A tiny shop located in the basement of a converted house on Kingston Road. If you're not looking for a comic store, there's almost no way you'd find it.
I came here a while back looking for a few Magic singles for a standard deck. They had a few binders for me to look through with slim pickings - many rares that aren't played and some foil uncommons/commons. I was looking for a few very in demand rares and mythic rares. I was able to find one of the cards I was looking for which was a little overpriced compared to TCG Player.
The store itself is pretty cool but small. Every wall is covered in comic books and although I wasn't here for that this time, there's a good chance they'll have what you're looking for. The staff member that assisted me wasn't that well versed with Magic but I think the store is more of a comic store so they can probably help you on that front.
I'm going to say it's ok for Magic. It's a really small store as in I'm not sure where you could set up enough tables for a bigger event. It also might be tough to fill out your deck if you're missing some choice cards. Still, it is the only store in Pickering I know of that caters to this niche. read more