We visited for the first time yesterday, after driving by many times previously. The parking lot was packed, so we weren't sure if we would be able to be seated spur of the moment. Thankfully, we were seated right away. We were served water and a wonderful tray of bread and focaccia with marinara -- everything was delicious, especially the sauce. (OMG!) We explained to the waitress that we wanted to also order an entree to go, and asked for the best timing to do so. Our waitress remembered this and returned at the perfect time to take that order -- rigatoni with marinara and meatballs. We had a 30 mile trip home and the dish was still warm when we arrived! It did take a while for our food to arrive. We were a little concerned because we did not want to drive home in the dark. Our food was very good when it arrived -- the Chicken Vesuvio was amazing, and the leftovers are even better today. Our family member liked the Alfredo, but thought it was a little watery. We were too full for dessert, but carried out a tiramisu. This was also delicious. The dining areas are Italian styled supper club. We were seated to the left of the bar. It looked like the dining area to the right of the bar was a little nicer, but again, we did not have reservations. We were appreciative of the table we were given. Some updates are needed, but we were comfortable. The service was amazing. The host/hostess was friendly and welcoming. The waitress was terrific. The bus boys deserve a special mention -- they were back and forth with water multiple times, and one even offered additional bread to soak up the Alfredo sauce. They were humorous and kind and for being so young, they were very professional--said how much fun it was to work there. (They deserve some special kudos!) Overall, this was a wonderful stop. We'll be back and will try other dishes. We hear that the vodka sauce is also amazing. read more

See all

There are good restaurants and there's Holy Cannoli a great restaurant. What makes the difference is the proprietor. In this case her name is Melissa who was more than nice to us and made sure our experience was second to none. We felt so at home we closed the placed out. When I say the penne pasta is al dente, there's still fight in them, definitely not wimpy, pair that with their light creamy vodka sauce and is quite possibly the best pasta I've had lately. Special mention also goes to the grilled octopus on a bed of Arugula. The restaurant is called holy cannoli so of course we had it but what takes the cake is the tiramisu- just get it trust me you'll like it. If you don't we can't be friends anymore. read more

Holi Cannoli - Italian sausage/ Penne sausage in vodka sauce/ Gnocchi in vodka. Marinara sauce is excellent - Italian Near Me - Elkhorn, Wisconsin

See all

First the good: The gnocchi is made in house and delicious. Also, their dirty martinis and tiramisus are pretty solid. Second the not so great: I ordered a side of spinach for a little over $8 and the portion was very small. Plus, the spinach came out half uncooked and with a piece of broccoli stem in it too. Finally, there was some confusion with the order and the server wasn't very accommodating and essentially told my party that we were misremembering what dishes were ordered. However, it was Labor Day weekend so I can get being overwhelmed by the volume of people. Overall, I would give it another shot but I'm not dying to go back on a busy weekend. read more

See all

Best Italian food in Southeast Wi. Service is also superb!!!!!!!! Keep going back for more. read more

Should be called Holi Tiramisu . The tiramisu is trying to make a monthly meeting in my belly! We love sitting at the bar, and tend to be creatures of habit when we find something we like. My husband loves the cannoli chicken-says it's loaded with flavor. I go for the famous chicken Parmesan with the vodka sauce on the side - if i could make this sauce at home i wouldn't leave the house. read more

See all

Lovely Italian restaurant we found in our travels, so glad we stopped here. We were traveling and we'd fortunate to identify this restaurant while driving. It was not too far off our route and they were able to accommodate us in the dining room as the bar area was packed. Our server, Beth, was friendly, excellent and provided detailed recommendations. She checked back with us multiple times but was not intrusive. We took our server, Beth's, recommendations on dinner selections - chicken parmigiana and gnocchi (house made). Both were excellent, flavorful and delicious. Servings are generous and service is quick. read more

See all

My husband and I came in for a 6:00pm reservation. We were seated promptly and had our orders in by about 5 after. Our appetizer and soup did not reach our table until about 6:40. Our dishes were cleared by 6:50. At 7pm our waitress came by to see if we were okay and noted "It shouldn't be too much longer." That's the last time she saw us. We walked out at 7:20pm. We had been there previously with great service, albeit a few years ago, and really looked forward to returning tonight. We likely won't again and are extremely disappointed and dissatisfied. read more

The atmosphere is so dark and needs an update. The red sauce was delicious. The rest of the meal for a group of 4 people was edible. We tried the mamacita sauce, vodka and ali oglio. We also had the calamari. The highlight was our waitress who was sweet and attentive. read more

Great Lake Spot. Eat at the bar, fantastic Service! don't pass on that chicken with that Vodka Sauce either....... read more

Cozy little gem! Cocktails, food and desserts are all great. Our family loved the Chicken Vesuvio, Gnocchi with Vodka Sauce and the Chicken Marsala! Alejandro the bartender is fantastic and super attentive. read more

Definitely a must visit. The food is very authentic and delicious. Staff are always very pleasant and helpful. The owner, Melissa, is a very warm and inviting person. read more

We were very excited to try Holi Cannoli as we do not get the chance to eat out often as just a couple by ourselves. We had a 4:30 reservation and the restaurant was almost empty except for two other tables of diners. We were escorted to a table in the corner by the swinging doors to the kitchen that the servers were constantly coming in and out of. This table was the only table that had two " antique" chairs that looked like they had been garbage picked from a back alley while all the other tables had black wood dining chairs. The floral print covers on these chairs looked like they were the original covers from 100 years ago and they wobbled terribly. I don't know why we had to be seated at that particular table when maybe only about four other tables were seated the whole time while we were there. We were not overly impressed with our choice of pastas and had to ask for refills on our drinks after we were done with our meal. Overall, we were disappointed in our dining experience and I could not get home quick enough to wash my clothing from sitting in those horrible chairs that were only at our table. It is so hard for us to get a night alone out and hopefully we will make a better restaurant pick next time or at least one that has a comfortable table and chairs. read more

My sister and brother-in-law have a lake house on Lauderdale Lakes (I know... lucky them!). When we visit, which so far has happened twice in two years, we love spending quality family time with them at their lake house. We also love getting out to eat / drink whenever possible, and we've now been to Holi Cannoli on both of our visits. Both times HC has been a five star dinner experience for all of us - kids and adults. Super friendly and attentive service, delicious food and drink, and the claw machine in the entry area has also been a huge hit! You can't go wrong with the pasta dishes or specials. On a recent visit, my sister and I shared an arrabiata pasta with shrimp and broccoli and also an eggplant sausage appetizer. Paired with a dirty martini for me and a glass of wine for my sis, we both left happy with fully bellies! Enjoy! read more

There's nothing like Holi Cannoli, nestled in a cute lake town the food is unforgettable and best martini around. Staff and owner are always friendly it's like you're part of the family. One of our favorites for years! read more

My favorite for years! Alejandro, bartender is great! The food is always delicious whether it's on the regular menu or a special. A real "little Italy" gem in Elkhorn. TY Melissa! read more

Food was excellent, I had a fish special which was polenta crusted salmon with a brandy cream sauce; and on a bed of mashed potatoes and sautéed spinach. Hubby had classic spaghetti and meatballs and they were delicious as well as the marinara sauce. highly recommend. Cozy atmosphere. read more

Service Saturday was fantastic. The inside is great. Tiramisu is among the best. $28 a bottle a Raymond r collection red blend $30 salmon special included sausage escarole soup (or salad). $23? Chicken Marsala menu item did not include soup or salad. The meals were good. $120 all in with 20+% tip for the above. Very happy but 30 min drive for where we are on Geneva lake so we like to dine closer. read more

I've been wanting to try Holi Cannoli for a while now and hubby and I found ourselves kid feee tonight so we went for it and we were not disappointed. We sat at the bar as the wait was going to be quite a while for a table but that was fine by us. The bartenders were great; very attentive and fun; good vibe, seemed like a few regulars which is always good at a restaurants. We ordered bruschetta to start with Pinot noir and Pinot Grigio. The flavors and topping were plenty. Hubby ordered gnocchi with vodka sauce and Blackened chicken; I opted for rigatoni with pesto and grilled chicken. Both dishes were great portion size and flavor. We each tried each others and honestly, I'm not usually a vodka sauce fan but it was amazing. We also had bread with marinara on the side. Very delicious. We ordered tiramisu and cannoli for dessert; I opted for the chocolate covered cannoli shell. Both were very good and finish entirely. We will certainly be back! read more

See all

Authentic Italian! Growing up with both of my parents being Italian American and learning to cook with my mother, grandmother and great grandmother from Italy, I know fresh Italian food. Holi Cannoli has it down. The sauce/gravy is excellent as well as the entire menu. We are there once a week and I give it a 5 star rating for sure! read more

Delicious Italian food and great service. A welcoming and fun place to go for dinner!

Wonderful menu. A bit pricey but service is excellent. Low key, small but a true gem.

We were on a 25 day road trip around the USA and this was the best meal on Day 16 of the trip. Friendly welcoming staff and the food!! Great portions and amazing flavors, and a diverse fun drink menu. Don't miss this place read more

WHAT A GREAT PLACE! It's been ten years since I've been here. It's half way between Lake Geneva and Oconomowoc. Serious nowhere. I remember the place being an old Italian throwback with Dean Martin playing as dinner music Well, the place hasn't changed- nor should it. My wife ordered the vesuvio and it was wonderful. As good as any place in Chicago. I had the chicken parmigiana with the vodka sauce- ridiculous! Total winner. We also got their enormous amazing salad with olives, cheese and peppers. We split a cannoli for dessert. I've eaten cannolis my whole life. I've been to famous places in New York. This may have been as good as any I ever had. The menu is limited and the pasta itself is nothing to get excited about. We were staying in Milwaukee and drove an hour each way. It was so worth it! The service was extra attentive and friendly. read more

Best Italian food in the area! Highly recommend their calamari, sausage & peppers, caprese salad, and bolognese sauce. read more

Amazing food, came here on a friend's recommendation and returned a 2nd time with family. Will return again!

I haven't visited in a while, but after seeing Holi Cannoli featured on food network, I had to come back for 'The Best Thing I Ever Ate.' We ordered the chicken parm with vodka sauce (instead of marinara) and it was SUPERB. The chicken was succulent and cooked to perfection and was covered in the rich and flavorful vodka sauce. I don't think I've ever tasted anything so delicious...but it turns out i could have subbed out the pasta for gnocchi! I can't wait to come back to try this ultimate combo (chicken parm with gnocchi instead of pasta, topped with vodka sauce)! Despite the tragedy of the previous owners passing away from Covid, their daughter is carrying on their legacy with phenomenal food and service. This is my favorite place to dine when I'm near the area! read more

See all

Great little find in the middle of nowhere. But those who know return regularly. Excellent food--not just you Nonna's sugo. Definitely will be back. Don't fill up on the great bread because you won't have room for the great entrees. read more

BEST FOOD IN ELKHORN! Our waitress was so kind and helpful. The food came out fast for how packed it was. The ambiance was awesome and reminded me of unos in Chicago. read more

Absolutely delicious food, only Italian restaurant that's as good as those back home (Chicago)!! These others just don't know good food!!

We have wanted to try this place for a while and will never go back. Waited at the hostess desk for 7 minutes made eye contact with several servers but they kept walking the other way. When the hostess appeared we expressed our dismay and she said you can stay or you can leave we are short staffed. As rude as she could possibly be. The short staffed excuse has become ridiculous! They require a star rating to post ! read more

I heard about this restaurant from social media, chicken park specifically. Went on a Saturday night, not thinking a reservation would be needed. I was wrong. But they were very gracious to accommodate. Started with fresh bread and red sauce. That's different. It was good. We did miss the Parmesan. Calamari was very good. Sauce served with it was unique but good. Chicken parm didn't win the best ever for me but it was very good. I asked for heavy sauce as I like it saucy, extra $4.95. Yikes! A little heads up would of been nice. That is hefty charge. Chicken Marsala was good. Chicken was tender. It came with mashed potatoes. It could of used a bit more sauce as the mashed potatoes had no gravy. We had to pass on desserts , but they looked great. Next time. ... Overall decent meal. Not cheap. No salad served with the entree. We will return and make a reservation. Our server was amazing. The owners and everyone we interacted with were nice people overall!! read more

Finally, a legit and memorable fine dining experience in southern Wisconsin. Not your average "curds, brats, burgers," cheap-o, cattle feeding trough type of food one tends to grow tired of eating in this area, and priced as such. If you're more interested in portion size vs money spent than the quality and flavor of the food, don't go here. Nor is this a place to visit if you expect food geared towards the local hawg crankin' straight piped palate: sweetened or salted to the max, with tons of cheese and bland spices so it doesn't interrupt the rapid consumption of 27 beers. This meal was not *just* the best food I've had around here, but also one of the best Italian meals I've consumed in my life, and that covers some serious ground. My vesuvio was nothing short of epic, and my date really enjoyed her mussels and shrimp. Our server was amazing, as was all supporting staff. Dishes were bussed off the table as fast as we finished one and moved on. H.C. was a traditional supper club prior to its current form and still retains much of that charm; apparently some other reviewers took issue with this. Not an issue for me at all. It was clean and tidy to a fault and probably the first restaurant I've been to in the area that didn't have that telltale stench of dirty kitchen and didn't have sticky tables, seats, and floors. Great job tonight y'all, we'll be back. read more

Love this restaurant! We usually spend Birthdays and special events grabbing dinner and drinks here. Drinks and food are crafted well and are delicious! read more

Wow. Excellent food. The chicken cannoli was spectacular along with their salad and bread with marinara. Drinks are spectacular and of course their Grasshopper desert drink is the best. read more

Great food, generally good service. Wish they still offered pizza but the pasta is marvelous.

Food is okay SERVICE is TERRIBLE!!!!! They forgot about our order. Waited 40 minutes. Will not go back. read more

Always the best food in town. Not possible to have a bad meal here Beth is the absolute best

We had a party of 7. Service was spot on!! Everyone was extremely friendly and the food was very good. I thought the prices were pretty good considering how expensive everything is. read more

We came in on Saturday night without a reservation (5:30-ish) and were able to get seated right away, however pretty soon the place was full. We had the same entree- Pasta ai pescatore, which was really good, but a bit spicy for me (I am not used to this level for an Italian dish). Seafood was cooked perfectly. We also had Holi Cannoli cheesecake which was ok, but not the best I've ever eaten. The service was excellent, very attentive and fast. read more

Holi Cannoli - Pasta ai pescatore - Italian Near Me - Elkhorn, Wisconsin

See all

It's been 5 years living in Elkhorn to finally stop in and eat at Holi Cannoli. Every time I'd drive by the place was either closed (earlier in the day) or it appeared dated on the outside. Don't get me wrong, it's true what they say...don't judge a book by it's cover. Walking in this place had an almost dreary supper club appearance. Once again, don't just a book by its cover. Opening our menu i was a little shocked by the prices...but then again, everything has gone up. Some things I did think were a tad overpriced. Bread and sauce was brought to our table right away and the waitress got our drinks. She was an amazing waitress by the way. Our first taste of the sauce I knew was going to make or break this place. Let me say, BY GOD! Coming from an Italian family, this was one of the best sauces I've ever eaten. My wife who is hard to impress was VERY impressed. We ordered fried mozzarella for our appetizer. We were expecting mozzarella sticks. Nope. Better! Fresh fried slab of mozzarella, breaded in a delicious batter and smothered in the delicious sauce. There simply wasn't enough for us as it was SO good! My wife and daughter both ordered the chicken parm. Delicious! I ordered something off the special menu. Not sure if it's a daily special menu or if they always have it. Either way, I really enjoyed it. Overall I would rate this place 4 1/2 stars. (Wish I had that option). Mainly due to the price of the food. It was delicious and we will be back but we are now a little more prepared for the pricing. It does taste all home made though. You get what you pay for. Don't let the outside appearances turn you away. This is a great place for that nice dinner out every once and a while. I'd probably call in advance to make sure that there is room available because there isn't a TON of room and the bar area got full pretty quick. read more