. The service was rather quick and efficient. The food was kinda exactly what I thought it would be. I was in the mood for bar food and it didn't disappoint! I'd definitely go back before or after a show! read more

See all

Took a chance pre-theater and we were not disappointed. Hadn't made reservations anywhere, and we were walking by (as we had dozens of times before) took a look at the menu, and figured that everyone in our party could find something to satisfy them. The hostess was lovely, and gave us a round table upstairs with a view of the street. Service was prompt and our server was very helpful with menu questions. The table agreed that the fried calamari was some of the best we've had in a long time. The chicken Caesar salad had warm sliced grilled chicken and was excellent. Nice variety of desserts and prices aren't too out of control. read more

See all

This place has along bar but we sat down at the end . At first we got menus and I ordered the Stella in the Stella Glass . The menu is very huge here . They offer a pre fix Theater menu for under $50 . I ordered the Ruben sandwich on rye bread! It comes w/ Russian dressing, sauerkraut. And a side of fries , or chips as the say . My friend ordered the shrimp tacos. W/ blacks beans and rice ! You get 3 to an order! We then proceed to get there chicken wings which come 10 to an order! Blue cheese is there dip! The wings could have used one more turn for the sauce to go in the wings , but otherwise it was great! The place is very nice it's has a mongany bar . Lots of booth . This bar goes around w/ 2 separate entrances to go in ! The bartender was great here w/ serving us too! Lots TVs for games here to watch . read more

See all

Perfect place to wait out a storm before heading to Longacre Theater before a show. Pricey, sure, but everything is in this area. Also, super clean unisex bathrooms, signature cocktails & excellent wait staff & bartenders, so I hope that some of that extra cash patrons fork over is passed along to them-they truly made the experience superb! read more

See all

Great atmosphere and service. Not bad bar food either. Would definitely recommend and return next time we're in the city

We visit Hurley's every time we are in NYC. It never disappoints. We had the fish and the steak and loved it. We like to eat on the second floor. Our waiter offered excellent service. Great bar on the ground floor as well as on the rooftop if you want to have a drink before or after a show. read more

I ordered a Shepherd's Pie. The filling was bland and tasteless. The only good part of it was the mashed potatoes. Essentially, I spent $25 for mashed potatoes. Service was fine. It was loud, as a sports bar usually is. I only went there because it was a few doors down from my theater. I will never go back. read more

We had a great time here! Drinks were great and cold. The staff was very good. The food was pretty good. We enjoyed our experience here. It was a nice place to go before the show and we thought that everything we experience to is pretty tasty. read more

See all

Good place to stop before or after a show. Long list of beers on tap. Good service. Menu is simple but food is delicious.

I love this cozy bar. The place was dressed up for Christmas and had a nice vibe. Overall the food is pretty good for bar food. The soft pretzels were amazing and the mustard and beer cheese were fantastic. The pub burger was good too and they even cut it in half for us and served onto two plates since we were sharing it. I liked the French onion soup as well, which was decadent and flavorful. I was hankering for a warm cocktail and they offered to make me a bailey's coffee even though it wasn't on the menu. It was just what I was craving! read more

See all

Very fun TIMES SQUARE BAR SCENE....cool old booths for seating...cozy lighting great menu of bar food...Irish cheese fries...with a brown gravy dipping sauce...great menu..excellent servers...lobster bisque...excellent texture, & flavors! Perfect location,lovely decor ! Highly recommend for post theater drinks & eats! read more

Hurley's - Exterior...they even have outdoor dining...great location...cool saloon style bar & great restaurant opposite the bar! - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Had a surprisingly great meal here for a midtown pub. Service was also fast and efficient. Hangar steak cooked nicely, salmon was fresh (although had to ask for the sauce). Good buzz in the dining room. Appetizer, entrees for four, two rounds of drinks and a shared desert, all under 90 minutes. Had enough time to make 8:00 showing and get drinks before curtain. Great meal without breaking the bank. Will be back and recommend to others. read more

Great spot for a pre-show snack and beverage! The hot cider and bourbon cocktail was perfect before the very chilly wintery matinee performance of Hadestown right across the street at the Walter Kerr theatre. The staff was attentive and pleasant. Highly recommend Hurley's!! read more

Came here RIGHT after the first night of a show at the Longacre (point of clarity it's been awhile since a shows been in this theatre I believe) and naturally we all we next door to the bar and hung out with our friends to talk about the show and eat. I sat at the bar tonight and STEVEN was a fucken ROCK STAR! I normally don't stop to write a review mid meal but I had to because the bar is packed and he is just doing an amazing job! Food is coming out HOT and FAST and is tasty, drinks are good and it's a fun vibe! DEFINITELY recommend! Hopefully you get Steven! read more

Hurley's - Chicken wrap, gin and tonic & onion rings - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

GREAT place to watch sports. I dropped my family off to see a Broadway show and I was looking for a bar to watch football. The theater usher recommended the bar across the street called Hurleys. What a great bar and experience. The bartender was so welcoming, set me up right in front of my game, and recommended a great cocktail, called Sex on the beach. I was lucky enough to sit next to two sports enthusiast which made the game more exciting. The bar is really long with two sides, and lots of Tv"s. When I first came in it was a little quiet then out of no where the bar filled up. The bartender was so calm and pleasant through all the chaos's. I've been to bars in NYC where the bartender's are so rude and act annoyed your there, not here. Alicia was the bartender and through it all she was so upbeat and fun. I left her a nice big tip for her hard work. She was so thankful she actually came up to me and shook my hand, she was very grateful for the tip. Class act. We don't live in New York but will definitely be back to Hurleys when we do. Great stuffed clams FYI. read more

Convenient to the theater, we were seated and served immediately. I had the southwestern chicken salad, which was delicious - generous portions of guac, chicken, corn, and black beans on a large plate of lettuce. My aunt had the Reuben and said it was "excellent." Our server was very attentive and had the check to us in plenty of time to make it to the theater. read more

Hurley's - C - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My husband and I came into NYC from NC to check out the Christmas decorations and shows. We were walking down the street and saw a sign for hot bourbon cider and thought, great way to warm up. Hurley's is very inviting with great decorations and warm staff. We were just coming in for a drink but after being entertained by the bartender we decided to stay and eat at the bar. Alicia the bartender is fantastic. She makes you feel like you have been coming to the bar for years, like cheers. She's supper outgoing and funny, it was a great experience and definitely would recommend Hurleys to our friends. Look forward to coming back next time we are in NYC. read more

Love Hurley's...have been going there for 15 years. Great food and service at reasonable prices. Particularly for midtown!

Bad experience. The bartender or the chef must had missed one of my orders. I had waited for more than 60 min for the second dish after pushing twice. The fish was overcooked and tasted tough. The bartender didn't think anything unusual while no any sorry. read more

See all

This historic establishment is built for show people! I stopped in before my Broadway show was to start and got seated immediately. I ordered the steak salad and it came out soooo quick!! They know you're trying to make a show. And it was delicious! I must stop if you're seeing shows on that street. read more

Hurley's - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Beer list w NO PRICES... ...BIG TURNOFF for me Wife had $16. Martini Be Aware....check comes w 20% gratuity already added !! Atmosphere 5 out of 10 Won't be back.... ....too many better places read more

Packed and raucous bar, the two female bartenders killed it ,keeping the crowds drinks fresh

How have I never reviewed Hurley's before? We have eaten here quite a few times, whenever we are in NYC for sure. The food is good, very good in fact. There is something for everyone and is perfect before a show or after for dessert. The service ia always prompt to attract theater goers and I suspect if it is just friends gathering, also prompt but not rushed. Most seating is upstairs and decor is attractive and fun. We of course like the "private" booths. Prices are good too, a surprise in the Times Square area. read more

Solid place....they were super bust for st. Paddy's day. Stopped in for a pint and some baked clams. Both were fine. read more

Hurley's - Hurleys - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Good place for a drink pre theatre drink. Service was slow. Ordered the chicken tenders, it bland and dry. read more

Hurley's - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

It was so bad. I stuck with easy appetizers and an old fashion. The drink was so bad! I couldn't finish it. The hummus was gross, and even the carrots looked old. Avoid this trap. read more

Hurley's - It was the worst old fashion ever made. - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Great burgers..very nice pub near the hotel (in for Peter Gabriel). Great obscure music in house. Very nice bartenders. Simple review for simple fare. read more

I stumbled upon Hurley's hoping to scout out a fun bar for me and my friends. I walked in, ordered a drink, asked where the restroom was. When I returned there was a bill next to my drink. When I asked the bartender why she rang me up she said, "oh, I thought you were just here to use the restroom." As a bartender myself, if you're going to assume things about your customers you are not cut out for this line of work. For reference. This was a Sunday. The bar is not a full capacity. read more

Hurley's - a group of people sitting at a bar - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

Honestly, I was surprised and delighted. Some establishments in this area don't care because they don't have to. The food was really great and the service was awesome. They operate as a team and that makes everything flow. I did the Pre-Fixe menu with French onion soup, steak (done perfectly), and chocolate mousse cake. And the mojito was good too! read more

Hurley's - French Onion Soup - Pubs Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Oh my, how far the mighty have fallen. Being in the heart of the theater district is beyond valuable! And the huge space makes it profitable, but I am sorry, I was spoiled when I used to go to their original place in Rockefeller Center (... all right decades ago), where it had a more upscale appearance, and the most amazing crispy duck signature dish. Don't get me wrong, the food is okay, just not more than okay. I even held an event, renting out their upper floor some years ago ... it was great and they gave us our own bartender (cash bar), and we took good care of each other. Great staff; friendly and attentive, which is hard to do with such a large crowd, I am impressed by the staff. read more