On September 10, 2026, I purchased a vehicle from James and Andy (Owner) for $3,000. Less than 16 hours after the transaction, while driving the vehicle home, the engine experienced a catastrophic mechanical failure on Karcher Road in Nampa, Idaho.
I contacted the owner, Andy, to request a full refund of the $3,000 purchase price. He declined, citing the "As-Is, No Warranty" clause in the purchase agreement.
During our discussion, the following occurred:
The owner offered a replacement vehicle listed at an additional $2,000 above the original price. I declined this offer after identifying issues during the test drive.
When asked about the frequency of mechanical issues in $3,000 vehicles, the owner stated it was rare.
I requested an even trade for a different $3,000 vehicle of equivalent value, which the owner declined.
As a result of the unresolved dispute, I am initiating formal complaints with the Idaho Transportation Department (ITD) Dealer Services, the Idaho Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division, and the Better Business Bureau (BBB), as well as pursuing legal remedies through civil court.
I am currently collecting documented accounts from individuals who have had similar business experiences with this dealership for informational purposes. read more