Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Holy Cow

    4.5 (2 reviews)
    Open • 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Order Holy Cow Takeout or Delivery

    Holy Cow Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Holy Cow

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 months ago

    Food and Service was AMAZING! Highly recommend going there for lunch or dinner any time of the week!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Holy Cow

    You might also consider

    Smashville - Nashville hot fries

    Smashville

    4.5(123 reviews)
    3.9 mi
    •$$

    The burger at Smashville was good, the patty was not seasoned and the burger as a whole was pretty…read moregreasy. Not really their fault, just the style of burger. I just wish there was something fresh or crunchy to balance out all the soft textures from the bread, beef patty, and cheese. I also added beef bacon to my burger, even though it's not listed as an add on the menu. I really wish more of these newer smashburger restaurants had lettuce and/or tomatoes as an add on topping. That would help cut through the grease and make the burger feel a little lighter. The restaurant is very clean and bright, I liked the atmosphere while I was in there and the staff were nice!

    Small venue in the heart of New Brunswick. Metered parking where you can find it, virtually no…read morenearby on (the same) street parking. Quick and easy ordering process, staff don't waste any time getting your order & getting to work on it. Oddly enough there is an ordering kiosk at the counter right next to where you would order with staff. I guess that is for if you're feeling anti-social. Sitting area upstairs, so it is not wheelchair or elderly friendly for the sitting area. No outdoor seating. A very hustle & bustle kinda deal. We had the double patty smash. Overall was it "WTT?" Worth The Trip....YES! Absolutely!! The burger was amazing. It tasted like the smashburger in my mind. Perfection! So even at 30 minutes from my house and horrific parking, I would definitely come back. Grades: Double Patty: A++

    Photos
    Smashville - Ordering area

    Ordering area

    Smashville - Single Patty

    Single Patty

    Smashville - Exterior

    See all

    Exterior

    Holy Burger - Holy Chicken Burger, Double Brisket Short Rib with Egg, Fries and Sweet Potato Tots! HOLY CHICKEN

    Holy Burger

    3.8(11 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    $8 for two chicken sliders, a handful of fries, and a mini soda? Count me in. I was pleasantly…read moresurprised by the quality of the chicken, the softness of the slider buns, and the crispiness of the fries. I was offered "regular or spicy" sliders while ordering - I chose spicy. The flavor of the orange colored sauce was good (nothing to write home about) and the spice level was only a 2 out of 10 for me (it might as well have just been the regular sliders). I took my meal to-go, because the location itself doesn't have the greatest ambiance. It looks pretty cool - high ceilings, relatively clean surfaces and floors, bright orange paint around the ordering counter... But there wasn't any background music or TVs - so when you walk into a place that has zero customers dining-in and chatting, it's not the most inviting atmosphere. Overall, this is a cool spot with 1) extremely prompt service - I was inside for just under two minutes between ordering and taking my to-go bag of food 2) good quality halal chicken and 3) great pricing for a quick lunch or light dinner!

    Holy burger has crazy high ratings for a burger place, so needing a quick bite in the area I went…read moreto check it out. Walking in the register was closed with a sign that just said to use the tablet to order. Going to the tablet there were a good number of disparities from the posted menu on the wall, most of which may have been the same, but were unclear from their descriptions. Things just didn't match up, and that included the prices of things. The board read $3 to make a combo, but the tablet had it at $5.50 for example. The descriptions of the burgers didn't fully describe what was in the burgers as they had on the board, which we have already determined to be dubious. I managed to ask someone for help when they were serving someone else. I found out the burgers use American cheese and so I wanted to substitute. Apparently the solution was to mark "no cheese" and "extra cheddar cheese" which adds another $2.50 to the total. Add-ons have now increased the price by $8! The burger started at $13.50. At this point I get my food and the flavor is good enough, but while the menu board advertised short rib and lamb, it was indistinguishable from ground beef, and I'm unsure if I just got well-done ground beef. The seasoned fries were very plain tasting. I couldn't taste any seasoning on them at all actually, but they were crispy. When you end up pay $25 for a middle of the road burger with fries and a drink at what should be a quick lunch spot, it leaves a bad taste in your mouth, fortunately not literally. The meal was worth maybe half the price, but I likely won't be coming back to give it that second chance, which is unfortunate considering the other high reviews.

    Photos
    Holy Burger
    Holy Burger - Chicken sliders

    Chicken sliders

    Holy Burger - Interior

    See all

    Interior

    Old Man Rafferty's

    Old Man Rafferty's

    3.5(751 reviews)
    3.8 mi
    •$$

    I remember first going here about 14 years ago and was very impressed then. At a recent dance event…read more(Liberty Swing) it was clear that it was still THE PLACE to go, especially with a large group of foodies. Bottom line: no matter what you order it will be excellent. Even with a dozen people on Saturday night, we managed to get seated. With the wide variety of menu choices, everyone was able to get exactly what they wanted. One very interesting dish I hadn't thought of was the chicken pot pie, which sounds very pedestrian, but wait until you see it. Amazing. I ordered the Ahi Tuna salad and it tasted every bit as good as it's picture-perfect looks. Superb service, plus literally everything that came to the table looked like a magazine picture. I cannot recommend it highly enough.

    I've been coming to this restaurant on and off for about 15 years, which makes this review…read moredisappointing to write. Over time, I've noticed a clear decline in quality at the New Brunswick location. In contrast, the Hillsborough location has remained relatively consistent, which makes the difference even more noticeable. To be fair, I'm willing to give a pass on the slower service during this visit since we were seated outside and it seemed like they may not have been fully staffed for that area. That said, the bigger issue was the food. We ordered ravioli and chicken parm with pasta. The ravioli sauce was extremely watery, to the point where it resembled soup rather than a proper sauce. The chicken parm was overcooked, as was the pasta. It's disappointing to say, but based on this experience and the overall downward trend, I don't see myself returning to this location anytime soon.

    Photos
    Old Man Rafferty's - Gluten Free Dry Pastas

    Gluten Free Dry Pastas

    Old Man Rafferty's - Prime Rib French Dip with crispy fries and coleslaw

    Prime Rib French Dip with crispy fries and coleslaw

    Old Man Rafferty's - Exterior

    See all

    Exterior

    Holy Cow - tradamerican - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...