Deep dish pizza was delicious, with a high gluten crust that stood up well to the innards. Yummy! Salad was fresh, even if the dressing wasn't hand-made. The service was exceptional....several friendly young-folk welcoming us and providing quick, attentive service. We'll be back. read more

If you like a New York style pizza this is the place the sauce is tangy and the thin airy crust was cooked to perfection the cheese blend was spot on only thing different is the cut. round pie into squares? Calzone was great as well order the hog knuckles they are worth it read more

Best pizza from here to Cali. I'm a local but live in California now. Every time I come home I HAVE to eat here at least twice!! It's so good! Super interesting, special pizzas. Staff is stellar. Locally owned and the oldest restaurant in town. And it's obvious why. It's the best. No better pizza anywhere out here and I haven't found one in Cali that beats it either. Thanks for always making my trip home extra yummy and one more thing to always look forward to. read more

They have the best pizza in the area. Great ambiance and service. Try the calzone, it's good stuff. Good selection of beers on tap, when they have time to change the keg;) read more

My husband and I tried this restaurant for the first time tonight and had the most wonderful experience!!!! The pizza was hands down the BEST pizza I've ever had in my entire life. And I mean that with every fiber in my being. Mouth watering delicious BUT the SERVICE!! Holy crap you guys you have set the bar for excelling in customer service. Every single one of you was so warm and friendly and funny and so comfortable to interact with! I can NOT say enough good things about our first experience there tonight. Absolutely loved everything and will be back as often as we can! read more

These guys need to offer indoor dining. In my opinion this Pizza travels poorly. I look forward to getting to eat a hot pie from Hogback.

We waited for 30 minutes while it was made & it was beyond worth it! Probably the best pizza I've ever had. We got the Triple Bypass deep dish 10" and it was enough for 2 people. read more

Hogback Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

Great pizza crust, great service, great music. Theyre nice to my kids who come in often and I really appreciate that. read more

Great pizza and atmosphere. The owners and staff are extremely friendly and welcoming. Something about pizza cut into squares just does it for me read more

Stopped for dinner before heading up to camp. Good pizza - got a cheese and one loaded. Cheesy garlic bread was a hit with the kiddos. Fast, friendly service. Very clean place. The kiddos (and hubby) loved the pinball machines. We'll probably stop again when we are in the area. read more

A+. I love the divey atmophere. It is hard to be divey and family friendly, but this place nails it. The slice of pizza/pint of beer special won me over. Then I got the pie. So good. The crust is sturdy, but tender. Not sure how they accomplish that. There are herbs in the crust that are great. Big complaint - the crust is so good that my husband, who usually lets me have the crusts to chomp on, now finishes the whole thing! The hog knuckle pepperoni rolls are sort of like a crescent roll (made of the good pizza dough) around plenty of pepperoni. They are brushed with garlic oil and sprinkled with some Parm before being baked to a tender, crispy brown. Served with a nice cup of marinara sauce. Salad was simple but covered all the basics and then some. Great croutons! read more

Hogback Pizza - Triple bypass pizza with light cheese, the standard would be extra cheese. Note that its cut in squares. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

We came back here on our road trip because it looked so cute when we drove through town the first time. Delicious! Creative decorations. Highly recommend. No Diet Coke! read more

Hogback Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

Fast and friendly service, great pizzas and calzones! Wish they had more inside seating

Great take-out, consistently. We love the calzones. The White, Luna Bear and Boots Electric pizzas are excellent choices. The Hog knuckles are yummy; sort of like mini calzones. Want something healthy to accompany your carbs? The 457 salad is the best. We happily order take out from Hogback every other week. Great way to replenish after a long run or bike ride. read more

The deep dish is over 2" tall and got the thumbs up from my jersey boy husband. The 457 is absolutely delicious. 3 pinball games offer entertainment while waiting and there are NO TVs (yay!) Was too hot to sit on the patio but there were 6 tables inside plus seating at the bar. read more

Hogback Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

See all

Best pizza ever!! Would eat here everyday if my cholesterol allowed it !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

They are always consistent with their food service and it's great pizza. Best in town

Great consistent take-out, great hang spot, friendly staff. We started a new trail group in town this year on Thursdays & met here every other week before the run/hike & hung out to eat great food & enjoy a beer or 2 afterwards. I love the calzones. For pizza, my faves are the White, Luna Bear and Boots Electric. The Hog knuckles are yummy. The 457 salad is good, healthy accompaniment to the carbs. The weekly specials are pretty creative. The Notorious P.I.G. was especially excellent. Local pork & palisades peaches, if I remember correctly. read more

Pizza was delicious and New Castle historic downtown is charming and incredibly interesting. Will definitely eat here again!

By far the best pizza I've ever had! The deep dish is amazing and lots of cheese Next time I'm passing through Colorado, I'll definitely be making a stop. Friendly service and a great at atmosphere. read more

Hogback Pizza - Deep dish cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

Actually pretty good pizza....like....I would choose this pizza over Papa John's in a second. I have 2 issues with them which prevent me from leave 5 stars. 1 - They almost never answer the phone! I always find it hard to place an order because....omg...answer the phone! 2 - they cut the pizza into squares. It makes me eat more. I have to remember the next time I order from them to ask them to cut the pizza into triangles. :) But other than that, very good food! read more

The atmosphere is amazing, the crew are awesome But best of all the pizzas are to die for!!! The best pizza in the valley! Plus the make-over is fabulous and updated! Love to see the old gas station and liquor store have an amazing come back!!!! read more

Awesome food. Awesome decor. Awesome staff and great pizza. We'll be back! Great stop for family on vacation with not much else around. read more

Great Chicago-style pizza from a Chicago transplant. The Triple By-pass is my favorite.

Delicious deep dish pizza! The staff was kind and the restaurant was very very clean and nicely decorated. read more

So my love of this place started literally the first night I moved to New Castle. My realtor gave me and my wife a gift card at closing and said try them out you'll have a nice meal and won't have to cook on the first night in your new home. Well that sealed the deal. Went with a 'triple bypass' and was sold. When my father would cOme visit he always wanted to go grab lunch there. Dustin and Denise are awesome, they know their customers and wouldn't even ask my name when I came for pick up, they'd grab the boxes and ring me up...years after I moved away I'd still get that same friendly treatment when I walked in. Traditional Neglect, BBQ chicken, hog knuckles, hot sandwiches...it's all good folks! read more

This pizza is very good. Lots of flavor. I truly believe if this place added delivery in new Castle and or was open on Sunday during summer for football this place would make a killing. read more

The owners are so nice! A really unique pizzeria. I enjoy eating their pizza there and in good weather, eating outside. The place is fun!

Seriously some of the best pizza in the valley! Hog back never disappoints and the customer service is awesome! love the fact that the pizza is cut into squares because it reminds me of home, Chicago. read more

Could be a good pizza place but they can't take an order worth a darn! Ruined my family's dinner one too many times. Too bad.

Outstanding pizza! The only place my husband and I go for pizza in this area. Great staff as well. It's always fun to drop in and pick up a pizza or stick around and play some pinball. read more

Hogback Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

Sorry but too overpriced for greasy pizza that cut into squares. We prefer Brick house pizza in Rifle. Or the deep dish at Little Cesars.

The food and service was outstanding!! Highly recommend!! We sat outside on the back patio. Cute and nestled between two mountains. If you love pizza, you will love this little gold mine!! read more

See all

Amazing pizza. Been Eating since day 1!! Something to crave!! Love the pizza, I am from Steamboat but have to grab a pie every time that I am in town! Which is not enough for my mom living in New Castle. Have some favorites but everything and anything on the menu you can't go wrong by ordering! Keep killing it Hogback Pizza! And grabbing a beer while waiting for your awesome pizza at their awesome BAR is a great way to pass some time in New Castle as well. Specially with their kick ass pin ball tables! read more

Excellent pizza, cold beer on tap and a great atmosphere! Try the zombie or the Chicago stuffed deep dish....aw so good! read more

Hogback Pizza - Friendly bar know welcoming a drink or two - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

My boyfriend used to live up the street from this place and it never gets old! Who can pass up good pizza and beer along with a game of pin ball? read more

Hogback Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Colorado

Me and my boyfriend went here and we were surprised to find a hidden gem! Between the pinball machines, amazing service, and incredible food and pizza options, I wouldn't change a thing. I definitely will be coming back here! Best pizza spot on the western slope. Also, kudos on the awesome decor of the place! I used to live in Seattle and in Portland and this place reminded me of something I could find in downtown in one of those places. It was a huge breath of fresh air! read more

Here visiting family had the El Guapo so many good pizzas to choose from it was spicy as promised and delicious. The others at the table had subs and they looked and smelled awesome and they raved on how good they were. Biggest plus they have slices and you can order basically any toppings you want. Will be back again when visiting town. read more

We were bummed about getting rained out of camping this past weekend so promised ourselves we would spend the time checking out places we hadn't been to around the area instead. We came over to Osage Gardens to pick up some plants and decided we were starving on the way back- saw Hogback pizza as we were driving by, quickly did a U-turn and checked it out on Yelp....5 stars all around, and much deserved! We both did the slice deal....only $5.95 for a pint and a slice? Great deal. I was glad to see they had Ranger on tap and was included in the deal. I had a slice of pineapple, and the reviews were right- crunchy, cripsy goodness. The dough has herbs/spices in it, and it tastes fresher than regular dough. Plus, service was probably the friendliest I've witnessed at a pizza joint. Both guys came to check on us on the patio and ask how the pizza was/make small talk. Will be back to order pies! read more

My husband loves this pizza. Service is always friendly. Service is quick. Not a lot of room to sit and eat so consider calling ahead.