We recently had an event at the upstairs room of the venue and I was thrilled with the service we received. Alexa & Sean could not have been more hospitable! I am GF and Sean immediately made me feel comfortable and got me a delicious chicken and cauliflower meal. He is great at his job. Alexa also was fabulous. She was the main bartender at the event and was kind and worked very hard to make everyone happy. I would totally recommend having an event here! The downstairs bar is nice also. It's a great place to hang out. read more

Horseshoe Tavern - Upstairs - New American Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

I've been here for a few more trivia nights and have tried their cucumber avo shrimp salad which is a winner for me. I did come back for ribs and found I wasn't as impressed as the first time I had them surprisingly. Staff are always wonderful. The place does get super loud and a little cold with the AC so as long as you're prepared for that, it's a good time. read more

Horseshoe Tavern - New American Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Horseshoe Tavern is a great casual bar to watch a game or hang with friends. I enjoyed the wings which are available as half or full orders. If you order a full, then you can try two flavors. I tried the lemon pepper and garlic parmesan wings. Both were very tasty and flavorful. The portion was generous and wings were filling. I also tried the dulce de leche cake which was also good. All in all, I would be happy to return to Horseshoe. read more

See all

A friend of mine and I got together to get dinner. When we arrived we parked on the street nearby. We walked in and sat ourselves. Kelly was our server, and she was great! We ordered the chicken sliders and the shrimp cajun shrimp penne pasta. It came out quickly. My sliders weren't bad. I just were a little too well done. I tried the pasta, and that was good! I also enjoyed the vodka martini. All in all I had a good experience! read more

See all

Fun place to watch sports, hang out, and eat! I was there Wednesday for some trivia which was fun too. I had a chicken sandwich which was good! I came on a busy night between trivia, a nice weather evening where people were likely looking to get out, and sports being on, so wait staff was busy, but wouldn't stop me from going back to Horseshoe another time! read more

Hands down! Best burger (Angry Burger) I've ever had in my life. Burger patty was excellent. Cooked perfectly and jalapeños were grilled rather than pickled. Grilled onions as well. So perfect on Brioche bun. Also, bartender (Stephanie) was incredible,made the experience that much better. Great personality. Next time in Morristown, plan on stopping in. Open until 2am is a plus as well. read more

Was eating at the bar.. security took our seats and said they needed to make room (... it's possible they thought my sister was finished because she put a napkin to cover the spit out hair she found in her burger) they didnt take the seats from the guys next to us that were not eating. We left. What an awkward experience. read more

See all

Great food, very pleasant staff, nice atmosphere. Try the bacon wrapped ribs app! Salads are very generous!

Food was okay. It was a typical quesadilla. Service was fast, but I came at a non-busy time. The restaurant was situated around the bar, with seating around. During the day, you could get some natural light from the windows. When back later and got some drinks. At night, they open up black lights. It has a pretty nice vibe if you just want to stand around the bar or sit at a table. read more

The Horseshoe Tavern offers great food at decent prices. The staff provides good service, and it's a comfortable, nice atmosphere. Not too dark, not too bright. The music's usually not too loud. Plenty to watch on the TVs. Best wings in the area, a really good cheeseburger and a very tasty Chicken Parm. (Drunken Chicken) Prices today are generally too high IMO, but the quality here makes up for it. read more

Great place for sunday football or any sports. Gets crowded but great beer prices and just an overall good time with friends and family. Definitely not a place to sit down and talk while the games are on! Exactly what you want from a local sports bar. Quick service, modest beer selection and good pub food. read more

Great place for a drink and apps. Came here for a quick drink and some apps with some of my friends. I was very happy with their COVID precautions- everyone had a mask and the tables were all socially distanced apart. The food was pretty good and pretty standard pairings with your drinks. Would recommend if you are in the area! read more

See all

Fun place to get whacked eat crappy food....smell when you leave kinda bar. Love it!!! Owned by the Walsh conglomerate in town, they have a ton of places to get drunk at and people do!! Whoohoo!! Their kitchens are microwaves, but the beer is cold! Great prices , good bartenders, their bouncers will assist you and our cops there are friendly. Cheers read more

Went after checking into hotel and grabbed a late lunch. Sat at the bar, it is a bar! Heavy drinkers here. But my focus was lunch. The spicy chicken sandwich was crazy good! It had a kick to it, the slaw on top was yummy with the spicy chicken. The fries were coated but had a good bite! The food was hot! The side of the sandwich is split'able. The fries were extra charge but worth it. The service was friendly and very attentive! They even served SPRITE! My lucky day! As I said, it's a sports bar but it would be nice to see HGTV son one channel!!! Ha ha I know I'm reaching. It sure looks like the perfect spot to come drinking. Maybe next time. read more

Horseshoe Tavern - Spicy chicken sandwich - New American Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

PROS: This place was a very unique bar to go to. It had games, a lionel train that circles the place, a country theme to it, and more TVs than a usual bar its size. The staff was very nice and they kept the place clean. For a bar they had a good amount on the menu and many draft beers to choose from. CONS: Like many places in town there isn't a whole lot of parking for it. The bathroom could also be jammed since it can only accommodate a couple people compared to the amount the bar normally takes in. OVERALL: Definitely a bar I'm planning on going back to. Minor setbacks won't stop me from enjoying lunch here while I watch a game on one of their many TVs. read more

We arrived multiple hours late to our Hotel nearby due to weather delays and had been at the airport for hours so we were hangry! We left the hotel and crossed the street to a place that looked like Italian but they were closed. Just a couple of doors down was this unassuming tavern. They served food/drinks and would work for our needs at that time. Boy was I wrong, it was soooooo loud that we couldn't hear one another talk, but the food was huge portions and all three items we ordered were really great! Calamari was crisp, fresh, and tender! Dipped in their homemade marinara set it OTT! Husband had the fish n' chips and I had the cheesesteak. We weren't expecting much for either but we were pleasantly impressed by both dishes! We normally eat before 6 and this was going on 8:30 so neither of us wanted to eat huge amounts of food that late but it was a challenge to stop when we did because the food was so good! The service was much better than anticipated, as well, as they were so packed but we never had to look around to find our waitress. Certainly worth a stop, if you're in the area. None of the fried food was greasy but it looked like it was going to be. read more

Horseshoe Tavern - Philly Cheese Steak - New American Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Horrible service. Sub par food. Scam restaurant. They water down drinks so much it's a rip off.

Great service yummy fried pickles. Relaxed atmosphere for a drink or two. Music is high but enjoyable.

Great bar. Anna, Brielle, and Andrew are some of the best servers I've seen. Drinks always full, food is always great. 10/10

Love it. Good beers, good people, great food! Had to tie one on here and just really enjoyed the environment, ambiance and decor. Will be back! read more

Horseshoe Tavern - New American Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

Went here for the first time with my boyfriend for some drinks and food. The vibe was amazing! Every age range so you didn't feel out of place. The food was amazing. What makes this place is the service. I have never been somewhere where you had 4 people come to ask if you were ok or needed anything. Words cannot express how incredible it was. It did get a little weird for us around 9 when it turned into a club and the 20 something year olds started bumping and grinding. Cannot wait for our return! read more

I came here with a group of friends to see a band called the Amish Outlaws,( yes their really Amish, but left their homes and never returned during Rumspringa.)They don't play often in my area so our group decided to make the trek to Morristown. I ordered the tickets online, and to my surprise when I arrived I was greeted by a very nice door man who checked us in and asked if we purchased tickets online or if we needed to purchase them at the door. I let him know we purchased them online and he directed me to the girl behind the counter. The checkin was fast and very organized . The girl had pages and pages of names of who paid online and she looked it up and found us in two minutes, and then we were given wristbands. Usually it takes forever to check in when you purchase tickets online, not this place! Horseshoe Tavern has a really nice large bar on the main floor. It takes up 3/4 of the entire room. There are some booths on the outer edge of the room for dining and sitting with friends. I didn't try the food but it did look good for bar food. They also serve a late night menu. Across from the bar area are a set of stairs that lead up to the second floor and they have a DJ playing while the band played. The crowd at Horseshoe Tavern was mixed, college students, 30's, 40's 50's etc. This place also has skee ball and comfy sofas and places to sit and mingle on the 2nd floor in the Raven Room. It can get very crowded and does get very loud when the music is playing so talking is All the bartenders were very nice along with the entire staff. The drinks were good, and Horseshoe Tavern was prepared for the very large crowd this band draws. There are also many flat screen tv's for viewing sports events. I was lucky, my friend found a parking spot on the street for free because it was after 8pm otherwise it's metered. If street parking is full, you can park in The Dalton Garage on Cattano Ave behind Century 21: If you arrive after 5pm there is a flat rate of $3. Anyone who is exiting the garage after 9:45pm does not pay- the gate is open and you drive out. (You still take a ticket upon entering) There is also self parking at the Hyatt Regency on Speedwell Ave if you are staying at that hotel. I would definitely like to return to sample their food and catch another band. read more

See all

this place is super loud lol. good for a night out. the food not so good. i got the loaded tots. i asked for no onions and jalapenos (one is stinky and one is spicy for me).......mainly tomatoes, bacon, sour cream, cheese, and ranch? odd combo but ok. the tots were crispy but greasy! it was a lot for just me. i was meeting people and i didn't think i was gonna share. everyone was either drinking or eating their own food. i wouldn't order that again but i would probably come back to the place becuz its not bad. seemed to have mainly after work guys or polo collar type shirts men lol. read more

A saloon by any other name ... I like loud music -- a lot even. And I like beer -- and eye candy too. All available here in abundance. But when this joint is full and the music is cranked to the same volume as front row seats at a Led Zep concert -- it is impossible to talk, hear -- even think. Maybe that's the point. :)) read more

Nice spot to grab drinks with a friend, catch a game or just go in for a late night with the group. Bar is the best place to start and the dj is great. read more

Unfortunately my friends and I had a terrible experience here last night, which could have been easily avoided if the situation was handled differently by the manager of the bar. We were in the women's restroom when a man barged in without saying anything (he looked drunk) and we proceeded to tell him that this was the women's restroom and that he needed to leave. He just kept yelling at us that "this is his bathroom" and asking us "do you know who you're talking to". He opened a utility closet in the bathroom which ended up being the reason he was in there, however we had no idea as he never explained that to us and just kept yelling at us. He then told security to "get us the fuck out" and said that he doesn't care. We explained everything to security and they completely understood and knew that the manager was in the wrong. Overall it was a terrible experience considering this happened within 5 minutes upon entry, and the manager seemed to get a power trip from barging into the women's restroom unannounced and kicking out girls who were concerned over safety matters. Do better. read more

Came here for sunday football around 12:30pm. Just wanted to grab some apps, drinks and watch the game. I would rate the food a 2.5 - the pretzel was big but it was burnt on the outside so we didn't finish it. The mozzarella sticks were good, but they're pretty hard to mess up, and the buffalo wings were average. There's definitely places in Morristown with better wings. Service is a 3 - we stood at the podium for about 5 minutes before we were told we could seat ourselves. With Covid, I thought they would prefer to seat people to social distance accordingly. It took a long time to order drinks and even longer to order food. We debated going up the bar to order food there since the waitress wasn't coming over to the table. I would return to only drink and watch the game, not to order food. I would also order 2 drinks at a time to offset the long wait times. read more

See all

Very nice spot for a drink, with great selection. The food here seems to range from eh to good - not their strength here. The decor is very nice, particularly in the Raven Room upstairs, and the service is friendly. If you're going for food or price point, there are better options. However, if you're going for a bar with good selection, and a great looking spot, this place definitely offers that, with good service on top of that. read more

Horseshoe Tavern - New American Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Food was good, service was ok, we were the only people there, appetizer was never received, but the food was good and it was a nice place.

Came on a weekend night and it was busy enough to be almost packed. There are multiple TVs so this is a good spot as a sports bar. They also play some good music here. There's an upstairs with live bands on most weekends. 1) Wings - Good quality, got the buffalo which is spicy and BBQ which was great. 2) Sliders - Didn't come with lettuce or tomatoes which subtracts from it but overall solid cheese burger sliders. Overall, I'll come back to game days or if a friend/coworkers want to go out here. read more

Very disappointed in upstairs service . Get second drink and it's a cranberry water... supposed to be vodka clearly . Go downstairs and bartender promptly replaces it, much appreciated but should not have been given water in the first place. CONSIDERING I made this post thank you for your time , bye getting tossed read more

Average bar with average food and drinks. I've walked by several times and it's often packed on the weekends so I decided to try it. Not a fan of their Happy Hour drink specials but I recommend their 3 Apps for $20 special. $8 IPA draft is slightly above average considering I tried two different kinds and neither tasted "right". It's definitely time to clean their beer draft lines and check their CO2/O2 levels as well. read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch, Burger, was cooked perfect, and fries were great! Fun atmosphere too.

My co-worker and I come here at least once sometimes twice a week for happy hour. Let's just say it was not happy at all. The manager was not in and it showed in the wings that were overcooked, taking 10 mins for me to pay my check and watching the bartender spill more alcohol than she served. They raised their prices on some happy hours items which is fine, but service and food need to warrant that price adjustment - I now need to find a new spot because I won't be back. read more

Myself, my wife and another couple came in last month. The experience was outstanding, from the service to the food and drink! Tiffany (Mgr.) and our bartender/server Bruce were there to make us feel welcomed and a great time was had by everyone. The Friday we visited there was a "Radio Bingo" contest we really enjoyed playing and winning! We're definitely going to be returning to the Horseshoe in the future! If you're in Morristown, check it out! read more

the bouncers were absolutely horrible kicked people out for spilling a drink in a crowded bar and were hostile and just overall disgusting.

My wife and I were in Morristown and decided to find a place to get a burger and a beer for lunch. The Horseshoe Tavern was walking distance. They had a grilled peach and prosciutto flatbread so we tried that instead. It was excellent, as was our bartender, David. We'll stop by again. read more

I'm glad this bar exists because I can always find a seat during the week (well the 2 times i've been there). The first time I went I ordered sliders which were completely raw inside to the point where they were falling apart and I had to sent it back. I didn't realize it until I was half way through one and realized something was incredibly wrong. The second time I strayed away from anything that could potentially be under done and it was an okay experience. I would say for watching sports and having a drink it's okay, although the service is lacking and it's hard to track down a waiter, I still think it's a good place to go for drinks and trivia. read more

Horseshoe Tavern - New American Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

Great bar in Morristown. Food is great and service is top notch. Had such a fun time with my group of friends this past weekend. We will definitely return frequently read more

I'm having a hard time with this review. The food is average grub and adequately priced, the service is very good. But the drink pricing has me suspicious. This is a place does not give itemized bills as a regular practice. Be careful here. I will not be returning. read more